at17- 我歌 故我在

[alan0307hk]

唱得好好聽..... 勁鐘意...><

[KingClef]

原本是因為Kay的我歌故我在而喜歡Kay的, 一直都覺得沒有幾多個人可以發揮得好這首歌, 但二汶實在是唱得太好了, 加上Ellen的一手好結他, 整首歌用另外一種方法表達出來, 意境完全不同, 實在是不得了~~~!!! like爆!!! 很欣賞她們的arrangement!!

[COLORPAN]

其實降key呢個問題

一個歌手 選擇一個適合自己既key去唱 達至最好

難道做錯了?

難道高音=好歌=好聽=皇道?

唔緊要 音樂 好聽與否 可以好主觀

[Otwinklestar]

She has a beautiful voice! It's different to Kay's version, but both are very good. Every singer must be unique, that's how you can survive in showbiz.

[iamaveryuglyboy]

at17造音樂方面都好努力嫁^^佢地冇乜點拎獎 但系都堅持 真系好值得鼓勵 我系kay粉絲-3-都撐佢=v=

[Leyland1993611]

d假音好正.....

[funnyperryha]

好好=]

如果高番一個key就到原key好好喇

[saybelebala]

個感覺同kay唔同...好清新,~good~

[chadthediary]

二汶把聲真係靚到不得了，又入咪

無意跟原唱比較，但個人比較喜歡二汶版本

[Ritassz]

另一種清新=)

Both Kay and At17 are great

[klsuperman]

阿Kay本身同二汶係老友，如果唔係都未必會揀呢首咁難唱嘅歌去­唱啦！所以唔好因為一兩個key去左音就咁大反應。

[michelleelle]

各有各好聽丫

at17真係唱得唔錯

個日我都在場

他們ge演出確確實實贏得全場熱烈拍掌!!!

其實有冇降key有咩所謂

首歌本身又唔係佢地

邊個歌手冇走過音

我覺得今次表演可以接受

好過有d歌手勉強唱

唱唔到個feel之餘仲要走哂音

[joystick169]

Ellen 個樣 ... 可能結他太重 .... juz kidding

是降了 key 唱但聽的舒服耶

[rccsole]

的確降了key

but still a wonderful performance

[helixinred]

能唱咩key係天生,而且唔會個個一樣.無話高d好d,低d無o­甘好! 呢點大家都要清楚!

[AzNpRidenWAT]

can u explain why that is 天生?? ur saying all the good artist were born to be a singer?? they dont need practice at all??

if u sing bad.. dont say its becoz of your parents fault!!

[helixinred]

你究竟了唔了解我o果番話係講緊咩野?

聲底,唱到o既key, 每個人都唔同, 如果唔係,你同我同所有人都會一樣聲! 而每一個女人都係女高音! 同時間每個男人都係男低音! 呢個就係所謂天生.

唱歌技巧就唔係天生,要好多訓練先做得好! 你依家會唔會清楚d?

[AzNpRidenWAT]

無錯... 每個人生出黎條聲帶都唔一樣... 所以我地把聲都唔一樣... 如果細細個就開始練聲既話.. 當你成長到發育既時候聲帶同聲線都會變... 到你定聲既時候...個振時就係你把聲既成果..當然如果想有好­既效果就一定要從細個好好保養.. 聲底先會變好.. 聲帶變闊同厚...唱到既key都會寬厚... 但係如果你既聲線係唔好聽既話.. 咁就無辦法..

[AzNpRidenWAT]

講來講去... 我靜係想否定你所講既 "能唱咩key係天生" ... 你依傢清唔清楚d未?? 定係想死牛一邊頸啊!!!

[helixinred]

不如我問番你一個問題?你知唔知自己係咩key? 假設你係c key先啦! 如果你將首歌改做g key你會唔會成首歌都唱得晒? 唔好答我住. 自己試下先! 呢個係鐵一般而你無可能否定到o既事實!

你依家會唔會再清楚d?

[helixinred]

by the way, "天生"英文係 inborn或者用gifted都得.

[AzNpRidenWAT]

how about say something that is related to your stupid comment u made "能唱咩key係天生"?? and please lol... i was born and raised in states so dont even try using your pathetic english dictionary as a tool to ignore the fact that u made a stupid comment.. and u know it..

[helixinred]

你開始有d失去理性!

首先我已經講o左我o既睇法,你唔同意,我又再試圖搵個你可以自­己試吓o既方法,唔知你有無試過?但我寫完對上個回應之後,我後­來就覺得我應該o甘樣o既寫. "你會唔會試過唱一首人地唱到而你又唱唔到o既歌?" 呢個會更加容易明白.如果你試過一次或以上.o甘就證明我講o既­野係有理據.

[helixinred]

你o係美國出世同長大! 真好! 但可惜你無美國人/西方人o果種胸襟,聽人地o既意見或嘗試去搵­答案,從你第一日o既回應都已經無實則理據支持你o既論點! stupid? 真係觀點與角度!

[helixinred]

我英文真係好普通,但gifted同inborn係我初中o既時­候學.

quote "ur saying all the good artist were born to be a singer??"

上面o果句你寫o既,但我初中o果陣老師就教我唔好o甘寫.如果­我係你我會o甘寫"all good artists were ...."

可能你d美式英語同我認識o既有d唔同.我唔係美國人,不過我有­唔少美國/外國朋友.

最後想同你講o既係.at17同呀kay都係我同樣o甘鍾意!我­o既回應唔會偏幫其中一邊!

[AzNpRidenWAT]

ur so arrogant....ok lor... if u dont want to admit ur wrong.. i have nothing to say...

[helixinred]

無野講???你揾到理據就可以上o黎發表吓! 同埋可以問吓d識唱歌o既人啦! 我都想聰吓你仲可以有d咩講?

[kattyty]

personally this is my favourite song of Kay, but to be fair at 17 is really singing out of tune sometimes, such as 2:17 走音...and 3:36 有个KEY 有D怪 .最后果几粒音连guiter都走埋...

its a good performance, this song is very difficult to sing, i think she s just not too familiar with the song.

[tubefu]

i agree, this is Kay's defining song. other singers will try, and will have a hard time with this song. Only Kay can perform this song so easily and confidently.

[AzNpRidenWAT]

kay 走音 in her LIVE singing this song too.... kay is good i like her but u guys are protecting her too much

[hoiningt]

kattyty, this vid is only 3:17 long, so how come u sed they r out of tune at 3:36?

[kattyty]

thanks for correction, it meant to be 2:17, and 2:26.

[chickchick111]

儘管我我挺喜歡KAY

但若執著AT17在音準上稍有問題來說....

不要忘記kay音準也不怎麼出色(至少是近一、兩年)

[joeydoraemon]

也老實說, 我也不盲目維護kay的音準

但我想這跟at17走音沒關係吧

[tubefu]

i think it's the opposite. kay's high keys has gotten better and sharper than three years ago. in the original recording on Kay's album, she is kinda off. if you compare to her live performances at Nokia and 903, she has gotten much sharper, higher, and more precise and more confident than when she first debuted. i guees it depends on her mood for that day. she's not always at 100%, but when she is at the top of her game, her singing is flawless.

[isamu135]

I think AT17 and Kay are both great.

Eman and Kay both have great voices.

Although I think Eman's voice is just slightly more delicate than Kay's.

[joeydoraemon]

我個人認為, 我歌故我在的特色也在高音位置

我想大概Loving You不唱海豚音也失色不少

至少我認為這首歌最困難的, 部分都在高音

at 17就是降key降得太多了

撇開這些不說

at 17唱得慢起來有點拖

不夠流暢

而且低音和高音都走了音

如果kay是show off高音,

那at 17豈不降了key也唱不到?

[tubefu]

agree, the high notes are the best part of the song and what makes this song so special. for a HK singer, Kay can hit the high notes quite well. why shouldn't she show off her talents? that's like telling Mariah Carey to stop 'showing off'.

that's what so sad about HK for the last decade or more. everyone is so soft and emo. finally we have a singer like Kay who is trying to turn HK music around so that HK music could be recognized internationally. like what Jane Zhang has done for China.

[energy222]

我想問下,你從何覺得at17降了key？

或者my recording錄得不好,但現場聽真的超高音而又穩。值得一­提的是現場音響超差,加上聽聞在場工作人員是極不配合歌手的。a­t17仍能唱出如此水準。

我再細聽Kay唱Live的youtube片段,她們的key是­一樣的。我想說,這兩位歌手一樣有水準。Kay的風格是比較有韻­味,而林二是清新的。

[harrison723]

@energy222

走音我就聽唔到 不過降key聽得出

[everbanega922]

@energy222

綠得差姐...

我估現場會好聽D

[LEECY112]

@energy222

降唔降key唔關覺唔覺事

你點解咁執著有冇降key?

降就降,唱得好聽就得

而家兩首一拍埋

哩個係降左key

有得否認架咩?

你要唔要度下佢地個frequency去證實你既錯誤?

[energy222]

再者我想請問閣下的耳仔聽到她那一粒音有走呢?你要明白,同場的­表演者還有kay的。如果at17唱得如你所言般"難聽",你認­為她們會有信心在原唱者面前賣弄嘛？請不要亂下批評。

[joeydoraemon]

大概要用用耳仔的是你 原key kay的最高音為G#, 但at17只是上了F# 如果你不懂音律, 不妨找個會的來聽 似乎盲目保護at17的是你 至於走音, 當然她們不是如Stephy那些大走音 但你可知甚麼是微走音? 就是聽上去好像準音, 但又不到位那些 但你聽不到, 我也沒話好說 但我再聽多少次我都不是亂下批評 P.S. 同場有Kay在場只代表他們有信心, 他們有信心也不代表他們唱得好

[joeydoraemon]

你不懂聽, 找個會聽的來吧!

(其餘的我寫在上面了)

[l0709394]

well said, it really loses some spirit of the song

[tubefu]

Kay is much more evocative and smoother. The song is supposed to bring out the singer's best stuff, hence why Kay's stronger performance is memorable and suiting.

[mickeytf]

感受到她們是認同歌詞內容的,表達得真情流露。另外也對歌曲做了­很多個人化的處理,使歌曲真正成為屬於她們的歌。

^^~

[leluson]

Eman is very good

I like At17

She sings it better than the original one

add oil~!!!

[pennsy33]

超級好聽阿!!!!!!!!!!!!!^0^

[cw827]

好勁呀

[sfj238]

無論是旋律 歌詞 還是質感

這首歌該屬於at17...

音樂是該讓人聽得舒服動聽。

at17比謝安琪好聽得多了!!!!!!!!!!!

[chenec]

照你咁講 全世界嘅rock n roll咪全部應該收皮？淨返D folk song畀你聽

[orangecity999]

agree, 唔同人有唔同感覺,,兩個都好好

[ellybb118]

我認同,,,,

我個人意見,,

我覺得at17係完完全全同隻歌融合埋一齊

而丫kay就好似特登要show off 佢d高音,,

[joeydoraemon]

我認同

kay是特登要show off佢d高音

at 17是特登要show off佢d走音

[l0709394]

not bad~

[Edd5885]

LOVELY VOICE EMAN

[sylvia0825]

thanks for sharing!!

高音位唱得好好聽~感動中~

17是最好的^^

[CHOCOLIC123]

well done at17^^

[wing15ki]

二汶好勁好西利好勁好西利，好高音。

然後從ellen的頭和bodymovement可見她彈結他彈­得非常投入xd

[Monting0]

一路都覺得二汶唱歌唔錯。果然沒錯，聽over the rainbow已經覺得好。

[2210love]

very nice!!