Added: 4 years ago
From: DatingMyPiano
Views: 26,851
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (100)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • My only criticism would be that the tempo through some of it was a tad fast but otherwise that was amazing!!!!!

  • Just amazing ! :) How many years piano did you play ?

  • Just uploaded my own version of this amazing song, please have a look :)

    keep up the good work :D!

  • wow! i love it, i'm learnig it, and than i'm gonna upload it to!

  • I searched it so many times. and now i found it because my girlfriend showed it du me..

    It's a sad song . I mean so.

    But it's soo good. ! Best song on the piano ever

  • Is this piece hard?

  • played very well

  • JJ, It was beautiful, I had never heard the song before until now.

  • too fast and rushed with some parts

  • That was so amazing! I love this song! And your piano makes it to become so alive. I guess is the emotion you feel when you play it. You did an excellent job playing it.

    Merry Christmas to you too man and have a happy new year!

    Thank you so much!

  • very well done!

  • god, this song is so beautiful.

    and you play it so well.

    good job :)

  • beautiful!! im excited about learning this now :)

  • i love this song! u have a really nice cover. if i could give more than 5 stars i would. so i give 16 outta 5

  • This song is truly amazing. I just Bought

    The sheet music for this song yesterday and have been working on it for about an hour and a half. This video motivates me to work a little harder and put a little more effort in, because this song is truly moving and beautiful. Whenever I hear it, one particular part in twilight (book) comes to mind for me. Esme's song. Fantastic job :)> vampire with one tooth!!!!

  • You are absolutely amazing. I've been playing violin and piano since I was 8 but I'm only 15 so not that long but I really want to be as good as you on the piano; I can play it on the villin but I'm still a little sketchy but with more practise I'm sure I can get there.

    Anyway, I just really wanted to let you know that you are absolutely amazing and that I really love this so and you've played it perfectly!!

  • Lol nice name! I'm always glad to see others expressing their love of music! :) I just wanted to express my appreciation for your vid and see if you would check mine out too! Thx Again!

  • Very Nice, Excellent touch, great feeling, I am moved, Thanks

  • amazing

  • this is awesome. someday i'll get this song done and sound like this. haha

    hopefully..very beautiful.

  • aber du spielst sehr gut und das klavier ist suuuper !! :-)

  • musst du so viel am anfang labern ??

  • Wow, You really are amazing. I've always wanted to learn how to play, but I come from a very non musical family, so it's kindof hard haha. How did you start teaching youreself? x

  • sri it took so long to reply. I had a cheap keyboard that had a screen that showed you the key to play and once i'd memorized the song i found the sheet music for it to see what it looked like on paper, then used that as a guide to learn more and more songs until i got to where i'm at now. im working on a few others now, i've my own song i wrote for my mom the will go up soon iit's almost 8 minutes long, as well as oltremare by ludivico euanidi, and harmony grove by greg maroney

  • Amazing. This is my favorite song, and your version made me cry, i love seeing it done.

  • the most flatering comment yet :)

  • ahhh :) Good job! I am trying to play this song and it helps so much when i hear someone else play because i have a good ear and its better. Thanks!

  • I think the piano play is really great ..... but ... I also think there´s is not enough feeling for the song....

  • the more i whatch the more i realize that, i used speed as the emotion for my song, rather than trying to make it sound like a story.

  • beautiful piano. ♥

    beautiful sound. ♥

  • perfect,

  • I really like you playin this song! I also play this song and i would like for you to check out my video of Me playing this song! please check it out and i hope you like it and please comment on it too! thanks bye!!!!!

  • This is great! Wow man! You're good. By the way this song makes me cry... This song is beautiful...

  • thanks, the benefits of now having a girlfreind for 5 years has it's perks.

  • THANK YOU you made me full in love with piano again XD could you possibly do a tutorial please i'm learning it for a song for a funeral/concert ^^

  • 'funeral/concert' how werid...

  • just keep practising your ass off, eventually you can play it with your eyes closed

  • nicejob <333

  • for me it was perfekt....thanx

  • nice playing you have really good feeling when playing piano.there are few things wich made this not PERFECT.

    1.Some parts where really to fast just be carefull to not increase the speed so much

    2.You should make some good use of the pedal it would give the song an even better sound.

    Joe.

  • hey thanks. I was wearing head phones with the mp3 playing while a was recording this, and I think I fell behind a bit and had to catch back up. I see what you are saying though, I watched and listened to the bass and heard it was to fast t points, not much though. say if the tempo was 80 I was doing between 83 and 86 at times. I always hear about my foot work. Not having any formal training I just wing it.

  • Nice rendition! A few fumbles but you covered them well and the heart of the piece remains solid. The biggest challenge with this piece is making each passage sound unique. So I would say the next step here is to make that happen. Listen to yourself play and hear where the music should rise and fall. Even smaller passages have their own climaxes.

    Overall, though, good work! You do this piece justice.

  • constructive critsism is what I need, I think If i new how to work the pedals properly it would make the song story a little more interesting, it's hard to do it just with speed and the right "touch". thank you.

  • Practice practice practice! That's the best solution. Just play it until you hate it (then you know you've practiced enough).

    I'll give you some examples of what I was saying:

    1:27 There's a dramatic increase in speed, here. Take your time on those top notes so that the whole section doesn't rush. It was better the 2nd time it happened.

    2:11 I like your tempo changes here. I also hear a sort of "call and response" line here with the repeated notes that could be done. (Again at 2:27)

  • At the same time, don't take my word for it. My primary focus is on the violin-not the piano.

  • ur amazing

  • you are amazing! Im going to try to learn how to play this song! =D

  • woah, thats like... perfect [:

  • amazingly gorgeously beautifully played

  • JJ - Whoa! Shocked doesn't even begin to cover it. I never would have thought of you as a pianist. Gotta say I'm impressed. Don't waste that gift.

    -Philosophical

  • You're amazing :)

  • person below me.... BOOOOO!! AND U MADE A MISTAKE SPELLING THE WORD "MISTAKE"!!!!!!!!

  • now thats fast... i still cant do it with that speed... i wonder how long will it take me to finally do it well

  • amazing.you are so talented

  • Wow. Its awsome to find someone this good who can play by ear. I can't read notes, but will you make a tutorial video on how to play this? Its beautiful; i would love to know how.

  • i love this song is beatifull

  • OMG I LUV THIS SONG!!

  • omg that is was awsome..ur not the only one obessed with this song..i'm learning paino just so i can play this song..my husband plays paino and I forbid him to try to play his song. Tha ti want to do it first. well c how it pans out..I might just put it up on youtube so u can c how i did

  • BEAUTIFUL!!

  • amazing mate that all i can say just amazing

  • you reminds me of me:)

  • Hehehehe, do you think you can teach me piano and this song? Cuz that'll be awesome. This is like the bes song played on a piano.

  • very goood, great job =]

  • damn dude u are good and u learned piano by urself...wow and timing was perfect everything was PERFECT

  • you know the fast bit.. my timing always gets messed up at that.. i have to slow down and then the whole piece is RUINED I TELL YOU!

  • i had same prob at first. this how i did it listen to song on headfones while playing just the right hand and play along until u get it perfect and keep doing that until u begin to hate the song. so when ever u play it ur muscle memory will automaticall play at that speed everytime then try to blend the left hand into it even if it just a key at time then add another and another etc.

  • beautiful

  • by far the best version of it.

    i love how you have the timing just perfect.

  • i agree perfect timing (:

    my left hand fails at timing right now ): <

  • me too

  • It's great. I"m obssesed with it too, the only problem is that I can't play piano quite yet and I don't have one. So I learn by sound on my chorus teacher's piano at school. I only know how to play a few easy things and a little bit of River Flows in you. I wish I could play!! So it's nice to listen to other people when I know I can't do it. Thanks!!!!!

  • wonderful...

  • Beautifully Played ^__^

  • wow this is the best one iv heard :D im learning to play this song myself n im about halfway through it. your vid really helps me get the feel of the song, thanks!

  • how did your song turn out

  • Thank you for the christmas present!!! That was beautiful!!!

    I hope to someday be able to play like that!! Lessons start next week.

  • :) i hope your lessons are going well!!! always listen to what the music sounds like as your playing, like concentrat on the bass if the sounds correct the rest the treble will fall into place.

  • I love this song too. Nice job with it.

  • This is one of my favorite songs! Playing piano is a hard enough thing with piano lessons. But playing like you are with no lessons is something everyone shoudl be impressed with. What your doing is beautiful.

    I think people should always encourage others especially if they show as much natural talent as you do.

  • thanks, wow a year to reply huh. I keep humble because there is always somebody better.

  • i hear few mistakes

  • i know, the more i whatch it the more i hear them. it's almost irratating

  • i dont know why they give such comments..

    you really have talent i enjoyed it..

    keep it up

  • i dont know why they give such comments..

    you really have talent i enjoyed it..

    keep it up

  • Awesome, J. J.. God has given you a wonderful gift; keep these videos coming!

    Love,

    Aunt Jeannie

  • Wat r u talking about no talent retards? She hasn't had piano lessons either. Beaten by a 13 year old. I am a babe. And ur an a**. So no harm done. But I'll give you the props 4 the song. It wasn't that horrible. I've heard a million times worst. And it's not even on piano.

  • its no wonder you like the song so much... it's the most overused and popular chord progression in all pop music.. I think about 1 in 6 songs uses that exact chord progression (which is sad... but doesn't make it a bad song... just a little clidhé...)

  • amazing :D

  • she gives good head for 13 dayum

  • Really? thats amazing! Now tell it to someone who likes you! :)

  • ouch. you guys are harsh. i need criticism but dang.firebitch132 im happy for your sister, let her know i couldn't afford lessons so i've never had one,

    and i'f you'll stop claiming to be a babe i'll make the intro shorter for you.

  • I really did like it though, you have a good talent!

  • LOL!

    you got served firebitch132

    he is good, i enjoyed it =)

    he has a point about not having lessons, he is very good for having learned piano without lessons =)

  • wow... wordless

  • i did enjoy it a lot!

    also one of my favorite songs at the moment

    keep doing your thing!

  • I have goosebumps!!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more