this should be the real list: 1.Marino 2.Favre 3.Manning 4.Elway 5.Montana 6.Brady 7.Young 8.Bradshaw 9.Aikman 10.Staubach 11.Unitas 12.Starr 13.Graham 14.Baugh 15.Brees
Elway #1, Marino #2, Manning #3. no qb had an overall better skill set then elway. nobody threw a quicker and chrisper pass then marino. no qb had conducted an offense better then manning!
This is really lame overall. Montana is the greatest and Manning #2. Maybe Brady would be 3rd at best. Brady is damn good, but his coach and team around him have made his career.
Joe Namath is the most overrated quarterback of all time! If he hadn't guaranteed Super Bowl III, no one would know his name. He won the SB MVP without even throwing a touchdown in the game. His stats are awful, with the exception of pass yards. 173 TD 220 INT 65.5 QB Rating!? Come on!
@MonteandTheMachine why not Brady has a higher winning percentage out of every QB ever to play the game. Brady has been to 4 superbowls just like Montana, and Brady has an undefeated 16-0 record not even Montana has done that. Montana played with the best player ever to play the game Jerry Rice even the NFL network says Jerry rice was the best. brady won 3 rings with no pro bowlers on offense, And Brady has the most touchdowns in a season month and quarter, Montana has no regular season records
this list sucks dick. bias ass pats fan putting brady at number 1 and drew fucking bledsoe at 11 you have got to be kidding me. you are retarded, kill yourself. and its randall cunningham not allen deuche bag.
Whoa, manning in the top 5? I say he's barely in the top 10. And Marino at 8? Sure he never won a super bowl, but when you talk about talent, he's at least in top 5, mabye #3. But I do think you got 2 and 1 dead on, except I'd say that Montana and Brady should have like a 2 way tie for first. But if Brady were able to win one more super bowl, hands down best QB ever.
no way is brady #1 hes not even top 5 hes nothing without all-star recievers the 50 TD season was a FLUKE heres my list 1.Joe Montana 2.Brett Favre 3.Peyton Manning 4.Johnny Unitas 5.Dan Marino 6.John Elway 7.Tom Brady 8.Steve Young 9.Terry Bradshaw 10.Roger Staubach
5. John Elway....I still put Montana over Brady even though they have the same number of SB Rings and post season performances because of the fact that Brady hasn't gone the length Montana has...but Brady will pass him over time...
#1 is Otto Graham 8 championships in 11 years, including that he even won a basketball championship on the one year he played basketball, nobody can beat that.
#1 is Otto Graham 8 championships in 11 years, including that he even won a basketball championship on the one year he played basketball, nobody can beat that.
what ppl dont realize is that joe montana was a system qb...they were the first to run the west coast offense..every other team in the nfl up until like 1990 ran there offense from like split backs and 2 wide outs..even on passing plays..if u study the game, the offenses were so simple..the west coast offense was the first EVER system to have the shotgun without a tight end and more than 2 wide outs
@sedro32 Actually that is NOT true. The West Coast offense may have gotten its nickname during the 49ers years, but even Sam Wyche admits it is just a slightly tweaked version of the Paul Brown/Otto Graham offense philosophy. So in regards. I respect every quarterback on this list and say they DO deserve to be here for their accomplishments. But the "BEST" would have to go to a player who, REGARDLESS OF THE ERA, won and no one, let me repeat that, NO ONE won more often or better than OTTO Graham
The only QBs in NFL history to win FOUR Super Bowls are: (1) Terry Bradshaw (2) Joe Montana.
The only QBs in NFL history to win THREE Super Bowls are: (1) Troy Aikman (2) Tom Brady.
The only QBs in NFL history to win TWO Super Bowls are: (1) Bart Starr (2) Roger Staubach (3) Bob Griese (4) John Elway (5) Kurt Warner (6) Ben Roethlisberger.
There are a total of 17 QBs who have won only ONE SB: including S. Young, B, Favre, J. Nameth, D. Brees, both P. & E. Manning, J. Theismann and J. Unitas.
tom brady should NOT be on this list at all 2 of 3 super bowl wins were won by a field goal and his only good season oops got caught cheating in the 1st game i say they never stoped cheating because he isnt that good this season proved that
There are a number of issues with this list. Firstly, I would like to point out that while I am one of the biggest Patriots fans out there, Tom Brady should NOT IN ANY WAY be at the top of this list. Some other concerns include that Roger Staubach is #15 while Drew Bledsoe is #11, there is something very wrong with that. Also, Fran Tarkenton, Otto Graham, and Len Dawson should all be on this list...whereas you went with Jim Kelly and Drew Bledsoe instead.
I'm sorry.... but Tom Brady should NOT be on the top of this list. I'm not saying he's a terrible QB but it's the system that makes him look better than he is. Look what happened to Cassel... he took over for Brady, and went 11-5. What'd he do with the huge contract over in KC? Absolutely nothing.
I'm thinking Montana, Elway at Number 1 and 2. They did the most for their respective teams.
Drew Bledose, Peyton Manning, and Tom Brady should'nt even be on that list
and I highly doubt this person or any of you that brag about Otto Graham, actually lived in the time or seen footage ofhim playing. Not saying he was bad, just saying it's funny he getsall this praise and 80% of them never seen him play
If brady wins one super bowl more he will prob be # 2 behind montana right now he is my num 5. brett farve aint num one because after his first super bowl he could 't get over that hurdle again and win the big game
bull shit he is number 1, he isn't even the number one guy in the NFL right now not even number 2. ever since spygate he hasn't been the same. yeah he got hurt last year but this year he didn't do it. this is a bs list. payton is by far the smartest in the nfl and brees is fantastic as well, and if brady was so good then why isn't he the number one guy for the AFC in the pro bowl? come on he had a great streak but it is over now his career isn't as good as montana's
Manning is only one of the best because he always has the best wide recievers in slot. And he still isn't that great he threw like 16 interceptions this year. and cool he threw alot of yards but still come on, Reggie Wayne, Pieree Garcon, Anthony Gonzalez, Austin Collie, Marvin Harrison, and probably more. They were all good/great recievers not because of Manning but because they were. IMO Philip Rivers is better. He threw for alot of yards too but not with fast recievers. And LT steals tds...
@icwlover You are saying ring do not count for anything? Winning a superbowl takes a team, but so does winning mvp. You cant go winning mvp, at the qb position, with crappy receivers like Rache Caldwell, or Jabar Gaffeney. Not taking anything away from Peyton Manning, but he has had good receivers is whole career.
You know what. These kinds of debate would just turn out to be moot. For those who insist that this debate leads to something. Let's pit just one QB against one QB... without the O-line, secondaries, WRs, RBs, Coach. You know, just throw the football. Let's see who's the best.
PatsFan4LifeKBH. your crazy. Peyton is 10 times better then tom brady. I dont care how many super bowls he has one that dont make tom brady good. Peyton is way better and brady will never be close to how good peyton is.
Dear Fantasy Football Nerds: SB rings matter - not the stats. Not saying Brady is #1 of all time - but a QB like Brady who won 3 SBs deserves a spot in the top 10 or 15. You fantasy football stats nerds are really starting to annoy people who spend time to think.
Joe Montana has 4 (1980s). Terry has 4 (1970s). Can you compare them? Not really, because they're in a different era. For me, Montana is the best ever. And that's my opinion. Could Manning win 4 as well? I believe so. Could Brady win 4? I believe so too, 1 left. At the moment Brady = 3 rings; Manning = 1 ring. So at the moment, he's better. Capice?
Capice? No. Not at all. There are many criteria by which to judge athletes, including quarterbacks. If number of championship rings are the lone criteria, then Terry Bradshaw (TB) and Joe Montana (JM) are the best ever, yet we NEVER hear TB mentioned as one of the best QBs ever. He won 4 SB rings in a 6 year span. Montana won 4 over an 9-year span. Since TB won 4 in a shorter period, by YOUR criteria, he's the best ever. I guess Robert Horry = 2nd best BBall player ever: 6-7 NBA rings.
I agree with you on that one. WTF is with you and this 'YOUR' criteria BS.. did I ever mention that its the lone category? Come on. Brady can pass - so does Manning. Both have the intangibles. You've put that one out of context with Horry in the mix. Goodness. Geez. Okay, then answer this, why oh why with Manning that great can't win more than one SB? Simple as that. The answer is: Team. Lone criteria? Where'd you get that?
Manning only has 1 super bowl ring because he sucks in post season and chokes every year(except 2006 he got lucky that year in the sense he didn't choke for once)
this list was obviously put together by some mentally challenged bostonite. TOM Brady number 1???? DREW BLEDSOE MAKING THE LIST OF TOP 15 ALL TIME??????????????????????? COME ON.... really think brady will be doing at 40 what brett favre is doing now???? LETS GET REAL PEOPLE
Brady's not even in the top 10!! He only had that one outstanding year three years ago when he had Randy Moss (when he was still good), Dontae Stallworth, Wes Welker, and Ben Watson. Brady's not even in the same league as Montana, Dan Marino, or Peyton Manning.
@Pandamatrix85 No, because winning percentage is a TEAM stat, not an individual stat. Terry Bradshaw won 69% of his games, so are you saying he's better than Manning (65%) and Marino (61%)?
YOU FUCK OFF!!!!!!!!!! brady sucks monkey balls and peton manning is 3 times better and the only reason brady even has a superbowl ring at all is because b4 2008 they had a monster defense!
are you 12 or something? 'because b4 2008 they had a monster defense' -- the point is? which Super Bowl champion doesn't have a good secondary? You need some brain cells.
dude i am highly pissed i mean i was gonna give u a five star raring until i saw dan marino at #8 andthe worst of it all u put troy akiman at #7 u disgust me u homo ass fucking cock sucker u can go n give troy a bj and for all i care u can roll over and fucking choke reading this comment and die!!!!! u just suck mager balls and u have a little bird n finally how can tom brady be first now come on really!!!
WTF is Brady is doing at 1???? The best ever is Brett Favre closely followed by Marino, Montana, Elway THEN Brady. O and where the hell are Warren Moon and Dan Fouts????
what idiot made this ranking? Marino at #8... should be top 3. Montana at #2... He is by far #1!!! Bledsoe....serious?? he is on here wow!! Brady is good, but #1 no way!! Fouts needs to be in there.
Hey Panda"C word" please post what you intend to post, and be proud of it.....or not. But don't post it, then post a trail of bitch as disclaimers to show what little you know about the post that you posted prior. Does your uterus hurt now? We really don't care.
Bledsoe in the list removes legitimacy from it. Brady as number one makes it known that you're a Pats fan with no real connection with the great QB's of the game, and lastly, no refference to the almighty Dan Fouts just makes you a fucking idiot.
Clearly this must be a joke. to have Dan Marino and John Elway not in the top 4 is retarded, and to have Terry Bradshaw even on the list is funny . Bradshaw had like two more TDs than INTs for his career he just happened to be on a great team.
Why do you call Tom Brady a pretty boy? Why do you call it wacky tobacky? no offense, but you sound like a gay person or a faggot. Tom Brady has so many records and great accomlishments that he has to be #1, his accomplishments/records are too long to list.
I messed up this list, you should look at my Top 15 Quarterbacks in NFL history video, it's about 90-95% correct, cause it's based entirely on stats, accomplishments, and ability in the clutch.
Staubauch was better than Aikman. I am a Niner fan and no way would i put Young four on a list. Marino is better than him. Also Namath has no business being on this least. He is one of the more overrated players of all time. By the way "guydaves" is a fucken idiot.
I agree Namath is overrated, also Terry Bradshaw is overrated, look at his stats if you don't believe me. Also, yeah, "guydaves" is an idiot. Young has a higher TD pass percentage than every other great quarterback in NFL history, and has a pretty low interception pass percentage, in other words young is an underrated passer. Young is the best overall quarterback in NFL history, but in terms of passing talent he's #4. Staubach was a better QB cause he could run but Aikman was a better passer.
I know Bradshaw is overated and so is Namath i know my football haha. But ya Young is the man i know that. I really don't think he is number 4 but he is top 10. Aikman also had a way better team than Staubauch ever did. He also had an amazing line back in the Nineties.
I think that your right, Aikman did have a better team for several years, so yeah Staubach is better. Thanks for pointing that out. Young may not be #4 but he is at least top five. Is there anything else you would like to point out, just asking cause I'm going to make a new top ten QBs of all-time video pretty soon.
Whoa! Hold it! Roger Staubach WAYYYY better than Drew Bledsoe!! better than terry bradshaw! Better than Dan Marino! Better than Brett Favre! Better than John Elway! Better than Steve Young! Better than Joe Montana! And WAYYY better than Tom Brady!!!
Wow, if you knew me, you'd know I know EVERYTHING about this stuff! Football is like my life! I know more about it than most people! So why don't you shut the fuck up and watch your gay Tom Brady!
Dude, football is my life, I think that I know what I'm talking about. But we probably value different attributes and abilities differently so that's why it's debateable.
I think that Bledsoe deserves to be here, he's in the top ten or twenty in just about every career passing statistic, I think he should make the hall of fame but not first ballot though.
stats r overrated. i honestly think that mcnabb is a better qb then bledsoe. but most ppl would disagree becuz he didnt put up the same kinda stats bledsoe did. and dont tell me im biased becuz im an eagles fan. he led then to 5 conference games and a super bowl wheres bledsoe only took thm to 1 super bowl
Donovan Mcnabb is better I agree, but he also had a better team. The Patriots won a lot of games with Bledsoe even though the whole team(other than Bledsoe and Vinatieri) was pathetic. You take away Bledsoe from the Pats when he was their quarterback and they would have a top 5 draft pick every season. As for Mcnabb he has a good team, he has a fast defense that likes to blitz a lot and he has Westbrook. So true Mcnabb may be better but let's a wait a few years before i put him on this list.
Did you throw a bunch of QB pictures up in the air and used the order they landed? OR are you a Detroit Lions fan? Your list is 0 & 15 yes it is! You must be a patriots fan the cheaters have three super bowls because of that spy gate bullshit the first super bowl they choke it up to the Giants.
Brady's #1, he had 50 TD passes only 8 picks, he could have had 60 TD passes if he wanted to. Also prior to his injury he was on pace to beat Elway's record for career 4th quarter comebacks. His record with a lead at any time in the 4th quarter of a regular season game is 85-1. But most important of all he has the highest career win percentage of any quarterback in the Super Bowl era.
this is good but marino is better 6than brady and aikman and montana and young and manning and elway i mean brady should be more like 4 but this is the best ive ever seen so far
Winning makes great QBS,nos stats. Jim Kelly? He went 0-4 in superbows, he wasnt a winner, same goes for marino, great Qb with great stats but surely winning championships is the true measure of a great QB. The truly great WINNING Quarterbacks have won 3+ championships ie- Bradshaw, Montana, Brady,Starr etc. That is surely the what matters most,not passing yards,tds etc. They guys are great stastistic quarterbacks but not WINNING ones. I bet u marino would gladly swap stats for rings.
screw you manning always had good recivers around him to help him and the one year that brady got descent recivers he basically was unstoppable back there throwing for more then 50 tds
It's frustrating to see Marino at number 8. All the quartebacks ahead of him with rings had running backs. Marino was all by himself with basically no running game for his entire career. He has a better arm and was just as accurate if not more than any quarterback on this list.
Whats with all the Brady Hate. IMO he is great because he had 4 different receiving core and only this year he had a lot of talent at receiver but even with troy brown and David Patten he still managed to beat my team The Steelers every year. And he led his team to the AFC Championship with Reche Caldwell as his number 1 receiver no other QB in NFL has has played great with 4 different receiving corps thats why he is number 1
cmon it goes 1. Brady 2.Montana 3. Unitas 4. Elway 5. Manning 6. Marino 7. Young 8. Aikman 9. Farve 10. Bradshwan 11. Staubach 12. Grahm 13. Kelly 14. Warner 15. Starr
joeylab97 1 week ago
this should be the real list: 1.Marino 2.Favre 3.Manning 4.Elway 5.Montana 6.Brady 7.Young 8.Bradshaw 9.Aikman 10.Staubach 11.Unitas 12.Starr 13.Graham 14.Baugh 15.Brees
DillonVentura3 3 weeks ago
Elway #1, Marino #2, Manning #3. no qb had an overall better skill set then elway. nobody threw a quicker and chrisper pass then marino. no qb had conducted an offense better then manning!
xxalchemist1128xx 1 month ago
This is really lame overall. Montana is the greatest and Manning #2. Maybe Brady would be 3rd at best. Brady is damn good, but his coach and team around him have made his career.
Skreggie44 2 months ago
peyton manning #1
UnstopableChiken 4 months ago
wow song wrong brett farve should be number 2 and joe shoukd be number 1.............wow you dumb
cokelovers56785 4 months ago
jim kelly over staubach you gotta be crazy!!! Kelly no superbowls come on!
vakeromty 5 months ago
Joe Namath is the most overrated quarterback of all time! If he hadn't guaranteed Super Bowl III, no one would know his name. He won the SB MVP without even throwing a touchdown in the game. His stats are awful, with the exception of pass yards. 173 TD 220 INT 65.5 QB Rating!? Come on!
nolifereview 6 months ago
@nolifereview exactly idk y everyone thinks he's such a good qb cause he's obviously not!
DillonVentura3 3 weeks ago
peyton manning shouldnt be on this list
MegaCowboysfan123 8 months ago
Horrible song and bad list. Drew Bledsoe doesn't belong among the greatest QB's of all time.
savagesports 9 months ago 2
An obvious Pats fan. Brady doesn't deserve to be in the same league as Montana.
MonteandTheMachine 11 months ago
@MonteandTheMachine why not Brady has a higher winning percentage out of every QB ever to play the game. Brady has been to 4 superbowls just like Montana, and Brady has an undefeated 16-0 record not even Montana has done that. Montana played with the best player ever to play the game Jerry Rice even the NFL network says Jerry rice was the best. brady won 3 rings with no pro bowlers on offense, And Brady has the most touchdowns in a season month and quarter, Montana has no regular season records
TheJewballer 10 months ago
brady is the best
mpcolucci12 11 months ago
this list sucks dick. bias ass pats fan putting brady at number 1 and drew fucking bledsoe at 11 you have got to be kidding me. you are retarded, kill yourself. and its randall cunningham not allen deuche bag.
madmac993 11 months ago
Comment removed
madmac993 11 months ago
De donde chingadios sacas a Tom Brady como #1, no mms
reymarino123 11 months ago
bledsoe dosent belong in the top 50 lmao
jusherct 1 year ago
Dan Marino is the best QB to ever play the game.
Clasby440 1 year ago 2
Brady over Montana? What the hell are you smoking?????
dhart1977 1 year ago
no mms no es posible esto pnche fraude
000disco777 1 year ago
I think you made a mistake in the top three you probably ment to put #1 Joe Montana #2 Payton Manning #3 John Elway
mmmmmmham 1 year ago
my tops are. 1. Montana 2. Elway 3. Favre 4. Marino 5. Unitas 6. Manning 7. Brady 8. Baugh 9. Tarkenton 10. Moon 11. Warner 12. Stabler 13. Bradshaw 14. Young 15. Starr
southpark997 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my tops are. 1. Montana 2. Elway 3. Favre 4. Marino 5. Unitas 6. Manning 7. Brady 8. Baugh 9. Tarkenton 10. Moon 11. Warner 12. Stabler 13. Bradshaw 14. Young 15. Starr
southpark997 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my tops are. 1. Montana 2. Elway 3. Favre 4. Marino 5. Unitas 6. Manning 7. Brady 8. Baugh 9. Tarkenton 10. Moon 11. Warner 12. Stabler 13. Bradshaw 14. Young 15. Starr
southpark997 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my tops are. 1. Montana 2. Elway 3. Favre 4. Marino 5. Unitas 6. Manning 7. Brady 8. Baugh 9. Tarkenton 10. Moon 11. Warner 12. Stabler 13. Bradshaw 14. Young 15. Starr
southpark997 1 year ago
Why is Marino number 8
Ktallica 1 year ago
There is no way in hell that manning or brady is higher then farve and where ya title and other nfl grates that need to be there
TANOFTZ 1 year ago
Whoa, manning in the top 5? I say he's barely in the top 10. And Marino at 8? Sure he never won a super bowl, but when you talk about talent, he's at least in top 5, mabye #3. But I do think you got 2 and 1 dead on, except I'd say that Montana and Brady should have like a 2 way tie for first. But if Brady were able to win one more super bowl, hands down best QB ever.
yourface1812 1 year ago
OMFG Brady is shit. Elway #1 Montana #2 Staubatch #3 coming from a cowboys fan
EazyESjc187 1 year ago
yaman1922 1 year ago
1. Joe Montana
2. Tom Brady
3. Brett Favre
4. Dan Marino
5. John Elway....I still put Montana over Brady even though they have the same number of SB Rings and post season performances because of the fact that Brady hasn't gone the length Montana has...but Brady will pass him over time...
buckda54 1 year ago
this list is a joke.
#1 is Otto Graham 8 championships in 11 years, including that he even won a basketball championship on the one year he played basketball, nobody can beat that.
theseattlesound1 1 year ago
this list is a joke.
#1 is Otto Graham 8 championships in 11 years, including that he even won a basketball championship on the one year he played basketball, nobody can beat that.
theseattlesound 1 year ago
tom brady is number 1 like always!! suck it manning
Baileylf13 1 year ago
i quit watching this video when he put joe namath ahead of stabauch. WHAT A JOKE OF A LIST.
halodystroyer44 1 year ago
oh god.... this goes in the file of "only knows what he remembers"
TheDisonant 1 year ago
How is Drew Bledsoe on this shit , but WARREN MOON isn't ?..
ImTheShiet47 1 year ago
what ppl dont realize is that joe montana was a system qb...they were the first to run the west coast offense..every other team in the nfl up until like 1990 ran there offense from like split backs and 2 wide outs..even on passing plays..if u study the game, the offenses were so simple..the west coast offense was the first EVER system to have the shotgun without a tight end and more than 2 wide outs
sedro32 1 year ago
@sedro32 Actually that is NOT true. The West Coast offense may have gotten its nickname during the 49ers years, but even Sam Wyche admits it is just a slightly tweaked version of the Paul Brown/Otto Graham offense philosophy. So in regards. I respect every quarterback on this list and say they DO deserve to be here for their accomplishments. But the "BEST" would have to go to a player who, REGARDLESS OF THE ERA, won and no one, let me repeat that, NO ONE won more often or better than OTTO Graham
TheLuvers666 1 year ago
BLEDSOE BEFORE KELLY? wow
sedro32 1 year ago
I like tom Brady. but he isnt #1, #1 should be joe montana, and peyton manning is better than tom brady. tom should be like 3rd or 4th
atlfalcon20223 1 year ago
Joe Montana is better than Tom Brady.
shydow1000 1 year ago
The only QBs in NFL history to win FOUR Super Bowls are: (1) Terry Bradshaw (2) Joe Montana.
The only QBs in NFL history to win THREE Super Bowls are: (1) Troy Aikman (2) Tom Brady.
The only QBs in NFL history to win TWO Super Bowls are: (1) Bart Starr (2) Roger Staubach (3) Bob Griese (4) John Elway (5) Kurt Warner (6) Ben Roethlisberger.
There are a total of 17 QBs who have won only ONE SB: including S. Young, B, Favre, J. Nameth, D. Brees, both P. & E. Manning, J. Theismann and J. Unitas.
Mr88playmaker 1 year ago
12 jim kelly his number was 12!
MrRon752 1 year ago
tom brady should NOT be on this list at all 2 of 3 super bowl wins were won by a field goal and his only good season oops got caught cheating in the 1st game i say they never stoped cheating because he isnt that good this season proved that
geoffreypruitt80 1 year ago
There are a number of issues with this list. Firstly, I would like to point out that while I am one of the biggest Patriots fans out there, Tom Brady should NOT IN ANY WAY be at the top of this list. Some other concerns include that Roger Staubach is #15 while Drew Bledsoe is #11, there is something very wrong with that. Also, Fran Tarkenton, Otto Graham, and Len Dawson should all be on this list...whereas you went with Jim Kelly and Drew Bledsoe instead.
Boodish 1 year ago
typical patriots fan all suckin bradys dick fuck that nigga he sucks
estafuego8807 1 year ago
pats fanboy
brayden99Roblox 2 years ago
I'm sorry.... but Tom Brady should NOT be on the top of this list. I'm not saying he's a terrible QB but it's the system that makes him look better than he is. Look what happened to Cassel... he took over for Brady, and went 11-5. What'd he do with the huge contract over in KC? Absolutely nothing.
I'm thinking Montana, Elway at Number 1 and 2. They did the most for their respective teams.
jbailey598 2 years ago
This is a shit list, I LMFAOed at it.
Drew Bledose, Peyton Manning, and Tom Brady should'nt even be on that list
and I highly doubt this person or any of you that brag about Otto Graham, actually lived in the time or seen footage ofhim playing. Not saying he was bad, just saying it's funny he getsall this praise and 80% of them never seen him play
LivingWorstNightmare 2 years ago
montana is better than brady
TheYOitsFRANKIE 2 years ago
joe montana is way better then tom brady
dane199977 2 years ago
If brady wins one super bowl more he will prob be # 2 behind montana right now he is my num 5. brett farve aint num one because after his first super bowl he could 't get over that hurdle again and win the big game
vhrocks4 2 years ago
bull shit he is number 1, he isn't even the number one guy in the NFL right now not even number 2. ever since spygate he hasn't been the same. yeah he got hurt last year but this year he didn't do it. this is a bs list. payton is by far the smartest in the nfl and brees is fantastic as well, and if brady was so good then why isn't he the number one guy for the AFC in the pro bowl? come on he had a great streak but it is over now his career isn't as good as montana's
masonberg 2 years ago
Dan Fouts should be #1.
PancakeRemody 2 years ago
Brett Favre should be #1
TheCarpenter90 2 years ago
you got a lot of nice QB on there but tom brady 1 come on
dane199977 2 years ago
This list is pathetic. I ROFL'd at it.
tetsuyaryuji 2 years ago
Manning is only one of the best because he always has the best wide recievers in slot. And he still isn't that great he threw like 16 interceptions this year. and cool he threw alot of yards but still come on, Reggie Wayne, Pieree Garcon, Anthony Gonzalez, Austin Collie, Marvin Harrison, and probably more. They were all good/great recievers not because of Manning but because they were. IMO Philip Rivers is better. He threw for alot of yards too but not with fast recievers. And LT steals tds...
ChargersFanForLyfe 2 years ago
Fuck All You Guys Are STupid u dont compare from rings because brady didnt win the sb THE PATS DID u compare them by mvps
manning=4 manning just won his fourth jan 8 2010
brady=1
icwlover 2 years ago
@icwlover You are saying ring do not count for anything? Winning a superbowl takes a team, but so does winning mvp. You cant go winning mvp, at the qb position, with crappy receivers like Rache Caldwell, or Jabar Gaffeney. Not taking anything away from Peyton Manning, but he has had good receivers is whole career.
humantripod22 2 years ago
You know what. These kinds of debate would just turn out to be moot. For those who insist that this debate leads to something. Let's pit just one QB against one QB... without the O-line, secondaries, WRs, RBs, Coach. You know, just throw the football. Let's see who's the best.
janmichaelj 2 years ago
PatsFan4LifeKBH. your crazy. Peyton is 10 times better then tom brady. I dont care how many super bowls he has one that dont make tom brady good. Peyton is way better and brady will never be close to how good peyton is.
heat442 2 years ago
you don't care how many SB rings each one has? Isn't that what EVERY pro football player dreams of? That's what matters, winning. Not the stats.
janmichaelj 2 years ago
Dear Fantasy Football Nerds: SB rings matter - not the stats. Not saying Brady is #1 of all time - but a QB like Brady who won 3 SBs deserves a spot in the top 10 or 15. You fantasy football stats nerds are really starting to annoy people who spend time to think.
janmichaelj 2 years ago
Therefore, by your criteria, Terry Bradshaw is the greatest quarterback ever (4 Super Bowl rings).
Delphinus72 2 years ago
Joe Montana has 4 (1980s). Terry has 4 (1970s). Can you compare them? Not really, because they're in a different era. For me, Montana is the best ever. And that's my opinion. Could Manning win 4 as well? I believe so. Could Brady win 4? I believe so too, 1 left. At the moment Brady = 3 rings; Manning = 1 ring. So at the moment, he's better. Capice?
janmichaelj 2 years ago
Capice? No. Not at all. There are many criteria by which to judge athletes, including quarterbacks. If number of championship rings are the lone criteria, then Terry Bradshaw (TB) and Joe Montana (JM) are the best ever, yet we NEVER hear TB mentioned as one of the best QBs ever. He won 4 SB rings in a 6 year span. Montana won 4 over an 9-year span. Since TB won 4 in a shorter period, by YOUR criteria, he's the best ever. I guess Robert Horry = 2nd best BBall player ever: 6-7 NBA rings.
Delphinus72 2 years ago
I agree with you on that one. WTF is with you and this 'YOUR' criteria BS.. did I ever mention that its the lone category? Come on. Brady can pass - so does Manning. Both have the intangibles. You've put that one out of context with Horry in the mix. Goodness. Geez. Okay, then answer this, why oh why with Manning that great can't win more than one SB? Simple as that. The answer is: Team. Lone criteria? Where'd you get that?
janmichaelj 2 years ago
Manning only has 1 super bowl ring because he sucks in post season and chokes every year(except 2006 he got lucky that year in the sense he didn't choke for once)
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
@janmichaelj What About MVPS
icwlover 2 years ago
MVPs matter.... but that turns to lead if you can't win the whole thing for your team, doesn't it?
janmichaelj 2 years ago
this list was obviously put together by some mentally challenged bostonite. TOM Brady number 1???? DREW BLEDSOE MAKING THE LIST OF TOP 15 ALL TIME??????????????????????? COME ON.... really think brady will be doing at 40 what brett favre is doing now???? LETS GET REAL PEOPLE
bwalsh124 2 years ago
bull shit brady is NOT #1 manning is
ethan119800 2 years ago
Brady is 10 times better than manning
PatsFan4LifeKBH 2 years ago
@PatsFan4LifeKBH
Brady's not even in the top 10!! He only had that one outstanding year three years ago when he had Randy Moss (when he was still good), Dontae Stallworth, Wes Welker, and Ben Watson. Brady's not even in the same league as Montana, Dan Marino, or Peyton Manning.
Delphinus72 2 years ago
Brady's win % is 77 Manning's is 67 and Montana's is 71 and marino's is between 55-65(not sure) does that help point some things out?
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
Terry Bradshaw won 4 Super Bowls and has a 107-51 record (67.7 winning percentage) so by your criteria, I guess Terry Bradshaw is #1 or 2.
Delphinus72 2 years ago
@Pandamatrix85 yeah man straight up. delphinus.....shut up bitch
macgdynasty 1 year ago
@Pandamatrix85 No, because winning percentage is a TEAM stat, not an individual stat. Terry Bradshaw won 69% of his games, so are you saying he's better than Manning (65%) and Marino (61%)?
Delphinus72 1 year ago
@Delphinus72 you call u self a patriots fan, your not, brady has three super bowl rings and manning only has one, so brady is better
Baileylf13 1 year ago
FUCK Brady and by all means I do respect him but replace him with tarkenton and turn montana and tarkenton around then it is correct
thesuperraterman 2 years ago
FUCK OFF!!!! Brady is awesome!!!! He belongs at least in the top 5
PatsFan4LifeKBH 2 years ago
YOU FUCK OFF!!!!!!!!!! brady sucks monkey balls and peton manning is 3 times better and the only reason brady even has a superbowl ring at all is because b4 2008 they had a monster defense!
xKLUTCHKILLAx 2 years ago
are you 12 or something? 'because b4 2008 they had a monster defense' -- the point is? which Super Bowl champion doesn't have a good secondary? You need some brain cells.
janmichaelj 2 years ago
@PatsFan4LifeKBH Top 50 maybe. Top 5? NO WAY!!!
Delphinus72 2 years ago
Bledsoe? Bledsoe was the worst player in playoffs!!!!!!!!!!! and Montana is the #1 all time! no brady!
Tarkenton was a top 15 and Fouts! u need read more history
martinmxz7 2 years ago
dude i am highly pissed i mean i was gonna give u a five star raring until i saw dan marino at #8 andthe worst of it all u put troy akiman at #7 u disgust me u homo ass fucking cock sucker u can go n give troy a bj and for all i care u can roll over and fucking choke reading this comment and die!!!!! u just suck mager balls and u have a little bird n finally how can tom brady be first now come on really!!!
FootballDudification 2 years ago
brett favre my ass i mean if you were smart you would know that not all records are good i mean most interceptions of all time come on
freedomboiee20 2 years ago
As soon as I saw that Bledsoe was number 11, I knew Brady would end up number 1... Give me a break.
35walrus 2 years ago
WTF is Brady is doing at 1???? The best ever is Brett Favre closely followed by Marino, Montana, Elway THEN Brady. O and where the hell are Warren Moon and Dan Fouts????
Almaza1 2 years ago
@Almaza1 I think Peyton Manning showed Sunday night that he's better than Tom Brady, and he doesn't have Randy Moss to throw to.
Delphinus72 2 years ago
So what, Peyton has Reggie Wayne to throw to!!!
PatsFan4LifeKBH 2 years ago
umm.... WRONG!!!!! Favre is NOT i repeat NOT!!!!! #1. Brady is better than Farve, and Joe Montana is #1 with Brady at #2-#5
PatsFan4LifeKBH 2 years ago
there is no good reason to put brady at number 1
top 5 but not number 1
missionbears 2 years ago 2
what idiot made this ranking? Marino at #8... should be top 3. Montana at #2... He is by far #1!!! Bledsoe....serious?? he is on here wow!! Brady is good, but #1 no way!! Fouts needs to be in there.
jbree005 2 years ago 2
wow Namath at 14.... he shouldn't even be on her. He was an average QB. Only famous because of that prediction in SB III
jbree005 2 years ago
where is John Elway, have you never watched him play????
TNkenny 2 years ago
I never seen anything so wrong, for so many reasons in my life!
Chutzpah515 2 years ago
sorry, i meant #1,jy cutler deserves to be #1, not tom brady!!!!
NIntendoLover241 2 years ago
tom brady doesnt deserve to be 31, jay cutler does, he plays for the best team in the nfl!!!!!
NIntendoLover241 2 years ago
what is drew bedsore even on that list for because you are a pats fan maybe bedsore was good but not top 15 material.
kingers36 2 years ago
take steve young and replace him with elway and your perfect
monbo345 2 years ago
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHH WHAT!!!???!!!!!
illustratedcore 2 years ago
Bledsoe>Kelly
Oops.
DJLassic 2 years ago
Hey Panda"C word" please post what you intend to post, and be proud of it.....or not. But don't post it, then post a trail of bitch as disclaimers to show what little you know about the post that you posted prior. Does your uterus hurt now? We really don't care.
quarnyflu 2 years ago
Bledsoe in the list removes legitimacy from it. Brady as number one makes it known that you're a Pats fan with no real connection with the great QB's of the game, and lastly, no refference to the almighty Dan Fouts just makes you a fucking idiot.
quarnyflu 2 years ago
nice list but here are my top 3 of our time #1 Tom Brady #2 Peyton Manning #3 Brett Farve
pzbbs 2 years ago
Bledsoe deserves to go to the HOF but I gotta admit I missed up this video
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
YES BRADY FINALLY RECIGNIZED
NewEnglandPatsWeekly 2 years ago
Brady's been recognized* for a long time, just not in the 2008 season cause he was injured and couldn't play!
guysdave1 2 years ago
Clearly this must be a joke. to have Dan Marino and John Elway not in the top 4 is retarded, and to have Terry Bradshaw even on the list is funny . Bradshaw had like two more TDs than INTs for his career he just happened to be on a great team.
mulhulla 2 years ago
joe montana should be #1 not pretty boy tom brady. what were they thinking?must've been smoking the wacky tobacky!!!!
MrEddie5467 2 years ago
Why do you call Tom Brady a pretty boy? Why do you call it wacky tobacky? no offense, but you sound like a gay person or a faggot. Tom Brady has so many records and great accomlishments that he has to be #1, his accomplishments/records are too long to list.
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
peyton manning should be #1
doroblue 2 years ago
I can see how you may think that, but he's a post season choker, if he won back to back Super Bowls he'll be #1, but until then he's #3.
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
Brady all day
garaakiller313 2 years ago
where is kurt warner?
clubharper1 2 years ago
I messed up this list, you should look at my Top 15 Quarterbacks in NFL history video, it's about 90-95% correct, cause it's based entirely on stats, accomplishments, and ability in the clutch.
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
You fucking douchebag. How the fuck do you put Tom Brady #1? It's clearly Kelly Holcomb. Fall on a dick, homo.
JRontherim 2 years ago
FAVRE should be #1, ten times better than brady
FAVREandREDD 2 years ago
drew bledsoe better than stabauch and kelly plz are you insane
darrenderrick 2 years ago
Brady #1
TheSkillaz2 2 years ago
Staubauch was better than Aikman. I am a Niner fan and no way would i put Young four on a list. Marino is better than him. Also Namath has no business being on this least. He is one of the more overrated players of all time. By the way "guydaves" is a fucken idiot.
Niners8016 2 years ago
I agree Namath is overrated, also Terry Bradshaw is overrated, look at his stats if you don't believe me. Also, yeah, "guydaves" is an idiot. Young has a higher TD pass percentage than every other great quarterback in NFL history, and has a pretty low interception pass percentage, in other words young is an underrated passer. Young is the best overall quarterback in NFL history, but in terms of passing talent he's #4. Staubach was a better QB cause he could run but Aikman was a better passer.
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
I know Bradshaw is overated and so is Namath i know my football haha. But ya Young is the man i know that. I really don't think he is number 4 but he is top 10. Aikman also had a way better team than Staubauch ever did. He also had an amazing line back in the Nineties.
Niners8016 2 years ago
I think that your right, Aikman did have a better team for several years, so yeah Staubach is better. Thanks for pointing that out. Young may not be #4 but he is at least top five. Is there anything else you would like to point out, just asking cause I'm going to make a new top ten QBs of all-time video pretty soon.
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
terry bradshaw is better then tom brady
jallop 3 years ago
Whoa! Hold it! Roger Staubach WAYYYY better than Drew Bledsoe!! better than terry bradshaw! Better than Dan Marino! Better than Brett Favre! Better than John Elway! Better than Steve Young! Better than Joe Montana! And WAYYY better than Tom Brady!!!
Troy Aikman #1!
Peyton Manning #2!
Roger Staubach #3!
Do your research!!!!
guysdave1 3 years ago
You don't know your stuff, sorry dude but I'll leave it at that.
Pandamatrix85 3 years ago
Wow, if you knew me, you'd know I know EVERYTHING about this stuff! Football is like my life! I know more about it than most people! So why don't you shut the fuck up and watch your gay Tom Brady!
guysdave1 3 years ago
Dude, football is my life, I think that I know what I'm talking about. But we probably value different attributes and abilities differently so that's why it's debateable.
Pandamatrix85 3 years ago
Everybody has different opinions!
guysdave1 3 years ago
Troy Aikmen was overrated he had stars all around him thts y he had those SB's not cuz he was the best ever but i agree Brady is not the best
bobbarker030 2 years ago
how am i not surprised you put tom brady as #1
LaihoValo9 3 years ago
nononononononon. dan marino is no 1......:-)) only dan..gogogogogogogogogog
poprad81 3 years ago
ass hole tom brady is the numb 1 stupid
bollllllllla 3 years ago
this is the best top 15 ive seen, but bledsoe doesnt belong
philliyfanbo 3 years ago
I think that Bledsoe deserves to be here, he's in the top ten or twenty in just about every career passing statistic, I think he should make the hall of fame but not first ballot though.
Pandamatrix85 3 years ago
stats r overrated. i honestly think that mcnabb is a better qb then bledsoe. but most ppl would disagree becuz he didnt put up the same kinda stats bledsoe did. and dont tell me im biased becuz im an eagles fan. he led then to 5 conference games and a super bowl wheres bledsoe only took thm to 1 super bowl
philliyfanbo 3 years ago
Donovan Mcnabb is better I agree, but he also had a better team. The Patriots won a lot of games with Bledsoe even though the whole team(other than Bledsoe and Vinatieri) was pathetic. You take away Bledsoe from the Pats when he was their quarterback and they would have a top 5 draft pick every season. As for Mcnabb he has a good team, he has a fast defense that likes to blitz a lot and he has Westbrook. So true Mcnabb may be better but let's a wait a few years before i put him on this list.
Pandamatrix85 3 years ago
Bledsoe! What a joke!!!!!
menashaTE89 3 years ago
WORST top 15 EVER!!! Tom Brady is overrated and dosent belong in the top ten. Marino and Favre belong it to 3!!!
menashaTE89 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Man, I'm a Pats' fan but, I don't think Brady better than Montana.
unit89012 3 years ago
Comment removed
unit89012 3 years ago
Did you throw a bunch of QB pictures up in the air and used the order they landed? OR are you a Detroit Lions fan? Your list is 0 & 15 yes it is! You must be a patriots fan the cheaters have three super bowls because of that spy gate bullshit the first super bowl they choke it up to the Giants.
MikeAndolini 3 years ago
ES UNA REBERENDA BASURA GARBASH
LIJANDRODARK5 3 years ago
joe is best
willieparker13 3 years ago
u have no criteria at all...why brady 1st? Steve and John above Marino?
patraulpunk 3 years ago
Brady's #1, he had 50 TD passes only 8 picks, he could have had 60 TD passes if he wanted to. Also prior to his injury he was on pace to beat Elway's record for career 4th quarter comebacks. His record with a lead at any time in the 4th quarter of a regular season game is 85-1. But most important of all he has the highest career win percentage of any quarterback in the Super Bowl era.
Pandamatrix85 3 years ago
Bradshaw, but not Stabler?
baayboii 3 years ago
Tom Brady sucks nuts. Roll video.
Where's Fouts loser. Best Qb not best team Qb.
jkr1433 3 years ago
putting steve young and troy aikman ahead of dan marino is also retarded
festwhore2 3 years ago
1 more Super Bowl, then Brady will be the best of all time.
Hatter14 3 years ago
tom brady NO#1? fuck that,and what the hell is drew bledsoe doing anywhere near this list?must be a patriots fan.
festwhore2 3 years ago
roger staubach and troy aikman are the best r u people high!!!!!COWBOYS 4 EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!
curdogz99 3 years ago
bradys not 1
ssbbFREAK7 3 years ago
this is good but marino is better 6than brady and aikman and montana and young and manning and elway i mean brady should be more like 4 but this is the best ive ever seen so far
tombradygangster 3 years ago
brady will be #1 when all is said and done thats for sure
and even though manning hasnt won multiple SBs, hes still on that list for sure. not #2 though.
VictoryRoad04 3 years ago
this list is beyond laughable.
hovde4 3 years ago
Tom Brady should be more like 5th.
fbfan12 3 years ago
no no no no! u got it wrong for the most part
dasaintsrcomin95 3 years ago
Winning makes great QBS,nos stats. Jim Kelly? He went 0-4 in superbows, he wasnt a winner, same goes for marino, great Qb with great stats but surely winning championships is the true measure of a great QB. The truly great WINNING Quarterbacks have won 3+ championships ie- Bradshaw, Montana, Brady,Starr etc. That is surely the what matters most,not passing yards,tds etc. They guys are great stastistic quarterbacks but not WINNING ones. I bet u marino would gladly swap stats for rings.
darrenn438 3 years ago
Drew Bledsoe over Dan Fouts?!
GN988 3 years ago
wow horrible ratings brady should be 2 and manning should be 1
nipun2345 3 years ago
screw you manning always had good recivers around him to help him and the one year that brady got descent recivers he basically was unstoppable back there throwing for more then 50 tds
hamid525 3 years ago
marino should be number 2. namath is overated as hell theres no way he deserves to be up there
richgannonrocks 3 years ago
thank you this vid. is better than your 10 thanks no Brady haters yes!
tombradygangster 3 years ago
It's frustrating to see Marino at number 8. All the quartebacks ahead of him with rings had running backs. Marino was all by himself with basically no running game for his entire career. He has a better arm and was just as accurate if not more than any quarterback on this list.
Soniaspapa 3 years ago
Whats with all the Brady Hate. IMO he is great because he had 4 different receiving core and only this year he had a lot of talent at receiver but even with troy brown and David Patten he still managed to beat my team The Steelers every year. And he led his team to the AFC Championship with Reche Caldwell as his number 1 receiver no other QB in NFL has has played great with 4 different receiving corps thats why he is number 1
IronMan50780 3 years ago
manning should be lower and elway higher and farve higher
ELIMANNINGSUKZ 3 years ago