RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr space BAD!!!. monster floating in endless time. Where am I? or am I ?. ground control to Major Fukstein
There was actually a time, when people could understand art without being under weed or having drunk alkohol. Neither did they use the obscene word "jizz", to describe their positive feel about something...
after I witnessed him travelling through space through another dimension.. I remember he walked across a white tilted floor, saw an old man and finally saw the black object. As the movie neared the end, he was lying in bed and that was the moment my eyes shut, fell down and passed away. I woke up in the morning, not remembering what happened, I got up drank lots of water and looked at the screen, and it said.. 'End' and I was like wtf.. rewinded and it all made sense again.. I never exper it aga
Man I remember my roomate went home for the weekend and others too so I decide to watch this movie. I drank so much vodka, so i was like, eh let's watch it. First i wasn't amused when I witnessed the flying spaceship because it took so long for it finally land but finally I was watching him talking to the computer. I remember I passed out on the floor when he was fixing the computer. I got up 10 minutes later, sat on my chair, and there i saw it, magicail lights everywhere, left, right, oh my go
How can you tell if it's art or not if we all have our own preferances and tastes, you can't argur against those.. just wondering if anyone knows the answer?
No words to truly describe this, I once sat in the sun by a loch in Scotland listening to this and it brought tears to my eyes it was so beautiful and life affirming....
To diy, start the echoes track a slit second before the Jupiter... title appears. i time it be keeping the volume up on the original track. After dave fades, the audio continues, fades, then is abruptly cut. A split second (wait for it!) after that, unpause the Echoes track. If your cd player doesn't it may be slow by some few ms, but should be fine.
you got it right if the 3rd ping hits right after the Jupiter title cuts to the starfield.
Wow... This is... outstandingly beautiful and amazing. The build-up and raw emotion is absolutely breath taking. And thank you, @jusblaze99 for your explanation, which has helped me better understand and enjoy this short clip (as I have not seen the movie).
Hey guys I just uploaded this video in 3 parts set to Shine On You Crazy Diamond (live version recorded in LA 1975). It fits really well. Check it out it`s on my channel! :)
It's the first time I hear the original Meddle version. The only one I had ever heard up to this day is the Echoes: The Best Of Pink Floyd version (modified to reduce the lenght or something) which is simply not as good.
Dave Bowman was drawn into the monilith and transformed into a new "God?/perfected being?" he then (in 2031? I think) created a new mini solar system out of Juipter and her moons.
Basically, from what i have read, the monolith brought the main character to an expanded phase of the evolution of the self- beyond the physical, into a timeless godlike being. What we see in the final phases of the movie indicate two things: His timelessness (him seeing his older self), and formlessness
(the way he travels the cosmos and the starbaby at the end). ALSO, it seems like Kubrick wanted THIS MOVIE to be a shift in the VIEWER'S evolution (the movie screen being "our" monolith, and the close up shots of his eye ALSO being the eye of the movie watcher-
both astonished by the evolution they are witnessing). FINALLY his understanding of the limitedness of reality, (this realization is expressed by the old version in the bed ALMOST touching the monolith, IF the screen were 2D, which it is to the viewer, and is also 2D to him once he realizes that his reality is finite- a movie.)
Pink Flloyd = One of a kind. Whether you think they are weird, good, or evil; you gotta admit they did some amazing things with sound... and had their very own. Pure genius
Too soon. So many musicians die so young. Seems to me the only vocation that has a shorter life span is high lead logging... but them who make it to 55 usually good for antoher 30 years
pink floyd is satanic in no way. and yea maybe that comment wont make any sense if you arent familiar with pink floyd's ideas and ways of expressing them. which now i can see you arent. i quoted that few sentences from the song ''breathe'' because for me it fitted the comment you posted. on how artists usually young, not only artists but people that stand out in general, or ''ride the biggest wave''. Pink Floyd are true geniuses, and not only musically.
If you watch 2010, then read 3001 (both of which I highly recommend) you see that Dave has joined with the entity. This might be that process or his enlightenment. The completion of his life may have been a gift like hipro suggests.
There's def the implication that humanity is experiencing another step or jump in evolution thanks to this entity.
thanks for replying.i can understand what you mean,the monolith gave the primates intelligence at beginning of film,to what you said.definately widens your mental horizons thinking about all of that!!!peace!!!
Kubrick was known for not following the themes of the books he was making films of, lending his own philisophical meaning to interpretation, it's probably why he refused to film 2010. So I would say that the plot of the later books is not as relevant.
The parts where it shows him getting older and older rapidly is him coming to terms with the end of his life. His human body is fragile and was destroyed when he went through the monolith. Like the part where he breaks the glass only to look up to see himself on his deathbed. In order to become the starchild at the end he had to give up all parts of his old life.
Each time I watch this vid, I wonder how on Earth it is possible to have such an amazing imagination... Can we call this imagination? I don't even think so, this movie and this music are made by the greatest band ever and a genius of the cinema., they just are... PERFECT...
I think the ending is symbolic of: The Room is obtaining of things we thought were important yet are worthless because we can't take them with us. He is alone because all our lives we are on own spiritual and intellectual journey and nobody can come with us. WE are always looking forward only to look back when we get to where we are. In the end he looks forward one last time and can no longer see himself. There is nothing left. Might the monolyth represent nothing? He then dies and beomes ???
Ok, Iguess so...but ca,n you help for the meaning of those scenes: Comandant in his space clothes, getting in a room finding himself quite older having a meal, getting more older laying in a bed... the monolyth standing in his bedroom...and finally a space baby getting closer to Earth...ouch, I'm a little bit lost for the meaning. Any Idea that could make it clearer for me ?
Well its like this, Bowman comes in contact with the Jupiter monolith which ends up bringing him in and just like the aliens that invented the monoliths Bowman reaches the final stage of human evolution where he becomes a bodyless being that flows with the universe and his final journey is his journey into the monolith and although its not specified i believe the aging process with the monolith is his final stages in life right before becoming the "starchild".
Thanx alot scarface for your answer and your interpretation. "becoming the starchild" perhaps does it also mean that life is some kind of eternal cycle of borning, getting older dieing and re-borning.... Anyway, thank you for sharing your point.
Its my pleasure really im fascinated with the movies and books and since Pink Floyd is one of my favorite bands this is like hitting the jackpot i think many would agree that "Echoes" sounds better than the original soundtrack of this video
The song synchs with the change of scenes and emotions so well, and they both end at the exact same time. I don't even think I'd believe the band if they said themselves they didn't deliberately do it. Floyd's keepin some secrets man!
It would be hard for them to intentionaly set the film to music as VCR's were not popular in the past. Betamax wasn't either. Not that its out of the realm of possibilities though.
They could've had a reel of the film and a projector. I'm usually a skeptic of most off-the-wall theories but the two just synch so much. Who knows though
i agree ... in my opinion, echoes is the most intrigating song ever...it has a perfect harmony between the song and the video ... it's just perfect...AMAZING...David gilmour ...best guitar player ever...
Had a the VCR version - a very long time ago and in fact still have it in all pristine glory - as it should be. I love the moment after the guitar wailing etc that Rick drops inn with his his keyboard skills - the whole piece is about 23/24 minutes long in its entirety.Meddle - love it.
yeah...rick...was a big lost...we'll miss him a lot... i try not to think but, i can't see how will be whem david's time arrive... it will be a very cool day...
The writer of the phantom of the opera Lloyd Webber stole it for sure. The phantom was made after echoes and it has the same exact notes and time signature. Even roger waters writes about it in a song saying that webber is an assholl
"We live we die and death not ends it"-Jim Morrison
And that applies for all religions and all people.Reincarnation,Heaven,Hell,Purgatory call it whatever you want.I've finally understood that all we're being prepared for in school,the so called "life" is actually a synonim for survival which is at least stupid if you ask me cause most people survive to nothing.They get up in the morning to a job they don't enjoy,they eat,they sleep and die.I know I'd rather live a day and enjoy a life of love
they actually said they made this song to this movie, they were supposed to do the soundtrack to the movie and they got rejected so they did the song to it for that reason...
You got it the other way around man, Kubrick asked them to make the music for the film and Pink Floyd rejected it, later Waters stated that he regrets it.
Either way, it's amazing. God. I wish they had the clips of Dorothy and the House in the Tornado on it's way to Oz for "Great Gig in the Sky" on the Pulse tour.
floyd knew as much as A C Clark and Kubrick big change was coming up, this was made wasnt it in the late 60's, during the great pluto uranus conjunct
coming up again around 2012, this time a square, synched with the mayan shift, the galatix 26,000 year cycle and americas 6 year great pluto death and rebith transits from 2009 - 2015
Wow metalguy you can actually prove that certain artists are better than others, that's amazing. Can you do me a favour then? To settle an argument, would you be able to tell me who is better Debussy, Dolly Parton or Adam and The Ants.
the begginning is awesome...
victorviku 10 months ago
FANTÁSTICO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
luiz270977 11 months ago
mir gefällt es sehr gut.
nicosa01 1 year ago
I fuckin' cried at the end. Holy shit, that was fucking beautiful.
MoonBarrett 1 year ago 2
if you think the first movie's cool, try the rest of the story. It gets really good. Excellent combination here.
nitwiticus 1 year ago
Perfect!
lucciorodriguez 1 year ago
Was für eine genial Kombination.Meine Lieblingsband und mein absoluter Lieblingsfilm.Das paast sehr gut zusammen.
36Cocker 1 year ago
@36Cocker Ja, Mein auch.
2800kevin 1 year ago
10 IDIOTS with no class at all
Flip465 1 year ago
this video makes me want to cry tears of joy
lviabobby 1 year ago 2
the religious tones are incredible
lviabobby 1 year ago
RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr space BAD!!!. monster floating in endless time. Where am I? or am I ?. ground control to Major Fukstein
Frankenfukstein 1 year ago
@Frankenfukstein Mass Effect is alive!
Wwhackk 1 year ago
Strangers passing in the street
By chance two separate glances meet
And I am you and what I see is me.
bltsponge 1 year ago 2
awesome + awesome = this
Mieszo 1 year ago
@Mieszo actually this is more like awsome^2 :P
jbenz1993 1 year ago
I think it's a huge same they didn't do a 40th anniversary edition, one that also included this synced up with Echoes.
LOTIL62 1 year ago
There was actually a time, when people could understand art without being under weed or having drunk alkohol. Neither did they use the obscene word "jizz", to describe their positive feel about something...
Simbirsk2130 1 year ago 20
thumbs up if you've watched this on weed and thought it was one of the best things you've ever seen
cloudstrife1288 1 year ago
Comment removed
WallaceCrumpet 1 year ago
things can only compare to this.
Psychoactivator 1 year ago
A masterpiece of filming and an excellent soundtrack combined.........heaven..........
leeche1956 1 year ago
420 likes until i clicked it
i almost feel bad
CactusCoolGuy 1 year ago
after I witnessed him travelling through space through another dimension.. I remember he walked across a white tilted floor, saw an old man and finally saw the black object. As the movie neared the end, he was lying in bed and that was the moment my eyes shut, fell down and passed away. I woke up in the morning, not remembering what happened, I got up drank lots of water and looked at the screen, and it said.. 'End' and I was like wtf.. rewinded and it all made sense again.. I never exper it aga
Fetcha200 1 year ago
Man I remember my roomate went home for the weekend and others too so I decide to watch this movie. I drank so much vodka, so i was like, eh let's watch it. First i wasn't amused when I witnessed the flying spaceship because it took so long for it finally land but finally I was watching him talking to the computer. I remember I passed out on the floor when he was fixing the computer. I got up 10 minutes later, sat on my chair, and there i saw it, magicail lights everywhere, left, right, oh my go
Fetcha200 1 year ago
How can you tell if it's art or not if we all have our own preferances and tastes, you can't argur against those.. just wondering if anyone knows the answer?
Fetcha200 1 year ago
weirdest band. weirdest movie. perfect!
sidewalkcakes 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No words to truly describe this, I once sat in the sun by a loch in Scotland listening to this and it brought tears to my eyes it was so beautiful and life affirming....
ericscollar 4 minutes ago
ericscollar 1 year ago
Comment removed
ericscollar 1 year ago
Google video has an un-segmented version.
To diy, start the echoes track a slit second before the Jupiter... title appears. i time it be keeping the volume up on the original track. After dave fades, the audio continues, fades, then is abruptly cut. A split second (wait for it!) after that, unpause the Echoes track. If your cd player doesn't it may be slow by some few ms, but should be fine.
you got it right if the 3rd ping hits right after the Jupiter title cuts to the starfield.
enjoy!
regnadkcin2k 1 year ago
And I see this is part 3. I suppose I should watch parts 1 and 2.
Takura4 1 year ago
Wow... This is... outstandingly beautiful and amazing. The build-up and raw emotion is absolutely breath taking. And thank you, @jusblaze99 for your explanation, which has helped me better understand and enjoy this short clip (as I have not seen the movie).
Takura4 1 year ago
Hey guys I just uploaded this video in 3 parts set to Shine On You Crazy Diamond (live version recorded in LA 1975). It fits really well. Check it out it`s on my channel! :)
Gigsixstrings 1 year ago
It's the first time I hear the original Meddle version. The only one I had ever heard up to this day is the Echoes: The Best Of Pink Floyd version (modified to reduce the lenght or something) which is simply not as good.
AwesomeCoasters 2 years ago 2
@AwesomeCoasters Then u never heard the full lenght version of Shine on you Crazy Diamond? Because on Echoes is a modified version of this Track
Greetings from Switzerland
Navlis86 1 year ago
@Navlis86
Well I have Wish You Were Here so yeah Ive heard full lenght SOYCD and yeah I know that's the original version that's then been modified
(don't you think the original Echoes is better?)
AwesomeCoasters 1 year ago
Dave Bowman was drawn into the monilith and transformed into a new "God?/perfected being?" he then (in 2031? I think) created a new mini solar system out of Juipter and her moons.
"To use together"
Rotor108 2 years ago
2010 actually
Illuminati10101 1 year ago
OK , its been a while since I read those. Good books.
Rotor108 1 year ago
Was für eine einmalige Kombination.Mein absoluter Lieblingsfilm mit dem Song meiner Lieblingsband.Einfach einmalig schön!!!
36Cocker 2 years ago
can anybody explaine the ending to me ?
mp5masta 2 years ago
@mp5masta
Basically, from what i have read, the monolith brought the main character to an expanded phase of the evolution of the self- beyond the physical, into a timeless godlike being. What we see in the final phases of the movie indicate two things: His timelessness (him seeing his older self), and formlessness
jusblaze99 1 year ago
@jusblaze99 ...continued
(the way he travels the cosmos and the starbaby at the end). ALSO, it seems like Kubrick wanted THIS MOVIE to be a shift in the VIEWER'S evolution (the movie screen being "our" monolith, and the close up shots of his eye ALSO being the eye of the movie watcher-
jusblaze99 1 year ago
@jusblaze99 ...continued 2
both astonished by the evolution they are witnessing). FINALLY his understanding of the limitedness of reality, (this realization is expressed by the old version in the bed ALMOST touching the monolith, IF the screen were 2D, which it is to the viewer, and is also 2D to him once he realizes that his reality is finite- a movie.)
jusblaze99 1 year ago
I love the crescendo at 2:00 as the visual moves to the other room
merolleiro 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Awesome movie... shitty song...
jinjou 2 years ago
No doubt one of the great bands of all time...they will be missed!
Wendellwx 2 years ago
@jinjou My God, that's blasphemy!!! Pink Floyd in music is like Kubrick in movies.......perfect masterpieces.
Szederp 2 years ago
@jinjou That's blasphemy. This song perfectly fits the movie. Pink Floyd in music is what Stanley Kubrick is in movies.....magicians
Szederp 2 years ago
They were great! I could cry every time I listen to this...
after 6:10 ... gorgeous..
JunjouRomanticaFan 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This song is so epic!
olisaoli 2 years ago
Pink Flloyd = One of a kind. Whether you think they are weird, good, or evil; you gotta admit they did some amazing things with sound... and had their very own. Pure genius
sparwood8 2 years ago 5
legendary!
Fiji2006 2 years ago
the highest and epical achievement of two genius, the perfection of a diamond: i cry of joy !! RIP stan, syd, and Rick!!!!
genesisvirgine 2 years ago 5
They died? When? How? (bummer, that)
sparwood8 2 years ago
stanley kubrick died 7th march 1999
syd on 7th july 2006
rick on 15th on december 2008
genesisvirgine 2 years ago
Too soon. So many musicians die so young. Seems to me the only vocation that has a shorter life span is high lead logging... but them who make it to 55 usually good for antoher 30 years
sparwood8 2 years ago
@sparwood8
''long you live, and high you fly. but only if you ride the tide. balanced on the biggest wave, you race towards an early grave'' (:
Ibakecookiess 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@Ibakecookiess
Pink Floyyd is satanic ... and that comment is unintellegible
sparwood8 2 years ago
@sparwood8
pink floyd is satanic in no way. and yea maybe that comment wont make any sense if you arent familiar with pink floyd's ideas and ways of expressing them. which now i can see you arent. i quoted that few sentences from the song ''breathe'' because for me it fitted the comment you posted. on how artists usually young, not only artists but people that stand out in general, or ''ride the biggest wave''. Pink Floyd are true geniuses, and not only musically.
Ibakecookiess 2 years ago
well i've in the side of god, but if pink floyd is satanic mmmmmmm i like the satanic music;)
raulishoogallagher 2 years ago
a long ago... RIP
ELIbEFALCON 2 years ago
6:00 wonderful bliss
phish92hood 2 years ago 4
Agreed
Rawnesss 2 years ago
ya lo decia A. Rimbaud en una carta antes de salir de Paris, "la vida esta en otra parte".
Jimhendrx67 2 years ago
Two brilliant works combine. What could be better?
AdamSwed 2 years ago 41
La musica ben s'addice alla magnificenza delle immagini........
dctgfr 2 years ago 4
2001 is pretty much a trip film from the last 20 mins of it. If you play echoes in the last 20 mins its fucking amazing
phoneix91 2 years ago 5
simply amazing
3:54 is legendary too
noname390 2 years ago
great vid!
GS34000 2 years ago
Senza parole!
dctgfr 2 years ago
Great song!
LesPaulGoldTop21 2 years ago
when you watch this part, you realize this was intentional.
ginteardrops 2 years ago
Very cool. It does seem to fit the film perfectly. Thanks for posting.
BggProductions 2 years ago
whenever i watched 2001,am always confused by the ending?what does anyone else think the ending is about???great vid though dude!!!
racefaceec90 2 years ago
Evolution! In the far future, the man will not die, will born again! That's was a gift from the monolith. By the way, it's my interpretation. =D
hiproquista 2 years ago
thanks for reply!!!i think,as you say everyone has their own take on ending!!!!
racefaceec90 2 years ago
If you watch 2010, then read 3001 (both of which I highly recommend) you see that Dave has joined with the entity. This might be that process or his enlightenment. The completion of his life may have been a gift like hipro suggests.
There's def the implication that humanity is experiencing another step or jump in evolution thanks to this entity.
smillar98 2 years ago
thanks for replying.i can understand what you mean,the monolith gave the primates intelligence at beginning of film,to what you said.definately widens your mental horizons thinking about all of that!!!peace!!!
racefaceec90 2 years ago
Kubrick was known for not following the themes of the books he was making films of, lending his own philisophical meaning to interpretation, it's probably why he refused to film 2010. So I would say that the plot of the later books is not as relevant.
johnmustrule 2 years ago 2
The parts where it shows him getting older and older rapidly is him coming to terms with the end of his life. His human body is fragile and was destroyed when he went through the monolith. Like the part where he breaks the glass only to look up to see himself on his deathbed. In order to become the starchild at the end he had to give up all parts of his old life.
homicidemanex 2 years ago
I'd be fuckin pissed if a giant rectangle came in my room and turned me into a baby!!! x<_x
N0xM3RxC 2 years ago
Would you ?.. Wouldn't you like a new start ?.. A new beginning.. I wouldn't mind :)
arturojose16 2 years ago
I lul'd
ThePsychoDuo 2 years ago
this is the only way to watch 2001: a space odyssey. I felt like tripping the entire ending part
yoiamdaruler 2 years ago
2:56 :O good lord amazing
Mcezz606 2 years ago 6
3:55 is epic
thewhipwhoppinking 2 years ago 6
my ears start jizzing at 2:57
brazil111 2 years ago 31
@brazil111 I splooged at 4:05
bearmare 1 year ago 2
you posted my release of the synch from TPB, didn't you?
it is the only one which includes the end credits after the soundtrack cuts off.
sheesh, man, you could at least have mentioned your sources. bad user, no rating...
synth3s1s 2 years ago
fuck off
brazil111 2 years ago
go to hell, asswipe! at least i mentioned it politely.
synth3s1s 2 years ago 2
yeah go make a case of copyright infringement on this lol. you're funny big ass job you've done syncing a song to a movie.
roger waters should post here flaming on the poster too, he's done a lot more than you.
bar000n 2 years ago 5
Im roger waters and im flaming.. lol
Stop guys just enjoy the fuckin music
Aracnidas 2 years ago 2
Each time I watch this vid, I wonder how on Earth it is possible to have such an amazing imagination... Can we call this imagination? I don't even think so, this movie and this music are made by the greatest band ever and a genius of the cinema., they just are... PERFECT...
fifouforever 2 years ago 7
Questo video è qlk di fantastico,filosofico e la musica è perfetta..............nn ho parole per commentare qlk di perfetto e tanto futuristico.....
micluilui 2 years ago
I am absolutely convinced Floyd did Echoes to 2001.
The Oz thing not so much.
seandelgado 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this song fitting to the film like that is TOTAL RANDOMNESS!
bonejangles22 2 years ago
perfect.
reclaimer113 3 years ago
Your timing is almost perfect (with regard to matching 'Echoes' with '2001'). It's a rare feat for someone to pull that off. Bravo!
bitterfly77 3 years ago
I think the ending is symbolic of: The Room is obtaining of things we thought were important yet are worthless because we can't take them with us. He is alone because all our lives we are on own spiritual and intellectual journey and nobody can come with us. WE are always looking forward only to look back when we get to where we are. In the end he looks forward one last time and can no longer see himself. There is nothing left. Might the monolyth represent nothing? He then dies and beomes ???
safenders 3 years ago 3
"the star child"
kooldogyiris 2 years ago
indeed, he becomes the child from the stars or "Star Child"
SexyAlien2 2 years ago
nice acid trip
tritanopia 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Exactly my thoughts..
Artas1984 3 years ago
Pure genious. Im at a loss for words....simply Brilliant.
scarfacedan09 3 years ago
Ok, Iguess so...but ca,n you help for the meaning of those scenes: Comandant in his space clothes, getting in a room finding himself quite older having a meal, getting more older laying in a bed... the monolyth standing in his bedroom...and finally a space baby getting closer to Earth...ouch, I'm a little bit lost for the meaning. Any Idea that could make it clearer for me ?
jinav62 3 years ago
Well its like this, Bowman comes in contact with the Jupiter monolith which ends up bringing him in and just like the aliens that invented the monoliths Bowman reaches the final stage of human evolution where he becomes a bodyless being that flows with the universe and his final journey is his journey into the monolith and although its not specified i believe the aging process with the monolith is his final stages in life right before becoming the "starchild".
scarfacedan09 3 years ago
Thanx alot scarface for your answer and your interpretation. "becoming the starchild" perhaps does it also mean that life is some kind of eternal cycle of borning, getting older dieing and re-borning.... Anyway, thank you for sharing your point.
jinav62 3 years ago
Its my pleasure really im fascinated with the movies and books and since Pink Floyd is one of my favorite bands this is like hitting the jackpot i think many would agree that "Echoes" sounds better than the original soundtrack of this video
scarfacedan09 3 years ago
the most astonishing movie ever.
salvoben 3 years ago 3
Wrong song, right film.
At 01:27:39 of the movie, I play on my I-Pod the songs SPEAK TO ME/BREATH and ON THE RUN, and then: BYE BYE FRANK, HELL-O DAVE!
Note on chapter 22: Entr'acte. During the Interact, my friend would SPEAK TO ME and Frank would BREATH.
(I've been mad for years about von Braun's theory.)
Can someone remake this and call it (von Braun's Magic Spell)?
Timer ON, Subtitle ON, volume ON.
Do not try this at home!
The third song next in line will be _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.
Vincent01853 3 years ago
Incrible
Sincronized "The Wall" (Pink Floyd) + "the Great Dictator" (Charlie Chaplin - 1940)
Very perfct!
Youtube
suicidadealuguel 3 years ago
are you stupid or what?? !!!
davelbarbaro 3 years ago
Long live to Roger Waters
Rhiannoncalantariel 3 years ago
Roger Waters humm hard to say but I´d defently say Syd Barret
davelbarbaro 3 years ago
there are no words to decribe how ... it is
GedBauglir 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
satanism / occults / illuminati
P07H34DJr 3 years ago
WHAT?
ChrisWales22 3 years ago
The song synchs with the change of scenes and emotions so well, and they both end at the exact same time. I don't even think I'd believe the band if they said themselves they didn't deliberately do it. Floyd's keepin some secrets man!
xxdrew333xxx 3 years ago
It would be hard for them to intentionaly set the film to music as VCR's were not popular in the past. Betamax wasn't either. Not that its out of the realm of possibilities though.
homicidemanex 3 years ago
They could've had a reel of the film and a projector. I'm usually a skeptic of most off-the-wall theories but the two just synch so much. Who knows though
xxdrew333xxx 3 years ago
that was so good i put it on full screen all light out.26 mins of my life well spent
rko123jja 3 years ago
It's as if this whole sequence were the music video for Echoes.
FoxDougan 3 years ago
The build up to that beautiful guitar riff at 2:57 is just incredible!
foxyroxytm 3 years ago 33
YES
brazil111 2 years ago 6
Thanks Kaiserwilhelm23 for sharing.
5*!!!
Hugs. Maria Inês.
MITYF 3 years ago
good film
kaiserwilhelm23 3 years ago
Awesome! Thanks for Posting!
dobrav99 3 years ago
this is more art than just music to me.
Todict 3 years ago 5
his face at the beginning had be gigglin like stary eyed infant. nice.
chloesprite 3 years ago
wow. i dont need to leave a comment for this. you just watch it- thats all you can do.
pagboy529 3 years ago
reminds me captain Nemo
masteranza 3 years ago
i agree ... in my opinion, echoes is the most intrigating song ever...it has a perfect harmony between the song and the video ... it's just perfect...AMAZING...David gilmour ...best guitar player ever...
g4t1nh4zZ 3 years ago 2
the song and movie combine very well..
augustina91 3 years ago
This is by far one of the most underrated songs in rock history.
And its also the best. Period.
Fado91 3 years ago 4
Had a the VCR version - a very long time ago and in fact still have it in all pristine glory - as it should be. I love the moment after the guitar wailing etc that Rick drops inn with his his keyboard skills - the whole piece is about 23/24 minutes long in its entirety.Meddle - love it.
VALUVIANNIC7 3 years ago
yeah...rick...was a big lost...we'll miss him a lot... i try not to think but, i can't see how will be whem david's time arrive... it will be a very cool day...
g4t1nh4zZ 3 years ago
look at the baby... It's Thom Yorke, with the weird eye and everything
hlaakso 3 years ago 5
He's such a creep.
SparkamusPryme 3 years ago 3
Thom Yorke is a god!
jakep34 3 years ago
This is why I used his lyrics:
"You're so fucking special,
I wish I was special
...but I'm a creep"
SparkamusPryme 3 years ago
This music is about Pink Floyd -not Thom Yorke, and at the risk of stating the obvious Thom would not have been born. Thank you.
VALUVIANNIC7 3 years ago
RIP Richard Wright.
LtAgar 3 years ago 4
rest in peace rick the word has lost a master musician
bigade66 3 years ago 2
been to long since i seen 2001, must see it again!
Eqvaliser 3 years ago
R.I.P. Rick. Will miss you.
Kidon24 3 years ago 2
forever an echo in our hearts and mind R.I.P
jimsim3 3 years ago
"Lloyd Webber's awful stuff runs for years and years and years
An earthquake hits the theatre, but the operetta lingers
Then the piano lid comes down and breaks his f_cking fingers
It's a miracle" --RW
In reference to the Phantom Plagiarism.
995516222 3 years ago 3
tsssssssssssssss awessssssssssooooooooooooooome, i had a dream like this tssssssssss
Jimhendrx67 3 years ago
Sounds like Phantom of the Opers :)
evannalynchfan1 3 years ago 2
yes!
cibeles24 3 years ago
The writer of the phantom of the opera Lloyd Webber stole it for sure. The phantom was made after echoes and it has the same exact notes and time signature. Even roger waters writes about it in a song saying that webber is an assholl
psychokilla6669 3 years ago
finally somebody else notices this,
KHeyHeyHey 3 years ago
"We live we die and death not ends it"-Jim Morrison
And that applies for all religions and all people.Reincarnation,Heaven,Hell,Purgatory call it whatever you want.I've finally understood that all we're being prepared for in school,the so called "life" is actually a synonim for survival which is at least stupid if you ask me cause most people survive to nothing.They get up in the morning to a job they don't enjoy,they eat,they sleep and die.I know I'd rather live a day and enjoy a life of love
mapamond 3 years ago
this part of the movie is exactly the same length as this song, coincidence.. i think not, heh heh
mrkrinkle44 3 years ago
they actually said they made this song to this movie, they were supposed to do the soundtrack to the movie and they got rejected so they did the song to it for that reason...
mrkrinkle44 3 years ago
You got it the other way around man, Kubrick asked them to make the music for the film and Pink Floyd rejected it, later Waters stated that he regrets it.
Narkomanden 3 years ago
yeah, yeah your right thanks for correcting me. aFTER i wrote it I was thinking I was wrong..
mrkrinkle44 3 years ago
Either way, it's amazing. God. I wish they had the clips of Dorothy and the House in the Tornado on it's way to Oz for "Great Gig in the Sky" on the Pulse tour.
Man oh man.
Amazing.
sixtiessoul 3 years ago
I agree, Pink Floyd are the Masters Of Music in so many ways
Mystwicca 3 years ago 2
This part of the song is absolutely one of the best musical pieces ever written.
Jouwl 3 years ago
".......and the 2001 series, this encounter produces a conceptual breakthrough that accelerates humanity into the next stage of its evolution."
Arther C Clark, Wikipedia.
"Cloudless everyday you fall upon my waking eyes
inciting and inviting me to rise
And through the window in the wall
Come streaming in on sunlight wings
A million bright ambassadors of morning "
eloboo 3 years ago
floyd knew as much as A C Clark and Kubrick big change was coming up, this was made wasnt it in the late 60's, during the great pluto uranus conjunct
coming up again around 2012, this time a square, synched with the mayan shift, the galatix 26,000 year cycle and americas 6 year great pluto death and rebith transits from 2009 - 2015
eloboo 3 years ago
favourite song and favourite movie
lalalamort 3 years ago
thanks for the great sync. Love that i can just pull this up whenever the mood strikes. You've done a great job.
FullOnFlyhead 3 years ago
coolest shit EVER!!!
kokoheal 3 years ago
Wow metalguy you can actually prove that certain artists are better than others, that's amazing. Can you do me a favour then? To settle an argument, would you be able to tell me who is better Debussy, Dolly Parton or Adam and The Ants.
mulliganmadness 3 years ago
I think floyd was asked to do music for clockwork.
NASENT 3 years ago
erm no lol. beethoven is like THE integral part of the story, plus its in the book lol
wouldnt have been the same if it was dark side of the moon coming out of the window near the canal lol
cdmacdonald2112 3 years ago
They were ask to do music for it
but they were asked for the rights to one of their songs
but they refused
fhqwgads5000 3 years ago
sorry for that mess of a first sentence
they WEREN'T asked to do music for it specifically
fhqwgads5000 3 years