Added: 4 years ago
From: AngelInNewYork
Views: 1,071,405
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (689)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • she is gorgeous. I bet theres not a man alive who doesnt fancy her . Im a girl and i think shes shit hot

  • meh

    

  • I stumbled across this by accident and what a beautiful song by such a beautiful woman (yes I am aware it is a cover). She looks AMAZING in that black and white dress.

  • Comment removed

  • why is everyone hating, this sounds so chill, just a different vibe from the original but sexy and cool nonetheless. nice atmospherics. this is a sick song. at least they did it their way, as IMO you should. lighten up guys.

  • Awesome expression!!!

  • Fuck off hipsters. This cover is as wondrously beautiful as she is.

  • Compare this to the original by Big Star or to Elliott Smith's version. This is so awful, she really destroyed the song, all its emotion and its innocence.

  • this is by far the hottest she has looked. And damn she's hot!

  • fucking beautiful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • Gente...

  • Love garbage. I'm getting lots of people prefer the original so forgive me for asking, but I never heard this before, who sang the original?

  • @63punkaddict Big Star (1972) :)

  • Its so beautiful :') its so innocent and sweet

  • Oh, no Danzig cover?

  • Soooo nice, loved the original, love this.

  • gorgeous.Not to take anything away from Garbage - but how could you mess up such a brilliant song. xo

  • haters! always have something to say, they want the whole world to know... sad but true... love garbage, this is real music....

  • Love it!!! If you like this check out danish act INOUWEE with the song "YOU"

  • Gasp...when mtv actually aired MUSIC. :o Real music at that

  • All that voice in such a tiny mouth

  • Where can I get this, or in what cd did it come (without using some Youtube converter)?

  • @xx33rroo You should be able to find the "single" on amazon, it might be paired with Push It.

  • I thought that was an actual music video, good job!

  • My sister is friends with their guitar players kid, i picked her up from their house and i met him, i about died from the awesome xD

  • How feeble. Love Garbage but this is dismal. Their own song "13 x Forever" (the b side to "Special") is way better than "Thirteen".

  • Im going into highschool next month and i happend to see this, it really resonated with me. Garbage it such a great artist and all her songs have a true meaning if you take the time to listen insted of makeing rude comments :)

  • this sucks!!! They ruined a beautiful song! Common everyone, stay classic!!

  • @jmksongman according to wikipedia, Alex Chilton was particularly fond of this version of the song

  • Id bone her:)

  • she so fucken hot drives me nuts

  • @archie977 Haha i know especially at the beginning when she's getting out of bed....she has awesome legs.....

  • Haha, this is great. The front page of comments here isn't full of stuff about how crap this is compared to whichever version or the original...

    I shall hold my piece in that case and let the cordiality carry on.

  • ok so why cant i find this song on itunes or anything? help

  • I would like to have makeup sex with Shirley, (I mean have sex with her, in her makeup, ... her pillow would look like somebody smothered a clown!)

  • @viewitmytube

    i actually laughed out loud reading that!!! XD

  • bloody hell, not on itunes. had it as bonus track on version 2.0 cant find the disc

  • UNICA!!!!!!!!!

  • Damn Shirley Manson is one sexy lady... Thank you for the eye candy, Shirley :)

  • Thirteen was written by both Alex and Chris

  • She sounds soo much like Goldfrapp.

  • shirley manson is beautiful. she inspired me to dye my hair red, i love heerrr <3

  • Brilliant stuff!! If u like this check out danish act INOUWEE with the song "you"

  • id this the offcical video for the song??

  • @vvz1234 as far as i know there is no official video for this song. i cant remember which song this video is for though...i'll do research.

  • @vvz1234 1st one is "why do you love me?" 2nd one "sex is not the enemy" last ones are mixes of old videos and live performances

  • @garbagegirl42069 thank you very much!:)

  • Shirley Manson I love you!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @klemintine238

    Personnally, I'm disapponted you don't even know Thirteen is NOT a song by Elliot Smith. The original version was written by Alex Chilton and released in 1972 by a very influential band called Big Star. That "true indie icon" of yours was in love with Big Star's music, so maybe you should check them out...

  • @MickHaines ...Thirteen was actually written by Big Star's guitarist, Chris Bell - not Alex Chilton. Proper credit should be given to him (RIP) for writing such a fantastic song.

  • @thatvinguy

    Na, it was written by Alex Chilton. Thirteen was one of the songs Chilton brought when he joined Bell, Stephens and Hummel in 1971. Do some research, check out the Jovanovic Big Star book... You'll find Thirteen is definitely NOT ChrisBell's.

  • @MickHaines

    Cheers - checked it out - best I can tell is that they both got writing credits for the song. (Couldn't get my hands on the book)

  • She's beautiful.

  • Thirteen is a great song in general. I might like the Garbage version but I don't know. This video (From a different video) does not match the song at all.

  • Everything is really good. Except the bass guitar, as usual in this band. Pom pom... Why dont they play something more creative, more personal ? I have the feeling that you don't really care about that. If it works like this, it'is ok. No ! Hopefully, the songs are really good. But make better bass parts !

    Sincerelly yours, guys !

  • @MrSach0611 i would love to watch the porn u speak of. this is a sick bass line. does it have to be a real bass always. gawd people hate change.

  • i did not see any connection to the song in the video and did not care to see her having her morning poh but nice version of a good song

  • 1m51sec... a sample, but I'm wondering where it's coming from. A french lady saying "il nous manque exactement toutes les conditions..." and then it's too faded for me to understand the rest of it. Does anyone knows where this sample come from?

  • isnt that video from "sex is not the enemy"?

  • I just fell in love with Garbage all over again.

  • Big star version is better but this is okay.

  • Nunca me cansare de ver este video y nunca me saciare tanto de no escuchar esta musica.

  • Great song! if u like this check out the song "YOU" by danish act Inouwee.

  • @kaari1 OKKK

  • I actually like this version better than the big star original.Simple and heart warming.

  • the chick is hot but elliott smiths version is better

  • this song is a cover of ellliott smith <3

  • Comment removed

  • @xpunk22 History lesson: Elliot Smith covered a Big Star song. His version is lovely, theirs is magical.

  • @ddye78ham yep and nobody else should touch it. especially c.love

  • Comment removed

  • +such a beautiful song of love

  • +such a beautiful sonng of love

  • Rock and roll is here to stay. Have I heard that lyric before?

  • Comment removed

  • Amazing song!! Check out danish act Inouwee with the song "Empty bodies" If you like this:)

  • so beautiful! she is amazing! great cover...she even makes sitting on a fucking toilet look good. how many people can do that?

  • so beautiful! she is amazing! great cover...

  • she is such a stunner

  • im not going to lie, this is a terrible cover.

  • @chansondete

    This is SO beautiful...

    You must be fucking RETARDED.

  • what's the song starting at 0:38? does anyone know?

  • @melissaypak

    "Sex is not the enemy".

  • @melissaypak I think the vid is for the song "Sex is not the enemy". Sorry if I am wrong. 

  • what is the video when shirley sits on a lavatory?

  • @firstdateaftercoma pretty sure it's androgyny...but there may be more.

  • Where can I get this track? Ain't heard it before. SM you're a goddess.

  • mmmmnnn, very good one, should be a single

  • I love the cover. From folk to grunge....the video kind of throws the song itself off though. Still a lovely cover. If anyone IS a fan of folk by any chance you should check out the cover of this by elliot smith. :)

  • I think this is the wrong kind of melodrama for the source material. It's whatever : \

  • Great music!. Check out the danish band INOUWEE with the song "empty bodies" if you like this. THX!

  • Suck

  • this is garbage

  • Wow, this sure sounds different on Youtube than at the beginning of The Hangover. Though, they say the camera adds a few pounds, so there you go.

  • what the guy below me said.

  • Ugh!! Chilton's turning over in his grave!!!

  • they really covered this well.

  • Growing up does not make you the person you are now. Your parents do not influence you. Bringing up as a way to form minds is a lie. You get genes from them, sure, but they are mixed AT RANDOM and only few properties of our bodies are inherited in a SIMPLE way. You are not just your inheritance. Not at all. You are something completely new. It's strange that other people can communicate with you at all, you are so different. Accept it.

  • @agquarx What in the world...

  • @agquarx I'm nothing like either of my parents, go true individuality!

  • Growing up is more than some needless or shitty transition; it's a challenge, so meet it. It's a gift, so accept it. It's a sorrow, so overcome it. It's a tragedy, so face it. It's a journey, so complete it. It's a struggle, so fight it. It's a chance to explore and experience the best that you can become. Growing up, at least from my perspective, is courage that is patience under pressure. Anything less is not worthy. Enjoy being who you are, not a replica, but an original" Peace

  • @SatansMajesty Did your Lord Satan tell you to express such attitude? I admire you. I am a follower of the Lord Satan myself.

  • @agquarx Actually the name came about because of a guy, who by no big surprise is no longer in the pictue ... but what the hell the name is quite killer so fuck em ! Eh ! lol Mia xxx

  • @agquarx LOL... now I get it.

  • @SatansMajesty Very well put. Where did you learn such fanastic valu--Oh right...

    Fucking around though, very wise comment.

  • @SatansMajesty Word Up ! :)

  • @SatansMajesty

    At least you "think" you have a clue...

    can't believe you got that many thumbs up.....

    i Know exactly where that those thumbs should go.

  • @SatansMajesty Or it's being ostracized, bullied, misunderstood, castigated, abused, institutionalized, and scarred emotionally for life.

  • @SatansMajesty oh dear, you are quite clearly a conservative who likes to patronise people

  • @SatansMajesty Well said!

    

  • @SatansMajesty

    Well said. Each age has its own pleasures and challenges. I believe that the art of living well is discovering what these are at various points in the journey.

  • @SatansMajesty wow thats wise

  • @SatansMajesty I ordered mine without cheese, I'd like to return it.

  • @SatansMajesty So profound..but coming from "satan's majesty, take it with a grain of salt?? haha =p..nice one though

  • shes bomb...

  • Growing up is more than some needless or shitty transition; it's a challenge, so meet it. It's a gift, so accept it. It's a sorrow, so overcome it. It's a tragedy, so face it. It's a journey, so complete it. It's a struggle, so fight it. It's a chance to explore and experience the best that you can become. Growing up, at least from my perspective, is courage that is patience under pressure. Anything less is not worthy. Enjoy being who you are, not a replica, but an original" Peace

  • it somehow reminds me the  60's........

  • elliott smith(L)

  • what a beautiful song! I love Shirley (even more) on this video

  • "Come inside now it's okay"

  • One of the most beautiful women.

  • ...ǝsןǝ ǝuo ou puɐ ɟןǝsɹnoʎ ǝq...

  • OTRA DE MIS FAVORITAS... NADA MAS Y NADA MENOS QUE POR LA LETRA

  • Why can't we have more rock stars like Shirley Manson instead of Myley Cyrus and Lady CaCa?

  • i love this song thank you big star for writing it but i love this version so much more

  • Comment removed

  • My ex was a song writer her favorite band was Garbage, She would listen to them for hours, I came to love these songs as she did. Every time I put Garbage on and listen to them it takes me back to those days of sharing my life with her. She committed suicide when I was away on a trip. She was terminally ill with cancer and she waited for my absence to do this.

  • @MrSevasti1 Ooh... sad. But also nice to have music so you can remember the shared days.

  • @MrSevasti1 That is awful...

  • @MrSevasti1 damn thats horrible im sorry for your loss

  • Wow. This is great stuff. Who sang the original?

  • @captainadam1 big star

  • @captainadam1 Big Star sang the original, also check out Elliott Smith's cover, so good.

  • Happy Birthday Shirley Manson!

  • @RedDollShoes ^ ^

  • 0:44 i hear her farting on my mind

  • sounds like goldfrapp

  • This is good but the best cover is Wilco's. Well this video is better oh la la.

  • sorry for my ignorance... but I want to ask: can please someone tell me from what video is taken the images starting at 0:39 ? I see cuts from some other videos of Garbage but I cannot find this part/video... maybe it's not from a video clip? thanks in advance. and oh! awesome cover! (even when the original one is just perfect!)

  • @ForBeerAndSmoke -- I'm pretty sure its Sex is not the Enemy

  • @tdesjarlais10 Thank you so much for the help! I got it now! thanks again!

  • Yes!

  • @mountainhigh88 this is a cover of a song written by Alex Chilton and Chris Bell back in 1972. they were in a band

    "Big Star" ....

    so, its a cover of their song. Elliott Smiths version is also a cover.

  • Great Elliott Smith cover. :)

  • What is this song about?

  • the softness of your voice, the sadness of your eyes...so precious and peaceful

  • she might sing well, but she got all of the innocence of this beautiful song. too bad.

  • The clip from like 0.39 where shes got the mad red hair. What video is that?

  • @ElJucifer The video for the song "Sex is not the enemy"!

  • @annabane3 Thanks so much!

  • Love the music!! If you like this Check out the band INOUWEE with the song "Devil noise"

  • my favorite kinda yeasterday today

  • god - i love her SO much

  • This is an amazing song! I like Hole's version too :)

  • she kind of looks like lily allen at 1:10... well, obviously, lily allen looks like HER age wise, but you know what I mean...

  • GARBAGE is correct!! Shitty cover of a great 70's tune

  • Song So Amazing 

  • Finest Beauty on the Walk

  • Where is this from?

  • Comment removed

  • Growing up is more than some needless or shitty transition; it's a challenge, so meet it. It's a gift, so accept it. It's a sorrow, so overcome it. It's a tragedy, so face it. It's a journey, so complete it. It's a struggle, so fight it. It's a chance to explore and experience the best that you can become.

    Growing up, at least from my perspective, is courage that is patience under pressure. Anything less is not worthy.

    Enjoy being who you are, not a replica, but an orginal

  • @TheFairiesofGreen I happened to read this, at a very good timing. Hmm can't tell you just how good. :]

  • @sweetrage425 lol kill yourself

  • @anonynomnomnom Aha na that's pathetic :D 

  • @TheFairiesofGreen you see something great

    i see growing up as nothing more than a box of garbage it gets in the way sometimes it stinks sometimes it can attract unwonted things you can live your whole life being told your not as smart as someone slightly older when you are the yearning to learn things can be strong but it breeds ego

    the yearning to be understanding can be great but it breeds self pain

    the yearning to be a boss of your own life leads to other people hatting you and ignorance

  • @TheFairiesofGreen  stfu its is easy and nice to spout such pretty word but in real life it means nothing.

  • @secretdesires says your 27? and you still dont get it.. do the world a favor and Grow Up or better yet Shut Your Mouth !!