Added: 3 years ago
From: Onegin65
Views: 22,539
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (37)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • How this written aria could be sung? And so brilliantly!

  • MARAVILLOSA !!!

  • A beautiful interpretation

  • i just hear the interpretation of Leontyne Price and Joan Sutherlan, all magnificent but i like better Joan´s version

  • BRAVISSIMA!!!!! La voix du siècle!!!

  • que dire de plus que cette grande Dame a toujours chantée avec une classe et un sérieux extraordinaire,encore merci à Madame Caballe

  • I love Miss Price on this, but here Madame Caballe is seriously good, wonderful!

  • I cannot understand who anybody could possibly dislike this rendition?? At present there are 8 people who don't like...

  • Clearly the finest rendition of one of Verdi's most treacherous arias (if not the most longest). It requires extremely wide vocal range, rapid register changes, notorious arppegio-like flexibility at the top of the stave, and excruciating coloratura articulation. Only Caballe manages the written notes a tempo, without the elephantine rallentandi of certain other famous sopranos -- and maintains beautiful tonal quality at every instant. A stupendous example of the art of singing.

  • You can sing Rosa Ponselle sing Ernani on youtube, too, and it's remarkable. Not to take away from Caballe, because I love Monserrat.

  • The best Ernani Involami I've ever heard!

  • it's my surname!

  • wonderful singing.... Shes amazing

  • La Caballé degli anni sessanta era davvero brava e musicalmente a posto. Cosa che puertroppo non si può dire di quella successiva, che in pratica si riscriveva la parte dalla prima all'ultima nota!

  • To bestmaster3

    What you say aren't truth. Sutherlan never sang Ernanion stage nor in no production.; only she recorded for Decca in 1985. Caballe recorded for RAI Ernani in 1968; only sang this opera onstage in one production: San Francisco 1984, five performances.

  • Comment removed

  • I don't agree, Caballe makes the best coloratura here, even than the Sutherland's recording on sixty.

    Freni never could make coloraturas and generally all Verdi is outside his fach; in several interviews she herself declared that sung Ernani was one of his great errors.

    Leontyne Price, of course, has the most suitable voice to sing all the score.

  • @lrmusica I like Miss Caballe; however, this aria is Miss Price's and no one could touch her in her prime.  So, I agree with you the entire aria seems as though it were written specifically for her and she performs it magnificiently.

  • Seriously, if you have those high pianissimi ... what difference? :D

  • Siempre una leccion de canto. Gracias Montserrat

  • I think She isn't too bad, even if the better version of this aria is obviosely from Maria Callas

  • Great interpreation - love her voice.

  • Bellissima giovane voce

  • Very nice. The whole performance (with Christoff and Prevedi) was very good.

  • Interesting that she transposes this down at this early stage in her career... still, a brilliant recording.

  • That is interesting, I'm glad you mentioned it. I have no answer...let me know if you come up with something.

  • This is not transposed down - it's in the right key. I have LP and CD versions of this performance - the CD is 1/2 step high!

  • Que buenisima! Una diesa de canciones.

  • extraordinaria Montserrat

  • One of the most beautiful voices in history dear.

  • Simply marvellous.

  • she enchants with her voice, the best and most natural I have ever heard...

  • one of the greatest voices ever recorded... many thanks for post.

  • Grandiosa como siempre Montserrat Caballe.

  • I am not Madame C's greatest fan but find it impossible not to like her here.

  • @lungdoc They are envious, fans of another singer who can not appreciate art as a whole

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more