@hogwashsentinel It was, which was surprising to everyone at the time, because the show usually has pretty good CGI (like the plane crash as seen by the Others in A Tale of Two Cities).
haha imho this is probably one of my top 10 worst lost eps ever. Stranger Land, Kevin Johnson, What Kate Does, Recon, and Namaste are terrible too. even nikki and paulo episode is better lol.
@darthmilo77 Haha. And here I was feeling special for making that connection, I love that he made the reference. The last bit of music in tonight's ep where sawyer says "we're gonna take the submarine" had me thinking that I'd heard that before. Sure enough it was the U-Boat song from MOH.
I love how you can practically see Lindelhoff and Cuse saying "You should be so bloody impressed by this." Honestly, there's no reason at all for that shot, so it seems like they're actually showing off the crappy effect.
Pause at 0:12. That periscope-thingy at the front of the conning tower looks like an in-game polygon from a 1990's era FPS for crying out loud. Were they drunk when they put this shambles together?
Wow, at 0:11 just look at how blury the textures are! Not only that but the submarine is so low-poly that you can even see where the polygons meet on the edges!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
lol i never noticed how truely fake this really looks. To be honest i dont even care and don't see why any lost fan should care that the submarine submerging sequence wasnt "up to standard" they show is how good it is because of everything EXCEPT the CGI effects, come on people get a grip. 1 poor scene out of how many awesome ones?
me too. it took me so hard out of the episode for that moment a bit after. it was easy to forget and 'submerge' myself back into the episode, but they really should redo that scene for the dvds.
Looks legit.
3rkid2 5 months ago
what the...I don't remember the cg being that awful
hogwashsentinel 5 months ago
@hogwashsentinel It was, which was surprising to everyone at the time, because the show usually has pretty good CGI (like the plane crash as seen by the Others in A Tale of Two Cities).
Cyberhamon 3 months ago
im still lost..
grooveclubhouse 7 months ago
haha imho this is probably one of my top 10 worst lost eps ever. Stranger Land, Kevin Johnson, What Kate Does, Recon, and Namaste are terrible too. even nikki and paulo episode is better lol.
andreolmedo 9 months ago
lol.
ManlytearsUK 10 months ago
So if the money isn't going into the graphics OR the writing (at least the writing of the final season) -- then where the hell is it going?
HUNTdRADiO 10 months ago
Thumbs up if you came here from TvTropes
trustnoone81 1 year ago 5
Dude, no one really believed that effect did they?
grumpytosnowwhite 1 year ago
YAY! Its Red Alert again! (rocks out to Hell's March)
ericfuchs123 1 year ago
This was practice for the 1st year animation students I bet...
AEigner 1 year ago 4
Puts the "sub" in submarine Sub-sitution
ReconOne123456789 1 year ago
With all the money they put into this series, you'd think they could give a little more to their cgi
pvandpb 1 year ago
Nice U-Boat.
DiscoGlacier 1 year ago
Actually this reminds me of Silent Hunter more than an N64 game. It's smoother than most N64 models.
shadowfax273k 1 year ago
the sub was submerged already
al28283 1 year ago
Ah, the submarine dive, reminding us all of the graphical prowess of PS1 games. :)
Cyberhamon 1 year ago 5
HAHAHA
Rogerdof 1 year ago
Worst animation in all of Lost.
jarpasmannen 1 year ago
Obvious CGI is obvious
Electra41Empress 1 year ago
It took ten Cray computers to make this scene.
DieHardDeus 1 year ago
@Accisma PlayStation1 is more like it.
CanadienDestroyer 1 year ago
I watched this over and over on my TV recording.
I literally laughed for 5 minutes at how poorly animated that submarine was when I first saw it.
Zancoth 1 year ago
The music is a reference to Giacchino's score for Medal of Honor. That's the only relevant part of this scene.
darthmilo77 2 years ago 3
@darthmilo77 Haha. And here I was feeling special for making that connection, I love that he made the reference. The last bit of music in tonight's ep where sawyer says "we're gonna take the submarine" had me thinking that I'd heard that before. Sure enough it was the U-Boat song from MOH.
VeggieInvader 2 years ago
I love how you can practically see Lindelhoff and Cuse saying "You should be so bloody impressed by this." Honestly, there's no reason at all for that shot, so it seems like they're actually showing off the crappy effect.
Rmlohner 2 years ago 6
Is this from Lost: Via Domus?
axemblue4 2 years ago
Haha, nice.
Scarecrow3001 2 years ago
Comment removed
swevensent 2 years ago
WETA EAT YOUR HEART OUT!
cambaprecoz 2 years ago 3
this is terrible
copymachineamy 2 years ago
The cgi should be made better for the dvd.
It should've been good the first time, but it's not, so a do-over for the dvd !!!
TheTwelfthDoctor 2 years ago
Aww man, that is totally half assed!
Crevek 2 years ago
I was like "wtf, why is it a crappy blender made sub in the nr.1 series ever made" a real anti-climax really
jarpasmannen 2 years ago
this reaaaaally sucks, poor quality
phantomfireNL 2 years ago
Hard lol. Not really.. Just saying.
disturbedsengi 2 years ago
Pause at 0:12. That periscope-thingy at the front of the conning tower looks like an in-game polygon from a 1990's era FPS for crying out loud. Were they drunk when they put this shambles together?
ancalites 2 years ago
Wow, at 0:11 just look at how blury the textures are! Not only that but the submarine is so low-poly that you can even see where the polygons meet on the edges!
theblah12 2 years ago
If they would have cut away around the 8 second mark, it wouldnt have been that bad. Hope its redone for the Bluray/DVD!
mrclifton88 2 years ago
Wow.
vman339 2 years ago
that's pretty bad cgi for a pretentious tv show.
reyontoyeny 2 years ago 3
Wow. I thought people were exaggerating, but it DOES look like 90's video game CGI.
fyrenwater 2 years ago 7
This Submarine, like my N64 has an inability to display non-straight lines.
jackface0410 2 years ago 44
Oh dear...
MacabreBerries 2 years ago 5
AVATAR 2 already ?
juliancallan 2 years ago 5
Worse than Final Fantasy 8 FMVs. Good shit.
Cavauro 2 years ago 3
lol
Mesarphelous 2 years ago
God I fucking loved the N64.
LargeLeader 2 years ago 77
I didn't know lost did visual homages to Metal Gear Solid 2.
mustrapefoley 2 years ago 3
Oh my, that looks like something my GameCube could do.
MiffTheFox 2 years ago 2
fail cgi
taufiq1991 2 years ago
wow look at those amazing playstation graphics lol
spongedan219 2 years ago
I know the other submarine was called the Galaga, but that's just ridiculous!
darthmilo77 2 years ago 2
this is fucking hilarious
reminds me of the the jaws 3 ending when the shar blows up
LMAO
love lost tho, dont get me wrong.
wally815 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol i never noticed how truely fake this really looks. To be honest i dont even care and don't see why any lost fan should care that the submarine submerging sequence wasnt "up to standard" they show is how good it is because of everything EXCEPT the CGI effects, come on people get a grip. 1 poor scene out of how many awesome ones?
You don't watch Lost for the CGI.
DoomsdayDevice9mm 2 years ago
you're right
febifurx 2 years ago
Rendered on an abacus. A broken abacus.
Freecell82 2 years ago 3
The strange thing is that it didn't look half as bad in The Incident.
JackieMagenta 2 years ago 4
This shot is etched into my memory. It totally shattered my immersion in the episode.
boiledelephant 2 years ago 3
me too. it took me so hard out of the episode for that moment a bit after. it was easy to forget and 'submerge' myself back into the episode, but they really should redo that scene for the dvds.
TyrannoJack 2 years ago
this is like atari graphics :D
robr1981 2 years ago 4
They should not have bothered with this shot, while I can see why they did it, it's fairly obvious they didn't have a big visual effects budget.
fluffyman85 2 years ago 5
i rememeber seeing this and laughing so hard!
THATS TERRIBLE GRAPHICS!
copymachineamy 2 years ago 3
gracias por la mejor escena de todo LOST, con gráficos del metal gear 3
Chunelco 2 years ago 2