Hilary Duff - Beat of My Heart (Live)

[MissDignity90]

this is my favorite HILARY LIVE PERFORMANCE !! ^_^ .. Hilary Duff Forever .. ^_^

[JPGforRealzzz]

She is lip syncing but sometimes it's because the programme WANTS the artist to lip sync and the sound will be better, you know. She doesn't have to lip sync anymore. Hilary Duff has one of the MOST (WANTED) beautiful voices ever. I love her. And another note, this programme is from my country, Spain, and almost all the singers who appeared there DID playback. Don't blame her. x

[nurialeonify]

this is playback

[emoondacase]

she look so old now

[XoSparklyoX]

@emoondacase This isn't even that recent, this is 5 years ago xD She's gonna be a mom soon...

[lipglossadorable]

Hello, reader. If you had started reading this, don't stop or else. I hate people who post these these kinds of comments but.... Post this to 16 videos in 30 minutes and promise your self to never listen to these kinds of comments or make one up. But this one is real. If you don't post this, a boy with no head and legs will show up in ur room at midnight kill you. Everyone will forget you. start posting. the time will start as soon as you finish reading this. yes I do hate these comments

[SoyLaLa93]

I STILL ADMIRE HER.!! ♥.♥

[MissDignity90]

i adore her .. // n fcuk all those 46 people who disliked this vdo!

[missgabriela90]

Actually Live!!!♥ her!

[cliquegirlicious]

shes amazing i used to love her! and people who think she always lipsyncs have you been to any of her concerts? i have been to three she sang live in ALL of them

[dreamworldlala]

shes singing for real so stfu

[cutegirllove1998]

wow great live

[ben94611]

No guys!

This is live but this user just change the live audio to the CD audio that why she sing so nice

The guitar,The drum and the keyboard are all from a CD

I watch this live at my home and it's live

[cherryxinh2pm]

not live. It's lipsync :(. she look so old :-s

[DrSeussPwns]

Still, it must be awkward to

be in the audience when u realize

that ur fave singer isn't singing...

[MileyNr7]

Her Voice is so awesome...<3

[loverofzebras]

awww i love this song! memories

[guritza80]

playback



[miptie1]

i miss the old hilary.

[ladygagaga24]

She is WAY to skinny here!

[maahem33]

people dont seem to realize that in Europe, this is NORMAL. They WANT YOU to lip sync it!

[iamsunshinegirl510]

@maahem33 why?

[peligroalavista]

play back buuu

[fani817]

she's too skinny on this vid

[zookeeniburger]

she is so incredibly beautiful, i wish i could find a girl like her

[BlackPinkize]

HER LIPS ARE BLUE!

[TheAngel669]

she's great.. she's soo pretty i want her to make new films and songs..

[StraightUneerie]

who cares about the lip synching. She gives a handful of musicians a job!

[Mannequin2009]

@StraightUneerie a lot of people care...she has no reason to lip....at all lol

[selenague]

lol i think when she had t horse teeth but luv dz song

[aandrebs90]

one of the most crappy lip synching i saw

[j4nneET]

shes so amazing:)

[theandyandsamyshow]

she looked so sad and unhappy during most of the performances promoting "Most Wanted" :[

[13sarabobara]

I sang this for a talent showed! Standing ovation baby! haha Loveeee this song!

[LeekuTikku]

I love Hilary Duff but she is Lip Singing :( I just played this simultaneously with the music video and when you turn down the volume of one it sounds exactly the same

[pleeteuk]

i love hilary

[Pinkysh101]

shes never NOT lip synched!

[xoxonkittikxoxo]

@Pinkysh101 Wrong, "o smart one". She sang live at the AMA's, look it up. Also look up "Hilary Duff - Come Clean LIVE [Yes, Live!] - Today Show [29/6/2007] " She's live in both of those.

[Pinkysh101]

@xoxonkittikxoxo thnx for letting me kno! ill go check em out:)

[Rattrap767]

its playback... lip sang

[oxdorin]

wateva~ she's hot and loveable

[TheMileyHilaryFan]

all tho im her biggest fan i gotta mention that is totally lip synching...so sad,cause her voice is so beautiful in live

[8299181]

playback

[silenthillmaster755]

oh i wanted to see if she could sing...lol

[daviddiabetik]

PEOPLE!! This show MAKES the artists lip sync, just like TOTP. Go watch her perform this song at the AMA's she sang it live. It was amazing. Stop acting shocked that this is lip synced, she can't help it that she can't sing live on every television appearance.

[rustydevilll]

@daviddiabetik

bro, she is singing

she just has a loud backing track

You are dumb.

[charicebiggestfan]

@daviddiabetik this is not lip syncing because there is a track of her song playing and she sing along u understand

[littlefickle]

jason hook looks so out of place!!! (guitarist on left now with five finger death punch)

[cacafeia2]

+.+ Hilary!!! <3

[Guilhermetmfranco]

lip synching bitch! learn how to sing!

[daviddiabetik]

SHE IS LIP SYNCING, GET OVER IT! She sings live, most of the time. This is a Spanish Television Program that REQUIRES people to lip sync. Go watch other artists sing on this show, THEY HAVE TO LIP SYNC. Get over it. When she does sing live she is amazing.

[krazyashlee101]

She is lip-sync. She was sick, get over it. She lip-synced once

OMG KILL ME

[TexasLover7]

She's really beautiful, but looks bad during this time of her life; which is during the time she was with that Madden guy. See what happens when the influence is there? But, nowadays (2010), she looks great!  That relationship was toxic. Who needs that?

[TheRyanToob]

watch?v=znC2KZMQoBk

[CaettyChannel]

hm...i think she is really singing...

[chfanx]

she's talentless like Britney 

[shelbowshelby]

shes lip singing

[Lucilasotor1]

omg i love her!

[Anthagiox]

Since most of you are too stupid to realize, a lot of shows put a track over the recording to make it sound better for television. Look at the way she's breathing, she's obviously singing in real life. They just put a track over the original recording.

[charicebiggestfan]

@Anthagiox yeah that right

[AEO68]

@Anthagiox actually she is lip singing it bc hilary cant sing well live and this show does make ppl sound good

[remao]

@AEO68 that is stupid! watch her concert videos she always sing in live

[weedy984]

her is a shock!!! SHE IS LIP SYNCHING!! AS USUAL!

[abigmusicfan13]

@weedy984 English Fail.

[weedy984]

@abigmusicfan13 what do you mean? excuse me, a small typo. HERE. Doesn't change the fact that she is lip synching.

[daviddiabetik]

She sings live all the time, but this TV show makes everyone lip sync. It's a show in spain.

[weedy984]

@daviddiabetik no she actually doesn't sing live all the time. She lip synchs about 95% of the time. Everyone knows this

[Anthagiox]

@weedy984 No, no one "knows" this. She sings live most of the time.

[funn1bunn1]

LIVE?????? NO WAY! YOU'RE 4!

[HugeFanOfBritney]

I'm disappointed for this girl :( She seems to have a pretty good voice but she NEVER sing live, NEVER!

[MissAmericanDreamO9]

does she ever sing live? never heard her sing live.

[h44512]

shes shit at lip synching. doesnt that prove that shes a live singer?

[diafaber]

in this program (from spain) all the singer never sang their song live...

i know because im from spain

[panicduckky]

nice lip syncing hilary.

[JohnSpelledWithAnH]

Wow. Musicians could at least make a "lip synching" recording of the song so it's not so obvious :P

[PurpleDotsRule98]

I like this song and I don't really thing she lip-synched

[EdwardScissorhands99]

can she actually sing

[weedy984]

@EdwardScissorhands99 she occasionally will sing her really slow songs live but she NEVER sings her fast songs like this live. I doubt she can .

[KanonIFan]

mmm...playback? =(

[krakkenboe]

if it is lip sync she is still good cause she was sick ;)

[cinn90]

not live

[Kthrules94]

ive spent the past half hour trying to find a video where shes actually singing live.. and there are no videos when she genuinely is.

i wonder if she can even sing, im pretty sure that her voice is so mixed that its not even her voice anymore

[Danis2246]

It's soo obvious she is lipsyncing. The drum kit & guitars etc arn't even mic'ed up either. That's soo funny.

[DVDFreaker]

You can see her spine at 2:31, she needs to go back to chunky Hilary!

[isaacreynoso10]

She could at least look like she was having fun :P

[inesusanne94]

Live? haha! bullshit!

[Concept3601]

i dont mind if artists cant sing as long as they sound good in studio and they write their own shit

[moviephone314]

shes ALWAYS lip syncs ALWAYS!

[inesusanne94]

@moviephone314 I know, It's so fucking enoying!

[maitkoiha]

why does she ALWAYS lip sync!? i sware to god! i used to look up to her .. but she looks like she's had to much H or X or K or Meth or somethin...

idk...i could cry right now, she was my inspiration for like everything...i still things she's beautiful. but she has a good voice why does she lip sync?!

[KarnMS]

@maitkoiha

So, how can they say that it is lip-sync, if at the end when she is grateful she is panting!

[maitkoiha]

@KarnMS TOO ALL THE HILARY FANS WHO READ THIS, I'M SORRY THAT WAS NOT ME, THAT WAS MY FRIEND, SHE IS NOT A HILARY DUFF FAN AND I LET HER USE MY ACCOUNT UNTIL SHE GOT HER OWN. SORRY!

I LOVE HILARY DUFF, AND YES THIS SONG WAS PLAYBACK SO SHE WAS SINGING BUT SINCE SHE HAD A FEW SONG BEFORE THIS PERFORMANCE, ITS JUST BACKUP

but i LOVE hilary :D

[KarnMS]

@maitkoiha ahaha ok don't worry well i love her also, and i think she can sing very well...i love averything about her: acting, singing and how she is...

[maitkoiha]

@KarnMS i love her too. i've loved her since casper meets wendy

[123Jenny90]

Yeah she's lipsinging

[Lammouth]

Lip syncccccc!!!!!!

[supermodelbrawl]

lip syncing

[IloveCupcakesandTea]

dosent it look like shes lip singing ?

[ReallLadyyGagaa]

LIP SYNCER

[xoDressage]

at first i thought she was lip synching.. but you can hear her breathing. she is only lip synching the "to the beat of my.. and the chorus part"

[IloveCupcakesandTea]

@xoDressage no you kan hear the breatyhing cuz she recorded it that way

[Normenne]

She's so obvioiusly lipsyncing

and loooks oh so enthused to be there

wtf is that kind of stage presence

oh and for good measure she looks anorexic

prolly bulimic

she smokes meth to make her skin pretty XD

[jamie207]

yea man she has went way to skinny she looks awful now i think bring her chunky with blond hair back

[BeyondsSister]

Lip syncing. -_-

[nichkhun22]

she kinda look like shes gonna die.

butta i like her.

[paulie]

OH GOD.

[rawfan2007]

umm beautifull but such obvious lip singing

[esserepensante]

i think so, playback

[Zuix69]

playback :)

[Holly2743]

playback ???

[Angy232523]

She had a strange face! What hapenned?

[TheGjkcity]

cuz she is grow up She is the best 4ever my hero

[Angy232523]

She´s beautiful =D

[weedy984]

@Angy232523 she got fake teeth put in so her face looks completely different

[marie81794]

TOTALLY LIP SANG

[fairandseqaer]

definitely!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[NANAaiko]

@marie81794 obviously she doesn't know how to lip sing~ good 4 her! haha!

[dcshoes182]

@marie81794 ss obvious..LOL

[animefreak3755]

i wish she wouldnt lip sync.

[thedeath4ever]

Straight hair fits her more!

[jac0bunderme]

she looks like a totally diff person here

[MsTampon12]

Is this lip-synched?

[IWantLumpia]

@MsTampon12 She sounds the same in every performance for a reason.

[SoBringItOn1]

her stylist should b shot her gloss makes her look like her lips r blue and she looks like she has bags. she also sounded hell tired as soon as the song ended. but she looks much better now. also she isnt lip syncing she has a LIVE band and it impossible for a band to fake.

[TheCheekie123]

@SoBringItOn1

It's lip-synched.

[cinnamoncb14]

Wow, she lip synced but she still is FOREVER BEAUTIFUL!

[TheGjkcity]

I agree with you I don't care if she is lip synched but she is gone be 4ever the best LOve her KOSOVO

[angelhopes117]

@TheGjkcity ,umm.. she died???

[angelhopes117]

@TheGjkcity Is that true; she died? 'cuz you said "she is gone."

[weedy984]

@angelhopes117 no she didn't die, i don't know why anyone would say that. She just got engaged lol she is definitely alive

[musiicas]

euhmm..FAKE??!!!

anyway...i like her and i know she has a great voice but that sounded fake when she says to the beat of my heart? what the fuck....

[DanEmmaFeltonfan]

great song :)

[DanEmmaFeltonfan]

great video

[jintheband]

i say i wanna play this sing on band hero buhoo

[lucas161616]

love (L)

[LesSecrets]

She looks so ill, here.She's to thin. I'm glad she's better

[MissThatsMe]

the lipgloss is purple guys, thats why here lips looks blue...

[lindsay0066]

I really love her, but look at her lips. they look so blue.

lips looks only blue if u to thin or u`ve gor cold.

But I really have to say that i like her so much more when she is thin. i think she looks so much older and sexier!

kiss =)

[susoy]

I think her anorexia is effecting her performances.

[soleilmh]

This is sad...

[lauu63]

i think she was sick:S, her zface is soo...strangeeee, i dont know

[DanyTanase]

i think that she is sick

[TheLeonalewis321]

wow so lip syncing

[babeaspormiboxer]

I don't thik it would be possible to call yourself a singer if you do playback

I know she can do something better than this and even if she couldn't, it would be nicer to hear her voice live

[GRACE050792able]

she look skinny here

[SweetAymen]

yea she looks skinny!!!!!!

[IMAHOBO2]

nice lip syncing

[hjkdillon]

YO! IMaHoMo DO NOT!!@! acuse HILARY! OF LIP syncing you homo!

$*#* you Noob >=(

[mart775]

she's obviously is lyp syncing in this show fucktard

[CryxInnocence]

i feel so bad for her here, you can tell shes so sick from being anorexic back then..

always love you hilary <3

[heartlover165]

wait really?? i thought it was cuz she was like in drugs or somthing b4

[lauu63]

@CryxInnocence she wasss very thin there! have she ever been anorexic?????

[cawiivip]

I hate how she always does playback. Like sing live girl, come on. I know she can do it.

[TheGjkcity]

wow guys if you realy love hilary you don't wanna to care is she is singing live I love her I a big fan off her from KOSOVA and I don't care if she is singing live

[rosesarkar95]

although i luv u hilary but i gotta tell ya , ur looking really bad in this concert, and y dont u ever sing live,if u sound bad live i am quite sure ur fans will luv it dat way only!

[barbara908]

or they could of autofixed it on tv? i hope you know that everytime something is on the tv they AUTO fix the audio thats why in tv shows live performances on ellen ect. sound perfect. they edit most of the audience out and shit so maybe its not playback?

[MnkNewYorker]

she's doing playback, isn't she?

[amandaandconniemedia]

I think she is defiently lipsynching, she sounds perfect and exactly like the track on her album and they surely edited her voice on the album track

[martinofino]

surely playback...sure"!

[jairafrando1]

i miss her

[rhodeme]

she never sings live....

[Avrilackles]

Eu detesto cantor que canta playback

da pra perceber que ela só está dublando

é porque ela não tem voz o suficiente para cantar ao vivo

horrível

[fabitapunk]

she looks sick!!

but i love her XD!!

[SmeezySisters]

lip syncing and geez... she looks half dead with that lipstick colour

[22Soccerchick1]

if it was live, how could they change the sound of the microphone so quickly and efficiently? she sounds perfect, and the sounds are EXACTLY like that of the track.

[aandrebs90]

in my opinion this time she's live, except the beginning, from 2:20 and other little parts, the rest it live, you can tell the rest from this little parts.

i admit the thankus at the end sound even stranger so...

[TheGjkcity]

i have listen care the video and she is singing live

[oldtimesong]

god, she was so fucking thin here...

[pDdrOxUrSoXoFf]

she's lip-synching on this song because...i've tried singing this way-it's because the way of how they remixed her voice on this track. but the other performances-she doesn't. :)

[Strongerbet]

esta super incomoda!!

[KaiserElizabeth]

Maybe she is not comfortable singing live? Ive neve seen her not lipsync.