Hilary duff-Beat of my heart (live)

[jojo01231]

some people really born to sing!

[whaatzuupp]

i miss you :'(

[Duffohil]

This performance is so great! Haha altough I've always said she looks wet xD

[KanonPk]

I Love You Hilary :(

Una lastima que ia te hayas casado = (

Pero igual que te vayya bien en Todo ;)

[cieratime389]

OMG THE DANCERS ARE HILARIOUS!

[SuperSweaterVest]

I really like Hilary, but her sister is talentless and has a big nose...Can you handle the truth? Sorry, hate to be the one to tell you but you're still okay.

[thegutisisters]

I MISS YOU.

[SuperSweaterVest]

There is something fascinating about this performance...A certain mystique...A certain je ne sais quoi?

[carlabow22]

U don't hear much of her these days

[jonasbieberfanlife]

@carlabow22 i know :( it is sad. i miss her sooo freakin much

[SweetlySammie]

the dancers look so gay.

[samanthabarbre]

I don't like it...

[sultan1122]

I love hilary, but this is not live. She must have recorded it earlier in the studio or something

[IloveHilaryandAshley]

OMG! She is so gorgeous! What a great role model! I LOVE that dress!!!

[daviddiabetik]

Totally live. The dancers look ridiculous though

[jaclynxox89]

i miss THIS hilary. =/

[Jridden2009]

what choreography!!!

[HilaryHils97]

i love hilary and the dancers are so funny

[cousintitanic]

thats some stupid looking dance rutin

[SiimplyJack]

excellent, has a beautiful voice live

the master is an excellent performer

I love it! and the strange singing!

HILARY want new album;)

[Almajhool2008]

look at her dancers looks like stupids

[sudoglover7]

this is live cause in the actually song her voice has this weird thing to her voice and it doesn't do that here...if you listen to the details in her voice from the actual track...

[ttttrent]

gosh, i love her! ♥

[supercarebear123]

she dosnt need crap u know all that recording\fixing crap she has a beautiful voice a true voice NOT like miley well i kindalke hertoo haha lol

[kevinwiesmann]

that isn`t live

[spricket06]

@kevinwiesmann yes it is!

[mstonyxD]

mm staba xevere el conciertazo.. ksmre..! gringos de mierda!

[mikaavila]

That's 2005!

[alexandre596]

she's awesome live =D

[allyproject]

what performance was this and what year? this HAS to be old because she looks younger.

[alexandre596]

I know it's on AMA - American Music Awards

but not the year =/

[sakuriinha]

fala sério, quem diz que a roupa dela e o cabelo estão feios... eu achei LINDO e pra mim não poderia estar melhor. os dançarinos, pqp muito bons. a banda tá ótima, a entrada dela foi super boa. essa foi uma ótima performace, e acho que está no top 3 dela :))

[alexandre596]

só os dançarinos que tavam estranhos =P

[sakuriinha]

sério? eu gostei muito dos dançarinos... pra mim foi o melhor da apresentação! achei a coreografia bem original. :D

[musicmaniacx9]

i agree with yahiie shes looks hott and shes growing up

[HugeFanOfBritney]

this is playback but pre-record ,still love her :)

[Coffeeholic82]

That dress is way to short. You can see her "taco". You'd think with all the money she earns, she'd get a brush or get a better hair stylist. That's just my opinion so, whatever. She sounds great though.

[Coffeeholic82]

She sounds really good but she looks like a slut in that lack of a dress. Sorry. She also looks really tired.

[yahiie]

she doesn't look like a slut, she looks hot.

[xothatgurlxo]

at 2:28 her voice doesn't go funny, that's how the song goes

[lukeBAM]

o soz. i dont rly listen to this song much so i didnt know.

[xothatgurlxo]

ooo i gotcha

[cloughproduction]

This is a really good live performance. You can clearly tell the differences between this and the produced record.

[kmit2805]

the best forever

[beyondtraces]

hilary's HILARious dancers, i think that's the point haha

[bencew]

Seriously, who cares about her voice when those dancers are so bloody hilarious? :D

[BreakingDishesz]

its fucking lipped. Why can't she just sing live? oh, i forgot she CANNOT sing.

[cudlees]

es una PORRRRRRRRRRRRQUERIA NISIQUIERA ESTA EN VIVO

[RoberthIsCALIBER]

YOU COULD TELL she's not LYPSYNCHING because 1:05 when she walks over the boys the volume llowers

[PadgeX]

I KNOW this is not lip-singing.

[spanish4ever]

she looks nervous because at that moment she was being seen by 60 million people more or less...anyway she's a godness and she did it great...and it was actually live, you can hear the difference in 1:05.

LOVE YA HILARY!!!

[jen79106]

i love hil

[angelloveable12]

OMG i love this song

[zitakuhn]

i think it's live..

[cartofu2001]

now that s live singing...she s grea!!!pretty great voice....ill put her to good singers.

[PrincessxStories]

You can tell she's not lip SYNCHING because it hasn't got the same...flow as it does in the videos where they edit and puff it all up. But she is singing with a backing track, as everyone does.

[ARTHXEM]

Es playback!!!

[Moyer0605]

Tu no escuchas muxo de Hilary Duff.. verdad?

Si la escuxaes a menudo notarias que es en directo

[nassrol]

LIVE

[sharonwillmann]

ily so much hilary but the bak up dancers r not that good the marching t hing was funny

[jonathanshadow13]

i <3 hilary!!!

[Viperaaaa]

She looks so sad and serious on every concert. Her songs are not bad, but she little squeal, when she sings ;) :P

[andrescastillo7]

I love you Hilary!! great live performance!!!!!!!

[ZackryHarry]

Dancers are gay. Marching is cool.

[mungin2]

WOW! Her voice is so beautiful!! ILY Nummer 1# FAN

[HsexygirlP]

:))) those dancers are soo funny...and she has a great voice i love her...this song is amazing ..Shes such an amazing singer live ...

[91princess92]

I remember seeing this!!

Shes such an amazing singer live

[halfwaytocliche]

Hilary really does need to sing live more, like here. Why is she hiding her great vocals with playbacks? She sounds awesome here, it's a great change.

[hilaryannduff22]

its her record company that tells her to lip sing

[LionsGoRawr92]

It's lip synch. Not lip sing.

And she's live here.

[hilaryannduff22]

actually its lip singing i work for a music company i would now and she singing along to a track and its no big deal all stars do it

[fknawsum]

yeah you guys she's not lipsynching, on her album she is more higher, and here she has a deeper voice and alittle like its more harsher, raspier, if that makes any sense.

[stemmlerd1]

that is obviously NOT lipsynching. that is clearly live. she is so amazing. i love her so much =]

[xocharley]

wow~! awesome performance & great voice ...sluty cyrus, foreheadnna & gagauilera should take note!

[ajotaArmando]

canta muy bien en vivo!!!!!

[rexvicdan]

canta tan bien en este video que ya hasta descargue el video y el audio lo converti en mp3 para cd esta padrisima la version ay si tienes dudas ps me escribes para que t explique como puedes hacer eso saludos

[mmon3y]

lol da backup dancers but u go hilary u can tell shes singin live n not lipsinging

[tamisueda]

Oh my God... The dancers are funny!

And she's obviously NOT lip syncing... Why do you guys care so much about it?!

[liznpollis]

wow she is actually singing live thats so awesome :)

[sidewaysizzy]

i agree u can tell she isnt lip singing and she is still awesome!

[laesyah]

wow, she is good....

[saugac03]

Wow she's good live... and no, she's not lipsynching

[c6h12o6glucose]

is she lip syncing? I don't have a problem with it, but I just can't tell for sure.

[fredburger97]

wow that is really amazing! hilary duff is the best and the dance is pretty cool since that they are all able to do everything at the exact same time

[fergieluvr101]

no shes not lipsyncing

u can tell in the beginning

[LuvinpinkXX]

wicked.xx

[Bethanlovesjonasbros]

I just Love this song...Its Awesome! Its got such a great and catchy kinda rhythm. LOVE IT! x Add me as a friend and suscribe if you like Hilary duff?!?! xx

[Pegometres]

me encanta!! viva hilary!!

[kmit2805]

hilary the best forever i loveeeeeeee

[flx16]

she was sooo nervous... 2:30... xD

was she lip syncing??? =S=S...

anyway.. that performance was a little boring =S...

[spanish4ever]

Shit she is so fucking c00l, I love her, and she's not lypsinging. GO HILARY YOU'RE AWESOME!!

[cristineappreciates]

beat of my heart and wake up are my favorites from hilary... felt she gave the best she can give to this performance, and really appreciate her this song and this video...

[wolfsyaoran]

It's live, and for da people who doesn't know it's posible to put that kind of effects in a voice LIVE...

[j6yz]

thank you!!!! hilary did great this is my favorite performance out of all of them!

[ravenadrienne1]

Fantastic, I've become odsessed with this song lately!

[relientk95]

i'll never stop loving her :)

[tbdnhel18]

she's really great live!!!

[KeokiStarr]

if she is so good why is she lip syncing

[tomtorture08]

shes not lip syncing

[lilshorty839]

dude just cuz she has a great voice does not mean she is lip syncing

[LoveNotWar1992]

she isnt u num nut

[tbdnhel18]

I love her!!!

[blabla2haha]

she si really good live <3

[bandaidsrDEK]

great video! :)

[megorooni]

why can you not hear the crowd...?

[PEUTERD]

hahahahaha the men behind her :D

[mpdam000]

i love this song and i love hilary wowowo

[laylamiaa]

finally a video i found of her not lip synching !

i liked it.

she shouldn't lip sync

[emolyemu89]

hehe dancing men make me laugh and she's not lip synching in this performance! the harmony may sound the same but u can deffinitely tell tht it's live the harmony is more faded on the album thn it is n this...u can just tell...and u cant hear splices at all i'm not a huge hilary duff fan but tht's live....u can hear her taking breaths if u listen close enough especially whn she's turned around

[DignityB19]

I really love this performance alot alot

[goshxe]

i think she's not lypsinging here. but if she is i still like her cause she's awesome and cute :)))♥♥♥

[lindsayfan9]

its better lindsay lohan....♥

[goshxe]

agree with 200%. i do preffer hilary.

[5i2]

she sings live here! you can tell , but she sings really good live :)

[RedJenkins1]

I would bet 500 dollars that the vocal is never live when she's dancing. You can hear the splices and you barely ever hear her take a breath. The harmonies sound like the exact same recording. Plus I've heard certain producers say that she aint so hot in the studio.

[manezzzyo]

wow so why do you care if you feel more than her? can you sing like her? are you a better singer? why odn´t you go with your crap to someplace else? you just making people mad and its so not good for the world :P

[cloughproductions]

That's because the backing vocals are made by backing singers that were there you moron. What producers - name some. Check out ehr performances at endfest - she's amazing live. Fool.

[goldpumps]

she singing live and that is a BEST!!!

I love Hilary dUFF!!!

[rosesanimegirl]

she is just amazing!!and I love her shoes and no way she is lip synching she goes of key some times, that proves she sings live so hah!

[Druxia]

she's really cute

[andrefowl]

I always watch it. I just don't get tired of it. I LOVE HILARY SOOOOO MUCH! SHE'S THE BEST!

[xhilaryxduffxfanx]

Omigosh this is such a good live performance.

I LOVE you Hilary!

OMG get rid of those stupid idiots behind her! What the HELL are they doing jumping about at 1:32?!

[umamakesh]

The 4 guys behind hilary are driving me crazy

[manezzzyo]

that is the best performance of her

she sound just perfect

[tlstj123]

i hate her gress though, and man is she skinny!

[tlstj123]

i luv this i seen it wen she sang it on TV

[hezSOflii]

one of her best performances for suree