Added: 3 years ago
From: DavidCookCentral
Views: 46,674
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (72)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i know it from House . Nice perform !

  • 1st: it's I FARM for my meals

    2nd: is he trying to beat Daltrey??? haha

    3rd-it sucks

  • I THINK THIS IS THE BEST OF DAVID COOK WISH HE DID A FULL VERSION OF THIS SONG!!!

  • Not nearly as much passion as Daltrey sings it with

  • lame

  • he nailed it.

    like he did every single week. (:

  • @stephanielostthegame -- he is a very competent singer. But he relies too much on his faux bluesy-vibratto. Like all Idol singers, they all seem to add an extra layer of sauce on everything, they can't just leave a note. I understand, you're trying to stand out, but I can predict how he's going to approach every note. He never suprises me. I did like the octave jump -- that did catch me a bit, and he stopped phrasing everything the same way during that ...

  • Hey dude i did not say Pearl Jam was this great band. I am NOT a pearl Jam fan. I am an Eddie Vedder fan. And i will stand by my comment his cover is 100 times better that this version. I guess that is why Eddie is big time and this guy is still looking.

  • Really? I though it was a poor job, terrible cover. Really song sounds like shit on 33 speed. I guess i am extra critical about this song since it is in my top 3 of all time greatest Classic Rock Songs. Just my opinion. If you want a good cover of this song check out Pearl Jams. They dont make it sound like shit. Hell the Blue Man Group does this 10 times better than this.

  • @LesSmith45 Fuck Pearl Jam. Most overrated band in history.

  • 2:12

  • @davidcookcentral is there any studio version available?

  • this show like died... u never hear anything about it anymore

  • Great song by my fave Idol!

  • He has a nice voice, I like it but this version... it's a who song so... can't expect anyone else to do it half as good

  • welcome back David Cook!

  • WHAT THE FUCK IS THIS??????!!!!!!!!!!!

  • good vocals... crap song version... where's the ultra trippy intro

  • OMG! that's too short!!! I want more!!!! 

  • That's it!? So short!!!!

  • I don't think there was a studio version of this done, was there? This was a teaser...I needed MORE!!!

  • @ewolfgirl I was just thinking that!!

  • @ewolfgirl Me to. I would love a studio for this!

  • I love this.

  • It's okay... I really didn't expect him to sing that good... I mean he can't produce the same kind of voice as someone that's around 65now.

  • ugh

  • wow, this is way different than what i expected reading the comments. i was expecting him to like plow over this song with a bulldozer, failing epically, but i really liked it. this was actually a good version.

    not like the who - no ones like the who - but this version is pretty amazing(:

  • Everybody always say "no one like original , no one can sing like original artist..." yes cof course. Why ? cuz they not the same person . If all we has same style & same voice. So, what will happen ? All we will be ROBOT LOL yes but its true

    And i always open mind to enjoy other version even thought its NOT ORIGINAL VERSION !

    LOVE DAVID COOK, ONE OF BEST BEAUTIFUL VOICE EVER

    HE'S TALENT & SO PRETTY CUTE <3

  • it seems everyone is like "NOTHING LIKE THE ORIGINAL I HATE IT" then they sing more originally and it's like "TO MUCH LIKE THE ORIGINAL I HATE IT"

  • @InterEDGE Respect.

  • He sounds amazing..i mean its nothing like the who but he did a pretty good job doing it is own way!! Good job david :)

  • You guys don't realize that if he covered the whole song it would've taken too long. They only get a certain amount of time to sing so with what he was given, he did a pretty excellent job in my opinion.

  • i love this song mainly because cook sang it. cook rocks! he's iconic himself! detractors, he'll stand the test of time!

  • We need a medic here!

  • somebody better call 911 for murder because he deffinetly just KILLED that song

  • wtf... Wheres the rest of the song..

  • hm...i know i will get rated down, but i don't like this version too. i really like his other songs, and other versions of old songs, but this one... no please, fail.

  • he sang like one verse from the song, theres so much more to baba o'riley than this....

  • nice vocals, but did the song injustice. it just deviates too far from the version im accustomed to

  • Love this cover =]

  • some of the kids in the front probably dont even noe this song which is sad

    o love this song

    well im a kid but i know it

    love The Who && David Cook

    This cover is pretty good :]

  • Terrific cover...your voice David is awesome!

    You are a true Idol, keep rocking!

    Love your concerts...I can't believe you are on concet #98!

  • ok, david cook is an amazing performer and has an excellent voice. but i can't stand this version of my favorite song. he takes away the badass aura of it and makes it somewhat of a pop version. he didn't ruin the song, but he certainly didn't capture the essence of one of music's greatest songs.

  • why are people putting your comment as negative?? totally agree with you!!

  • this version sucks.

  • real song rocks, his version sucks

  • love this song

  • what are you basing yourself on.. that was a homer simpson comment and i do mean it because of the ignorant ideotic content, the guy has a nice voice and he didnt change it drastically.... i like the who a lot and im always going to think that the original is better but if you dont know dont, talk,,, he didnt kill it you fucking moron

  • I think he deserved to win from the beginning

    But I think the finals should have been between him and Micheal Johns. Johns wasnt great at choosing songs, but had a fandibulous voice. Archie shouldve been third.

    Go Cook!

  • Yeah before MJ went home I was actually having a hard time deciding who I wanted to win the show him or DC.

  • I agree with you, except that I would have picked Carly Smithson over Michael Johns. She obviously had the best voice that season, except that she didn't always make the right song choices.

  • I think David did a great job for only getting 2 minutes of this song to sing. I WISH he could of performed the whole song.

    David Rocks!

  • The Who sings it better

  • duh

  • so rockin hot baby !!!!!!!!!!

  • How do you like them apples Archie!?

  • heheh it's from CSI NY

  • THIS IS OFF OF CSI!!!!

  • Uh huh. Riiiggghhht.

  • the song! lol i think its CSI Miami if i remember correct cuz the one off of CSI Las Vegas is "WHOOOOOO was it? who who, who who?!" lol i was watching it last night!!! ;D

  • I doubt that. The Who was years before CSI.

  • that doesn't mean it's not in it. all the CSIs credits at the beggining are set to The Who songs. CSI:NY is Baba O'Riley. CSI: Miami is Won't Get Fooled Again. And regular CSI is Who Are You.

  • Hmm.

    Good point.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more