Yeah, their lip syncing is just stupid, and billie joe as St.Jimmy was awesome. But in their defense, BJ wasn't an original cast member. The real dissapointment was that Tony Vincent wasn't there, imo the better St. Jimmy.
alright, for all of you people that keep saying "this sucks ass. i hate lip-synching and they arnt even playing correct guitar chords" have you shits been to new york city in the winter? it is fucking freezing. cold tempuratures+voices don't mix plus these people have to perform 14 shows a week. i want you all to try and sing above 400,000 people without blowing you vocal chords and playing guitar strings that are so cold that by the time youre finished playing your fingers look like shreds.
ok, 2 things; at the end, he should of held the flag upside down, would of made moar sense. second, i find it disturbing that the company that made me understand the lyrics to 21 guns which broke me down inside can sing good riddance with such a smile on their face. it's another break up song, not a cya later song.
but i just listened to the entire broadway recording straight through, i'm not dissing them or anything, this vid is just so left field for me
. obviously you dont like green day as much as you say u do if ur shit talking this play. green day worked on this play themselves, this is how green day made it sound and look. they hand picked these people to be in the play. so if uu dont like it who gives a fuck? its green days vision not yours and id appreciate if you shut the fuck up. thanksss
this isnt spsd to be green day and theyre not ripping off green day. theyre purpose is to convey the story of american idiot. to all you assholes below me shit talking the play: SHUT THE FUCK UP.
@meemsy1039 Yeah! its not like someone just took the songs and made it into a play. Green day was a part of making it too.So green day approves which means that its not really ripping off.People should stop talking shit and spend time doing their research.
i like the Green Day only version better, but this is still an amazing performance. it takes some serious balls to sing an play guitar on live TV, an the fact that they had so much pressure on them an they did so well is crazy.
i hope they do more Green Day stuff in the future!
@estimaze nobody in the macys daqy parade actually sings. everyone HAS to lipsing. if you actually went to see the show, you would hear how they sound exactly like this live. probably even better
grr i hate this musical shit, i mean they're all obviously very talentented but it just seems to cheesy to me.. its like none of them have any attitute :/
I hate lip sync, I just think that Green day would never have lip syncs.... And I hate the fact that the cast of American Idiot did it, even if every act in the macy's day parade does it.
0:22 and 1:32 you can clearly see they're playing the wrong chords. The guy at 1:32 plays the entire song half a step to high and doesn't even notice it...
@snorrijons okay... but some of them actually are playing guitar. not all of them. but some of them. even in new york not all of them play guitar. but theyre still amazingly talented. and if you can’t realize that, then there’s clearly something wrong.
@BiLLiEJoEisH0Txo8 Yeah, they are talented, I can't argua against that. I'm just saying that it's too obvious that some of them are not playing the guitar. I'm a huge Green Day fan and I love everything the AI cast does, but sometimes it's a little too obvious who's playing and who's not.
@snorrijons okay. :D yeah, you’re right. it is kinda obvious. even in the show in new york a few of them worn’t playing. but yeah, i still admire them beyond belief. theyre amazing<3
i love it !!! but i still think Good Riddance at Milton Keynes back in 2005 was the best performance of this song... anyway, is the same thing: GREEN DAY ROCKS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Thanksgiving is a part of unneccessary payment and american idiocy.now I can't really understand what green day was against to in 2004 and how they are acting like now.I won't really try to explain everything clearly but you can't regret that many things they do are a total contradiction together.Billie Joe was always right about one thing;he's a "walking contradcition".I'm still a big fan of the band,but what they're doing now really dissappoints me.
they should have performed macys day parade haha. yeah they did lip sync. every act does. i remember seeing idina menzel and kristin chenoweth on it and they DEFINTELY lip sanc so i think every act does
I tried to go see this but we couldnt get close enough. :( we heard the sound checks and then we heard them perform but it was impossible to get close enough to see
1:08 - 1:18 best moment *_*
DeutschrockDani 1 week ago
0:58-1:02
what happened?
NerdyMusicianify 1 month ago
Declan Bennett <3 all the other's are either flat... or boring...
TheBenAppleby 2 months ago
GERARD.
FallKABOOM 2 months ago
They are not singing, know why? THEY DON'T HAVE A MICROPHONE haha lol
08085356 2 months ago
@08085356 yeah they do. it's attached to the clothes and/or warps around their heads...
merbethmango 2 months ago 2
@08085356 correction: wraps. sorry. i type fast. haha
merbethmango 2 months ago
its Libby Winters, love her voice 2
svdewalde17 3 months ago 2
I Feel Like they Should Have Played Macys Day Parade : )
JesusOfSuburbia42 3 months ago 6
Gerard is sexy!!! and John is adorable cute
ILuvBillieJoe2004 3 months ago
0:29 ! Love her voice it's just amazing !
WargamRecord 4 months ago 4
that was fucking stupid, they were all lip syncing and billie joe wasnt playing.
christherocker98 4 months ago
@christherocker98
Yeah, their lip syncing is just stupid, and billie joe as St.Jimmy was awesome. But in their defense, BJ wasn't an original cast member. The real dissapointment was that Tony Vincent wasn't there, imo the better St. Jimmy.
Curlingkingz 3 months ago
Everytime I hear this song I tear up.
manny27999 4 months ago
0:29 love her voice
BeyongWetalist 4 months ago 24
I would kill to be in that musical.....
reverenfender 4 months ago
@reverenfender i would kill to see that musical haha
SuperBlueipod 4 months ago
@SuperBlueipod lol its amazing i saw it in april its going on tour nxt yr i think catch it then lol
reverenfender 4 months ago
Comment removed
acerdude3 5 months ago
they are all using epiphone guitars
StJimmy2568 5 months ago
@StJimmy2568 so?
Wildone995 5 months ago
@Wildone995 just saying.
StJimmy2568 5 months ago
Shouldnt they be singing Macy's Day Parade?
DNEsBandPage 5 months ago 2
lovelovelovelovelovefrigginlove. <3
unfabulous386 5 months ago
its recorded
diamond19971 5 months ago
its recorded
diamond19971 5 months ago
2 of these people have a Gibson... But the others have Epiphone...
KurtTheGuitarPlayer 5 months ago
EPIPHONE HUMMINGBIRD! :D <3 ma guitar right there
NorwaysSuburbia 5 months ago
alright, for all of you people that keep saying "this sucks ass. i hate lip-synching and they arnt even playing correct guitar chords" have you shits been to new york city in the winter? it is fucking freezing. cold tempuratures+voices don't mix plus these people have to perform 14 shows a week. i want you all to try and sing above 400,000 people without blowing you vocal chords and playing guitar strings that are so cold that by the time youre finished playing your fingers look like shreds.
noalocholrequired 5 months ago
there are only a few people playing guitars, the others are acting.
juliac92 5 months ago
I'm gonna call bull crap cuz they don't have any mics
rabricci2 6 months ago
@rabricci2 I agree with noalcoholrequired This is extremely well done for the circomstances
1018bandgeek 5 months ago
I love Rebecca so much.
MCRomg 6 months ago
2:00 haha^^
SheilaTwinkies 6 months ago
I was at this parade in person. It was awesome.
FinalLugiaGuardian 7 months ago
this crowd is fucking on something.. they're not even moving!!!
MG21749 7 months ago
i can hear tony vincents voice, but u cant see him....
HeadLoong 7 months ago
who sings first?
pinkypurple1234 8 months ago
@pinkypurple1234 The first guy who's singing is Gerard Canonico ;)
KattjaNOR 8 months ago
100 % PLAYBACK
mangakaification 9 months ago
wats up with the dude at 1:20 playing country
548latino 9 months ago
@548latino its not country?
Cappilover 7 months ago
Don't let that black chick sing this song...she sucks
mclovin2780 9 months ago
Comment removed
mooneclipse2010 5 months ago
@mooneclipse2010 not really racist. more judgmental than anything
mclovin2780 5 months ago
i luvthe whole cast with all my heart this is so amazing!!!!!! i wish the show was still on Broadway...
MrsArmstrong21 9 months ago
i swear to god i only can hear the black chick sing good voice but it overpowers everyone else
^_-
XxnaudxX 10 months ago
Thats a lot of Epiphone acoustics. i bet they got them for free
Beezaboy 11 months ago
@KattjaNOR Declan Bennett.
StarsHockeyChica 1 year ago
What's the name of the guy on 0:34-0:36? The guy with the bleached blonde hair.
KattjaNOR 1 year ago
i remember BTR lip syncing there...good times...
sonicuproar2000 1 year ago
Michael Esper <3 It's so sad that he's gonna quit :'(
KattjaNOR 1 year ago
@KattjaNOR oops, sry... some1 told me that was him.
therocker2552 1 year ago
@therocker2552 It's okay ;) Tony Vincent is/was St. Jimmy ;) He's no longer in the musical.
KattjaNOR 1 year ago
@KattjaNOR its now the guy from AFI
DNEsBandPage 1 year ago
John Gallagher Jr. was hilarious at the end, just the position he was in XD no hate intended at all
jonkim27 1 year ago
They are not actually playing the guitar. Obviously.
CPSHOWTV 1 year ago
I love Espers Solo :) <3 fav. part
Cappilover 1 year ago
HOLY CRAP THEYRE LIPS DONT MATCH TEH WORDS......
therocker2552 1 year ago
@KattjaNOR he's the one with the blond streak in his hair.
therocker2552 1 year ago
@therocker2552 Thats Chase Peacock ,not Tony Vincent.Tony wasnt there this day
carlybolton 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@therocker2552 Thats Chase Peacock ,not Tony Vincent.Tony wasnt there this day
carlybolton 1 year ago
@therocker2552 I know who Tony Vincent is but that's Chase Peacock....
KattjaNOR 1 year ago
ok, 2 things; at the end, he should of held the flag upside down, would of made moar sense. second, i find it disturbing that the company that made me understand the lyrics to 21 guns which broke me down inside can sing good riddance with such a smile on their face. it's another break up song, not a cya later song.
but i just listened to the entire broadway recording straight through, i'm not dissing them or anything, this vid is just so left field for me
mega48man 1 year ago 2
awesome performance!
great harmonies!
and it really showcases their amazing talents well!
iamvalerielane 1 year ago
0:00 - 2:00 THE BEST PART! ! !
SkyWalkerOptimuko 1 year ago
I hear Tony Vincent's voice but he's not there...
KattjaNOR 1 year ago 20
I love this! Amazing Cast!!!!!
MrZcornett 1 year ago
i liked the first guy
ssanrock97 1 year ago
. obviously you dont like green day as much as you say u do if ur shit talking this play. green day worked on this play themselves, this is how green day made it sound and look. they hand picked these people to be in the play. so if uu dont like it who gives a fuck? its green days vision not yours and id appreciate if you shut the fuck up. thanksss
<3
meemsy1039 1 year ago 3
this isnt spsd to be green day and theyre not ripping off green day. theyre purpose is to convey the story of american idiot. to all you assholes below me shit talking the play: SHUT THE FUCK UP.
meemsy1039 1 year ago
@meemsy1039 Yeah! its not like someone just took the songs and made it into a play. Green day was a part of making it too.So green day approves which means that its not really ripping off.People should stop talking shit and spend time doing their research.
jenniferfeliciano66 1 year ago
OK NICE
hilaryedy2 1 year ago
I saw them on Broadway, and was AMAZED when at the end the entire cast walked out and started playing this song!! I LOVE IT SO MUCH!
bordummonster 1 year ago
unbelievable !
LikesTheLastDay 1 year ago
Comment removed
sc93ful 1 year ago
Comment removed
sc93ful 1 year ago
I LOVE IT!!!!!!!!!!
shewantstogotousa 1 year ago
Wow. Just Wow
BTBHSOHBOY 1 year ago
this is amazing!!!
checkyesjuliet321 1 year ago
I got to see this parade. Awesome!
FinalLugiaGuardian 1 year ago
thumbs up 4 girl guitar players
reverenfender 1 year ago
you guys should make your own musik and don´t play so pften the same song(wich is beautiful)
P.s.: sorry for my englisch (german)
fenderstratlover09 1 year ago
Hey guys!
Does anybody know of a good review of 21st century breakdown?
Thx.
glamourgirl2411 1 year ago
no just no
to many losers with guitars
i want billie joe
biddy96 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
damn, its like an Epiphone pumpkin patch!
GeekBrainStew 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
damn, its like an epiphone pumpkin patch!
GeekBrainStew 1 year ago
damn, its like an epiphone pumpkin patch
GeekBrainStew 1 year ago
damn, its like an epiphone pumpkin patch
GeekBrainStew 1 year ago
this completly sucks. only billie joe can actually sing these songs
Assassinator15 1 year ago
Didn't they do Holiday as well?
TheKnightBus218 1 year ago
were they lipsynching
whoahippo 1 year ago
Dear John Gallagher Jr.,
I love you.
That is all.
allisonwonderrand 1 year ago 2
1:18 lol
Suppose to be an eletric guitar
but.. what the hell... Its still awesome :D
StarSonata10 1 year ago
Moritz pose at 2:00. <3
Chicochicka07 1 year ago 6
@Chicochicka07 omg you're right ! haha ! that IS a moritz pose at 2:00 :)
merbethmango 1 year ago
es una mariconada...
nimroddk 1 year ago
i like the Green Day only version better, but this is still an amazing performance. it takes some serious balls to sing an play guitar on live TV, an the fact that they had so much pressure on them an they did so well is crazy.
i hope they do more Green Day stuff in the future!
DanteBlack2274 1 year ago 3
I love you guys....I'm on the other side of the world but I love you:) :) :) ahahhahha:)
annastargirl 1 year ago
i swear i only hear 1 guitar...
Patt2417 1 year ago 61
@Patt2417 Go to the doctor.
matidawi 1 year ago
@Patt2417 then you sir have hearing problems.
SmartParts1125 10 months ago 4
I love the part at 1:14 it's so cool!
monkeyvine 1 year ago
I love this tooo!!! And john is really cute in here :) <3
monkeyvine 1 year ago
@monkeyvine john is really cute anywhere :)
merbethmango 1 year ago
@1:05 Who's the man on the left side with his red and black sweather? I hope that some one can tell me his name x
clubsupporter 1 year ago
@clubsupporter that's Chase Peacock :)
MyMindsAlive 1 year ago
what name girls singing as a 4 ??
MultiKappy 1 year ago
@MultiKappy you mean the 4th singer at the beginning of the song? That's Libby Winters.
MyMindsAlive 1 year ago
@MultiKappy It goes, Gerard... Wallace... Miguel... Libby(:
lifetimeperformer 1 year ago
her name as the girl sings in the order as the fourth
Poslech ?? pls
MultiKappy 1 year ago
this was live?
xkilagramx 1 year ago
ahhh! this is terrific!
but what happens if your left handed? :p lol
smileymiley111 1 year ago
sorry but that just made me puke
fosterzgreat 1 year ago
@estimaze nobody in the macys daqy parade actually sings. everyone HAS to lipsing. if you actually went to see the show, you would hear how they sound exactly like this live. probably even better
MakeupBySav 1 year ago
Weird how there are no microphones....or cords connecting their guitars to amps.....huh...
Im a huge green day fan....but I fucking hate lip syching.
estimaze 1 year ago
Weird how there are no microphones....or cords connecting their guitars to amps.....huh...
estimaze 1 year ago
@estimaze i want you to try and sing over 400,000 people and be heard by everyone of them without blowing your vocal chords.
noalocholrequired 5 months ago
@noalocholrequired Hence using microphones and speakers.
estimaze 5 months ago
Comment removed
cmarielizabeth 1 year ago
Bullshit
BurnyFiona 1 year ago
omg i <3 themmm!!!!!! :D Chase Peacock is AMAZING!!!!!!
lovemehateme318 1 year ago 2
why did green day get the High School Musical treatment?!
for fuck's sake leave it alone!
DookieAdz 1 year ago
It's like Macys Day Parade song becomes alive :D
insomniacPT 1 year ago
yay stark!
godlove2006 1 year ago
grr i hate this musical shit, i mean they're all obviously very talentented but it just seems to cheesy to me.. its like none of them have any attitute :/
fenderjackson73 1 year ago
I don't like lip sync :(
Rijnes 1 year ago
wouldnt it make sense to play macys day parade at....the macys day parade
greendayisgooooodd 1 year ago 44
@greendayisgooooodd No, because it's not Macy's Day Parade, It's Macy's THANKSGIVING Day Parade.
No, it's not the same.
matidawi 1 year ago
@greendayisgooooodd that's exactly what I was going to say!
I guess they didn't wanna play it since a lot of the people watching wouldn't recognize the song. haha
EarthUntilDawn 11 months ago
@greendayisgooooodd it's also because they don't have that song in the show... they play this one at the end of every show.
DeadMoose01 11 months ago 2
booya
13GreenQueen 1 year ago
I hate lip sync, I just think that Green day would never have lip syncs.... And I hate the fact that the cast of American Idiot did it, even if every act in the macy's day parade does it.
HitchinToPasalacqua 1 year ago 2
This is so beautiful! LOVE the harmony. I keep playing this over and over.
Imdawn1 1 year ago
This is so beautiful! LOVE the harmony. I keep playing this over and over.
Imdawn1 1 year ago
most amazing song but its better original
HelloHollywood1996 1 year ago
what a load of shit
GoingToPasalacqua12 1 year ago
0:22 and 1:32 you can clearly see they're playing the wrong chords. The guy at 1:32 plays the entire song half a step to high and doesn't even notice it...
snorrijons 1 year ago
@snorrijons okay... but some of them actually are playing guitar. not all of them. but some of them. even in new york not all of them play guitar. but theyre still amazingly talented. and if you can’t realize that, then there’s clearly something wrong.
BiLLiEJoEisH0Txo8 1 year ago
@BiLLiEJoEisH0Txo8 Yeah, they are talented, I can't argua against that. I'm just saying that it's too obvious that some of them are not playing the guitar. I'm a huge Green Day fan and I love everything the AI cast does, but sometimes it's a little too obvious who's playing and who's not.
snorrijons 1 year ago
@snorrijons okay. :D yeah, you’re right. it is kinda obvious. even in the show in new york a few of them worn’t playing. but yeah, i still admire them beyond belief. theyre amazing<3
BiLLiEJoEisH0Txo8 1 year ago
i love it !!! but i still think Good Riddance at Milton Keynes back in 2005 was the best performance of this song... anyway, is the same thing: GREEN DAY ROCKS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Christinagreenday 1 year ago
Really nice that is how a concert or a musical should be xd
GreenDayandMuse 1 year ago
Amazing guys great!
HeidyArmstrong 1 year ago
I love it But the orginal is still the best:)
greendaylistener0014 1 year ago
His is great!!! I saw the show in August with OBC and I wanna go again!! I love Miguel's hat lol
HappyMadisonDude 1 year ago
would have been fun if they played macys day parade on macys day parade :D :D
piloj123 1 year ago 3
Thanksgiving is a part of unneccessary payment and american idiocy.now I can't really understand what green day was against to in 2004 and how they are acting like now.I won't really try to explain everything clearly but you can't regret that many things they do are a total contradiction together.Billie Joe was always right about one thing;he's a "walking contradcition".I'm still a big fan of the band,but what they're doing now really dissappoints me.
cerenthekoala 1 year ago
Awesome like always -
JuulYT 1 year ago
Great!! The people are great!!
Janiina97 1 year ago
they should have performed macys day parade haha. yeah they did lip sync. every act does. i remember seeing idina menzel and kristin chenoweth on it and they DEFINTELY lip sanc so i think every act does
hbomb2704 1 year ago
I wanted to get close to see them but it was blocked off. How did those people get those seats back there?
Melissa2087 1 year ago
that kinda sucked.
Joberooni 1 year ago
This was my class song five years ago.
HTownCountryFan 1 year ago
I tried to go see this but we couldnt get close enough. :( we heard the sound checks and then we heard them perform but it was impossible to get close enough to see
OneManArmy228 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
freeze it at 0:22, that is totally off of the g chord, for all you guitar nerds out there, and the lip syncing was bad too. terrible performance.
himynameiskeefe 1 year ago
Comment removed
himynameiskeefe 1 year ago
Was great.
ImJustAnotherEmily89 1 year ago
every single act in the macy's day parade lip syncs.
GraffMan95 1 year ago
it was lyp sync for sure!! they dont have microphones!! O.O
pipoandrea 1 year ago
@pipoandrea
i just noticed that too. still a good performance though
kTangso 1 year ago
@pipoandrea They have mics clipped to their shirts and jackets.
anotherpoint0fview 1 year ago
very nice, but i think they were lip syncing...
KMcPANSY 1 year ago
too... many... guitars.... Still awesome:)
PetterMyhr 1 year ago
sounds like a bounch of douchebags
spikeman316 1 year ago
love this!!! <3 they are amazing! :D
Skittle8888 1 year ago
love, love, love mister john gallagher jr. <33
suzyjacuzzi6791 1 year ago
im one of the biggest american idiots out there and i still think they shouldv sang macys day parade i makes more sense than good riddance
demonballoon 1 year ago
@demonballoon they have never played that as a cast. or, at least, it's never been on youtube or anything. but, it would be pretty awesome. XD
suzyjacuzzi6791 1 year ago
@suzyjacuzzi6791 i think they shuldv practiced it at the least
demonballoon 1 year ago
Thanks so much for posting this! I missed it this morning :) Absolutely beautiful!
paige3406 1 year ago
the first and first and fifth guy can't sing >.<
well, they don't do Billie Justice at all!!
juloph 1 year ago
@juloph Hating on Gerard and Declan, the two (objectively) best men in the ensemble?
What, what, what are you doing?
EmppuRocks 1 year ago
sounds like too many American Idiots are critics here.
emmabugsmama 1 year ago 30