The greatest thing about the Giants is that they stayed true to themselves throughout this entire ride. 25 years ago, they were the same guys and they didn't try to be like the cool hipsters of the Lower East Side art crowd they were performing for. Now they're dads.
You know, if John was any other person, in any other band, his voice would be insanely annoying. Like most the time he sings really nasaly and stuff. But somehow, its just like the perfect voice for TMBG. Its awesome.
great film great song awsome people the film just dident show enough of Linnell ALL HAIL THEY MIGHT BE GIANTS! ALL HAIL JOHN FLANSBURGH! ALL HAIL JOHN LINNELL!
Linnell's voice is a little like Ringo Starr's. Ringo had a hard time staying in key when performing live. In the studio they could re-do it as many times as possible, when it's live, nothing could be fixed.
I think Linnell's voice is just not suited to live performances. Flans sounds good live, but Linnell... doesn't. Maybe he's just trying to push the "odd Linnell TMBG voice" thing a bit far. Who knows? It's a great song regardless (Y)
These guys are 100% amazing. I enjoy how we don't have to think for most of their songs. And you can tell they have so much fun with what they're doing. ^^
There doesn't seem to be any middle ground; either the meaning of the song is given to you on a plate, or it's hidden in cryptic wordplay. Either way's fine by me :)
this song is great. but i guess you know that, since you're on this here page. unless you don't like music or something. or you have bad taste in sound. can you taste sound? i hear colours sometimes... well this comment took an odd turn. peace
To everyone saying how horrible this sounds, remember that the finished product that ends up on a CD usually takes days if not weeks of rerecording and tweaking. Making it sound like the album version every time is very difficult.
No need to apologize... normally this song sounds just like the album live. This is just a bad take and poorly filmed as well. There is a clip of it somewhere on youtube with it kicking ass live.
Wow, comparing how they sound on the cd to this is...They just sound horrible here. The song sounds too strained and forced. But I do love this song, along with TMBG.
Wow..they should go to ed earlier and wake up later.This is like a before breakfast can-we-still play-it session.Great song though.Flans looks frustrated
hey giants,or at least you MIGHT be,why do you sound so snobby?take some chicken soup.if not for getting better,then for the delicious taste and the little chunks of chicken in 'em.
wow...this is a very....timid performance. it almost feels like as if they were told to not play so loud and are kinda confused about how to approach it.
Yeah there would usually be lots of jumping, especially from Flans, but in here he seems very lazy and the rest of the guys didn't look too happy. You'd think that the performance would be a lot better, especially the fact that they knew they were being filmed.
Even though I'm a TMBG fan, there's something feeble sounding of this performance. Perhaps it's because the accordion is much, much louder than both guitars combined and that Linnell's vocals are given too much reverb.
I heat this fucking song!!!!
thejokemorales 1 month ago
@thejokemorales I agree, it doesn't sound very good cold. Lukewarm is best.
mootothehood 3 weeks ago
nice
rhinomantis88 1 month ago
I love how Linnell kept playing the accordion afterwards. I do that sometimes on my piano.
forgingiron123 8 months ago
Poor John's voice was off this time. I feel bad for the guy.
jellywillreturn 11 months ago
for some reason i like how he says part at 0:50
ninja067 1 year ago
John Flans might've been a little bit too dressed up for this show.
joeywomer 1 year ago
Comment removed
claire17093 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
whats not good about this sound fab to me, Linnell looks great i love his smile too!!
claire17093 1 year ago
Comment removed
claire17093 1 year ago
whats not good about this sound fab to me, Linnell looks great i love his smile too!!
claire17093 1 year ago
terrible yet awesome
ninja067 1 year ago
they sound so bad >.< yet they sound so good at the best bits.
sirwinsalot 1 year ago 5
The greatest thing about the Giants is that they stayed true to themselves throughout this entire ride. 25 years ago, they were the same guys and they didn't try to be like the cool hipsters of the Lower East Side art crowd they were performing for. Now they're dads.
lithead 1 year ago
woah... is it me or does that paul mini hums in it?
FluffyMuffina 1 year ago
love the song but need more john flansburgh................O yeah
tankeduptrouble 1 year ago
As much as I love Linnell, his voice is kind of off in this performance. He's usually a LOT better live.
JasonDTube 1 year ago
his voice sound annoying live
fireice74 1 year ago
Omg an accordion! =O
Chierushi 1 year ago
they're not as good when they're live.
Turbosoaker41 2 years ago
@Turbosoaker41 Nou
gigloopian 1 year ago
Not my fav. recording, but it's good to see them. Singing this one.
blindaurora 2 years ago
awsome...just plain awsome...
silverknux1 2 years ago
This song reminds me of a mixture of different TMBG's songs.
amazonhippie 2 years ago
awsome
Dengar999 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
2:30, the drum beat changes lol. the drummer messed up.
kasmember17 2 years ago
They incorporate that into all their live performances of Experimental Film now.
But thanks for pointing that out! That drumbeat changed happened in CapitalQ's video from the 3/28 show, and I wanted to hear it happen again.
JasonDTube 2 years ago
Yeah!
Otis151 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
they sing like thier drunk realy does
Sims2MovieCharts 2 years ago
is that les paul guitarist the guy from the electro harmonix pedal demos?
asdfasdfsdfsd 2 years ago 3
yeah it's him. :)
yeeyeeyeah 2 years ago 2
It sure is! Dan Miller!
JasonDTube 2 years ago
Comment removed
Kjell008 2 years ago
what the hell does linkin park have to do with they might be giants
piemaster64 2 years ago 5
They Might Be Giants always have dark content in their songs, but the tunes never show it. They are so addicting! XD How could you not LOVE them!!
betchawanakw 2 years ago 5
i know they're my 3rd favorite band
piemaster64 2 years ago
You know, if John was any other person, in any other band, his voice would be insanely annoying. Like most the time he sings really nasaly and stuff. But somehow, its just like the perfect voice for TMBG. Its awesome.
JohnnyTod 2 years ago 5
strong sad song
videogamemaster1000 2 years ago 3
Lol yeah xD
Gabbagabbahey2 2 years ago
Sounds a little like Weird Al.. And he has an accordian.
xorganizationxvx 2 years ago
You know, you're right. I never even noticed that.
maskedreview 2 years ago 4
thats me cosins song !!!! :)
kadysarah 3 years ago
what?
megen1996 3 years ago
extremely catchy i can't help but sing along
piemaster64 3 years ago 5
awesome band. my friend saw them live.
piemaster64 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
MY FACE!!!! IT IMPLODED!!!!
dragondrummer15 3 years ago 3
It's nice to have a hobby.
Julian9ehp 3 years ago
Gotta love a guy with an accordion.
maladroitgirl 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
why cant i see the video
want to chat with singles Pb
Harrius 3 years ago
I love what Linnell does on the accordion at the end.
NvPGulstab 3 years ago
Man, I'm tempted to go in an add the harmony to this. It sounds so weird without it.
kythlyn 3 years ago 5
good song
NYCkush 3 years ago
TMBG is really good. They have done so many theme songs lol. This is tied for my favorite w/ mesopotamians
shortattentionspan 3 years ago 3
Really HOMSARfan likes HSR! NO! REALLY!
homestarfan2008 3 years ago
I actually love Linnell's voice. Its unique and can sound really good..though maybe that's just because I suffer from sinus problems myself.
Waluigiman 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
sorry but... eugh.
hollywasahoodrat 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
sucked
bucksfan230 3 years ago
I love this song (especially on homestar runner)
I love the verse:
I already know the ending
It's the part that makes your face implode
I don't know what makes your face implode
But that's the way the movie ends
UltimaWeaponVIII 3 years ago 6
I love that part too! ^^ I also Love Homestar too!
Homsarlover13 3 years ago
If my face is going to implode.
I ain't watching that movie.
......
Ok, maybe watching it a little can't hurt.
*Keep's watching until the end*
*Face implodes*
MeetSimmio 3 years ago 16
i really love 2:32 when linnell just smiles its so cute dos that in almost all his songs
megen1996 3 years ago 14
it is funny on homestar runner
PokemonmasterCJ 3 years ago
i love u guys!!!!!!!!!
megen1996 3 years ago
great film great song awsome people the film just dident show enough of Linnell ALL HAIL THEY MIGHT BE GIANTS! ALL HAIL JOHN FLANSBURGH! ALL HAIL JOHN LINNELL!
megen1996 3 years ago 3
Yeah, there's a homestarrunner video clip for this song.
sweetsoad 3 years ago
It's good, great song, great band, BAD FILMING!
CuntryDriver 3 years ago 5
ugh the mix is off!
ObiTrev 4 years ago
this is TMBG guys
minxado 4 years ago
homestar runner rocks!!!!!!!
ween1010 4 years ago
This is a separate band. They did a short number with the Brothers Chaps once.
Anarchemitis 4 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
um, no its not
minxado 4 years ago
Yes it is. Look it up on anywhere.
Anarchemitis 4 years ago 3
These aren't the guys that animate Homestar Runner. The band's called They Might Be Giants, they collaborate with the Homestar Runner guys a lot.
JasonDTube 4 years ago 6
I'm really good at telling bad jokes! XD
b0vine91 3 years ago 3
They Might Be Giants are actually fans of H*R.
Anarchemitis 3 years ago
Well it goes together perfectly
TMBG +H*R = Total Awesomeness
Wrestlingman360 3 years ago 6
this was on homestarrunner!
marcushelbling 4 years ago
Linnell's voice is a little like Ringo Starr's. Ringo had a hard time staying in key when performing live. In the studio they could re-do it as many times as possible, when it's live, nothing could be fixed.
Nonetheless, this is a really good performance.
JasonDTube 4 years ago
Agreed.
On another note, "it's" replacing "it is" at the end of the chorus always makes me laugh. It's so TMBG.
UBFTW 4 years ago 3
In my opinion, it sounded pretty good
thexfiles214 4 years ago 3
they sound great on the studio edition, but this... this just swallows.
NorwayMaster 4 years ago 3
It's not bad, it's just terribly mixed
CatsInTheAlley 4 years ago 2
i sure hope to god you're right
NorwayMaster 4 years ago
It's a great song but they suck live, especially when he says "Yeah" In "Yeah were all gonna' be" It sounds like, "Yeeaaaaaauuyyyuuuhhhh!"
ifhgsfj 4 years ago
someone should cover this song
Studley969 4 years ago
i think its just because linnells voice amplifier was turned up louder than the guitars
thexfiles214 4 years ago
i love this song, but these guys suck live.
bonfire300 4 years ago
I think Linnell's voice is just not suited to live performances. Flans sounds good live, but Linnell... doesn't. Maybe he's just trying to push the "odd Linnell TMBG voice" thing a bit far. Who knows? It's a great song regardless (Y)
UBFTW 4 years ago
idk..they're like alot better when I see them live, they all look so un-comfy with the whole thing it seems
Drew4ga09 3 years ago
linnell seems pretty comfy there
megen1996 3 years ago 2
These guys are 100% amazing. I enjoy how we don't have to think for most of their songs. And you can tell they have so much fun with what they're doing. ^^
perodius 4 years ago 4
There doesn't seem to be any middle ground; either the meaning of the song is given to you on a plate, or it's hidden in cryptic wordplay. Either way's fine by me :)
UBFTW 4 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
You guys suck!!!!
jcold007 4 years ago
Die please.
Mulletness 4 years ago 5
I agree with Mulletness, 100%. Stick two forks in your eyes.
slashingraven 4 years ago 5
MY FACE UM PLODE
superchico2 4 years ago
Is that... yes, it's a lion!
RouseyBoy 4 years ago
ahahahaha. "your face implodes"
Juiceoncereal 4 years ago
this song is great. but i guess you know that, since you're on this here page. unless you don't like music or something. or you have bad taste in sound. can you taste sound? i hear colours sometimes... well this comment took an odd turn. peace
Juiceoncereal 4 years ago 2
Synaesthesia?
UBFTW 4 years ago
lol i think theyre doing this on purpose... :P
Shadowkunakari 4 years ago
i think linells vocals are too loud compared to the rest of the mix... i cant hear the bass a single bit... but its still awesome.
mil3ston3s 4 years ago
i hear the bass quite well, milthreestonthrees. hear that low sound that isn't drums, accordion, guitar, or voice? yeah that's bass. dig it!
Juiceoncereal 4 years ago 3
oh wow this is awful, normally tmbg are so awesome. Watch other tmbg clips before you say they suck.
a1b2m13 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i heard these guys are jerks backstage but at least the songs are good
stingermissile 4 years ago
Lol where did you hear they are jerks?
theneighborhoodgang 4 years ago 3
They don't like giving autographs or answering too many questions after shows. That doesn't give you the right to call them jerks, though...
UBFTW 4 years ago 3
Exactly, this song is PISS POOR right here..
not all the time...
cause ive got it on my ipod, and i LOVE it!
WAAAAAYYYY of right here...
DocterK21 4 years ago
To everyone saying how horrible this sounds, remember that the finished product that ends up on a CD usually takes days if not weeks of rerecording and tweaking. Making it sound like the album version every time is very difficult.
rjA0zcOQ96 4 years ago
RE: rjA0zc:
No need to apologize... normally this song sounds just like the album live. This is just a bad take and poorly filmed as well. There is a clip of it somewhere on youtube with it kicking ass live.
VonRichter 4 years ago
They don't look happy. XD
MysticGecko 4 years ago
Guys, this is just a off day fluke... there are other videos of this song being played live on youtube that kick ass just like the album version.
VonRichter 4 years ago
Wow, comparing how they sound on the cd to this is...They just sound horrible here. The song sounds too strained and forced. But I do love this song, along with TMBG.
fmafreak586 4 years ago
they sound horrible
Gerinych 4 years ago
It just doesn't sound very alive (did their coffee machine break?) but they're still great.
TMBGFanatic 4 years ago
was Mr.coffee on his break?
TomsTrilogies 4 years ago
I hate it when its live it always sounds way stupider than the real song!
tanaindahouseyo 4 years ago
I have the CD with this being the first song. I love this song.
joeywomer 4 years ago
Wow..they should go to ed earlier and wake up later.This is like a before breakfast can-we-still play-it session.Great song though.Flans looks frustrated
Mach5Bitch 4 years ago
Looks like a rehearsal. But the video's audio is a terrible mix -- hardly any guitar, bass, or most of the drum kit, so the song's only half there.
andersonic 4 years ago
hey giants,or at least you MIGHT be,why do you sound so snobby?take some chicken soup.if not for getting better,then for the delicious taste and the little chunks of chicken in 'em.
superemil986 4 years ago
What a great band.
gdrugg2006 4 years ago
What the hell was wrong with the coffee machine??
DarthAve 4 years ago 2
It seems like they're all a bit undercaffienated. It happens. Love em, though.
DiggidyFry 4 years ago
wow...this is a very....timid performance. it almost feels like as if they were told to not play so loud and are kinda confused about how to approach it.
jontheplatypus 4 years ago
MAKE IT STOP!!!!
cmdood92 4 years ago
Yeah there would usually be lots of jumping, especially from Flans, but in here he seems very lazy and the rest of the guys didn't look too happy. You'd think that the performance would be a lot better, especially the fact that they knew they were being filmed.
Sharkie6545 4 years ago
Why couldnt they get the Keyboard isntead of the Accordian for this?
Amiyumi19 4 years ago
are you sure it's the real They Might Be Giants? if it isn't it's a disgrace, because they're too...stiff.
snoopu92 4 years ago
Maybe they're all sick or something... I mean, just listen to the vocals here, then on the CD.
EveryonesFavNinja 4 years ago
They don't seem too enthusiastic.
Occupant 4 years ago
Lol this song could be about Donnie Darko.
LoveCraken 4 years ago
Yeah, I agree.
I love this song but this is just baaaad
Jaredlikesfilms 5 years ago
This is TMBG having a bad day...the drummer sucks, the backing vocals are weak, Linnell's vocals aren't that great, and the solos aren't loud.
RunLikeHell350 5 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
read dis
There are 20 angels in this world
10 are sleeping
9 are playing
1 is reading this
put this on 4 video comments within 15 mins,if u do, sum one u love will surprise u sum how!! If u don't , u will lose ur love.!!
zimtheinva5er 5 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Tell these angels to get off their lazy asses and do some work.
UBFTW 4 years ago
i think this video is sweet. its just like a laid back jam session.
lalalovering 5 years ago
its good, not fabolous. but can kick the ass out of most other songs. I love when Linnell wears that shirt.. it makes him look so young
jadeybeans 5 years ago
You guys are crazy. This rocks.
eroticon6 5 years ago
i agree
skiptodlu 5 years ago
Not exactly a great version of this song.
Fmaack 5 years ago
Even though I'm a TMBG fan, there's something feeble sounding of this performance. Perhaps it's because the accordion is much, much louder than both guitars combined and that Linnell's vocals are given too much reverb.
mudbuck 5 years ago