They are both good...but it is prety obvious that tons of their ideas for like....everything....are based off of Amy Lee, whether it's intentional or not...they should try to do something to separate themselves a bit more....not to mention I think her first album or one of them is called Fallen....We Are The Fallen...hhmmm
@Jesuschick22 They did base the band name we are the fallen from the album Fallen lol. It's no coicidence lol. I agree Evanescence is way way better, but We are the Fallen are still very good. I do think they should try to make their style, and try to build a new reputation instead of living up to Evanescence old music.
@Jesuschick22 Oooohhh lol well that makes sense then XD yes I agree, they should go their own way...they are kinda like the little sister who tries to dress like their teenage sister....no bueno XD
If somebody asked me this question: which one do you like Amy or Carly? I would say: well, I don't wanna be offensive at anyone but, one of them BROUGHT ME TO LIFE, I learned what a TOURNIQUET was, showed me not to be anybody or EVERYBODYS FOOL... and that is it
We Are The Fallen suck!!!. A "metal" band with a vocalist from American Idol who previously released a pop album? Seriously? Amy Lee can eat her for breakfast anytime
@Jothike They ARE Evanescence minus Amy. Amy was 25% of the original Ev, IF THAT. These guys are ALL of the original members. A. Lee is just a glorified solo artist now and the Evanescence name means nothing anymore.
@gorboy Lol I listened to the new Evanescence album and it dissapointed me..and well..WATF is now more Evanescence then Evanescence now is..I don't like their new sound
Amy Lee. duh. We are the Nobodies even has three old Evanesence band members. Clearly, it was no 'accident' that they 'just happen' to sound EXACTLY like Evanesence. No originality means you SUCK.
I don't really do the commenting thing...Just wanted to say...I think Ben Moody has every right to use a song he helped to write in his new Band. As a musician that's sort of his material as well. I'm not saying the other girls voice suits the song better than Amy...I'm a huge Evanescence fan. I took the time to listen to a few of their tracks...and they don't really sound like the old Evanescence, either. They have their own thing going, they just look similar...
@hassan0rocker Of course that's your opinion and we seem to agree to disagree. In my opinion, Evanescence is and will always be ten times better than We Are The Fallen. Although don't get me wrong. We Are The Fallen have wonderful songs, but I have always been and will always be a fan of Evanescence.
fuck! if carly was an individual artist or start her own damn band instead w/ ex ev members i think i would've of liked her more. Anyways clearly its AMY LEE FTW! and that's a fucking #FACT
in the words of Charlie Sheen "AMY LEE" = "WINNER"
Neither of them Lip Sync idiots. If Carly couldn't sing then she would have NEVER been in American Idol. I love both singers. There is a distinct difference. Both sound good. Amy's is more feminine but both have very strong vocals. BUT... I do have to say.. Amy's live voice is NEVER on par with her Studio voice. Carly sounds just like her Studio voice when she sings live. They're both great singers. Stop being stupid and just enjoy the damn music.
It's so freaking retarded that you are even comparing the two when clearly Carly whatever cannot be compared to the goddess Amy Lee.It doesn't take a genius to see that she is clearly trying to copy Amy,when she claims she's not but sings their songs o_0..To put it simply We are the Nobody is simply failed attempt to Evanescence..I suggest you find your own style instead of coping Amy's style and music.
@loveisgreat41 We are the Fallen IS Evanescence minus Amy. The only diff people are Carly and Marty. The other 3 members are from Ev. It's expected that We are the Fallen does Evanescence music, Ben helped write songs on Fallen. Carly doesn't sound much like Amy. She sounds more like Cristina Scabbia. Quit your bitching about it. It's not worth your time. If you have a problem with them, stay away from the music. It's really good. You people are just too blinded by your hatred to see that.
Amy Lee tiene una voz hermosa mientras carly (sin ofender a nadie) simplemente es una copia barata de Amy (a como yo lo veo) y es lo qe Ben qeria pero es qe no hay comparación Amy en cualquier momento barre, trapea, encera etc etc el piso con Carly y la verdad me gusta we are the fallen por qe Carly tambien tiene lo sullo pero Amy tiene mas
I wish people would stop comparing these two bands! They both make great, deep music, and expand my musical library beyond shit about sex and drugs and night clubs.
Amy is better. I like both, but I like Amy a tad bit better. Honestly, the voices don't even sound that much alike in this video. If you really wanted to compare them, you should have used We Are The Fallen - Bury Me Alive. She sounds most like Amy in THAT song.
essa mulhe dessa banda we are the fallen q eu nen sei o nome dela,só faz sucesso por causa da amy...ela deve agradece amy pelo evanescence pq se o nome dela ainda é msm q pouco conhecido é por causa do evanescnce
Honestly I really don't like Carleys voice at all. If you accually listed it sounds very nasaly and gross. Amys is like an angel and Carley could never get her voice like that even how hard Carley trys to copy Amy
i honestly think carly is the better singer of the two!
dont get me wrong ive been in love with evanescence since 2003 and i was 5 then they have ever since been my favorite band but honestly carly is an amzing vocalist but amy is more versatile when it comes to music! she does more then just sing and her songs are harder to sing
i know thats so impossible but i wont it sooo much! A DUET FROM CARLY AND AMY with the lyrics was written by ben moody! i know manny people say ARE U STUPID but think over it. i think it will be the best song.
and i wont the old evanescence back :'( the new is not bad but not the real evanescence :'( DAMN THIS SUCKS why goes the best singer in the world into a diffrent way (sorry for bad english i am from german :D)
la comparación estupida, pusieron el mejor sonido a Amy y a la otro se escuchaba toda interferida y engorrosa, ambas tienen su talento, pero canta mejor Carly, tiene mas tecnica
Damn! How can people compare the QUEEN amy <3 With Carly! -.-" Amy aaaaaall the way <3 Amy does a G5 and in the new album at made of stone even higher!!!! ( Were she sais: I will still remember, when you've long, forgotten me )
Carly doesn't just sound like amy, and look a little like Amy, she looks ALOT like Amy. The same raven black hair, porcelain skin, and ice blue eyes. She even DRESSES like Amy Lee. Watch We Are The Fallen Bury Me Alive. Carly's flowing black gothic fairy gown is similar to clothes that Amy wears. Hell, Carly even copies Amy's body language.
Are people seriously gonna believe that Carly is supposed to be original?
NÃO SE COMPARA AMY COM ESAA CARLY AMY É MUITO MELHOR NA VOZ ALÉM DE QUE É MUITO MAIS BONITA QUE ESSA CARLY AÍ ELA NÃO CHEGA NEM AS UNHAS DOS PÉS DA AMY HAHAHAHAHAA
There is no comparison hands down amy lee vocals are better than carlys.Amy has power and range in her vocals carly cant hold a candle to her her vocals arent rele that good rele weak
both great in there own right,,however, i have yet to here carly's voice crack like amy's has..i think carly is more controlled in live consert performances and amy sounds better in the studio performances where she can take a break before each song
@eternalsilverlight lol yeah evryones voice cracks after a while and she doent fuck with her voice on the computer unlike the fake mockery bands like we are the fallen
@eternalsilverlight sorry if I intrude, but Amy is amazing, I think carly is only a rough draft even if the voice is not too bad, but looks like a copy
@eternalsilverlight Her songs are very difficult, and doing all those in a row can hurt the vocal cords. Don't blame her. Her talent is way better. <3
@foreverecsence not to mention that amy lee sings live with her actual voice and doesnt lipsync there for you can actually hear any imperfections in a voice live instead of listening to a track thats been fixed by autotune, something amy lee also doesnt use..
I hope they make a song together, just to shut up all the haters. They are TWO, count it, TWO different people, with TWO, again, TWO different voices!!!! STOP COMPARING THEM! GEEEEEEZ!!!!
@jctcmc59 Here's a fun fact: Both win because both have their own successful bands and their own good qualities. Any implication of contests is just immature divisive bullshit on your part.
FIRST OFF, Carly and Amy are both very very very very very talented. It's not fair that people keep bashing both of them, and another thing I'd like to say : Can't We Are The Fallen do covers? my gosh.. And plus, Amy didn't write ALL of Evanescence's songs. Just be happy that they aren't singing shit, right? I don't favor one over the other because they both have strengths and weaknesses. So to everyone, please calm your shit down and stop hating.
Amy is WAY so much better. Carly has the voice of a pop singer trying to sing rock, while Amy IS rock. Amy has the energy, you can hear the diference between her notes, while Carly, to me, is singing the same over and over again...no offence to her, but there's no comparision. Amy lee wins!!!
@Yereri Pop? Meh, have you actually LISTENED to Carly? Rock suits her better. And I agree that Amy does a better range of notes as she sings, but have you heard her live? Carly too has that... "energy" you speak of and in front of a live crowd she really delivers. No doubt about it. People are just pissed because Evanescence is going a different direction and WATF is that same sound that we remember from the Original Evanescence.
@paris101nicole well basically your trying to make we are the fallen look like a bunch of copy cats when there not and its stupid and annoying i mean i love evanescence and i love this band and you don't see me typing stupid shit trying to make we are the fallen look bad thank you and goodnight
@paris101nicole Um, see this is what pisses me off the most. People like you actually THINK that Carly's trying to be like Amy. Well guess what! Ben named the band. Carly's only there because she had the opportunity to SING, which she is AMAZING at. Ben and the band scooped her up because she is a GREAT SINGER. And the outfits, make up and hairdos are only because every other female in a rock band has the same setup! Try to find a rock band with a female lead WITHOUT heavy make up and black hair
@paris101nicole And I said what I feel. I never said you didn't have the right to freedom of speech. I value your opinion even though it pisses me off. I just wish people would actually LISTEN to the music and not compare/judge them based on their similarities. It bothers me. Ijs.
Smithson is copying Amy ) i like to listen to new rock / metal bands .. but i hate copycats and We are the fallen are definitely copying Evanescence. Ben Moody left Evanescence because of creative differences with Amy Lee. And now it looks like he created his own "Evanescence" where no one can "suffocate his creative genius".. lol ...so sad .. anyway .. Amy rocks !!!!! <3
ok they 2 have a good vocal but AMY LEE Wins absolutely look at my name i'm a Evanescence lover abd i realy dislike wen i knew Carly sings Going Under >:( if i don't like Carly is my opinion Amy lee forever you are he best for me :D
@AddictedtoKaitlin77 Good lord... you clearly are not a fan... there is a line in Like You where Amy sings "I long to be like you sis... lie cold in the ground like you." Both songs are about Bonnie. and that wasnt their first album. they had EP's out way before they even got famous.
amy lee's voice is better, although carly's voice is good also, but there is one big difference, amy lee is 100000x times more pretty and cant be compared with that ugly faced carly.
Literally Amy Lee is soooooooooooooooooooo MUCH BETTER THAN Carly....:PP Carly has a nice voice but you can't just compare her to AMY..i mean its AMY LEE..for GOD'S SAKE!!! The beautiful low note in "Your Star" (in the beginning to the really long note in "Bring me to life" (at the end)...AMY is AWESOME AND TO ME Carly is just a singer...and AMY is a ROCK AND METAL QUEEN...:D
They are both good...but it is prety obvious that tons of their ideas for like....everything....are based off of Amy Lee, whether it's intentional or not...they should try to do something to separate themselves a bit more....not to mention I think her first album or one of them is called Fallen....We Are The Fallen...hhmmm
Jesuschick22 1 week ago
@Jesuschick22 They did base the band name we are the fallen from the album Fallen lol. It's no coicidence lol. I agree Evanescence is way way better, but We are the Fallen are still very good. I do think they should try to make their style, and try to build a new reputation instead of living up to Evanescence old music.
1993btvs 1 week ago
@Jesuschick22 Oooohhh lol well that makes sense then XD yes I agree, they should go their own way...they are kinda like the little sister who tries to dress like their teenage sister....no bueno XD
Jesuschick22 1 week ago
If somebody asked me this question: which one do you like Amy or Carly? I would say: well, I don't wanna be offensive at anyone but, one of them BROUGHT ME TO LIFE, I learned what a TOURNIQUET was, showed me not to be anybody or EVERYBODYS FOOL... and that is it
Athena8823 1 week ago
People that think that Amy is the best singer ever... you should think again about it. Honestly, another female singers are better.
I like both of them, but i don't think they are the better singers of the world...
TheGothicBrokenDoll 2 weeks ago
Oh look...they sound similar..big deal.
anonymousdelilah 2 weeks ago
I prefer my wife, she's the third lol
FromAgen 2 weeks ago
amy what?????????? falso aprende a apreciar a las buenas cantantes WTF!!!!!!!!!!
zerocool867 2 weeks ago
They're both great singers and shouldn't be compared.
Guedea400 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you know, everyone will say amy is better. because she have more fans. can someone be just impartial? :\
anajoyceescorcio 2 weeks ago
Is it a crime to like both? You guys are pathetic.
dblubarry 3 weeks ago
WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATTTT!!!!
amy lee have a higher notes than this :\
oliver1376 3 weeks ago
We Are The Fallen suck!!!. A "metal" band with a vocalist from American Idol who previously released a pop album? Seriously? Amy Lee can eat her for breakfast anytime
MrGothicvampire 3 weeks ago
how can u even compare these two?! amy is amazing compared to tht scrubber. Evanecence forever! <3
ir0ckdudes 1 month ago
No hay punto de comparación OK. Fin Amy Lee FOREVA
GrisProw 1 month ago
Amy ftw
WATF is just a rip off...
Carly can sing very well..but I just not like the fact that they deny
that they nog 'inspired' by Evanescence
Jothike 1 month ago
@Jothike They ARE Evanescence minus Amy. Amy was 25% of the original Ev, IF THAT. These guys are ALL of the original members. A. Lee is just a glorified solo artist now and the Evanescence name means nothing anymore.
gorboy 1 month ago
@gorboy How can you say that???
yinyangirl364 1 month ago
@yinyangirl364 Because it is the truth.
gorboy 1 month ago
@gorboy Evanescence IS Amy Lee
MrGothicvampire 3 weeks ago
@gorboy Lol I listened to the new Evanescence album and it dissapointed me..and well..WATF is now more Evanescence then Evanescence now is..I don't like their new sound
Jothike 2 weeks ago
Amy Lee. duh. We are the Nobodies even has three old Evanesence band members. Clearly, it was no 'accident' that they 'just happen' to sound EXACTLY like Evanesence. No originality means you SUCK.
n3rd0usSh4y 1 month ago 2
Amy Lee no question
Evanescence7654 1 month ago 2
I don't really do the commenting thing...Just wanted to say...I think Ben Moody has every right to use a song he helped to write in his new Band. As a musician that's sort of his material as well. I'm not saying the other girls voice suits the song better than Amy...I'm a huge Evanescence fan. I took the time to listen to a few of their tracks...and they don't really sound like the old Evanescence, either. They have their own thing going, they just look similar...
Lyssabee420 1 month ago
it's fucking damn when listen carly and i had listened amy .
amy on summit
carly train to be on half summit
amy is best singer in our planet
fatoli99 1 month ago 13
makes me wonder what would happen if later down the line if bands decided to tour together what the fans of either side would think.
would they be for it or against it
just throwing this out there but I happen to like both singers
Pixiebabe 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3 EVANESCENCE <3
mstahtr394 1 month ago
AMY LEE
mstahtr394 1 month ago
Amy lee tutta la vita <3
MsFantasyEmo 1 month ago 2
They're both very talented!!!
Zundwig 1 month ago
Amy lee is an angel and a goddess so who ever tries to copy her will obviously go to hell. The end.
somebodycares16 1 month ago
@loveisgreat41 i agreeeeeee.. omg.. Amy is much better..
Carly tries to copy Amy ..LOL.. and we know that..!
AvriLomaniaa 1 month ago 2
Amy Lee OF COURSEEEEEEEE <3
AvriLomaniaa 1 month ago
Amy Lee
dabananaking09 1 month ago
Carly of course, her voice is beautiful, i dont saying that amy dont, but she is a lil bit squeacky....
r0saura091 1 month ago
Carly is much better live, Amy isn't as good without the band, Carly is a star, don't talk shit.
chuckfinley1104 1 month ago
i think the both are good, but amy is better than carly in studio and carly is than amy better in live. that's all.
anajoyceescorcio 1 month ago
Carly. Amy has better sound quality in her clips, but Carly hit that F#5 with SO much more power and clarity. Sorry, Evanescence fans.
athousandstrats 1 month ago 2
They both have wonderful voices, but Amy's is stronger and louder, and Carly fails to live up to that.
Amy Lee FTW!
And just to be nice, love you too Carly :)
3
fuzzyboots38 1 month ago
AMY LEE
castor10polo 2 months ago
I create an email count to insult carly "LOOOOOOOSER" thats all...
natievans911 2 months ago
I think they're both wonderful, although Amy Lee is honestly five times better.
Twilightfey 2 months ago
@Twilightfey here we are again xD, I agree about what u said, but comparing the whole both bands, WRTF r much better than the new Evanescnece !
hassan0rocker 1 month ago
@hassan0rocker Of course that's your opinion and we seem to agree to disagree. In my opinion, Evanescence is and will always be ten times better than We Are The Fallen. Although don't get me wrong. We Are The Fallen have wonderful songs, but I have always been and will always be a fan of Evanescence.
Twilightfey 1 month ago
CARLY!!!!!!!!
Amy's voice is just louder, so It sounds better, but i think Carly's better :)
souleaterhana 2 months ago
Amy Lee sounds much better
Let's be honest and Carly sounds good but her voice is not so powerfull as Amy Lee's voice
VatavucristiaN95 2 months ago
amy lee
davidcuban2010 2 months ago
AMY ! AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY !!! \m/
twilightfan24eb 2 months ago
Sorry ppl i vote Carly!!!!!
bvbarmyforeva 2 months ago
fuck! if carly was an individual artist or start her own damn band instead w/ ex ev members i think i would've of liked her more. Anyways clearly its AMY LEE FTW! and that's a fucking #FACT
in the words of Charlie Sheen "AMY LEE" = "WINNER"
ustinkize 2 months ago 2
AMY LEE IS BEST SINGER !!
Denissa775 2 months ago
Neither of them Lip Sync idiots. If Carly couldn't sing then she would have NEVER been in American Idol. I love both singers. There is a distinct difference. Both sound good. Amy's is more feminine but both have very strong vocals. BUT... I do have to say.. Amy's live voice is NEVER on par with her Studio voice. Carly sounds just like her Studio voice when she sings live. They're both great singers. Stop being stupid and just enjoy the damn music.
Sevrion 2 months ago
Amy Lee -3
LINKINxSartan65 2 months ago
Amy Lee is a PERFECT !!!!!!!!!!
giuliaRasengan 2 months ago
AMY LEE NO CONTEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
amyfan9811 2 months ago
AMY LEE
rockeriitahtellez 2 months ago
Amy Lee all the way!!!!!!! Nobody can hold a candle to Amy.
1864vampirelover 2 months ago
amy lee!
jumanabeth 2 months ago
It's so freaking retarded that you are even comparing the two when clearly Carly whatever cannot be compared to the goddess Amy Lee.It doesn't take a genius to see that she is clearly trying to copy Amy,when she claims she's not but sings their songs o_0..To put it simply We are the Nobody is simply failed attempt to Evanescence..I suggest you find your own style instead of coping Amy's style and music.
loveisgreat41 2 months ago 21
@loveisgreat41 OMG I CANNOT AGREE MORE!!!!!!!!!! thank you!
amyfan9811 2 months ago
@loveisgreat41 I fully agree
giuliaRasengan 2 months ago
@loveisgreat41 if i sing both of their songs does that make me a wannabe? O_o
person30355 1 month ago
@loveisgreat41 hey can you tell me what happend with the bands? 2 or 3 members of Evanescence left to start a new band?why?
evanescence3lithium 1 month ago
@loveisgreat41 We are the Fallen IS Evanescence minus Amy. The only diff people are Carly and Marty. The other 3 members are from Ev. It's expected that We are the Fallen does Evanescence music, Ben helped write songs on Fallen. Carly doesn't sound much like Amy. She sounds more like Cristina Scabbia. Quit your bitching about it. It's not worth your time. If you have a problem with them, stay away from the music. It's really good. You people are just too blinded by your hatred to see that.
rewindingmyemotions 1 month ago
they say that impersonation is a form of flattery , what female entertainer (singer) would not want to be compared to amy lee !
tunesmith2012 2 months ago
Amy Lee tiene una voz hermosa mientras carly (sin ofender a nadie) simplemente es una copia barata de Amy (a como yo lo veo) y es lo qe Ben qeria pero es qe no hay comparación Amy en cualquier momento barre, trapea, encera etc etc el piso con Carly y la verdad me gusta we are the fallen por qe Carly tambien tiene lo sullo pero Amy tiene mas
Nephtala 2 months ago
I wish people would stop comparing these two bands! They both make great, deep music, and expand my musical library beyond shit about sex and drugs and night clubs.
crazyspacechick 2 months ago
carly is fucked up but amy lee is the queen of the rock
xXblackflowerXx1 2 months ago
Amy is better. I like both, but I like Amy a tad bit better. Honestly, the voices don't even sound that much alike in this video. If you really wanted to compare them, you should have used We Are The Fallen - Bury Me Alive. She sounds most like Amy in THAT song.
emmygirlx96 2 months ago
essa mulhe dessa banda we are the fallen q eu nen sei o nome dela,só faz sucesso por causa da amy...ela deve agradece amy pelo evanescence pq se o nome dela ainda é msm q pouco conhecido é por causa do evanescnce
bruna21914 2 months ago
amy lee la mejor :)
dimevishuu 2 months ago
Amy <3
WujekLupinio 2 months ago
Amy Lee is better by far.. Carly sucks.
emiliexenigma 2 months ago
okay they're both amazing singers, but i must say i like carly more because i find it breath taking. amy lee you're good, carly YOURE AMAZING!:D
Sarablackballod 2 months ago
Amy te amooo
mateusfreitasdasilva 2 months ago
Honestly I really don't like Carleys voice at all. If you accually listed it sounds very nasaly and gross. Amys is like an angel and Carley could never get her voice like that even how hard Carley trys to copy Amy
XxmottobnfeebsxX 3 months ago
AMYYY its a nicer voice too :)
MrNicole2894 3 months ago
100% AMY LEE!!!! SHEIS THE BEST
CARLY IS JUST A STUPID UGLY WANNABE
friendlymargate 3 months ago
AMY LEE!
nattywoo86 3 months ago
No hesitation. AMY LEE
funkyfranx 3 months ago
la voz de amy tiene un brillo que la otra boluda ni ahi va a comparar..
MyEmiita 3 months ago
amy lee!!!!!!
bestfriendsmom1 3 months ago
i honestly think carly is the better singer of the two!
dont get me wrong ive been in love with evanescence since 2003 and i was 5 then they have ever since been my favorite band but honestly carly is an amzing vocalist but amy is more versatile when it comes to music! she does more then just sing and her songs are harder to sing
aaronbenvenuti14 3 months ago
@aaronbenvenuti14 Amys songs are harder to sing means that she is the better vocolist.
wilros2277 3 months ago
TEAM AMY!
Zerofuze100 3 months ago
amy lee hands down
jctcmc59 3 months ago
Amyy
Musicloverr188 3 months ago
Carly!!!
JunaMess 3 months ago
amy's ex is such a fucking loser, he just needs to die already!
wussboyd 3 months ago
Amy Lee Perfect 4Ever !!!
DaniLindh 3 months ago
AMY LEE LA A OWNEADO *_*
Saeko316 3 months ago
@AddictedtoKaitlin77 Both were actually.
Hollenvaen 3 months ago
AMY LEE
Tswiftismyidol1 3 months ago 32
@Tswiftismyidol1 Amy Lee
calicowoman1 1 month ago
Amy, Carly sounds to much like Amy.
NewDivded 3 months ago
amy doesn't have to try to be good she just is naturally and carly pushes too damn hard to try to be good. you can tell how she strains her voice.
jedythin 3 months ago
surely Amy ;) but Carly is good singer too :)
dzeva5678 3 months ago
Amy Lee!!!
BlackVeilBdarkfan 3 months ago
i know thats so impossible but i wont it sooo much! A DUET FROM CARLY AND AMY with the lyrics was written by ben moody! i know manny people say ARE U STUPID but think over it. i think it will be the best song.
and i wont the old evanescence back :'( the new is not bad but not the real evanescence :'( DAMN THIS SUCKS why goes the best singer in the world into a diffrent way (sorry for bad english i am from german :D)
700mathias 4 months ago
la comparación estupida, pusieron el mejor sonido a Amy y a la otro se escuchaba toda interferida y engorrosa, ambas tienen su talento, pero canta mejor Carly, tiene mas tecnica
MomentoEterno 4 months ago
i love amy and she are the best....carly never gona be good as amy
mandabirra 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@AddictedtoKaitlin77 like you was also made for her sister
zackysynyster14 4 months ago
What song did carly do at eb5?
evana7x105 4 months ago
Damn! How can people compare the QUEEN amy <3 With Carly! -.-" Amy aaaaaall the way <3 Amy does a G5 and in the new album at made of stone even higher!!!! ( Were she sais: I will still remember, when you've long, forgotten me )
pano0lis1990 4 months ago
Amy Lee does a G5 in Sweet Sacrifice (in the bit where she says "all the time.") Just saying. Beat that Carly. XD
andthemushrooms123 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Carly doesn't just sound like amy, and look a little like Amy, she looks ALOT like Amy. The same raven black hair, porcelain skin, and ice blue eyes. She even DRESSES like Amy Lee. Watch We Are The Fallen Bury Me Alive. Carly's flowing black gothic fairy gown is similar to clothes that Amy wears. Hell, Carly even copies Amy's body language.
Are people seriously gonna believe that Carly is supposed to be original?
REIREI29 4 months ago
i think amy is a bit better
but carly is awesome too
MrLoggfreak 4 months ago
AMYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
Emotionsthatrun 4 months ago
Amyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy é a mais foda
TheTritoxx 4 months ago
NÃO SE COMPARA AMY COM ESAA CARLY AMY É MUITO MELHOR NA VOZ ALÉM DE QUE É MUITO MAIS BONITA QUE ESSA CARLY AÍ ELA NÃO CHEGA NEM AS UNHAS DOS PÉS DA AMY HAHAHAHAHAA
TheEloyra 4 months ago
Comment removed
TheEloyra 4 months ago
There is no comparison hands down amy lee vocals are better than carlys.Amy has power and range in her vocals carly cant hold a candle to her her vocals arent rele that good rele weak
MrRabbit3699 4 months ago 2
They're both good in their own ways. Stop comparing them to each other when they're two completely different singers.
boundemotion 4 months ago
The Best amy lee I lOve voice is so much better than carly
an43719 4 months ago
both great in there own right,,however, i have yet to here carly's voice crack like amy's has..i think carly is more controlled in live consert performances and amy sounds better in the studio performances where she can take a break before each song
foreverecsence 4 months ago 4
@foreverecsence Actually Amy's voice cracks mostly because her songs requiere a bit more effort and her set list is much longer.
eternalsilverlight 4 months ago 18
@eternalsilverlight lol yeah evryones voice cracks after a while and she doent fuck with her voice on the computer unlike the fake mockery bands like we are the fallen
SufferTheConsequenc3 3 months ago
@eternalsilverlight
Totally agree. And where as in a live concert Carly stands next to the microphone flicking her hair, Amy Lee runs around the stage, head banging.
funkyfranx 3 months ago
@eternalsilverlight sorry if I intrude, but Amy is amazing, I think carly is only a rough draft even if the voice is not too bad, but looks like a copy
94ermi 2 months ago
@eternalsilverlight Her songs are very difficult, and doing all those in a row can hurt the vocal cords. Don't blame her. Her talent is way better. <3
Katclub8 2 months ago
@foreverecsence @eternalsilverlight
And let's not forget Amy runs around, head banging, while Carley just stands there.
funkyfranx 2 months ago in playlist Amy Lee
@foreverecsence not to mention that amy lee sings live with her actual voice and doesnt lipsync there for you can actually hear any imperfections in a voice live instead of listening to a track thats been fixed by autotune, something amy lee also doesnt use..
amyfan9811 2 months ago
Amy lee 100% EVANESCENCE FTW!!!
Mrgabi1239 4 months ago
It would please me to see this two persons sing a duet. Wouldn´t that be good?:)
ShugoCindy 4 months ago
Amy forever the best
dalia42 4 months ago
Amy lee... oyeaaaaaa... ruless.... amazing oyea..... 1000%.... la otra tipa canta feo xD
leiru55 4 months ago
I think Carly is amazing as her own person and deserves a shot without being compared to Amy. Their BOTH awesome but for different reasons.
Robin86 4 months ago
Carly
karakasize 4 months ago
Amy Lee and Carly Smithson should duet on a song...
HeyItsBalorei1 4 months ago
Amy Lee is obviously better, it will always be. His voice is a thousand times better... Fact! ;x
MiwakoBabyjaps 5 months ago
EMY LEEEEEE!!!!
elithaygabriel 5 months ago
I hope they make a song together, just to shut up all the haters. They are TWO, count it, TWO different people, with TWO, again, TWO different voices!!!! STOP COMPARING THEM! GEEEEEEZ!!!!
iSmile7568 5 months ago
Amy wins this hands down,,no contest
jctcmc59 6 months ago
@jctcmc59 Here's a fun fact: Both win because both have their own successful bands and their own good qualities. Any implication of contests is just immature divisive bullshit on your part.
Ygdrasel 5 months ago
FIRST OFF, Carly and Amy are both very very very very very talented. It's not fair that people keep bashing both of them, and another thing I'd like to say : Can't We Are The Fallen do covers? my gosh.. And plus, Amy didn't write ALL of Evanescence's songs. Just be happy that they aren't singing shit, right? I don't favor one over the other because they both have strengths and weaknesses. So to everyone, please calm your shit down and stop hating.
ayeitsgrachelle 6 months ago
I'm sorry man, i like both bands but Amy Lee is a MUCH better singer
ReelMusicFreak 6 months ago
Amy is WAY so much better. Carly has the voice of a pop singer trying to sing rock, while Amy IS rock. Amy has the energy, you can hear the diference between her notes, while Carly, to me, is singing the same over and over again...no offence to her, but there's no comparision. Amy lee wins!!!
Yereri 6 months ago 2
@Yereri Pop? Meh, have you actually LISTENED to Carly? Rock suits her better. And I agree that Amy does a better range of notes as she sings, but have you heard her live? Carly too has that... "energy" you speak of and in front of a live crowd she really delivers. No doubt about it. People are just pissed because Evanescence is going a different direction and WATF is that same sound that we remember from the Original Evanescence.
ASoulSoTortured 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Get over it already!!!!
callmewhenursober100 6 months ago
Carly wanted to be like Amy, Evancesnse first ablum is Fallen, carlys band is we are the FALLEN, she's copying her :/
paris101nicole 6 months ago
@paris101nicole ok just because carly band name is we are the fallen doesn't mean anything get better evidence
WORMIE4456W 6 months ago
@WORMIE4456W Wow dont tell me what to do, and what does this have to do with you?
paris101nicole 6 months ago
@paris101nicole well basically your trying to make we are the fallen look like a bunch of copy cats when there not and its stupid and annoying i mean i love evanescence and i love this band and you don't see me typing stupid shit trying to make we are the fallen look bad thank you and goodnight
WORMIE4456W 6 months ago
@paris101nicole Um, see this is what pisses me off the most. People like you actually THINK that Carly's trying to be like Amy. Well guess what! Ben named the band. Carly's only there because she had the opportunity to SING, which she is AMAZING at. Ben and the band scooped her up because she is a GREAT SINGER. And the outfits, make up and hairdos are only because every other female in a rock band has the same setup! Try to find a rock band with a female lead WITHOUT heavy make up and black hair
ASoulSoTortured 5 months ago
@ASoulSoTortured I HAVE THE RIGHT TO FREEDOM OF SPEECH! Damn it, there is a comment box so people can say what they feel!
paris101nicole 5 months ago
@paris101nicole And I said what I feel. I never said you didn't have the right to freedom of speech. I value your opinion even though it pisses me off. I just wish people would actually LISTEN to the music and not compare/judge them based on their similarities. It bothers me. Ijs.
ASoulSoTortured 5 months ago
Smithson is copying Amy ) i like to listen to new rock / metal bands .. but i hate copycats and We are the fallen are definitely copying Evanescence. Ben Moody left Evanescence because of creative differences with Amy Lee. And now it looks like he created his own "Evanescence" where no one can "suffocate his creative genius".. lol ...so sad .. anyway .. Amy rocks !!!!! <3
collbary 6 months ago
ok they 2 have a good vocal but AMY LEE Wins absolutely look at my name i'm a Evanescence lover abd i realy dislike wen i knew Carly sings Going Under >:( if i don't like Carly is my opinion Amy lee forever you are he best for me :D
EvanescenceDarkAngel 6 months ago
@AddictedtoKaitlin77 Good lord... you clearly are not a fan... there is a line in Like You where Amy sings "I long to be like you sis... lie cold in the ground like you." Both songs are about Bonnie. and that wasnt their first album. they had EP's out way before they even got famous.
Sevrion 6 months ago
amy lee is the BEST singer !
kuku3520 6 months ago
and besides carly has a deep toned voice, it just doesnt work..
BiotSavat 6 months ago
amy lee's voice is better, although carly's voice is good also, but there is one big difference, amy lee is 100000x times more pretty and cant be compared with that ugly faced carly.
BiotSavat 6 months ago
Literally Amy Lee is soooooooooooooooooooo MUCH BETTER THAN Carly....:PP Carly has a nice voice but you can't just compare her to AMY..i mean its AMY LEE..for GOD'S SAKE!!! The beautiful low note in "Your Star" (in the beginning to the really long note in "Bring me to life" (at the end)...AMY is AWESOME AND TO ME Carly is just a singer...and AMY is a ROCK AND METAL QUEEN...:D
27roxxx 6 months ago 36
@27roxxx totally agree.... well tat amy is betta singer........ Dx
DemonAngel5678 6 months ago
@27roxxx Amy Lee is not, has never been, and can never be a metal queen because what she does is not now nor has it ever been metal.
Ygdrasel 5 months ago
@Ygdrasel Amy Lee is passionate about her Music it dosn't matter what type of instsruments play by her side ;). Get over it.
theCOOKIEhehe 5 months ago
@theCOOKIEhehe
Lee is not passionate about her music because she has no music. She's a singer.
And if the instruments didn't matter, every musical artist would be acapella...And they're not.
But your ignorant remarks aside, the fact still remains she's about as metal as Flubber.
Ygdrasel 5 months ago
@Ygdrasel Whatever just leave your bad comments about evanescence at the door, ok? Build a bridge and GET THE HECK OVER IT.
theCOOKIEhehe 5 months ago
@theCOOKIEhehe I never said any bad comments, you moron. I stated a FACT that they are not a part of the metal genre.
Ygdrasel 5 months ago
carly is screaming!! why??? amy lee just singing!!!
ellierocker94 7 months ago 2
@AddictedtoKaitlin77 "Like you" was written for her sister aswell.
eternalsilverlight 7 months ago 15
Carly sounds like she does country rock kinda music
vexion15 7 months ago 2
now thats just SHITTY! amy wrote like you in honor of her dead sis and for carly to rip off that it's just beyond word!!
Alysin123 7 months ago 4
@Alysin123 What the hell do you speak of?
eternalsilverlight 7 months ago
@eternalsilverlight like you by evanescence
Alysin123 7 months ago
@eternalsilverlight
the song HELLO!!
therex4xu 7 months ago
@Alysin123 Carly did not Rip off "like you"
eternalsilverlight 7 months ago
@eternalsilverlight sounds like it to me...
Alysin123 7 months ago
@Alysin123 What? How did she rip it off? She didn't at all.
Hollenvaen 3 months ago
Amy Lee, Fue, es y sera La MEJOR DE TODAS.- Te amamos Amy Lee. Ademas esa carly no canta! .__.!
777Kamii 7 months ago
Carly sounds like a pile of screetching half dead cats.
Zaxxen69 8 months ago 2
I actually can't decide for female vocalists I worship them *-* they're both so god damn AMAZING!!! :D