Added: 3 years ago
From: MohdArfanBMohdAriff
Views: 126,984
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (282)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Oh, never mind about Noora being a twin too. I wonder how she's doing though without her two other sisters. :/

  • Comment removed

  • I know they need the money, but the behaviour of the Hospital Director is really disgusting. They exploited Manar like no tomorrow. They were more focused on the publicity and the "fame" than the baby's health. It's disturbing.

  • @Germania72 its life

  • so what happened to her other head?! :(

  • @iGinaCristina did you not watch the other videos? it died, certain death. It was a parasite nothing more.

  • Oprah is fat ass bitch like so many others parasites worldwide that are specialist in exploit human misery!!!

  • is there no part 4?

  • Oprah wasted no time in exploiting the situation.

  • Im like crying  I hope that manar rests in peace..

  • i am looking for part 4

  • That is just so sad, now I want to cry.

  • How sad..... Manar died..... After the surgery,she survived but she died after a few weeks......

  • manar might missing the other half of her

  • Part 4 was rather gruesome...maybe YouTube removed it.

    The family gave the parasite twin the name Islam and buried it according to their religion. Manar died just before she turned 2 from a brain infection stemming from the shunt valve problem.

  • Rest in peace monar

  • Yeah she died :'( On Wikipedia it says she died some says before her 2nd b-day :'(

  • to all asking if she died... yes she died of a brain infection around 2yrs old... so sad.

  • wait wait wait did Manar die or not i'm confused

  • Manar died, didn't she? RIP

  • Manar died, didn't she?

  • Manar And Islaam Were Beautiful Babies God Bless Them!

  • what a wonderful story may God almighty bless you manar and give you wealth inchallah!

  • sooo you feed both sides

  • @AmYoUrDaDy009 Did you listen, they can't. The parasite doesn't have organs! (that mean a GI tract, which means a stomatch, intestine, and rectum the poop it out)..It she did feed the parasite the other twin would suffer from infection and other complications.....

  • where is part 4 motherfucker

  • where the fuck is part 4

  • @shockerdude1000 ditto!!

  • @shockerdude1000 Thats what IM saying???????????? It skip the most important part.

  • Manar looked happier while her twin was attached to her. Why didn't the twin have a name? She is also a human being. I think she was alive with her own soul before the surgery when they had to sacrifice her to keep Manar alive. They were both so cute.

  • 7:28 - If what ever she's got you'll accept it, why didn't she accept two of them, Manar and the Parasite .. God

  • @silverdust1 Because the other baby would have killed the one with a heart and body. They couldn't survive off of one blood supply and one heart. Futhermore what kind of quality of life would that have been for the other child?

  • Amazingly strong mother <3

  • The mother is so strong. I applaud her for her strength and courage.

  • Look at the parasite. I mean Oprah.

  • heartbreaking story. fantastic mum.

  • i dont think this child was 100 percent ready to leave the hospital. she still needed the professional care and monitoring that her mother cant give her. sure theres no love like a mothers love, but that child should have stayed and been monitored under a doctors care a lot longer than she was in the recovery phase

  • iii

  • Manar had such a sad look in her eyes...

  • where the hell is part 4!!!!! i want the truth !!!!!

  • @heckova WHERE IS PART 4

  • i wonder is she still alive because that was in 2005

  • @caityycurran she died when she was 2 due to a fatal brain infection

  • @emwong89 awh that is so sad the poor we thing im gonna pray for her the twin and that familey :(

  • My first concern is that we don't find out what happens to her after the shunt is replaced, indicating that the surgery was not a success, which leads to the second.

    The connection between twins is profound when they aren't conjoined. It makes me wonder if Manar didn't shared more than just blood with her most unfortunate twin. To objectify this twin as a parasite, to leave her cold, uncovered and plaster this story all over the worlds 'news' is more than pathetic.

    Be grateful for what you have.

  • It makes me sad to know that after all this, she died. I just found this out. Something did change with her character. IDK......my sympathies to the family.

  • Wow, this is an outcome I did not expect. This baby was perfectly fine (mentally) before the surgery. Something has happened and it is not good. Perhaps it is the medication that is the reason, but the child has changed. Just from these vids you can see that. I hope that she will be alright. I hope it is the meds that is causing this. In any case, these are brave and caring people to take care of a single human in this way. It exemplifies what being human really is.

  • that womam is so so strong she supported her daughter willingly knowing that she may be dissabled she truly did love er for who she was if more people were like her the world would b a much better p;lace :)

  • Her sister kissing her that was so cute.

    Did she live u hope she did

  • @skillofdacentury She did not. She died of a brain infection a little before she turned two. However, maybe her case can help somebody else born with this condition in the future.

  • -sniff- that is so sad.

  • mmmmmmm where is part 4? maybe that part4 is disgustiing for some audiences maybe but you should ulpoad that part PLEASE!!

  • Atleast she is okay.

  • @JassieXD news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/4848164.st­m She died a year later sadly.

  • Why is there no part four?

  • Part 4???

  • yes wher is the part 4 cant find in anywher

  • Somehow I missed part 4?

  • what happened to part 4?????????

  • part 4?

  • She was so cute when she smiled, she looked to so happy. Its so sad :'(

  • Sad soo sad if u notice the baby smiled when she was with her twin but after she noticed that her twin was gone it's like the twin was the happy part of her

  • OMG this nearly made me cry

  • I was really hoping she would make it. :(

  • "She is my daughter, and I am her mother, no matter what." This woman puts thousands to shame.

  • Where is part 4?

  • aww poor baby____where is part 4?

  • where the hell is her dad?you never see him he must of bailed when she was born huh.......

  • @eugenelizard her father is at work.People in Egypt are working more than 12 hours

  • Where is part 4?

  • LOL YOU KNOW WHAT MADE ME LAUGH OUT OF ALL THT SADNESS..on 2:51 it sounded like she said no but it was Yes....yes LOL :>

  • It's sad she died

  • This is sad to watch :( Rest in peace little ones, i just hope they gave the underdeveloped twin a proper burial also, after all she was a person albeit without any organs or limbs but she had a functioning brain and if all went normally in the womb then she would of been a 'normal' child xx

  • Looks like you can separate a head or another body part...but you can not separate the soul.

  • what did they do with the retarded part?

  • Manar,this is so sad!You were so close to succed,and then you died..Rest in peace,sweet angel!

  • This is the saddest story I have ever seen. It brought me to tears! ): Poor Manar!

  • Manar died  :(

  • i think it would have been cruel to let the parasite baby live.. it had no vocal ability and no limbs which means there would have been no way for that consciousness to communicate with people. not to mention it would not be able to eat and would be in constant physical discomfort and in what would probably be mental bliss

  • @JustinKennith Little boy many years ago before surgeons who wanted to glorify themselves got involved, had a parasitic twin which again smiled and had thoughts. They lived together until the boy got bitten by a snake - he didn't die by surgeons - he and his twin head didn't die because he was a twin but by an act that could have happened and has happened to many a human. Manar smiled until they removed her twin... don't ever ever say the surgeons did good - they killed two children.

  • How is this baby doing today?How is she doing mentally?I hope everyting is ok with her now?

  • It's so sad tht in the end both had to die

  • @spennies Oh that's so sad, all that time and effort gone to waste. Poor girl :(

  • what an awsome mother.

  • :O shocking

    just shocking! god thats made me angry

    if i was a mother i would be broken hearted by haveing the doctors turn on me like that! no matter how they saved the little girl

    thats just crule >.<

  • did the baby die? god hope it ddint i saat here and cryed very tuching

  • You guys keep saying about how they didn't care about Islam, but if she had been born that way on her own, she would have died anyway. Why risk the life of two children to save one that had no chance? Yes it's sad and she was a person the same as Manar but by staying connected, she was slowly killing Manar as well. It was a terrible situation and a risk they had to take. Imagine if you were the mother, what could she do, she was helpless to save Islam at all. There was nothing more she could do.

  • thats a true mother right there

  • she died in 25 mars 2006 :(

  • You just can't cut off the brain..

  • Wheres the father???

  • did manar die?

  • @dianahernandezsssffx

    yes .. in mars 2006 :(

  • the End? i loves manars sister too they both where cute :D

  • NO she didnt want fame, as she smiles when she says that. Its ok crap mom, we know you didnt love your other baby since she was only tissie attached to your babys head. she USED to smile, well mom perhaps she knows you didnt love her twin sister......

  • It's a shame she has died u-u

  • I can see why they made her famous it seems a bit cruel , but the amount of people that can be helped with the money raised should make up for it and after everything that hospital did for that child they deserve some recognition I would say. thanks for sharing :)

  • did she surviv

  • amazing !!!

    That a child can survive like this !!

    The seccond twin "the parasit" was a child too !!! even if they say it wasn't !!

    It had a face and a brain and a body so it was an unperfect person but it was a person ..... alive when Menar was alive and dead when they separated her !!!!!

    They killed a human being so they will be punished by god!!!

    They wore meant to die together!!!

    Angels for ever !!!!!!!!!!

    That's what I think !!!

    who's with me???

  • that was truely an insprational and very beautiful story. God bless all those that did what they could for her! :)

  • Where is the father in any of this?

  • The "parasite" was human too!

  • @islandwarrior16 They neglected the parasit.

  • Don't blame the doctors, THEY ARE HERE TO HELP BECAUSE WE NEED THEM. AND they DO care about their patients, which some cases can get very personal and emotional for them just like this one.

    And for those of you who didn't like the surgery and the doctors...what if YOU were the one who were to have the parasitic twin on top of your head instead?

  • I had tears streaming down my face after this doco. What an amazing story, what precious little girls. There have been some comments on this page attacking the doctors and family, which I believe is terribly unfair. Obviously they wrestled deeply with the ethical implications of what they were doing. I would never wish to be faced with a similar decision to make. Ultimately, I believe the people involved did their best and treated Manar and Islam with respect and love.

  • That is very,very sad...the twin was a homunculus,a human without a..............well,it has a soul just not a "regular" one,so they killed it and then the other one died. And the worst part is the mom,at first she calls the twins "that" then at the end she says how much she loves her....

  • @Freedogdylan abourtion is not the answer yes the condition is bad but abourtion is worce would you kill a child even if they weren't born yet

  • that poor mother

  • I'm sorry to hear that she didn't make it. RIP little one.

  • @adriannicus she didn't make it? do you know how long she lived?

  • wow this is really sad but postive in a way, I know that our main focus was on the baby on all 5 parts that we watched but last 30 seconds on here of the words that her mom said was Strong, god bless her and her Mother and wish from the bottom of my heart that Manar would live and get healthy and have a chance to enjoy this beautiful world :)

  • it's stupid that the doctors only care about there reputations....

    and after waching part 1,2,3,4,and5 i'm just sad and happy because one twin died and the other lived

  • @domiD1999 the surviving one died too b/c of brain infection...

  • so very sad x

  • amazing x

  • Its so sad that the baby still died.

  • God Bless this Child.

  • so she dies????????????????????

  • Comment removed

  • What a sad story. That baby fought and fought its whole life... Makes me feel how lucky I really am to have a normal child

  • i love that mother

    i respect that mother

    she wanted to get that baby out of that hospital because they only seem like they wanted fame. all they talk is about money here, money there it's a human being not a piece of art work to show off

  • @kevinklot you must be a humanities student in arts haha

  • @kevinklot Its your Mother :D you are baby :D lOl

  • @kevinklot Yes but you have to understand the reasoning; they have spent a lot of money on her, funds that could also save A LOT of other children (think of all the other sick kids). By going to Oprah and having that money, they will address this problem so that the hospital can continue to function and save innocent children. It is not going to hurt Manar (the fame) to make some money from her illness, if it means that it will save other children. I understand what the hospital did.

  • happy end 

  • @jikadem Well, this baby died in 2008, from a brain infection. Now this is so rare, but there is change that if she were treated in the realm of western civilization - she would have stand a better chance. The most important is of course that abortion is practices on cases like this. No child should be born with this kind of conditions.

  • at 0:03 she was still holding her her as if Islam was still there, how sweet and she looked so terrified going into the cat scan :(

    RIP manor and Islam

  • MANAR, REST IN PEACE

  • man... i don't think i could ever do what the dr done or handled it as well as the parents.... a thumbs up is not even close to how good thees dr done it tack's a lot more than what most people have to do and deal with what every one did to save this baby, show's that there are true hero's in this world

  • omg! im egyptian and i know everything about islam and im realy extrordinarely sad about this! i mean... dude! i cried! :(

  • Where is the dad? This poor mother has gone through more shit in a two year period than most of us will have to in a lifetime. This situatuation has no doubt caused all sorts of hardship on this family and even their extended family members. I hope that they are finally finding as much peace as someone can in such terrible conditions. Thanx for posting the videos. They are gruesome but neccessary for us to see that life isn't as bad as we thought.

  • @ekocentric Yes, I wondered abotu the dad as well.. This was just a reminder we need to be thankful for what we have and stop worrying over dumb things like being fat or a broken heart or no money..

  • @IvANNAo4 You are exactly where I am in the gracious thoughts..I agree whole heartedly. Could you imagine this poor mom? I'm naturally a little on the suspicious side, so I'd probably wonder every time that some stranger approached me thinking that they wanted to either make money off of me or to feel pity for my kids.

  • so sad....

  • My stomach has been churning throughout this whole video. It makes me feel sick to know that this has happened, that they willinging killed a human being. Although I know it was the only way to save Monar. But poor Mona (Islaam) must have been scared, and holding onto the God that her family belives in in terror and fear, wishing for her sister again.

  • "Sadly Manar Maged Die."  R.I.P., Manar!

  • Wow...that was powerful...

  • Is that a Girl or a Boy??

  • @Taylor8688  girl

  • @Taylor8688 They said "she" so it's clearly a girl you stupid fuck.

  • So much money is spend in the world for killing and destruction. Where is the money for healing and livesaving???

  • So sad to read that she died in spite of all the efforts of the doctors and the courage of her family. The mother in fact lost 2 daughters, that must be so incredibly hard on her...

  • I wonder though, If Manar would still be alive right now if they hadn't separated Islaam. Like that boy that survived to 4 until he got bitten by a snake.

  • @ThePuppyLover13 that`s extremely unlikely. the Bengali boy`s twin was a lot smaller than Manar`s twin, therefore requiring less blood to be supplied by the heart. Manar`s heart on the other hand was already working so much over capacity that it had failed 6 times.

  • i consider any1 having a heart to hav a sole. the parasite didn't hav a heart, so i.. as wrong as this sounds, i don't consider it a person. a person can't be all brain.

  • @Kanna64

    So what's your view on heart transplantation?

  • @Kanna64 Then you MUST go back to school and this time LISTEN to your teachers.

  • @Kanna64 the hearth is just a blood pump, nothing more.

  • @Kanna64 The heart is basically a blood pump. the brain is what controls everything, that baby had emotions and it was aware of things. You can see by looking at its face it had a personality, just becuz it was born without a heart doesent mean it doesent have a soul.

  • She doesn't smile anymore..........

  • i dont know but i cried for the other head:(

  • ITZ SOO SAD I WAS CRYING AND I AM HAPPY THAT AT LEAST ONE OF THEM SURVIVED but only for a year itz SOO SAD! :'(

  • Manar was such a beautiful baby. Such a darling smile she had...

  • On February 19, 2005, 10 month old Manar Maged underwent a successful 13-hour surgery in Egypt, but died March 25, 2006 :'(

  • oh my. i wanted a happy ending . poor child. i cant even imagine.

  • wtf is oprah doing in this case??????

  • She died a year later after the surgery due to brain infection

  • LAMENTABLE la mierda de medicos estos, y la Oprah te cagas

  • Remarkable medical team given the resources they had. They should feel very proud even though Manar eventually passed...

    Oprah, go fuck yourself you media slut and ratings vulture!

  • @TSM8088 Her mother said she never smiled again after they killed her twin - remarkable - nah, proud - they should feel disgusted with themselves - killed two living entities, the second died in their heart and brain at that same time as the first but had to go through a lot of pain and sadness before their sad sad demise.

  • Alot can be learned from the surgery. They should have looked out side of their country for help. And not been greedy for the fame.

  • in the end you can't help but feel these type of surgeries might be a waste of resources that could be used to save people who actually have a chance to live on. Manar ended up dying months after this, and the doctors knew the entire time that she would most likely die shortly later even if the surgery succeeded.

  • so sad..

  • omg thats just sooo sad me mate is pregnant and she is having twins and her case this might happen

  • apparently the little girl never smiled again after they removed her twin..

  • well that has put a down on my day.

  • the mothers love...

    do anything for the children...

  • i dont think it is really fair that the media think that they have the right to barge into peoples lives like that, it must have been so upsetting to the mother

  • agreed

  • Bless her!

  • is she still alive??