Added: 5 years ago
From: l3igballer23
Views: 260,447
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (485)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • he started too high pitched

  • The ladies love him. He is Very handsome and lord knows he has a voice on him.

  • jerry stackhouse does the anthem better

  • He's a good improviser

  • you here all his fans, made the nba stars look bad.lol!!!

  • Comment removed

  • he started off a lil too high so he didnt really have anywhere to go at rockets red glare. but its still a great vocal performance and he recovered well. i has a nice smooth soulful voice. one of the best...

  • American Nowitzki ?

  • Wow he has one of the best male voices ever.

  • Very soulful ! Makes me proud to be an American!

  • Love him.

  • Love Elliot!!

  • Should have won AI the year he competed. One of the best singers ever!

  • @littleb42 I totally agree - he is probably the best singer the show ever had. 

  • The BEST male vocalist to ever grace the stage of American Idol!

  • I like the way once white boy started singing, Everyone was like WTF? This dog can sing!

  • one of the best male vocalists in AI.

  • he started out to high

  • Excellent job compromising the high notes, i think he could have took the free note but it wsa just unexpected so he took it easy then warmed back up on the end, the boy can sang!!! Most would have cracked and got off key. His Oh say on the end was a new chord but he got right back on the right notes, that's a pro, when u can fix ure mixtakes and non-musicans wont know. LOL

  • @Ashabobo good insight.

  • elliot did a great job on this

  • sometimes i wanna boycott idol but when u here a voice like this ur thankful

  • Jerry Stackhouse sang the anthem the next year against the rockets, honestly I think he did a better job, it was very soulful.

  • That white boy can sang!

  • Looked like Gomer Pyle when he started.

  • He started way too high, and so he covered it up really well with lots of adlibs. It wasn't irritiating, he just should have started in a lower key because he didn't all of the high notes. Regardless, he can sing Amazing Grace and sound incredible. He's one of the more popular finalists to sky rocket from American Idol, since his season that was nearly 5 years ago. I look up to him vocally. He's phenominal and it's so sad that he didn't make the finale w. Kat McPhee, bc Taylor Hicks was a joke!

  • he has so much soul in in voice i like

  • started way too high

  • If he dropped a key he prolly coulda hit the crazy note at Rockets red glare that woulda livened the song no doubt but great vocals =p

  • wth was nowitzki's hand on his chest? the guy is german. He's not even naturalized as a US citizen. lol

  • HA!

  • very very good

  • i think so far, he was the only singer i've seen putting his hand by his heart while singing the anthem.

  • Tremendo vozarrón que se gasta el carajo y lo demás es cuento.

  • I love all the riffs... love it!

  • he's so cute when he gets nervous. i hate it that he got his teeth/jaw fixed now, so i could hardly tell it was him when i heard his new song. it used to make him unique. now he's just a typical hollywooder...:(

  • Compliance with the Americans is that flag is admirable...

  • love elliotts voice omg its so wonderful to hear elliott sing

  • damn! that was awesome.

  • He's one of the only good live performers!!! Like his voice doesn't change from all the autotune and stuff. I love this version!!!!

  • I just don't understand...he was changing the notes coz he cant reach it? or it was just the style? Hmmm...he started pretty high so I guess that's what it is...that's why he hardly hit that note...but in general, it was still good.

  • amen to the person before me xD he is soo good! and this is the best ive ever heard someone sing the national anthem

  • i give him 100 out of 100 he did great nnot many people can sing that good live

  • Elliot is a phenomenal singer, but I didn't exactly like his rendition of the anthem. Lots of people sing this well, but this isn't where Elliot's soulful voice shines. Anthony Federov, one of my favorite idol contestants, has my favorite male rendition of the song and I've heard lots. My favorite female version is Beyonce's and Whitney Houston's.

  • Wow, soulful!!! Awesome voice!!

  • He's got a nice voice

  • it looks like he was just randomly picked from one of the seats by the way he dressed. LOL

  • airrjordan23 , yes that bothers me too. I don't know why entertainers always dress like something the cat dragged in these days. It's gross.

  • He's superb!

  • i LIKED TO SEE YOU GET UP THERE AND SING ITS NOT ALWAYS EASY ELLIOTT DID A GOOD JOB

  • i think it was good. he knew it was too high thats why he revised to fit his vocal ability!! he did a good job!! beautiful voice!

  • goodjob:]

    aw, hes so cute!

  • he's nervous

  • do you think the color guard commader relizes that the American Flag goes on his right?

  • he started too high... And had to recover, but recovered well... He does have a great voice i bet he could have done better if he started at a lower key.

  • one of the best male voices i have ever heard!

  • he is SO cute!

  • OKAY!!! He soo went flat @ parts but some parts were great like really great but overall i'm not impressed....... And if u're thinkin about comin to ask if i cud do bettr.... HELL da F*** yes!! So save it!! I'd give him 4 out of 10 for the effort but there were really sum nice notes in there!! So i'd say it was a fairly aite job!!

  • I could only count three or four and he barely went flat. He has great pitch.

    He did an excellent job and way better than you could do any day. Sorry :)

    8/10

  • Almost like Edyta Górniak with Polish Anthem

  • is it me or the loading takes forrever

  • wow his voice is veery high... great...

  • Damn he's good!

  • damn i loved it, hes prob one of the few artist that can sing live so i really dont agree with you him and daughtry sound great live he has a voice that suit acoustic songs and i think thats the hardest.

  • excellent job elliot!

  • hes voice of beautifulll. but it needs to be abit faster.

  • I don´t think theres no need to make a national anthem your own, so to speak. Some small things may be addded, otherwise I think it´s enough with Elliots unique voice, he definately over done this one, I get nervous by listening to it, check out the version by Steven Tyler !

  • he didnt hit the high notes

  • not the best rendition I have heard... parts of it sound amazing, yet I don't feel he hit the climaxes of his interpretation - I think he should've definitely started in a lower key...

    You can't blame it on the nerves - he's been under that same pressure before... Should've been prepared for that big of a venue

    Grade: C+

  • Seriously, ya'll, thats what being a singer is about: making a song YOUR own! Elliot definitely added his OWN flavor to the National Anthem...clearly the ones who are hating know NOTHING about singing! Its no such thing as a "right or wrong key" as far as the national anthem goes..ppl switch it up all the time! GET A CLUE!

  • yea he is a good soul singer! hear he's working on a new CD!

  • wow that was awesome!!!

    kelly clarksons is still my favorite just cause im obsessed with her, but damn hes awesome, im going to have to watch more of him!

  • Stop all the bashing...

    I think he did SPLENDIDLY.

    Elliott rules.

  • To "start in the wrong key" is somewhat incorrect considering none of you likely know what key he was planning on singing it in to begin with. He may have changed his tonality from the original note he started on during the song.

  • he's amazing

    i think it sounded great the way he did it.

    just shows you how quick he is, even though he started in the wrong key, he made it work. i would've been nervous but he did it amazingly.

    love you!!!

  • Yes he started off in the wrong key, And Yes, he had some flat notes to try and compensate. But, that's a part of being an artist. He did his damn thang!!! I loved him then and I love him now!!!!! He can do no wrong in my ears, lol.

  • a lot of great singers came out of american idol

  • he started alright but he just messed up the whole thing in the middle and towards the end. he was off key and he tried to play it off with his riffs but it just sounded so amatuer. I can tell he's a better artists on recordings but I can't stand his live performances. I'm dissappointed.

  • =) I love Elliot Yamin! It sounded great, such a soulful voice...

  • Ok I'm gonna tell y'all what happened. At the beginning he was waiting for the first note in his ear piece but it never came. So he started without it. He started too high for his voice, so he had to change the melody sometimes to compensate. I think he did a great job.

  • That's exactly what happened! He started in a key a a step or so higher than he intended. He recovered well for the most part, but it was awkward at times...

  • That was sensational! That one hater..you betta stop. That range was just perfect for his fantastic voice!

  • hes so funny in the beginning.

  • Ahh what a nice rape lol

  • IL EST TROP FORT C ABUZER

  • he has a great voice!

  • amazing voice!

  • AND U CAN?

  • He never said he could... The note didn't come in his ear at the beginning, and he accidentally started too high. But it was an excellent recovery!

  • wow i loved it .....

  • Next to Marvin Gayes version back in the 1980's this one of my favs

  • Awesome!!! love his tone!!

  • Elliott gave a very UNIGUE version of the national anthem..EXCELLENT ELLIOTT..he really should have won!!!!

  • i loved elliott the first time i layed eyes on him. hes absolutly amazing.<3

  • haha

    this is so amazing.

  • he is such a cutie pieeeeeeee

  • his voice reminds me of someone..cant think of whom..but anyhow he sang it great ;D

  • yo that was the best rendition of the star spangled banner from a male singer.i love it! he put so much soul into it!

  • i looove his voice and i do think that this was absolutely great but girls versions of the national anthem always sound better i think xd

  • Love him

  • Elliott is awesome singing anything ... he just has a great voice... no music either.. some have music... his phrasing is perfection. His tone one of a kind and gifted with superstar class..

  • him and fantasia had the best!!

  • i dont get it he did his own thing to the song, the problem is people are so use to the one way of singing the natl anthem, the traditional high notes and such, but he sounds exactly how he does live he does his own thing with songs and the people loved it.

  • oh btw i never said that he had a bad voice in general.

  • Marvin Gaye's rendition is the best of all time. This guy is superficial soul at best.

  • i love elliott to deathhhh!!!!

  • he might have been bad in this but he should have won american idol!! he has an amazing voice he was just havin a bad night!!!

  • I don't think it was that bad. And yes he should have won

  • ok then

  • I LOVE THIS! it's better than cook's, i mean seriously.

  • heck yes!!!!

  • Too many runs but not bad at all, IMO.

  • he sucked.

  • HOw the fuck can u say that? let me guess u went ofr david cook w/e u have a HORRIBLE ear for music then u fag!

  • just stating my oppinion.

    calm the fuck down.

  • wow ure coolb/c u say that maybe u should learn to spell *OPINION*

  • oh shit extra p in opinion

    everyone's gonna die now.

    if we're gonna start correcting spelling well:

    you're**

    because**

    you**

    you** (again)

    jesus fucking christ.

  • o wow your so cool b/c you say jesus' name in vein and b/c u say shit! OMG!!! wow you are such a freak

  • that's a shit comeback.

    opps mean crap, i'm not cool enough to say shit.

    i don't care if i said jesus' name in vein.

    oh. yeah. i'm a freak.

    thanks :)

  • good you recognized that your not cool enough

    halleluiah! praise god! god I hope u get hit bye a car in the near future

  • you spelled hallelujah wrong.

    wishing death to someone is really cool by the way.

  • ya i kno it is!! thanks for telling me even though i already new!! = ]

  • would it hurt to type one extra letter?

    know doesn't take that long to type

  • i just want to type somethings in abbreviations b/c i have a life i have to live?

  • LOL ON THE INTERWEBZ~~~~~~~~

    kay stop fighting with me.

    you're not getting anywhere.

  • ya you arent either and i am getting really tired of having to keep coming back to this video so ya just stop alright bye

  • what kind of comment is that. Fist of all he sounds great second get your ears and your attitude checked.

  • I checked this anthem out, after I saw people bashing Cook's. Wow, I'm sorry, but this one is awful! I was an Elliott fan when he was on Idol, too, but he ruined the anthem with those vocal runs that went nowhere.

  • Wow,, soul all through it... the best!!!

  • oh my gosh how many of you heard Cook sing this?? He did so bad!!! He really cant sing anything, hes only a rocker and hes not so diverse as people have said. Elliot singing this is soooo good and so was David Archuleta!!

  • He sounds like he sounds!!!!! Which I love.  Thank you Eliot

  • he sounds like a black man

  • Elliott rocks! That was a fantastic version and he obviously was feeling it. Like somebody else said, the man can sing anything!

  • me too. :(

  • i wish i could sing...:(

  • His voice seemed a little rough. He should've gona in falsetto for the high notes.

  • Elliott has no limations lol - jus watch any of his Idol performances for proof of that. If I can dream - an incredibly difficult song to sing - and he jus nailed it. One of the best voices ive ever heard. Altho Buble still far and away the best singer in the world for me atm - no limit to what he can do either.

    Ells

    1

  • I liked it:)

  • Good job, Elliott! The man can sing anything.

  • name that i was great,your so used to hearing women to do the national anthem,but he did for the men.lets see another male in the industry do it like that!!

  • soulful... Oorah!

    The Sarge

  • gosh he suck at national athem.

  • GOSH HE SUCK..WHUTS WRONG?

  • YOU are nasty to say that....what country are you in????

    Being patriot is good for the soul.....

  • You can be a good patriot without liking every version of star spangled banner.

  • i love Elliott

  • soulful like marvin!

  • type it in and you will see it was outstanding

  • Sorry... ONly Whitney Houston could do this!!

  • yeah when was this

  • yeah when was this

  • You people are mental, he obviously new he couldn't get the high notes thats why he changed the arrangement. I think he did well!! Id love to hear any one of you do it better....plus he looked super nervous

  • I remember when this happened. They should have had Stackhouse sing the anthem.

  • ok imagine a guy sing in that key (thats if you no what key is) would it sound right?

  • You can sing the anthem in any key or arrangement that you feel most comfortable with. He obviously didn't do that. And since he is a singer, he should know his limitations.

  • He just put too much "fluff" in his arrangement. And he started too high, that was his main problem. I do like Jerry's Stackhouse's version. That man can sing!!!

  • He's a guy, you can't really expect him to hit that the high notes. Some females don't even pull it off

  • Nope.

  • ummm when was this and wat game was it?

  • He did change the arrangement quite much, but it does not mean that he was out of tune or pitchy. Elliot is one of the few true male vocalists that AI ever has.

  • his control is poor compared to other singers and his singing changes in pitch at times. it wasn't HORRIBLE just not good.

  • he can't hit the high note :(

  • GO PATRIOTS

  • shut up women and let the boy sing!!! lol