Brooke White - Hero (4-15-08)

[kyo1223]

Pitchy~

[laurenalainaishot]

karen rodriguez sang it best!

[ARBO2k9]

@laurenalainaishot booo

[mariahfan444]

If I were Brooke I would've picked Petals (from the Rainbow album). It's one of Mariah's most restrained performances (vocally) and although the range would've been a bit low, it wouldn't have been as mehhhhh compared to Hero, which is pretty much a Mariah song that everyone knows.

[sixfobrutha]

She wasnt that good

[TotalDramaCountry]

Some say Ok but i saw awesome, They say "Oh she's no match to Mariah" well she's not competing against her version, she's making her own different rendition of it an i found it very good, keep on keepin on Brooke ;)

[nomnomxxchomp]

I think she has a really good and unique voice. :D

It's funny lol--about the thing Simon said about burgers b/c one time I got burgers without the buns... :/

[RossiSingh]

ugh my ears ...

[leonorv89]

She sang Hero??? Oh my God, i thought they weren't going to sing anthems of Mariah, like Hero, Without You or Always be My Baby, that just makes the things dangerous... It was a miracle that David Archuleta didn't sing We Belong Together or something like that XD

[Harmonious91]

@leonorv89 lol

[AnthnyMD]

@leonorv89 almost all her songs are anthems....she is just that big of a star

[stewardlie]

too plain just with the piano...bad arrangement i think

[mileysux69]

She is excessively breathing into the mic...

[koounna]

she reminds me of like a grown up taylor swift!

[bookworm186]

She really does, physically and personality-wise though. Her voice is completely different.

[alleyt1989]

she reminds me of a countrier version of sheryl crow.

[LOLCOPTER]

ryan was mean this round :(.

anyhow, it's okay.

[seank135]

There wasn't a wow moment in the song. It was all a bit flat and boring throughout.

[090783]

I like her more than Syesha..she should have stayed until top 3.even though Brooke mess up sometimes, she's probably the most original among the girls..I agree with Paula her sound is identifiable.

[MC2051991]

Agree!

[FM897]

She has an interesting carly simon/carol king vibe

[McNatanael92]

she's the worst!!!

[Lola2726]

I really liked this. The tone of her voice is beautiful.

[BryanCaw75]

for example stop/pause at 5:38

[BryanCaw75]

Im a fan of brookes but i have to say she was like doing these mean faces when she got judged, espeacially when simon was talking everytime the camera turned to her while simon was talking she was giving him this mean glare. but its idol you get caught in the moment lol.

[rjs5146]

can't ever compare to the mariah version!!!!

[curlingiron7658]

Holy Shit, she totally sped up the melody towards the end. I mean she was running out of breath towards the end.

[so102995]

she rocked at this song and i love her she is like the best she so should have won american idol

[Ueberbacker]

She did a beautiful and OK performance

this is my favorite song of all time

and she doesn't have vocals like Mariah but it's ok, because she did on her own

but Syesha was perfect and singing a more dificult song! That was impressive!

[Differentation]

to gudgurlgonebadd:

She did not ruined the song.. your so mean!!!

[Differentation]

The song is fitted to her voice..

[sarahfan56]

brookw was my 2nd favorite of the season! Carly was 1st!

anyway brooke did awesome here! =]

[Celestialtears006]

she needs to do cardio other than that not bad for a tryer.

[rjs5146]

i agree because it would really help her vocally ability with holding notes and keeping her breathe up!

[luvnmebabyproduction]

yall jealous and hatin cuz she stayed didn't she?

[gudgurlgonebadd]

please dont fuck up this song!

[TJRecords]

3:20 ???? Messed up on the keys

[arshkaur345]

sux

[sarahfan56]

what the hell ru on? shes awesome!