Genesis - One for the Vine

[ByGraceIGo]

LOVELY my friend...:-)

[stokkernk]

@ByGraceIGo Thank you so much!!

[2raben]

So much talent. It's already a hard piece to play just looking at sheet music. To do this on memory and with such precision, accuracy, and nuance...I'm in awe.

[stokkernk]

@2raben Thank you so much, your words make me happy. I've never studied music, and I'm not able to read, so I use memory... Thank you again,

Ales

[djhvideo]

Fabulous 

[stokkernk]

@djhvideo Oh, thank you!!:)

[zwelgjebast]

Nice one! Very well done! Greetings from Holland again :)

[stokkernk]

@zwelgjebast Very kind! Thank you very much!!:)

[aleblanc0023]

Man..this is FABULAS...This is my prefered one, specialy the live version.

I wish I could play it like this. If you have the MIDI file of your playing, pls give me a copy.

You can see the video that I made on the live version with L-O-R movie.

[Fallon144]

Man this is simply amazing. Perfect execution. greets frm holland

[stokkernk]

@Fallon144 Thank you very very much, too kind!!

[taraxxxx]

ur a GENIUS!!!! Im a big fan of genesis since their beginning! Now.. listening to you it seems to be in 1976 at their concert! you are gr8!

thx from my heart from ITALY!!! :)

[stokkernk]

@taraxxxx Ma dai, non esagerare! Però grazie tantissime, sei davvero molto gentile, sono felice che ti sia piaciuta la mia versione di questo pezzo meraviglioso.

[taraxxxx]

@stokkernk ma sei italiano?????

[taraxxxx]

@stokkernk siccome la mia ragazza suona pure il piano, non è che potresti scansire gli spartiti di questa, robbery assault and battery e a trick of the tail??? so che t chiedo molto e probabilmente nn lo farai.. ma c'ho provato :P

[stokkernk]

@taraxxxx Non lo farò, ma non per il motivo che pensi: non suono con gli spartiti, ma vado a orecchio. Sento attentamente gli originali e la arrangio per le mie possibilità. E poi studio su youtube dai video dei genesis, e da tutti quelli come me che mettono le loro esecuzioni. So che è una strada più tortuosa rispetto a leggere uno spartito, ma spesso risulta anche più efficace. Un saluto, e posta il video della tua ragazza che suona i Genesis, in caso:)

[michito46]

Me encanto. Me quede muy impactado. Muchas gracias por subirlo, realmente esta excelente.

[stokkernk]

@michito46 Gracias, de corazón, para escribir palabras tan bellas. Un abrazo desde Italia.

[michito46]

@stokkernk Ah, por cierto, un gran abrazo y mucha suerte !!!! Segui asi que vas por buen camino.

[axman777]

Stunning! I'm speechless.

Thank you for this incredible arrangement.

[stokkernk]

@axman777 Oh, thank you so much to you, really:)

[kfsfkakf]

Well, I'm done. I'm not gonna try to learn this anymore

[tomjobimforever]

Really awsome, beautifull... impressive, this the best version anywhere... congratulations. you made my day.

Keep the good work.

[stokkernk]

@tomjobimforever Thank you very very much, you're very kind!

[windwardpro]

Awesome! Brilliant! Super accurate. (All except the middle section transition) I almost guarantee you won't find ANYONE interpreting it more accurately on youtube than this.

It would be great to hear this on a real grand piano! Be all the more impressive.

[stokkernk]

@windwardpro Oh, thank you very much windwardpro, you are very kind!

[leads4agents]

How in the world did you play that without any sheet music? Very complex song! You did an outstanding job, I am going to post my version one day (it may be a while!). Your tempo was fantastic, I have heard so many covers on YT of this song and the tempo is usually off... Outstanding!

[stokkernk]

@leads4agents Thank you!!! I want to see your version! Please tell me when is done!

[RectumPilum]

Excellent! I have to learn this now!

[stokkernk]

@RectumPilum Thank you very much! Don't forget to tell me when you put your One for the Vine on youtube, I want to see it!:)

[iallcroft]

Lovely arrangement of one of Banks' finest.... bravo... could listen to it over and over. Many thanks for posting, and I'm not ashamed to say I'll be practicing this one. Quite excellent.

[stokkernk]

@iallcroft Thank you very much! I'm happy you've appreciated this rendition. So, I hope you'll post your "Vine" version:) Let me know! Ales

[docleepierce]

Wow! Awesome!!!! Thanks so much

[marco52jk]

niente da dire .. una delle migliori versioni su utube!!!!!!!!

[stokkernk]

@marco52jk Grazie mille Marco! Ho curiosato sul tuo canale, e debbo farti i complimenti io per il tocco fantastico che hai! Bellissime le cover dei Pink Floyd!

[marco52jk]

@stokkernk ciao grazie!!

[Eldanoth]

Non avevo mai sentito questa tua interpretazione... di questo..... capolavoro!

Solo uno che l'ama con tutta l'anima la può suonare in questo modo. Ti dico solo questo aggiungendo che non mi commuovevo da molto tempo per una tale bellezza. Se avessi i soldi ti regalerei un V-Piano che sarebbe appena all'altezza della tua magnifica prestazione. Continua :,)

P.S. (mad man moon, entangled, ripples...)

[twinsmm1]

Just Beautiful. One of my favorite Genesis tunes. Very well done.

[stokkernk]

@twinsmm1 Thank you very much! one of my favorite ever, too:)

[ginises83]

WONDERFUL !!!! you are the best !!!! please another song of Genesis ....for exemple ....Mad man moon .....thank you so much

[stokkernk]

@ginises83 Thank you, Ginises83, thank you sincerely. Mad man moon it's my dream... I'm working on it, but it's so difficoult!:)

[gengone27]

Bravissimo!!!!!

[stokkernk]

@gengone27 Grazie mille!!!!!

[onsen01jp]

Great song and fantastic play.

I like 5:07-5:30's cross hand technique.

[stokkernk]

@onsen01jp Arigatoo gozaimasu! That point... I don't really know if that is the right way to play that part. Surely Tony didn't play the bass with the left hand. But the overall idea is good enought, I think. Thank you again!!

[MrHudson111]

A fantastic rendition of a fantastic Genesis song, you have my utter most respect, as i also love to play the great Genesis music, but you are in a completely different league. to me. Please post more Genesis

[stokkernk]

@MrHudson111 Thank you very very much MrHudson! It's an honour to receive such a wonderful opinion from a british genesis lover like you! I'll post more Genesis, sure, I love their music: I'll play soon (I hope!) In the cage solo, cinema show instrumental, After the ordeal...

[krissyrose14]

Bravo! Excellent work, and great expression on the piano. After listening to this, I want to listen to the studio version. My favorite song on Wind and Wuthering.

[stokkernk]

@krissyrose14 Grazie!! Thank you krissyrose!:) Wind is a great album, and One for the Vine is a really great Banks composition, one of my favourite ever.

[miaris]

Wonderful.

[stokkernk]

@miaris Oh, thank you very much Mia!!!