Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (69)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • He has got a great voice but I prefer the version of the Arctic Monkeys. If Alex sings this it sounds more authentic to me. I don't know why.

  • I really dislike this version. He's killing it

  • What a great cover! :P

    No jokes, he did a good job with this song.

  • this is shit

  • To paraphrase the man below, you're fucking nonces.

    It's supposed to be different to the original. Not something comparable. If that were the case, no living artist would ever let anyone cover their music, in case it was "better".

    I bet Bob Dylan cries himself to sleep over All along the watchtower. No, that's right, he doesn't; because he isn't a fuckwit.

  • cheers man.

  • Even though this cover has a more sentimental tone, I think Alex's version is much more moving. When he sings it, it sounds genuine and the grittiness of his voice complements the lyrics perfectly. This singer just sounds like he's posturing and isn't really feeling the song's quality. But the instrumentals are still pretty and he's got a good voice.

  • give it a rest you fucking nonces. this is a quality cover. leave it be.

  • Alex Turner is much better than this

  • this is the guy by Yellow River?

  • no - that was a different act

  • i agree, this is nothing on the original, but alex turner plays the guitar on this so i don't think people should be slagging it off so harshly lol.

  • this is absolutely WANK.... anyways, doing an album of classic sheffield songs?? TC isnt even from sheffield he's from rotherham... he should get off the bandwagon and put down the handbook

  • Classic Mate :L

    Couldnt Have Put It Better Myself

  • Haha! Well funny

  • shit compared to the orginal thats a fact, only cover thats better then orginal is jimi hendrix cover of all along the watchtower tbh. and why would tony christie say that i mean there fucking good lyrics

  • its sounds lik a christmas song :-S

  • this version doesn't compare. it's just putting a classic overtone to an arctic monkeys song. which would probably sound good for any of their songs

  • a total classic version.. love it! HAIL :)

  • where the hells the arctics doing this? i cant find it anywhere!! and they done the bloody song lol. this is not bad but still, i want to hear alex turner do it, where is it?? :(

  • Im proper chuffed that the great tony christie covers a song from our boys arctic monkeys

    gains my respect instantly

    bout time somebody with a reputation like this acknowledged alex turners incredible composition and lyrical skills.

  • Tony Christie did say he thought the lyrics of this song sucked and looked like they were wrote by a child :/

    Still love the song and Christie though! haha

  • didn't he say once, that he would give his right arm, to have written these lyrics ?

  • wow, isn't that a bit too extreme?

  • well yeah, but i remeber reading him saying it.. ;)

  • The lyrics, I think, are pretty fucking brilliant.

    It's a gorgeous little story about a man that has a girl fall in love with him and takes her with him wherever it is he goes on the promise of romance and adventure.

    The singer is questioning the girl asking her if it's worth it; to settle so early, when the guy is obviously the only one that benefits. Will the relationship even last? It's a story of quick love but not true romance.

    The lyrics are good, and I may be wrong but it has depth.

  • what tha fuck ! this is so fucking amazing :) !

  • To be fair - You're correct...

  • Absolutely beautiful. Prefer Tony's version to original. Could listen to his voice all day long !

  • this is lovely

  • i hope some1 manages to get every word she said thats the best of his new songs

  • Probably the best Arctic Monkeys cover I every heard! Almost better than the original ;)

  • The start of this song is beautiful. It reminds me of You Only Live Twice and gives me that same relaxed feeling of calmy expressed beauty.

  • cant you tell richard hawley produced this album, great talent rw.

  • it is the first song on this album....think its a bit weak to start a album with a cover^^ but Arctic Monkeys rule! can't wait for the third album!

  • All the songs on the album, bar 1 or 2, are covers... All songs from artists from Sheffield :D

  • Fantastic stuff

  • woow:) this is the only Arctic Monkeys' cover i really do like

  • i like it :)

  • Interesting. Thought I wouldn't like it, but i kinda do.

  • 2 Amazing Sheffield Groups ;)

  • I've always thought this was Alex Turner's best song. It's certainly his most mature I think.

  • I like it, for real :| haha

  • Alex said this is how he wanted it to sound in the first place :)

  • you cant say its not like the original because its a cover not a copy.

  • i don't generally like the style this song has been re-worked into, but this cover sounds so pretty, i can't help but love it :)

  • Tony Christie should be up there with all the great singers, [Tony Bennett,Sinatra] beautiful voice, great song.

  • he's done this well. i think when you cover a song, you should make it your own and not try to copy the original style of the song

  • Totally agree :)

  • i like it.. but i dnt like it lol.

    it sounds realli old lol

    but it sounds quite pretty at the same time.

  • Alex said he liked this cover alot. It does absolutely nothing for me. It's like Grandpa singing. Sorry guys!

  • Quite amazing really

  • Sucha good cover right there.

    Proves that he's not just some idiot singing 'amarillo'.

  • where can i get this

  • iTunes? Download/buy album: Made in Sheffield.

  • Bloody hell, this is a very good cover. I'm genuinly amazed, it has a great feeling to it.

  • i think its a brill cover!

    didnt exspect that.

  • good, but not better than the original one

  • holly, well yep its not better than the original, but its still good, wooow, i never expecct that someone older would do some of this cover, wooooow, i cant belive this

  • although the original is obviously better, i love how this is so crooney and mature or something...

  • i kindda not like it.original was better fer sure.

  • Nice

  • In my opinion, better than the original ....beautiful cover

  • It's good, but not better than original :|

  • yup, agreed =]

  • Lovely version of a great song. Thanks for posting it.

  • I LOVE IT ! :)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more