Added: 5 years ago
From: MisterAnderson71
Views: 167,491
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (582)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • So many memories seeing the 9th Doctor. So many memories.

  • Great job, but the name of this song is actually The Scientist...

    Pretty appropriate for the role of the Doctor, I'd say...

  • This was a very well done vid my friend!!

  • Love it! It's just perfect (just like the Doctor & Rose ;)).

  • Fantastic editing and sensibility. One of my favorite songs and one of my all time Doctors/Companion teams. Well done. And thank you.

  • Oh, this was absolutely GORGEOUS!!! The rewind scene was just perfect!

  • ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!!

  • thumbs up if u think the doctor and rose should b together forever...

  • tears everywhere!

  • "9" is so underrated!

  • @Temaile 9 as in the ninth doctor?

  • @JanWey91 Uhuh, I like him a lot. He's very moody and broody, but he has that happy, cheery thing all the other Doctors have too.

  • someone else has this vid up

  • @thechelsey100 Got a link?

  • Mute this video and listen to it with Owl City's "Galexies" It's the most perfect song for Dr. Who!!

  • my first favourite over 2 years ago :)

  • the songs actually called the scientist

  • Ahh, you included the 9th Doctorrr <3 He needs more love :) I love him. Great job, awesome awesome job...

  • what episode is  3:12-3:16 and 4:11 from?

  • @tiapest126 Those clips are from the episode 'Love and Monsters' close to the begining of the episode I think.

  • what episode is 4:11 from?

  • There never will be another story like theirs. That's what I love about them. Great video!

  • Fantastic job!!

    The going backwards thing was cool. I laughed when Doc placed Rose back in front of the dangerous werewolf, though. X)

    Really nice job!! :D

  • the maniquins match the doctor's haircut!

  • this makes me want to see all the doctor who episodes that Rose was in...

  • LOVED the end! :D

  • Loved it !

  • Fantastic video! I loved your angle on Rose and the Doctor's relationship. Keep up the terrific work!

    Like/Favorited.

    Li Li

  • this is sooo sad ='( my fave pairing EVER! and also a sad song!!! Love it!!

  • This is adorable. It's the first time I've seen it and it's so simple and beautiful. D: Well done. <3

  • I found this video when it first came out, and downloaded the song straight away. And I still think its one of the best!

  • What episode is the part at 3.09 taken from?

  • I was crying at the end. :'(

  • amazing just simpley amazing

  • Brilliant job mate.

  • This is a good video and you should feel good.

  • one of the best doctor who vids on yt ever

  • wundervolles lieeed *___*

  • I've been watching DW vids on YT for years, but I never came across this vid before. Well done.

  • Every time I listen to this song, I play an imaginary monage of my ex and me before we broke up 

  • David Tenent is AWSOME!

  • Every time I watch this video I cry. I love it. Makes me so mad to think that they aren't together anymore. I've read plenty of fanfics where Rose comes back because there was still something left of bad wolf. They should totally do something like that :)...

  • nice rewind effect. Didnt see that coming... ;)

  • Love it!!!!!

  • Beautiful vid ! ;)

  • GOOGLE THIS ONE

    THE SECRET ADVENTURES of DOCTOR WHO and THE SCOLE GHOSTS :-)

    or

    John Joseph O'Brien and THE ANGEL ROSE ARE NO ONE :-)

    or

    ^

    IT'S A SCOLE GHOST JOKE ;-)

  • I told myself I could watch this without crying, but apparently I lied.

  • After seeing this vid. I have offically pictured this as Nine/Ten's + Rose's themesong. It's just so them! I love how thebacktrack effects works so well.

    Oh gosh, I'm tearing in front of the screen. Great vid. XP

  • do a video with "Silicon World - Effel 65"

    That would Go Will with Who!

  • THUMBS UP IF YOU THINK DAVID TENNANT SHOULD BE GIVEN A KNIGHTHOOD

  • @ironknightcommisar and he likes Coldplay

  • I don't normally like videos like this, but this one was great! Great job!

  • its look so cool when they go backwards :) even though it sad made me think of some things

  • this is one of the best vidoes i've seen.

  • *sniffles* that was beautiful :)

  • better then Coldplay(s) following the words into actions..Great Job Dr.Who.....two thumbs up!!!

  • Nice! There are a lot of doctor who videos using coldplay but this one is the best.

  • That was amazing. That must have taken a lot of work, but trust me when I say it was worth it.

  • This video makes me cry everytime. congratz on a beautiful job.

  • I think this was the first Doctor Who vid I ever watched...still love it. =D

  • what episode is 3:33 from?

  • @xxdramaqueenxx8 Series 2 New Who, Doomsday. (Last episode)

  • love this one so sweet miss ten/rose :(

  • this is very good.

  • I keep coming back to watch this video. It is absolutely THE pivotal Doctor Who fan music video. You've captured something utterly fantastic here.

  • still one of my favorite videos

  • that was just amazing

    first off the music fit very well since the doctor can travel through time ect

    and that ending part were it was rewinding was just awesome 5/5 and im adding to playlist if you dont mind :P

  • best doctor who vid i have found, i plan on showing all my friends twice

  • that was incandescently brilliant!:D

  • WOW! Now a have to take a deep breath. Such an amazing video!

    I don't know what to say...

    5*

  • Brilliant. I have watched this video SO many times and I just LOVE it. It's truly amazing and the mus ic and the whole song fits to the video. Autstanding!

  • Beautiful!

  • Wow do you have any kind of formal training because this video is amazing, the way all the clips fit into each other and the blending and everything. Its breathtaking. It reduced me to tears also!

  • This was very special - creative and unique unto the fanvid world. Thank you for sharing it.

  • gr8 vid! why did they all walk backwoods at the end?

  • Tomatoslater, they're walking backwards for a couple of reasons. The original video for this song features the lead singer walking backwards through the majority of the video. So walking backwards is a nod to the actual video for this song.

    The other reason because it's a reference to the lyrics. "I'm going back to the start". Even after all that Rose and the Doctor have been through, she will still choose to be with him if she can.

    Hope this helps.

  • es el video mas bonito que e visto en mi puta vida...

    5 estrellas

  • Love the dedication. That was fantastic!

  • I only recently started watching Doctor Who. Just finished the second season and completely sad that Rose isn't the assistant anymore. The finale reduced me to a puddle, but I love the vid. Lol, it helps!

  • its quite bizzare this- you look at 10 and you can /see/ him getting older. he aged 10 year in the 5 years he was acting.

    also quite a bizzare and wonderful rewind ending- it made me feel a lil weird. i started cry and i NEVER cry at youtube vids.

  • This is a phenomenal vid. I love it- an instant 5 stars!!!

    xx

  • omg. I like cried watching this... I love this show, and rose was the best for The Doctor's assisstant

  • Love you the way you put the clips together,brilliant video!! 5*****

  • wow,so beautiful=)

  • Beautiful. Especially in the lead of to David's final episodes:) Absolutley lovely.

  • I really love this video, I can't stop watching it and I never get tired of it.

  • Fantastic! Especially the backwards part.

  • this is so sad the rewind at the end really fits in with the song

  • cleverly made^^ I like it!^^

  • solid to the core, no joke.

  • I really like this! well done :)

  • i cryed so much good work

  • VERY nice :) one of the best doctor who videos out there. now can you make one to the song frozen oceans by shiny toy guns? pleassse?? It needs a good video like this!!!

  • I love the song, it's very touching and it really suits the mood of the video. The structure, the transitions, everything was perfect. Of course, it goes straight to my favourites. Congratulations!

  • Still one of the greatest Doctor Who Music Vids on Youtube after all this time.........

  • which episode is at about 2:10?

  • "The Christmas Invasion" David Tennant's first full adventure as The Doctor (even though The Doctor was unconscious for almost half of the story).

  • Coldplay - Scientist

  • Lol love doctor and rose lmao and loved ending

  • This video is amazing! congratulations! Really! I love it! Such a wonderful sad video!

  • awesome!!!!!!!! gr8 video m8:)

  • i simply love this video

  • Really excellent. Only love for this video. <3

  • I think this is my favourite ever Doctor/Rose video. It's so simple, but it's excellent.

  • i so love thsi video it so cute and sweet

  • Brilliant!

    Absoluely beautiful.

    It made me cry.

  • omg i had the beggining in the dream i didnt even knew doctor who then ().()\

    amazing if only i remmberd his real name :[

    bummer thats how dreams are you cant remmber every singel detail

  • Why would you watch this and comment if you are not a fan? Why waste your time callin folk weirdos just cause they like what you dont?

    This is heart tearin....If you have a heart...

  • I love this vid. After discovering it, I have watched it a ton of times...even tracked down the coldplay album to get the song. Keep up the good work!!

  • Great vid, brilliant (fantastic!) song choice too.

  • Coldplay-The Scientist

  • I love this, man. Pure brilliance.

  • truely lovely vid. I miss the ninth doctor but of course I love the tenth too. But it seems to me that the doctor loved rose more when he was the ninth. I mean, you'd never see the ninth doctor stranding rose away from him no matter the reasons.

  • I agree - the chemistry was even more apparent between Rose and 9. There was that time, though, in "Dalek" when 9 closed the vault on Rose and the Dalek.

  • i love this song of Coldplay

  • So sad! So fucking Sad! His love to her was stronger than for anybody else and she just had to go becoming trapped in another universe.

    Btw: I really hate the way she comes back in the 4th series. Why can't he tell her that he loves her? WHY can't she come with him in the "right" universe if Mickey can stay there?

    And why does The doctor give her a fake-doctor if that means he can't have her?

  • I agree totally! However, I think he's afraid to tell her he loves her. Because he's in love and she's in love, but one day he'll have to regenerate, and she's so enamored with him as he is that he's prolly afraid it would crush her. So he's a masochist and would rather inflict pain on himself than her.

    That's why when Billie comes back for David's last episode, I want him to tell her he loves her, and her to say she loves him even if he regenerates (although no relationship with Matt Smith!)

  • I want The Doctor to tell Rose he loves her before he regenerates again as well, badly I might add. I think the reason why he doesn't say it is because he knows she'll grow old and die where he won't and that hurts him too much.

  • Exactly what I ask my screen every time I watch Journey's End...

  • @LebbsexMedGabbe i think the star he was burning up ran out 1 and 2 he a time load and she is human he life span is limited and i guess if he said he loves her she would be forever stuck on him 3 i think in her home work she was pronunced dead and i think in season 4 he says another reason why she cant go back dont remember y though 4 i guess he gives he the fake doctor cause his life span is limited too and since he cant be with her the doctor can live it though fake doc

  • @LebbsexMedGabbe I totally agree with you. However, this all shows how selfless the Doctor is. Just because he and Rose can't physically be with her doesn't mean he doesn't love her any less. To give her a part of him is the best he can do for her. He's pratically immortal and she's just an aging human by the day. There will be a day where Rose will evventually die of old age, but why not die with the part of the Doctor that can be by her side. I absolutely love their story!

  • @LebbsexMedGabbe The Doctor gave her that other doctor as they could grow old together and live a proper relationship. I don't really know why he didn't take Rose with him but the only reason I can think of is because he can regenerate he can't be with her forever. When he lost her in doomsday he felt that pain of loss which would be even worse if they lived together and then she died. I think he left Rose there so she could be happy and that he could have closure and not be hurt oor vulnerable.

  • @LebbsexMedGabbe Because he can't have her. In a way it is the curse of being The Doctor and he knows it.

  • @LebbsexMedGabbe If he told her he loved her he wouldn't have been able to leave and he gave her himself except that Alt!Ten dies at a human rate. He gave Rose a person she already loved who she could grow old with. and as for why he did it if it means he can't have her, he did that because he's the Doctor. She would have stayed with him until the day she died and being together that long would have only made it worse when they separated.

  • @LebbsexMedGabbe That's how they tie down the loose ends. That's what keeps the series going. He's always alone so that everyone can dream about being with him. That's just the way the writer's write it. It's sad, but it's basic formula. Star Trek did it too with Captain Kirk. James Bond never stays with the same girl. That's just the way they like to portray action heroes. It sucks but it's true.

  • Freaking fabulous. Loved it!  Great job.

  • I really loved how the end was so reminiscent of the music video for The Scientist. Great work!

  • Excellent video!

  • Sooo well done! The song fits very well, and of course, we revisit all the happy and sad bits...

  • Escellent clip , really enjoyed it. Thankyou .

  • great vid i love david tennant

  • Great video from the greatest TV show of all time...and I only watched my first episode three months ago!

  • I Love this new Dr Who stuff, cant decide whether Chris or David is my fav....love watchin the two of them, and Billie is the best wee side kick!

    This Vid makes me wana cry!....

  • where do you get the clips from?

  • amasing vid!

  • Oh this made me tear up so much! I love everything about it, ESPECIALLY the moment when the clips start going backward. Such a brilliant editing move/concept (and reminiscent of the original video for this song), esp. because most Doctor/Rose videos go from 9 to 10, but this goes from 9 to 10 to 9 and I just LOVE that. It's just such a beautiful thing to see them get their second chance. Your video did this better than the end of Journey's End. :)

  • amazing, i wish i had the footge and the programe to mke things that gtreat. witch programe did you use?

  • Oh my god that is fantastic! Favourited.

  • I favourited this 2 years ago on my really old acount and Im watching this wondering why I favourited it.

    then it all started rewinding and i thought - thats why.

    thats pretty awsome

    Ill favourite it on my new account :)

  • That was very well done :)

  • fantastic! very beautiful.

  • Such a beautiful video. I love how unique it is and the ending is brilliant

  • Brilliant !!

  • Does anyone have any idea who the heck is Matt Smith?

  • He's been in a few movies, as well as some plays. Obviously they've gone for a relatively unknown actor to play the Doctor, makes sense.

  • This video captures the passion between the Doctor & Rose. A true true treat for fan films.

  • Aww, well done =)

  • really cool

  • it looks funny wen their runnin backwards

  • aww i almost cried ahhahaha good video

  • good video

  • good video

  • Wow, such a beautiful video. :)

  • really good! I liked the rewind-ish parts!

  • I love this vid, especially the rewind bits :)

    But I keep laughing at 4:22,

    "Get back out there and DIE!!!"

    Great message about rewinding, I love it x

  • yeah lol me too! and the bit where she puts Pete back out in front of the car... :P

    really great vid i love it!

  • i love this video this has to be the thousandth time ive seen it and im still tearing up.

    e

  • this song is called "The Scientist" not "Back to the Start", still a good vid though.

  • umm, I know that. And if you watched the credits you would realize that.

    I rarely call my vids by their song title, I prefer to make my own name for them.

  • i understand.

    what do u think of the new doctor?

  • WE ARE THE ONES WE HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR.

    Freedom is not worth having if it does not include the freedom to make mistakes.  Mahatma Gandhi

  • fantastic vid. david is the best doctor ever

  • david tennent is the best doctor!

  • i love this video it so cool and sad to

  • As the doctor would say.... Fantastic!

  • LOLz...

    Billie Piper was amazing, i really miss her, and i miss Christifer, he was a good doctor too.

    See, i rarley want to watch Doctor Who now, because i find it boring, where-as Billie & Christifor made it so exciting...

    I actually cried everytime Rose had to leave for good, because i'm emotional like that & i really miss her in Doctor Who :'(

  • i can sooo relate. even though David really brings drama, Chris could bring the drama

  • fantastic song, magical tv well worth the watch if there was a you tube classics page this would be on it

  • Oh wow. Oh WOW. That was amazing, so beautiful! That rewind at the end was incredible, absolutely perfect...

    It was SO SAD...

    Definitely going in my favourites. Definitely.

  • Amazing video - I love it. I really like the rewind effect toward the end - I wasn't expecting it, but it was a nice surprise. The song was asking for that sort of effect, imo. Best video I've seen to this song, hands down. :)

  • Your love for this series is infectious. I've never seen an episode of Dr. Who but I fell in love with the show just from watching this video.

  • beautiful song, wonderful show.

    i love this video!

  • Brilliant !!

  • I mis Billie Piper damit!!

  • so sad

  • Lovely.