Added: 5 years ago
From: frosthead55
Views: 172,631
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,068)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • so what the fuck happened to her behind the door?

  • 0.46 XP sound?

  • I defy anybody to not feel a string of emotion when watching this scene, videogaming at its best, truly brilliant.

  • I'm not gonna lie: I cried so hard after this I totally forgot to feel scared. This is the great, great thing about Japanese storytelling in general: When done right, it understands that what REALLY freaks people out isn't dim lighting or dudes in masks or buckets of blood. It's seeing human weakness and regret being exposed, manifested and finally punished.

  • FUCK U HARRY !! OMG I WOULD HOLD HER SO TIGHT WHILE CRYING SO FUCKING HARD AS SHE DIES BETWEEN MY ARMS :'(

    and yes i'm a girl and i love lisa

  • Lisa's<3

  • Gonna buy myself this game again, to witness this part - Most saddest part in any SH game :(

  • This is one of the creepiest parts of the game. Especially in the cutscene.

  • WHY IS IT A CUTSCENE? AHHHHHHH STOP BLEEDING!!!!!!

  • this scene broke my heart... it's okay, though. silent hill games just do that to me. I'm used to it. T-T

  • Haven't even played this game, but even I find this scene sad.

  • Poor Lisa, in silent hill 3 she appears as the fukuro getting messed up. Vaitel is such a torturer!

  • that's some fucked up shit! Konami really makes scary things!

  • its strong

    

  • Comment removed

  • didn't really understand why does she died :x

    anyone explain ?

  • @noklip com on dude she was already dead but she didnt kno thats it.......

  • @noklip i dont know either

  • @noklip

    Well ok! Lisa died a while ago before the events of this game. But Alessa kept her alive because she remembers Lisa as a kind care giver. But then Harry uses the flourose on Alessa, which saps her powers. And because Alessa doesn't have her powers, she can't keep Lisa alive, therefore she dies.

  • lol Lisa was a loser in life and a drug addict. She couldn't handle looking after Alessa Gillespie and wanted to quit, which was selfish of her, but she continued her job as long as she could have the drugs like a typical junkie. If Harry were approached by a fat ugly man crying and wanting a hug most of you porobably would not care if he ran away lol. People can be very selective about what is "moral" and "understandable" ahaha!

  • nostalgic game, beautiful and sad scene

  • Comment removed

  • me too

  • i cried ...

  • that makes me cry :( when blood come down her face and the music with the lisa makes me cry :(

  • I freaking loved Lisa :( I actually cried when she died. X(

  • The way she says "Stay by my side, Harry. Please..." just makes my heart fill with sorrow. :(

  • Remake this game

  • The song that plays when she dies is what adds a bunch of sadness too

  • The music just makes it 10x more heartbreaking.

    My eyes are just abit sweaty okay!

  • you know, this would be really sad if this game had better graphics for this scene

  • @midgerm

    This game came out in 1999, These graphics were amazing back then

  • THIS IS A FUCKING VIDEO GAME!!! RIP-OFF!!!

  • 0:56 WTF?

  • she is already dead she died in silent hill origions i think kaufman killed her

  • Comment removed

  • I played this game both on Sony Playstation 1 and on PC and its one hell of a good game. It brings back such good memories when I was little and even now when I see this scene I feel like I'm gonna cry. Why dont they make games like this anymore?

  • @BojanSrdanovic BECAUSE GOOD GRAPHIX ARE MORE IMPORTANT!

  • @BojanSrdanovic because, they are so many assholes that say: Good graphics are most important!

    But IT IS NOT! As well I LOVE this graphic. there is a difference between OLD graphic and shitty and unkind graphic!!! And the Story, the music, the characters, the gameplay all these are things that constitute a good video game! And exact this game has the best of it all! And if a GAME can make someone cry I would say thats better than only a quaint old game! sorry but youtube give me no more tags LG

  • @BojanSrdanovic because, they are so many assholes that say: Good graphics are most important!

    But IT IS NOT! As well I LOVE this graphic. there is a difference between OLD graphic and shitty and unkind graphic!!! And the Story, the music, the characters, the gameplay all these are things that constitute a good video game! And exact this game has the best of it all! And if a GAME can make someone cry I would say thats better than only a quaint old game! sorry but youtube give me no more tags LG

  • @Kakalake95

    I agree. Silent Hill is one hell of a good game, specially cuz I played it as a kid and it used to scare the shit outta me. Its got a great story and a CREEPY atmosphere. Also, Resident Evil 2 and 3 are great games too, I used to play them too as a kid. Yup, my childhood wasnt very bright heehehe. Anyways, thanks for response and I like the way you think. Peace mate!

  • @BojanSrdanovic sprichst du deutsch?

  • @BojanSrdanovic sprichst du deutsch?

  • @Kakalake95

    Ich nein sprichst Deutch. I am from Bosnia and Herzegovina.

  • How can one push kill someone?

  • YOU'RE TEARING ME APART, LISA!

  • @CharlesXavier aaaaaAAAAAAAAAAAAHAHAHAHAAAA!!­!! THAT IS FUCKING BRILLIANT! Absurd but simply perfect and wonderful "The Room" reference thoroughly appretiated!

  • jesus at 1:40 listen with headphones omfg that scared the shit outta me, its the middle of the night and im the only one awake

  • If I was stranded in a creepy town fighting for my life against demonic creatures only to come this far to hear "I'm the same as them"I would have pointed my gun at her head and said "Oh hell to the fuckin no!Bitch are you serious!?Get the fuck away from me!"

  • Not Tomorrow..

  • Harry uses Jedi force push at 0:55

  • I would have at least comforted her...with my gun in the other hand of course.

  • saddest moment in all SH games

  • Beautifully Grim :)

  • Definitely the saddest death in the whole series. Not even Harry's death was this sad.

  • @stevenn33 oh ok thanks :)

  • im not crying theres something in my eye!

  • this is probably the saddest thing i ve ever seen

  • i thought someone was knocking on my wall

  • @Boi1o1 so did I

  • Can someone please explain this scene to me? I've never played Silent Hill before. (I'm a wimp lol) What's happening to Lisa? And who's Harry?

  • @amandaletsplays99 Harry is the hero of Silent Hill 1. Lisa became a monster because she is dead long time before the game. It is diffucilt to explain this. Play the game, he is giant.

  • best scene of the whole silent hill series

  • Comment removed

  • So what happened with her?

  • @aLvianne7 In a nutshell, she was already dead like the other monstrous nurses in the hospital, but she didn't realize it until this scene. There's a lot more to it than that, but you'd have to play the game to find out the whole story.

  • this scene was definitely the saddest one i ever saw. thing i wonder tho, if harry didnt push her away like that and just hugged or something, would she have turned into an evil nurse anyway? and what happen if you try to go back in the room once the cutscene end? do you fight her?

  • @trackmort007

    No, you don't fight her. She's gone, though she shows up in the final cutscene if you save Dr. Kaufman. If you return to the room you'll find a diary, which was most likely written by her...before she...ughm...died.

    It's doubtful she would have been anything but an evil nurse. To be fair I think she would have eventually strangled Harry or bit his neck if he'd have accepted her attention. And apparently Harry felt the same way.

  • @Mirhaus I'm not sure she's evil in the game. I think, Alessa remembers she like a gentle, good nurse. So she's only mutated... Or i think so.

    Sorry for bad english XD

  • @Mirhaus

    I'm not so sure if she would have turned "evil" if Harry had accepted her. I think harry was the only one who "could" save her. She isn't really dead, since she has a physical body and her soul still lives with a clear mind. She even refers to herself as being alive, while the rest are dead. Heck, if in Silent hill 2 that guy can leave the town with a dreamed up version of his dead wife, then Harry could save Lisa.

  • @Katnipkity some people think lisa is actually dead or something, becose in the original game, she only appeared in alessa´s nightmare world, not the real world, then she could be just a imagination of alessa. im not sure cose lost memoryes book doesnt say it

  • Thats actually pretty sad. It sounded like he said 'im sorry' around the end.

  • if i was harry i would have spill some of the aglaophotis on her s doesnt havent to turn besides how much do u need cause in silent hill 3 heather/chyrle(crap dont know how 2 spell) only used like a tiny bit of it in the necklace so it should be that much to use to free lisa and cybil from the bad stuffs

  • @sorafbi1000

    She was already dead, and they are in the other world. Lisa only lives in the other world, she can't live in the real world cuz she's already dead man.

  • @sorafbi1000

    What MasterCheif said. Plus Harry had used the elixir on Cybil already, there was none left to give to Lisa. LIsa's not a case fixed by simple exorcism, she's basically a zombie who forgot she died.

  • My next silent hill short film is going to be based around this scene :)

  • save me from them.please, harry?

    pushes her away* DENIED!

  • @midgerm u 4got the last 3 words

    LIKE A BOSS

    hahahahaa

  • amo a Lisa y amo ese video juego

  • Is it bad if this makes me cry?

  • @DevilRiseS4 it makes me cry too :(

  • Actually,it looks like Harry killed her by pushing her...

  • iv never played this game, how did she die?

    

  • Fuck Thaattt

  • lol she had one bad PMS.

  • I felt sad at this part, even though she was kinda already dead, it was kinda sad

  • To save my daughter, I would have pushed her away, too.

  • I felt so sad when reaching this scene... :'-/ In SH2 it was even worse when I came to the "water ending"... :'-0

  • like sonic the hedgehog would say; "up over and GONE!"

  • kinda spooky

  • I'm not saying its a must, and its just my opinion but to me playing Gretchen Ross from the Donnie Dark OST when it fades into the scene where she starts bleeding makes it so much sadder. Then again, that's just my opinion.

  • I have to admit.. *sniff* I teared up a bit. V-V

  • yellowbellyheart.I won't do what you say.You could Be killed By Lisa don't you Think.Think First Before You Do it.If I were You Harry.I would Kill Lisa.

  • Harry do that Because Lisa is a Monster now.He needs to keep away from monster.Harry Will Die if He Stay with Lisa.Harry wants to find Her Daughter.Not a Wife.Lisa is Monster so Harry Don't Want Lisa.Harry is Sad because He don't want Lisa to Die.It's Harry's Fault because he Goes to Silent Hill.But this Part is Sad.

  • Omg,I'm depressed now. :c

  • I just got curious what this was in the video Silent Hilol.

  • shoot her, put her out of her misery

  • I'll never forget my reaction to this scene, never. 

  • best game ever with a very touching scene

  • am i the only person that thinks the song of healing from majoras mask would be perfect here?

  • you guys Lisa changes after harry pushes her though! she might have kept her humanity if it wasn't for him. i would have hugged her and cried with her and tolled her it would be okay. she was a great character. my fave!!! i cry when i watch it i cant stand that i have to do that to Lisa in the game! it makes me not want to Finnish it!! I'm so far in though but idk but Lisa shouldn't have died she was amazing!!!!! R.I.P Lisa | also i love the song not tomorrow beautiful!

  • His action, well... logical, and common sense isn't it?

    But still, he such an asshole. Can he open the door and check her for a second?

    Poor Lisa, she suffered a lot in her lifetime, and not even allowed to rest in peace.

  • @cuteaki Don't worry. She gets her revenge.

  • that scene is one of the most perfect scenes in video game history. im serious

  • so darn sad man!

  • Lisa:owww(bleeds)

    harry:err..... im leaving(leaves)

    lisa:Harry! im not dead! im just bleeding

    harry:(screams and runs and actualy bumped in to cheryl)

  • i love how the game graphics look bad NOW but the cut scenes are so detailed. if they had the technoligy to make the cut scenes look good how come they didnt do that in the gameplay? please dont troll me.

  • @mrbigmacchomper You clearly have no understand of how graphic design, programming, or hardware works.

  • @mrbigmacchomper

    Because the PSX(playstation 1) hardware or any other console from the 90's couldn't handle that type of graphic. and before you say something similar to "but it could handle the cutscenes or then why it show the cutscenes?". It's because is actually not running the graphic of the cutscene, it's just running a video included in the cd.

  • @BaadRichie thanks didnt know :)

  • god, out of the 70 or so times i've finished this game, this scene never fails to bring a chill down my spine. its so sad :[

  • you guys are like "harry was a bitch" in this scene, but think about it, if your friend started to spas out begging for you to stay, WHILE she bled out of her hair, nose, eyes, and mouth, would you stay and kill your friend (who had just turned into a zombie no less) or run away without trying to harm her?

  • not much of a transformation like the others she only bleed out of every hole in her body

    feel sorry for her though

  • I tried so damn hard to save her.

  • I tried so damn hard to save her.

  • poor lisa!

  • People can be kinda stupid sometimes. Imagine yourself in Harry's situation, looking at a friend. She tells you that she's 'one of them', and comes at you with open arms as she begins the transformation process. After the hell you've been put through, wouldn't you also be terrified out of your wits? Wouldn't you shove the monster away from you, and run away when she suddenly charged you with blood pouring over her?

    I'll bet every single person on this page would have done the exact same thing.

  • @Silme037 Wow that´s a very good comment...thanks for that =D i never took it like that...

  • @Silme037 For the record sir/ma'am, you totally kick ass. ;] Great point!

  • @1dbad haha, thank you ^_^ (it's ma'am, btw :P)

  • @Silme037 You're welcome! ^_^ And oh my bad, ma'am. :P

  • @1dbad hahaha, np :)

  • @Silme037 not me i would let her hug me so i can snap her fucking neck nah im not horrible

  • @Silme037 I agree that's what I've been saying but some ignorant people disagreed with me.

  • @Silme037 Yay i agree with you

  • @Silme037

    Thank you! They act like we are supposed stand there and hug Lisa with open arms. If I see anybody transforming with blood all over themself and anybody stumbling towards me like the walking dead. I would have got the fuck out of there too.

  • @Silme037 EXACTLY. Its easy to say that what Harry did was heartless, considering that were not in that same situation.

  • @Silme037 I would've ran :\

  • @Silme037 I whould have killed her :P

  • @Silme037 Yeah, he's visibly disturbed that he's abandoning her, but he does what's neccessary and if he did hug her, well the game would be much shorter wouldn't it? All in all, this series has some of the saddest moments I've seen in video games.

  • @Silme037 thats true, and you can even hear harry saying "I'm sorry..."

  • @Silme037 lol damn straight, fuck AWAY from me woman!

  • @cjjtheone haha XD

  • @Silme037 i would have ran id be to scared to touch her D:

  • @Silme037 i would have spread the wierd elixar on her

  • @Silme037 And also , would you prefer to kill you friend or just run away?

    What Harry did makes perfect sense.

  • @MomocoGOTT exactly. ;)

  • @Silme037 ... Empathy. Watch Soul Eater, the moment when Maka hugs Chrona at their battle. I wouldn't act like Harry. I'd act like Maka.

  • @Silme037 I agree. I would have down the same thing in that situation. It doesn't stop me from tearing up when I watch this scene.

  • @yamakagesama of course, it's such a tragic scene, who doesn't get emotional when they first watch it?

  • @Silme037

    You act like she's saying "I'm transforming Harry.." She was scared, and completely human when she approached Harry for console. It was when he rejected her that she lost her humanity, and began to transform. So if you're asking me if I would help out a scared girl who's been nothing but kind to me yes, I would.

  • @Katnipkity But you have to remember the situation Harry was in, he was focusing on survival rather than being sympathetic. She would have transformed whether he comforted her or not. He's just human, and he was just as equally terrified. It's nice you'd stay with her but you can't think what Harry did was insensitive. What he did was human.

  • @Silme037

    I can understand that he was scared, but she had helped him, and she just needed someone to hold her. The small part of him that was frightened ignored the fact that she was a scared and he chickened out.

  • @Silme037 This is a debate of morals vs logic, and in this case the moral obligation to help her was much larger than the tad part of logic that told alerted him of possible danger. That's why we call someone a chicken when they don't want to go on a scary ride because of the possible, and logical chance of an accident.

  • @Katnipkity good point.

  • At Least Eileen can be saved.

  • i want to cry every time i watch this scene, harry did the right thing

  • some one tell me wat happend cuss i dont get it is she bleeding cuss harry pushed her or sum thin?

  • @mrleoui9s Well...everybody in the Town is dead but their "ghost presence" is still haunting the city...like the zombie nurses and doctors in the hospital. Lisa, (like she says in the beggining of this scene ) , didnt noticed that she was dead too just like the others...When Lisa realizes she is dead, she desperates and begs Harry for help, mutating in a "Haunted form" just like the hospital employees...thus...she bleeds because she is a disturbing "ghost presence".

  • so sad

  • ALL TIME FAVORITE SCENE IN A VIDEO GAME.

  • harry, you asshole! you don't shove a woman forceably into a wall!

  • That's a shame. I'm playing homecoming now and it's depressing as well... Oh well :(

  • imagine your having sex with her and that happens fuck!!!!!!!

  • sad :(

  • I don't know much about silent hill, but harry seems like kind of a jerk.

  • What the fuck Harry? He acted like she was a zombie trying to bite him.

  • @LamentOfInnocence1 she probably would have turned him into a zombie so he would have ended up staying with her, he did the smart thing!

  • @daywalkerknight2000

    BUT SHES NOT A ZOMBIE

  • @LamentOfInnocence1 well whatever my point is she was BEYOND saving!I would have done the same thing he did.

  • @daywalkerknight2000

    Oh for fucks sake, just look at MrTouchShrieks comment. The highest rated one.

  • @LamentOfInnocence1 Harry did the best thing...read tyeelkins comment, explains a lot :)

  • @LamentOfInnocence1 They're not zombies. This is not Resident Evil. They're "Monsters", Evil beings summoned by Dahlia. How the fuck are you confusing them with zombies ?

  • @raven66614

    Read my comment, I obviously wasn't, I was saying Harry acted as if she was.

  • i hate harry and she was all over harry so i dont get it and i do get it -_-

  • I was scared when I come back to this room O_o ! And how Lisa dissapeared ??

  • It's funny how this death scene is so tragic, and yet, she's not really "dead"... just... zombie-nurse-ified....

  • HARRY YOU ASSHOLE

  • I'd run away too ...-_- honestly I would run, but I would try to shoot her first, mercy-kill her...

    Even if I ran and slammed the door I would probably make myself open it again, if only to kill her. -_-

    It's sad...

  • I'd stay to try to help and if worst came to worst I'd just have to kill her, I wouldent want to but it would seem like the only way or just dith her if she tryes to murder me

  • Why is she dying?