QUESTIONS regarding on Pedaling for this piece, my piano teacher didnt want to teach me this.
On the 2nd bar of this, the one that starts with a C sharp, then G# C# E x2. I see that the LED goes with the Csharp and a sign that goes at the 2nd G#C#E Do i let go of my sustain pedal at the point before i play the 2nd G#C#E ?
And also, how do i use the una corda pedal for this piece?
Appreciate if anyone can advice me =), im just a total noob
I think you played this piece with grace and beauty, and although not everyone will agree to the fact that this is the way it should have been played, we can all agree that it is beautiful playing and you are extremely talented. Continue playing!
@JamesinLA1 Then we'll all assume you've met Chopin and understand his music? If we'd all interpret it your way, then we'd no longer have opinions. And because we all interpret Chopin's music differently there's no right and no wrong.
She did play that waltz pretty well! Thanks for this vid, cuz this will be my inspiration cause I'm gonna play this piece in my upcoming recital. And my teacher made me memorize two Chopins!!! (the other one is the minute waltz) hah :D
she hits the piano keys a bit too hard, needs to ease into the keys more on the sustained notes. Clarity is indeed excellent on the faster parts, but the main melody waltz notes are a bit hard to listen to with the choppiness from hitting the notes.
i checked on the scale thing and it said this was a grade 7. but then again grade 7 might just mean u get all the notes right and have no real feeling when playing this.
this is the best I've heard on youtube, in my opinion. Others out there are playing it either way to fast, or are dragging it, and thus loosing the essence of the piece. She reads the ornaments well ^^
@BattiManZel I agree that tons of people are playing it too rushed, but I find that she's lacking rubato, some parts she should just hurry up a little bit.
@BattiManZel wat r u talking about? ive seen a 9-yr-old play better...actually, as one of the best interpretations. this one might be one of the top five interpretations iv heard, but...and its not hard 2 play either
@audreyhsux5727 What I was talking about, I put it right there. Well, you have to admit, you had the privilege of seeing more interpretations than I have I guessing, since you saw a nine year old etc. But I really did enjpy this, and expressed it as such.
I think that basically she just over-interpreted it. It made it sound too much like a whole new piece and not just the way that it was written. Expression is wonderful but don't change the whole meaning of the peace.
mad skills but I think it was a bit fast and then she changed her tempo a bit too much. It just didn't sound right. It's a matter of interpretation but to my personal ears it just didn't seem like the best way to play the piece. She is still an amazing pianist. That's easy to see.
@radagastthe3rd : i agree. It should be slower a lil bit more interpreting and emotions.I didn't feel much hearing this playing. I don't think this is the best interpretation of the piece. yet she's still a great pianist, of course.
I love to see gorgeous songs played by gorgeous women. chopin is my favorite because he has pieces for every mood and he captures the moment perfectly. true genius but i would love to hear how chopin intended these pieces to be played. not saying it was bad but i dont think chopin would have played it that way. could be wrong cause it was pure beauty and maybe that is all he intended it to be.
EXACT SPEED !!! THANK GOD !!! someone knows what they are doing..:)) needs more work on phrasing.....and slowing and speeding should be smoother... :)) but beautiful !
@bestfriendsforeva I agree that she maintained stunning clarity but with rubato I'm not so sure. The piece is meant to be 'Giusto' which means it has to be strict in tempo. It's only a personal opinion but I think it could've been so much better without or with very careful rubato.
Excellent job! Very nice tempo and dynamics. Nice hand positioning and very smooth and easy style. The piece just seemed to flow off your finger tips..
beautifully played.
marochan9317 2 weeks ago
Perfect
ternak001 2 weeks ago
i'm dazzed....completly dazzed.. by the way she plays this ,so elegantely,gently!!awesome!thump up !
makoto5574 1 month ago
You are awesome!!!,
legitlion1 1 month ago
Mkmimijnijnnojnjninjini
legitlion1 1 month ago
I like this interpretation :)
eseptim 1 month ago
This is one of favorite Chopin Waltzes and very hard to play as are most Chopin waltzes,
but you nailed it me dear. Best on YouTube! :-)
Thank you so much for this 5 Star Upload :-)
esacnitsuj1 1 month ago
Comment removed
DreamCaster2011 2 months ago
best version on youtube.
Subject134127 3 months ago
i am nine and i have to play this song!!!
AnnaMicrosoft 3 months ago
You play very very good. Much better than others I saw in Youtube.
fatfrabbit 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
QUESTIONS regarding on Pedaling for this piece, my piano teacher didnt want to teach me this.
On the 2nd bar of this, the one that starts with a C sharp, then G# C# E x2. I see that the LED goes with the Csharp and a sign that goes at the 2nd G#C#E Do i let go of my sustain pedal at the point before i play the 2nd G#C#E ?
And also, how do i use the una corda pedal for this piece?
Appreciate if anyone can advice me =), im just a total noob
TheAshKane 4 months ago
I think you played this piece with grace and beauty, and although not everyone will agree to the fact that this is the way it should have been played, we can all agree that it is beautiful playing and you are extremely talented. Continue playing!
PianoGirl852 5 months ago
She doesn't get the music in her soul. Did like her approach to the B section. She doesn't understand chopin.
JamesinLA1 6 months ago
@JamesinLA1 Then we'll all assume you've met Chopin and understand his music? If we'd all interpret it your way, then we'd no longer have opinions. And because we all interpret Chopin's music differently there's no right and no wrong.
ImmortalSpecies 6 months ago
Nicee :) I'm korean too and I play the piano too ^^
soominpark123 7 months ago
I hav to learn this song for the summer in piano. It's like summer reading but better ya know?
matthewsnk5040 8 months ago
짱 이에요
huijin1004 8 months ago
THIS ISTHE BEST .. youtube. com/watch?v=OdmXc84a6iE
MFPalubaJr 9 months ago
Delightful !... Thanks for sharing.
Cyrille.
Mynoufou 10 months ago 3
She has good hands.
Nobody else can do it like you do!!
erikasannn 10 months ago
it's perfect!!!
i'm playing it tonight in a concert!!
13pianomaniac 10 months ago
so good
nuzaaa1 10 months ago
She did play that waltz pretty well! Thanks for this vid, cuz this will be my inspiration cause I'm gonna play this piece in my upcoming recital. And my teacher made me memorize two Chopins!!! (the other one is the minute waltz) hah :D
Fi2pianist 10 months ago
素晴らしい音色ですね♪素敵です。
erikasannn 11 months ago
Who do not like she just crazy
nuzaaa1 11 months ago
you did a great job, but i think there're other interpretations on this platform which are way better.
susukek 11 months ago
REALLY GOOD! im learning this same piece for my concert! You video really helped :)
13542emma 11 months ago
Orgasmeándome!!!! Es posible!!!!
marianitzin 11 months ago
she hits the piano keys a bit too hard, needs to ease into the keys more on the sustained notes. Clarity is indeed excellent on the faster parts, but the main melody waltz notes are a bit hard to listen to with the choppiness from hitting the notes.
awakeinlove10 11 months ago
amazing dexterity and grace
slapmyfunkybass 11 months ago
..GREAT PERFORMANCE !! *****
sun21760flower 11 months ago
Great interpretation!
ShawnaWanna2 1 year ago
i cant find this song anywhere for nothing in the world
NiggaDragoon2 1 year ago
best interpretation ever !
Rena3127 1 year ago
i checked on the scale thing and it said this was a grade 7. but then again grade 7 might just mean u get all the notes right and have no real feeling when playing this.
feliciazhu555 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thank you so much for sharing your talents
bikingsage 1 year ago
thank you so much for sharing your talents
bikingsage 1 year ago
oh, i love this piece :)
dani00703 1 year ago
excellent performance, very nice!
lvmaniak 1 year ago
just wondering, what grade is this song?
TheSoken123 1 year ago
@TheSoken123 ] It is grade 9.
XDSakuraBlossomXD 1 year ago
@XDSakuraBlossomXD yeah, or even more.
TheSoken123 1 year ago
@XDSakuraBlossomXD
ABRSM ?
timcsh 11 months ago
@timcsh RCM. (Royal Conservatory Of Music)
XDSakuraBlossomXD 10 months ago
@XDSakuraBlossomXD is grade 9 as in freshman or cm tests? cuz i play it & its not hard...and im not gonna reveal my age.
audreyhsux5727 4 months ago
Yeah! I'm 11and I have to play this!!!
gpnmxtx 1 year ago
I am ten and I have to play this song!!!
00172000darkorbit 9 months ago
fucking good.
MlleOeufDur 1 year ago
this is the best I've heard on youtube, in my opinion. Others out there are playing it either way to fast, or are dragging it, and thus loosing the essence of the piece. She reads the ornaments well ^^
BattiManZel 1 year ago 27
@BattiManZel I agree that tons of people are playing it too rushed, but I find that she's lacking rubato, some parts she should just hurry up a little bit.
MrJabberzz 7 months ago
@BattiManZel wat r u talking about? ive seen a 9-yr-old play better...actually, as one of the best interpretations. this one might be one of the top five interpretations iv heard, but...and its not hard 2 play either
audreyhsux5727 4 months ago
@audreyhsux5727 What I was talking about, I put it right there. Well, you have to admit, you had the privilege of seeing more interpretations than I have I guessing, since you saw a nine year old etc. But I really did enjpy this, and expressed it as such.
BattiManZel 4 months ago
@BattiManZel
What a beautiful compliment. Thank you so much!
-Kyung
AidaTosca 4 months ago
@AidaTosca You are welcome :D
BattiManZel 4 months ago
I enjoyed your perfomance very much.
brians7553 1 year ago
Yuja Wang plays it with sharp and clear staccotos but I like this one because it's slow.
DaRkLORDnUb 1 year ago
wonderful playing. she certainly did not over interpret it, i defiantly liked it alot
birchtree95 1 year ago
I think that basically she just over-interpreted it. It made it sound too much like a whole new piece and not just the way that it was written. Expression is wonderful but don't change the whole meaning of the peace.
radagastthe3rd 1 year ago
@radagastthe3rd I have to disagree O_O This sounds perfect!
BattiManZel 1 year ago
mad skills but I think it was a bit fast and then she changed her tempo a bit too much. It just didn't sound right. It's a matter of interpretation but to my personal ears it just didn't seem like the best way to play the piece. She is still an amazing pianist. That's easy to see.
radagastthe3rd 1 year ago
@radagastthe3rd In the actual music, such changes occur, so I see no problem really in the pace.
BattiManZel 1 year ago
@radagastthe3rd : i agree. It should be slower a lil bit more interpreting and emotions.I didn't feel much hearing this playing. I don't think this is the best interpretation of the piece. yet she's still a great pianist, of course.
bachu247 1 year ago
Second time playing at 1:23 could be softer. It says so in the piece. Anyways good job that was great, but always could be better!
willysohn 1 year ago
Good playing, but she broke the unity of the music, as she did 3 pieces not 1.
grab1piece 1 year ago
My teacher just introduced this Waltz to me yesterday !!! I am so excited to start working through it.
DarthRC51rider 1 year ago
You play beautifull piano!
Thanks for sharing, I fall in love! ;-)
Kutnaampje 1 year ago
SOMEONE COUGHED! Someone had the nerve to cough during this beautiful performance!
thesexysithguy 1 year ago
Thank you! this is truly amazing. I like the tempo much more than the faster versions.
RainierWolcastle 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i'd tap that note ;]
iTzSLy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i'd tap that note ;]
iTzSLy 1 year ago
i'd tap that note ;]
iTzSLy 1 year ago
WoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooW
piano361 1 year ago
I love to see gorgeous songs played by gorgeous women. chopin is my favorite because he has pieces for every mood and he captures the moment perfectly. true genius but i would love to hear how chopin intended these pieces to be played. not saying it was bad but i dont think chopin would have played it that way. could be wrong cause it was pure beauty and maybe that is all he intended it to be.
ScabzNScarz 1 year ago
awesome !
hea93hea 1 year ago
ottima esecuzioneeeeeeeeeeee!
mariarosariavalente 1 year ago
That was wonderful.
InvaznGSC 1 year ago
im learning this for an audition...and my cousin plays it
juicyvids 1 year ago
wooow! makes me feel like a bug...:P
paliss06 1 year ago
wow! 1:38 - you play that part so well! Excellent!
lolalilolily1 1 year ago
I wanna play up on a stage one day! Like, at a pretty major event.. not a comp
044JohnnyDepp 1 year ago
beautiful.
and she has big hands
jgsky 2 years ago
@jgsky
Rachmaninoff had big hands!!!!!
sackwhacker 1 year ago
I love her gradual accel. and cres. she is so talented
anzelgirl 2 years ago
perfect. Thanks
iminlove1603 2 years ago
Thank you for this moment (from france) ^^
Japansae 2 years ago
this seems okay for my recital... ya. I just have some difficulties on phrasing a bit and some on dynamics but overall a very nice piece
xIcyCandyyx 2 years ago
Awesome !!!
ChrisFederico 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it should be a little faster
MsFantasticoll 2 years ago
no she didnt miss a note, just played really quiet
but she failed at 3:29
Reminderue 2 years ago
10+++.
kulisicd 2 years ago
did she miss some notes at 1:15?
nimm2999 2 years ago
สู้เค้า...น้องหมวย
KrabiCreation1 2 years ago
Amazing, amazing amazing.
I really Love it
xkuruma 2 years ago
*___*
Abbombissima 2 years ago
EXACT SPEED !!! THANK GOD !!! someone knows what they are doing..:)) needs more work on phrasing.....and slowing and speeding should be smoother... :)) but beautiful !
kumral76 2 years ago
beautiful!
oritzv 2 years ago 2
You give me inspiration to play this piece again thank you.
NodameSpecial 2 years ago
This is my favourite rendition of this piece on YouTube... really beautifully and gracefully played - thank you :)
richtw 2 years ago
this piece is around grade 7, i can play it and im grade 5. When I play it for my school music festival I will upload it.
Adampie2 2 years ago
@Adampie2 nice! i am playing it now but i'm not sure what grade i am :D :P :) good luck! i hope u make it with no mistakes it's hard...
siadion 1 year ago
wow can appreaciate it now looking at the key signatures and changes from sharps to flats!
bakerdude11 2 years ago
beautiful~
aznsecretluv 2 years ago
Comment removed
aznsecretluv 2 years ago
terrific. played how i would interpret it.
kuchikikamiya20 2 years ago
There is nothing to criticize about this performance. Flawless and beautiful!
JeremyxDuncan 2 years ago
Comment removed
AidaTosca 2 years ago
wow. you are absolutely amazing. this almost makes me wish i hadn't quit piano lessons back in 2nd grade. :'(
blauwmeansblue 2 years ago
Comment removed
AidaTosca 2 years ago
AWSOME!!!! im learing this for my contest song
holybladex10 2 years ago 8
@holybladex10 How did you get on in that contest? Any success?
Thesixthgoon 1 year ago
I love the varying pedalling styles and the contrast they make! bravo.
bryanvdk 2 years ago
yea, that's hella a pedalling...
Eyunbin 2 years ago
GOOD!!
nat4zk 2 years ago
in the beginning on the double notes, you drag a bit too much other then that bravo!
BrazillianKid 2 years ago
Excellent rubato and stunning clarity. Good job!
bestfriendsforeva 2 years ago 13
Thanks, Angela.
AidaTosca 2 years ago
@bestfriendsforeva I agree that she maintained stunning clarity but with rubato I'm not so sure. The piece is meant to be 'Giusto' which means it has to be strict in tempo. It's only a personal opinion but I think it could've been so much better without or with very careful rubato.
icarushjyoon 1 year ago
Comment removed
icarushjyoon 1 year ago
Beautiful. I tried to download it but I couldn't. Where can I get it? I live in Iceland so I cannot access the iTunes store. :(
arnagun 2 years ago
pm me. maybe i can teach you how
katashiro1028 2 years ago
Thanks, arnagun. I haven't marketed this clip for sale, so I don't believe you'll find it on iTunes.
AidaTosca 2 years ago
Surprisingly good... just a bit mechanical in the end part, but good tempo and dynamics.. /me likes.
Widiar 2 years ago
Excellent job! Very nice tempo and dynamics. Nice hand positioning and very smooth and easy style. The piece just seemed to flow off your finger tips..
czbbcl 3 years ago
Comment removed
AidaTosca 3 years ago
Thank you for the lovely compliment!
AidaTosca 3 years ago
very nice!
mingtzuchao123 3 years ago
Excellent! Superb drive to the tempo and rhythm. Don
prodad5 3 years ago
Thanks, Don!
AidaTosca 3 years ago
Comment removed
AidaTosca 3 years ago
Comment removed
AidaTosca 3 years ago
jaw dropped...
xdebugger 3 years ago
elegant a bit lifeless...still nice
7805mimo 3 years ago
I like, she have a elegant style.
DDGStrobilo 3 years ago
very good recording
GEARS7981 3 years ago
very good performance~!
MozartAppreciator 3 years ago
nice.
very good recording.
KirliaGirl 3 years ago