Nobody is CS&N....except CS&N. Don't think they are trying to compete with them. Be glad these young people are actually singing an awesome song by an awesome group and not some of this junk they call music now. As an old musician, would like to see more of this. I saw this years ago and hope they are still together singing nice harmonies. I love it!
There seems to be a spatial incongruity in how you are standing (front to back, (our) right to left) which makes this visually intriguing.
The only thing I would suggest would be to put a little more "life" into the performance. It's a little stiff. Not to say it's bad (I couldn't do as well). It could just stand to be a little more...relaxed. Is that the word? Nice job anyway.
I agree with another poster here. The voices are good and so is the harmony. Therefore, belt it out a little bit more on your next project, especially the lead singer. On this song, while it's good, the lead should be a little more pronounced, in my opinion, than the harmony. Good job, though. Keep it up!
Excellent!!! I do agree that the ending could be a bit better. That step ladder harmony thing that CSN does at the end is tricky with only three voices! They used 5 voices on the album. I believe Timothy B Schmit sings on it!
As a musician of many years, I must say so far this is the best cover of this song I have heard on YouTube. Recording and voices are balanced and vocal work is very good. Baritone voice is dynamite! No one can match CS&N, but this is pretty damn close. Work on the ending harmony a little bit more, but Keep it up!!!!
Very nice! very rare to see indian nationals singing like this type of music. 95 percent of indians sing their own hindi songs all the time. great job ROK1977.
This is not an easy song to perform and you all nailed it, especially those difficult notes and key changes toward the end. You all look very casual and at ease. This is one of my favorite tunes cause the words have poignant meaning that can be applied to anyone's life. You did the song proud and gave me the best 2 and half minutes of my week. Thanks, DO MORE!
Louder but your heart is in the right place. CS&N were a great group. Their message meant something back then. Liberalism is now destroying the world however, and we must overcome its influence. Peace!
got something against it...I'm a desi who sing US and UK music all the time and all my US friends think I rock. Besides these indians and I all grew up in North America thus explaining the North American accents and the fact that we like songs like this!
Nobody is CS&N....except CS&N. Don't think they are trying to compete with them. Be glad these young people are actually singing an awesome song by an awesome group and not some of this junk they call music now. As an old musician, would like to see more of this. I saw this years ago and hope they are still together singing nice harmonies. I love it!
jamesskb 4 months ago
very nice job!!
AntaresInScorpius 4 months ago
it ain't csny but these three are really, really good. keep at it!
dirtybitchnfilthybas 6 months ago
what the fuck this aint csny!
MrBuckkiller55 9 months ago
WOW! You guys surprised me - the harmonies are beautiful. Good job
Brontiet 9 months ago
This is really good. I love the harmony.
ltatch 10 months ago
beautiful!! yall did some very nice harmonies. thanks for the posting
TheDeadhead56 10 months ago
Great video.....I've been trying to pick out the harmonies from the original but can't. But you guys really separate them well. Good job!
Byrds1967 10 months ago
There seems to be a spatial incongruity in how you are standing (front to back, (our) right to left) which makes this visually intriguing.
The only thing I would suggest would be to put a little more "life" into the performance. It's a little stiff. Not to say it's bad (I couldn't do as well). It could just stand to be a little more...relaxed. Is that the word? Nice job anyway.
Tubetopfan1 1 year ago
not bad
grayhuze 1 year ago
Happy I stumbled across. So nice!
AndrewLockwoodMusic 1 year ago
too bad we can't see the chord hand on the guitar.
motamanx 1 year ago
I agree with another poster here. The voices are good and so is the harmony. Therefore, belt it out a little bit more on your next project, especially the lead singer. On this song, while it's good, the lead should be a little more pronounced, in my opinion, than the harmony. Good job, though. Keep it up!
Frances20011 1 year ago
great job
liketunes 1 year ago
Beautiful all the way through -- thank you!
zaineridling 1 year ago
Very nice! Don't be afraid to push that sound out.
DennyDFW 1 year ago
Very nice! Wonderful harmony, nice cover.
hunter3705 1 year ago
Really love your version.
zowlik 1 year ago
Oh man... This was beautiful! Hope to hear more!
ktbcsn 1 year ago
awesome guys.. great job.. god bless u all..!! keep the good work goin...
chin2unleashed 1 year ago
Great Job!
zowlik 1 year ago
very nice, very cool
Blkdrs 1 year ago
Wow!!!!!!!! Big song~~~~~~~~
x0703 1 year ago
the three of you are amazing :)
wondersaz 1 year ago
Very refreshing, you nailed it. One of the nicest covers of this song that I've ever heard.
MrNorthernmike 1 year ago
Good, but stand up straight and put some energy into it.
mcrbshoe 1 year ago
nice
grhr69 1 year ago
nice
gortklato 1 year ago
nice:-)
viganj7 1 year ago
I loved it!
bearthedog12 1 year ago
Wow! I don't know you - but you three sound fantastic!
claymohr 2 years ago
wow nice work
UndeniableLust 2 years ago
Really beautifully sung! Keep singing!
Amyjosing2 2 years ago
Nice job guys. Next smile a bit though. This is a happy song
Jukeboxguy00 2 years ago
Very nice vocals. The guitar takes its proper place as backup rather than being dominant.
I appreciate your efforts at visual composition. Nice depth. Keep it up.
I'm going to get the music and learn to play it tonight!
amphoravideo 2 years ago
My God that was a fantastic cover of a great song!!! Bravissimo
njmhk 2 years ago
Very nice job!
paulcliftonevans 2 years ago
very nice. but no one will every be able to match the vocal talent of the best singers of CSN and the Eagles.
fightcrib 2 years ago
formidabel= fantastic
i like it
go on
kokoxp1968 2 years ago
Fantastic !!!!
shawil 2 years ago
BRAVO!!!
growyourownmusic 2 years ago
Oh my the young lady in the red is amazing beautiful !
w1ldrover 2 years ago
Very well done
daddyogrande 2 years ago
good to see that this music has touched all kinds of people and ages, keep going in the right direction u sound great
THCJunkiE 2 years ago
Very well done, great harmonies. Awesome.
alberzeta 2 years ago
Comment removed
andyandyband 2 years ago
So guys (and gals), what are you up to nowadays? It's been awhile since this was posted. Still into the music?
lewiske 2 years ago
Its beautiful !!!!!!!
cryrocker 2 years ago
Excellent!!! I do agree that the ending could be a bit better. That step ladder harmony thing that CSN does at the end is tricky with only three voices! They used 5 voices on the album. I believe Timothy B Schmit sings on it!
Overall 5 stars!
DejaVuAcoustic 2 years ago
Sweet..
eurogoldexchange 2 years ago
You are blowing me away guys! Amazing!
Paolo
Paolo250376 2 years ago
You guys rock!!
jimax8989 3 years ago
As a musician of many years, I must say so far this is the best cover of this song I have heard on YouTube. Recording and voices are balanced and vocal work is very good. Baritone voice is dynamite! No one can match CS&N, but this is pretty damn close. Work on the ending harmony a little bit more, but Keep it up!!!!
jamesskb 3 years ago
haha I like this good harmonizing
rdeco73 3 years ago
beautiful!
reliablebow 3 years ago
nice...nice...nice
musicmaster13833 3 years ago
Excellent in every way...great harmony...well done! If you ever visit Colorado, I would love to sing with you!
mtndog 3 years ago
Beautiful - great vibe
buskerbuoy 3 years ago
Vraiment chouette!!
gerden238 3 years ago
Difficult song - good performance!
Showaddy08 3 years ago
Wow! I usually hate covers, but you guys are great!
carolc48105 3 years ago
Wow! Very nice harmonizing! Fine guitar playing too. Thanks!
streetheat1 3 years ago
Lovely vocal harmony´s!
Congratulations!
From Argentina
Gus
gus2312 3 years ago
that was just really great man
gosurf1 3 years ago
i dig it
smurphalotte 3 years ago
Great!! Thanks!! :-)
rawsomeone1 3 years ago
Heartfelt homage... Lovely, tight vocals.
ditman6308 3 years ago
Very beautiful...especially tyhe one operating the cam. VERY gorgeous!!!
braveheartbob 3 years ago
Fantastic!!!! You guys did a great job!!! Truly enjoyed it.
flightofideas72 3 years ago
Great singing and choice of song, love it!
ramonovv 3 years ago
music is universal. love yours.
wyattandjosie 3 years ago
Great job!! Beautiful harmonies.
ronboy51 3 years ago
Very nice! very rare to see indian nationals singing like this type of music. 95 percent of indians sing their own hindi songs all the time. great job ROK1977.
wafu2dati2eh 3 years ago 2
Very Nice
Jasonb828 3 years ago
I think is fantastic
munozarango 3 years ago
AWESOME!!!!!Where's American Idol when you need them?
recordplayerguy 3 years ago
i love your version next to original.thx!!
akira818 3 years ago
Very nicely done. a bit grainy video
rubiescanada 3 years ago
Nicely done
skipops 4 years ago
Great singing.Harmony is beautifully done.Keep it up!
simha43 4 years ago
wow! great singing, i never thought indians can sing this beautifully. 5 stars sadik
lancego30 4 years ago
GREAT job! You all have talent. Classic song.
scubadivercb 4 years ago
Great! You guys are tops!
Andy
Pensacola. Fl. USA
liamalock 4 years ago
very good stuff people!!! Are you three south african?
charoufunk 4 years ago
lovely...just lovely...
gatoperezoso 4 years ago
great! I loved the harmonies!
olimpio50 4 years ago
Beautiful!
LeilaniRocks 4 years ago
Very nice, the cynic in me thought it would probably be shitty since the original is so beautiful, but you guys did a great job!
HabsRule92Remy92 4 years ago
Samesame!
Sinsouk 4 years ago
that was beautiful. inspiring.
jackjack1970 4 years ago
This is not an easy song to perform and you all nailed it, especially those difficult notes and key changes toward the end. You all look very casual and at ease. This is one of my favorite tunes cause the words have poignant meaning that can be applied to anyone's life. You did the song proud and gave me the best 2 and half minutes of my week. Thanks, DO MORE!
elmolincoln2k 4 years ago
What a nice job. That was very sweet.
bckerz 4 years ago
Nice Job Id be happy to have you in my association of singers Email me. Thanks
lisou123 4 years ago
Wonderful!!!You guys could be like the Corrs. Keep it up!!!!!!
DJohRicky 4 years ago
Absolutely great! Thanks!
ktbcsn 4 years ago
This is really good...superb effort and great vocals!!!
tbwff 4 years ago
superb...you sound perfect...great harmonizing!!!! Hats off to you!
gmplaw 4 years ago
i went to see them in their supposedly last tour a couple of years ago at the manchester M.E.N , it was amazing best contcert ever been to :D
payney2k7 4 years ago
That is one of my FAVORITE songs by CSN&Y!! Great group!! I'd say you've done them justice!! I get teary-eyed writing this!!
tcidolfan 4 years ago
Louder but your heart is in the right place. CS&N were a great group. Their message meant something back then. Liberalism is now destroying the world however, and we must overcome its influence. Peace!
ericthebarbaric 4 years ago
That was so good. you have great voices!
lieutenant3vix 4 years ago
bunch of desi's? singing english music...hmmm
rashbabu 4 years ago
got something against it...I'm a desi who sing US and UK music all the time and all my US friends think I rock. Besides these indians and I all grew up in North America thus explaining the North American accents and the fact that we like songs like this!
corrupt200 4 years ago
Don't care what race they are. They sing well and the audience enjoys it. That's all it matter.
whyicare 2 years ago
is Wonderful! Wonderful! Wonderful!
compumaniac0 4 years ago
You all have some real potential. Don't be afraid to use your voices and let loose. Don't be afraid to move, too.
Leaning against the walls is not only too casual, but you can't sing from your diaphragm like that.
Music is supposed to be fun. Have more fun with it and you'll make it work.
Good luck to you! Lots of potential!
SharonCobb 4 years ago
Very good!
If you could mic it better then it would be even better.
Love the Ibanez(?)
Patsik 4 years ago
WOW! How did I miss this? It's amazingly good! I love this song and you do an awesome job...
AlonsoDeAlbuquerque 4 years ago
How 'bout putting out an album?
countblastula 4 years ago
that was really good.. loved the harmony
ShyGirly24 5 years ago
Is that a helicopter I hear? No matter. Sing louder! Don't be afraid of your own voices!
lewiske 5 years ago
A very well rendition of a song I wish more people knew.
esdu81b 5 years ago
Beautiful harmonies. Love it !
pierrelacroix 5 years ago
Im in love,surely im imagininging this x
sandybobbins 5 years ago
Wonderful! :)
cbetts1982 5 years ago
I thought it was very nice. Advice? Sing a little louder... Great Job!!
pidanp 5 years ago
What fun!!
You guys are great.
What's next?
heilgv 5 years ago
Another great rendition, good work guys! Ya beaut!
kumaritess 5 years ago
I agree with Rkain101. Very good indeed
bullhead101 5 years ago
Pretty good, people. Give the lady a prize!
RKain101 5 years ago
This is fantastic guys! Teach was good, this is better! Would love to hear even more. Cheers!
Hemanhemant 5 years ago