I've listened to this album literally 1,000 times over the past 35 years and this is one of the few demos I've heard that I like as much if not more than the finished version. This album is my absolute favorite album of all time and my # 1 of three album I'd take to a desert island. Beatles White album # 2 and The Wall # 3
"..and I smile sadly for a love I could not obey..." so true to me right now, I still loving her. what can i do? just cry and sing this song of darkness and disgrace.
@milescend ..Exactly..switches to camp androgeny or resignation on the final release from a more mysterious secretive undertone of LIED ...Good observation..I missed that until you pointed it out! cheers!
There should be no issue about the voice. It's Bowie pure and simple. And it's only a demo ffs!
For those who can't fathom it... this is what singers actually sound like when they're not doing much more than recording an acoustic jam session, with mimimal twiddling of mixing desk knobs, NO auto-tuned vocals, over-dubs or special effects taking all the 'grit' out of the song!
@jhiken Look for Ryko CDs. They all have bonus tracks - demos and alternate versions - and they're dynamite. Even though I have many Bowie albums on vinyl dating back to the 60s, I bought all the Ryko CDs and haven't regretted a single purchase.
@anonyms404 you're an idiot. you may not care about the creative process but it does exist and demos never sound as good as the finished product that is released to the masses.. why do you think its called a demo? do you know what a demo is? maybe you should look it up because if you dont want to hear a demo and instead want to hear finished product dont click the link of a song that says original demo in the title.. do you get that? and this doesnt sound like crap, your ears are broken.
Certainly different from the album, a bit more "space" sounding, and I'm glad to be able to hear this, I like hearing how songs are developed "behind the scenes".
but the album version, I think, works better with the flow of the album, because it sounds more "Burlesque" than "Alien"..as though Ziggy is communicating through a simple drag performer..
Ever been to a transvestite cafe / cabaret in the 70s, 80's? Ever?
This type of non smooth rendition is right on and this particular version you are slamming is spot on, actuallt too good and THAT's why you don't like it.
I just came across this by pure coincidence, but I have to agree with you. I have come to realize that if people like a singer, they will be enamoured of everything he/she does, no matter how awful it is. If they hate the singer concerned, no amount of talent will be able to convince them otherwise. Forget objectivity, it is just about non-existent! That's just the way people are ;-)
@expatbritingermany i dont believe that because i myself have many band crushes and love alot of stuff they do but then some of it i hate.. and will not give credit where its not due.. so.. maybe youre talking about some people and not all.. because if im this way then there has got to be atleast.. a couple thousand in the world who are the same.. because we as people are just not as individual and different then others as we would like to think. peace
@TheThroney - I think I know what you're trying to say. All I meant was it is difficult to be objective - whether it's your partner we're talking about, your mother, or your favourite singer/band. We are all influenced by personal preferences, which results in people raving about performances that are less than perfect, and others giving the thumbs down sign to excellent performances. It's part of human nature ;-))
I think he was just testing out different vocal styles. This is not his best vocal trial - glad he changed it by the last cut. Great to see how he envisioned the song structure as that is the coolest thing about this. Fantastic to hear an early trail of this classic!
Rest assured, there are plenty of live performances showing him to be just fine without "studio help"; and besides having a crisp sound and good seperation courtesy of the studio and some sound effects on some tracks for artistry's sake I really don't think he actually has his voice touched up in the studio.
the fact of the matter is that he sounds great in here. the mixing and mastering could be better, but its a demo. i do sing and i'll tell you that it's so hard to sing how he does here and you saying it's sub-par only shows you have absolutely no repsect for the creative process.
Maybe he doesn't sound as good as the original song but absolutely EVERY artist is going to sound a bit different if they make a acoustic version of a song
This has been flagged as spam show
I've listened to this album literally 1,000 times over the past 35 years and this is one of the few demos I've heard that I like as much if not more than the finished version. This album is my absolute favorite album of all time and my # 1 of three album I'd take to a desert island. Beatles White album # 2 and The Wall # 3
Johnnywhamo 4 days ago
Comment removed
Johnnywhamo 4 days ago
Thumbs up if you suspect Skrillex was the one who disliked this.
Sharpster7 1 month ago 3
i love playing this on guitar such a good song
namey420 2 months ago
Is it just me or is Lady Stardust by far the finest tune of an exceptional record that is Ziggy Stardust?
siebentau 3 months ago
I for one think this version is better X3 I love listening to raw demo versions. Usually you can hear more emotion.
JazzTheGoblinQueen 5 months ago
What a find, a raw class version of a work in progress.
Stardrambowie 5 months ago
Nice and inspiring always to hear the works in progress..cheers for the upload, Xen Smithy.
hootsmon 6 months ago
Awful nice
gustavovideo15 6 months ago
"..and I smile sadly for a love I could not obey..." so true to me right now, I still loving her. what can i do? just cry and sing this song of darkness and disgrace.
(sure she wont ever find this comment)
dabeast2411 7 months ago
He sings "Ohh how I lied, when they asked if I knew his name" instead of "sighed", interesting.
milescend 7 months ago
@milescend ..Exactly..switches to camp androgeny or resignation on the final release from a more mysterious secretive undertone of LIED ...Good observation..I missed that until you pointed it out! cheers!
hootsmon 6 months ago
and he sang all night...
Haxixer 7 months ago
thanks for this!!!!
halenharris 8 months ago
Beautiful
tantissimacacca 9 months ago
There should be no issue about the voice. It's Bowie pure and simple. And it's only a demo ffs!
For those who can't fathom it... this is what singers actually sound like when they're not doing much more than recording an acoustic jam session, with mimimal twiddling of mixing desk knobs, NO auto-tuned vocals, over-dubs or special effects taking all the 'grit' out of the song!
LantaGem 9 months ago
So cool!!! Huge fan and I never heard these demos. Are there more??
jhiken 11 months ago
@jhiken on the same album, ziggy stardust also has a demo! it's great.
gilalion 11 months ago
@jhiken Look for Ryko CDs. They all have bonus tracks - demos and alternate versions - and they're dynamite. Even though I have many Bowie albums on vinyl dating back to the 60s, I bought all the Ryko CDs and haven't regretted a single purchase.
kopachuk08 7 months ago
@anonyms404 you're an idiot. you may not care about the creative process but it does exist and demos never sound as good as the finished product that is released to the masses.. why do you think its called a demo? do you know what a demo is? maybe you should look it up because if you dont want to hear a demo and instead want to hear finished product dont click the link of a song that says original demo in the title.. do you get that? and this doesnt sound like crap, your ears are broken.
TheThroney 1 year ago
this song was about marc bolan for people who didnt know that
blackcladlizard 1 year ago
What a voice!!
Luarrangel 1 year ago
david's voice is heavenly in this track!!! thank you for sharing!! quite sublime!!
lunabird444 1 year ago
I LOVE DAVID BOWIE!!!!! in all the ways!!!!
love4blk 1 year ago
Marc will live forever
Joeyland 1 year ago 3
Certainly different from the album, a bit more "space" sounding, and I'm glad to be able to hear this, I like hearing how songs are developed "behind the scenes".
but the album version, I think, works better with the flow of the album, because it sounds more "Burlesque" than "Alien"..as though Ziggy is communicating through a simple drag performer..
carrollthirteen 1 year ago
I far prefer this version of the song. This demo and Five Years are my two favorite Bowie songs. He's just terrific.
frankzitoiii 1 year ago
excellent performance
nick40nick40 1 year ago
I just downloaded this mp3 at mp3iifffy. Check that site out - its sick. Google mp3iifffy
SantanaBulerr 1 year ago
Chill out sweetheart, your manhood isn't on the line over this.
I've seen Bowie do this live and this is a fair representation of what it's supposed to be.
Now be a love and give us a kiss.
ometec 2 years ago
you best be trollin.
EyMeng 2 years ago
Comment removed
EyMeng 2 years ago
Anyone else hear two voices over lapping in parts of this?
ometec 2 years ago
@ometec Think it may be Bowie and Ronson.
JRebG 1 year ago
You're in a small choir, nearly alone.
Ever been to a transvestite cafe / cabaret in the 70s, 80's? Ever?
This type of non smooth rendition is right on and this particular version you are slamming is spot on, actuallt too good and THAT's why you don't like it.
ometec 2 years ago
That is not David Bowie singing , good impression though!
tarkstar99 2 years ago
@tarkstar99 No, it really is him. It was on one of his albums.
Trismegustis 2 years ago
@tarkstar99 This is demo, which was released on album Ziggy Stardust - 30th Anniversary Reissue, published in 2002.
FilipHosman 1 year ago
the voice is supposed to be "gravelly" it's part of the song
ometec 2 years ago
to you
nuff said
ometec 2 years ago
It doesn't sound like crap, you hear like crap
ometec 2 years ago
Very genuine rendition, like the song itself.
ometec 2 years ago
en. wikipedia. org/ wiki/ Demo_(music)
gazb79 2 years ago
@zanisham9
RIP to Fen
ziggy95 2 years ago 4
THIS IS THE OPERA VERSION,
THE GODLY VOICE OF A UTOPIAN
THAT SO FILLS UP THE SONG
IT CARRIES ALL WITH MERELY THE PIANO
& IT HONORS THE MAN WHO INVENTED
PATHOS FOR THE 70s
THE NAPOLEON OF ROMANTICISM
MARC
EROS, NOT YET ALL DEAD
JTerrible63 2 years ago 37
That was some speech my friend
XenSmithy 2 years ago 7
Wow. This is the best comment I've seen on Youtube. Really made me smile and feel proud to be Bowie and Bolan fans :)
JRebG 2 years ago 4
@JTerrible63 Good heavens. You should have been a Butlins Bluecoat mate! The kids would have loved all that.
alexandermorison 1 year ago
I just came across this by pure coincidence, but I have to agree with you. I have come to realize that if people like a singer, they will be enamoured of everything he/she does, no matter how awful it is. If they hate the singer concerned, no amount of talent will be able to convince them otherwise. Forget objectivity, it is just about non-existent! That's just the way people are ;-)
expatbritingermany 2 years ago
@expatbritingermany i dont believe that because i myself have many band crushes and love alot of stuff they do but then some of it i hate.. and will not give credit where its not due.. so.. maybe youre talking about some people and not all.. because if im this way then there has got to be atleast.. a couple thousand in the world who are the same.. because we as people are just not as individual and different then others as we would like to think. peace
TheThroney 1 year ago
@TheThroney - I think I know what you're trying to say. All I meant was it is difficult to be objective - whether it's your partner we're talking about, your mother, or your favourite singer/band. We are all influenced by personal preferences, which results in people raving about performances that are less than perfect, and others giving the thumbs down sign to excellent performances. It's part of human nature ;-))
expatbritingermany 1 year ago
I think he was just testing out different vocal styles. This is not his best vocal trial - glad he changed it by the last cut. Great to see how he envisioned the song structure as that is the coolest thing about this. Fantastic to hear an early trail of this classic!
wpollock1 2 years ago
Rest assured, there are plenty of live performances showing him to be just fine without "studio help"; and besides having a crisp sound and good seperation courtesy of the studio and some sound effects on some tracks for artistry's sake I really don't think he actually has his voice touched up in the studio.
arabiansanchez 2 years ago
I actually prefer this version.
Just saying.
dudemcguy 2 years ago 14
the fact of the matter is that he sounds great in here. the mixing and mastering could be better, but its a demo. i do sing and i'll tell you that it's so hard to sing how he does here and you saying it's sub-par only shows you have absolutely no repsect for the creative process.
solargesture 2 years ago
you must have an amazing voice if you think these vocals suck... seriously?
solargesture 2 years ago 5
What's up with the Bowie vocals concerns?
Maybe he doesn't sound as good as the original song but absolutely EVERY artist is going to sound a bit different if they make a acoustic version of a song
And this is a demo as well
XenSmithy 2 years ago
What's wrong with the vocal? Sounds great like usual to me.
pobhockle 2 years ago
I love this version. Every singer doesn't sound incredible without a bit of studio tweeking. Come on.
ieatorbs 2 years ago 4
this guys right.
i too am a massive fan of bowie but this aint too good.
TyroneeT 2 years ago
You are a Twit ! Not the nice definition of one , the other one .
whillop 2 years ago
anonyms:
1) obviously, you don't know what you're talking about or all that much about the making of music, try singing like that yourself
2) this stripped down version kicks mad ass, thanks
guitarfreakkkkk 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
I just love this song. So touching<3
CosmicRuis 2 years ago
Bowie Kills here !
whillop 2 years ago
youtube for some reason isn't allowing this video to load right now.
that pisses me off.
zenocomplex 2 years ago
I believe it is Ronno playing piano on the album track.
Obviously David plays on this 'demo' version.
It's amazing to think that only a few chords and some words make such a masterpiece. Simple and brilliant.
For Marc Bolan too... God Bless him.
BloggStandard 2 years ago 6
damn, great version of this song. Bowies voice is in full perfection!
flimflam707 2 years ago 6
demos are so much more pure then final versions, i love this one so much =D
IxAmxAnxAint 2 years ago 27
better than the final cut methinks
iLuvvU2 3 years ago 2
Can anybody show me how to play this masterpiece on the piano, go great!! Ziggy rocks!!!
lopezgarin 3 years ago
It's not on the regular ziggy stardust cd, it's the anniversary special edition one.
sherriffflood 3 years ago 3
Yes, I have it on CD.
a68rebel 3 years ago
thanks for this post--love this song!
nevajanine 3 years ago 2
I ripped it from the Ziggy Stardust cd with bonus tracks,b-sides, and demos like this
XenSmithy 3 years ago
thanks
Deerizzle 3 years ago 2