Some things aren't quite in sync; for instance Whitney Houston acheived mainstream popularity years before the World Wide Web did. Facebook also appears a bit too early as well here.
People seem to forget that people that make these videos aren't professional songwriters. It's not going to be PERFECT or sound as polished as Joel's did, but I like that people have taken a good interest in modern history and are trying to continue the work. I think Colleen did a good job, and maybe one day Joel or someone else will do a professional continuation of the song.
I had been wanting to do something like this for some time. Quite a few of your choices mirror my own. Some of the words seem kind of squashed in and rushed to keep in time with the origianl song, but I realize that's got to be the hardest part of the whole project.
Give'em a break this was a good try probly make a better one now should make one that mentions all the crazy 2012 stuff going on like ice caps melting.
Ever since I first heard the original, I knew I'd like it more if the lyrics were of events relevant to my lifetime. I had toyed with the idea of doing something like this, myself, but I could never come close to how perfect this version is.
Good effort, but your events or NOT in chronological order. Check your dates again, tons are off. Furthermore, so many of these events have ZERO historical value, and nearly ALL are entertainment based. Good effort though, I respect the work.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm sorry but... terrible. The singing was off and a lot of stuff mentioned does not need to be immortilized in a song (Coldplay? seriously? when did they do something the whole world noticed?)
:) In Colleen's defense, it's really tough to write a song like this, and when you're doing it, you really don't try to hard to fit one single thing in, you just try to make it rhyme where you can and have the syllables match up. The content is less important. I didn't realize this until I tried to do the same thing myself, and I'm in the middle of it right now. I'll try to fit LOTR in, but it may not fit. We'll see. Look for my version in a little while.
Actually, I love it so much, and being less than a year away, it should be included. A few changes to the lyrics, and a quick recording would accomplish this.
I'm not saying it needs to happen, but to leave that event out, when it's so close, would be a missed opportunity.
And it doesn't matter, his historical election happened in 2008.
Forget the critics, this is amazing! A teacher's dream! Wish they could have been in consecutive order, but it was an excellent depiction of the last nearly 20 years!
Wow..... This is incredible after seeing this i think i'd like to take a shot at this my class is doing a project on this song I think i'll take a swing at this. And to think i remember more than half of that..... I'm getting old.... any way I LOVE IT!!!
Excellent job!! It's amazing to think what all has happened in what? 19 years? It's incredible to think about it being that long ago. But if you look at it the first gulf war was in 1990-1991 when I was 23 and that seems like just yesterday. Incredible. You never realize you get old so fast!!!
Look up "Simon Cowell" in "The Oxford English Dictionary" generally deemed to be the definative guide to the English language, and the will find "Pillock".
I couldn't believe it when the USA voted in Bush a second time and I couldn't understand why we Brits voted Blair ( or B.Liar as we call him) in for a second term either! What sort of people are we? How do you sleep Tony? I find it difficult.
Well,-- did they? The rest of the world watched and could not believe what appeared to be something of a voting scam! Conspiracy or cock-up? Who knows?
But we consoled ourselves that he wouldn't get in a second time! Oh, well!
And we held our breath over Sarah P! But thank goodness, sense was seen!
I'm not sure what prompted the argument about American arrogance, but here are my two cents. A 95%-5% split and an 80%-20% split are both inaccurate. Just because you haven't had a chance to leave the country doesn't mean you are an ignorant, arrogant American. I'm a bit wary of using the term "greatest country on Earth", but historically, America has been a force for good in the world and is a huge player in global affairs. Look what the recession in our country is doing to world markets....
I'm American, but I don't think that we're the greatest country in the world. I hate it when people do that, when they glorify America so much that it seems like they think that there's no wrong that America can do. America has its problems, just like every other country in the world.
I suppose I'm part of the "five percent" that has stepped out of the country.
ANYWAY, good song, though I think that maybe you could have chose better topics for some of the lyrics. But awesome nonetheless.
I've gotta say, though I'm not always happy about being an American, however you are, so deal with the country. And, usually (until about 2000) we have a good influence on the world. Also to all those non-Americans reading this, what's with the attitude? Sure America's fucked up right now, but its not like everyone in it is.
I dont no y everyone is fighting about america and britain its true amercians have self arrognce but its not 95 % of us its only the bunch of assholes who ended up living in america which is about 80% i am in the 20% that realizes that America is fucked up really bad and things are going down the shitter
Type in Dumb Arericans and go to the goegraphy one, just shows how self involved and unaware of the world outside thier own borders America is. also v funny.
ya not guna lie but the rest of the world did contribute to music lol if america sucks like you say how come all the international bands you listed came to america once they became or to become famous?
The Beatles became famous here (in Britain), and spent the majority of there time in the UK, as have Oasis and many others. yes they've toured America, but they've also toured france, germany, japan, australia, south afria etc etc etc. So don't think you're something special. If you wanna use the "they come to us when they're famous or to become famous" line then a lot of countries could make the smae claim. Pretty much every big, or trying to be big band or muscician has come to the UK to tour.
@TheRapper10000. Brought job growth to a hault, and it's the government fault. Lied and spread, like rash, now we are all out of cash.
Moviewhiz1 1 month ago
Here's a new line to the song George W. Bush is strange, Time for a Change OBAMA The NEW PRESIDENT.
TheRapper10000 9 months ago
Rofl "OJ Got away with it" quality is sorta ehh, but It was still good, if you don't like it people why don't you do one..
bvsandman 10 months ago
I'm either laughing myself silly or crying up a storm. Couple rough spots, but very nice!
canadiantrekkie 10 months ago
you need to do a slight update also why aren't anime, hero movies, hussien, MP3, or the data storage growth mentioned? good job though
dragonlordd 1 year ago
I cant find the original song because of these " creative " singing people for fuck sake...
novakin 1 year ago
Some things aren't quite in sync; for instance Whitney Houston acheived mainstream popularity years before the World Wide Web did. Facebook also appears a bit too early as well here.
pannoni1 1 year ago
omg u jus did my homework! :D
SuperBonkaz 1 year ago 4
Nice video! 9/11 and JonBenet's murder were the most tragic, and I liked how you put this video together!
destinlover88 1 year ago
awsome video! dont listen to those assholes lets see them make a better 1.
sargTucker 1 year ago
If you were to re-do this properly it would be SO damn good.
foodtrey 1 year ago
2:40, so sad, I still remember that tragic day
kingskater4 1 year ago
People seem to forget that people that make these videos aren't professional songwriters. It's not going to be PERFECT or sound as polished as Joel's did, but I like that people have taken a good interest in modern history and are trying to continue the work. I think Colleen did a good job, and maybe one day Joel or someone else will do a professional continuation of the song.
ecwinste 1 year ago 2
Holy Cow! How long did it take to do this?
VerbrannteSchatten 1 year ago
i gave this a chance but im sorry this is killing me i commend you for trying to keep billy's work around but ... i got nothing else to say sorry
chewylikesit 1 year ago
Im working on a remake myself its harder then it looks lol
brooksyinc 1 year ago
they american
dannycefc 1 year ago
Kim Campbell feels like an unimportant inclusion... but an interesting one.
lucas27 1 year ago
Excellent lyrics, lousy video quality. If you could get Billy to sing this, though...
Jaeger7793 1 year ago
fucked up
xxhenk321xx 1 year ago
not bad not bad i wish billy joel could make one 1990 - 2010 there would be so much to sing about
samiss98 1 year ago
lol. Everyone is covered, but Jack Sparrow. Nice job on the video.
Anjumin59 1 year ago
nice job
nukeakitten 1 year ago
lolol disney's fiding nemo
darkbleu006 1 year ago 11
AMAZING!!!!!
codyatcheson232323 2 years ago
if it was properly sung and produced its a great effort, new lyrics are fantastic.
oddjono 2 years ago
This is a great vid. 5/5 Lyrics fit together just needs better quality.
Stevo1129 2 years ago
awesome remake!
aleclego 2 years ago
LOVE THE FERBIE AT THE END!
NOxUxBiTxiTxDGMS 2 years ago
love the red sox picture <3 :D needed a lyric tho :)
redsoxgirlXD 2 years ago
the song has no problem but it just the tone of the song isn't right.
Armando51roosters 2 years ago
nice job
rainbow2251 2 years ago
the lyrics weren't bad, but the sound quality was TERRIBLE
Troghen 2 years ago
Why is the quality so AWFUL? I mean, I can tolerate loss in quality, but this is... amazing.
SillyEagle1992 2 years ago
Arcticwolf, I'm not condemning its inclusion but what historical event that was newsworthy did enough to suggest it was worthy of being included?
APH1991 2 years ago
You're kidding, right?
spameister 2 years ago
I had been wanting to do something like this for some time. Quite a few of your choices mirror my own. Some of the words seem kind of squashed in and rushed to keep in time with the origianl song, but I realize that's got to be the hardest part of the whole project.
Arcticwlf 2 years ago
What's so important 'bout Oklahoma City?
APH1991 2 years ago
Why don't you think Oklahoma City deserves a mention?
Arcticwlf 2 years ago
u suck
Keeton1996 2 years ago
Background music sounds terrible
bigdog011995 2 years ago
you did this really well I LIKE IT! Especially the "boy meets world" pic at the end :D
mjasmine95 2 years ago
once bonny and clyde took the hillside...for the barbarians have returned
azazel637 2 years ago
Nice. But no versions I've heard far made any refrences at all to DBZ. Which in my eyes is as important as the Simpsons.
~Kn~
KyoyasAngel 2 years ago
You did a pretty good job with the new lyrics. I dont get the poor musical quality. But i get the message - not bad. You get 5
wanshei 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think the harry potter part should be replaced with twilightt but I ABSOLUTELEY LOVED IT and u helped me with a school project <3
lulyrules 2 years ago
ok i love twilight. but hello Harry potter is so much bigger then Twilighy
watdidido2yourheart 2 years ago
nice try
Robcobes 2 years ago
awesome.
KnightOfTheLight95 2 years ago
Heck yea! Avenue Q!
PadfootLivesFree 2 years ago
i love the original and i thought that ur version of it was great.
iluvlaughter 2 years ago
It's not perfect, but bloody well good enough!
DysEleHrt 2 years ago 8
This is probably one of the best remakes on Youtube. Great job!
funkybeat01 2 years ago
Dont forget Jimmie Johnson!!!!
RunerRacerPeniguin5 2 years ago
This is kind of cool. It just hurts my ears to listen to it. Turn the treble way down
WVAFfalcon 2 years ago
That was awsome. I always wondered if he would redo the song for now a days, but no need now. you did a good job.
79turdferguson79 2 years ago
The original was missing 1964-1968. Anybody do one filling in those years?
asbpab1966 2 years ago
Not bad. Doesn't have the same punch as the original, but shows how much has happened in the world the past 18 years.
dstephens79 2 years ago
Give'em a break this was a good try probly make a better one now should make one that mentions all the crazy 2012 stuff going on like ice caps melting.
Crystalwolf78 2 years ago
Lots of people probably said this, but its depeche (depesh) mode....
TheMagicmanZev 2 years ago
can be made better....some pics arent mentioned
schagani143 2 years ago
Ever since I first heard the original, I knew I'd like it more if the lyrics were of events relevant to my lifetime. I had toyed with the idea of doing something like this, myself, but I could never come close to how perfect this version is.
Also, Ken Jennings FTW!! Fuck Peter Jennings XD
Yonkage 2 years ago
it's good you mentioned Dale Earnhardt because he's my favorite driver.
1986Sheri 2 years ago
At least this is in chronological order.
IchBinDieKaiser 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Good effort, but your events or NOT in chronological order. Check your dates again, tons are off. Furthermore, so many of these events have ZERO historical value, and nearly ALL are entertainment based. Good effort though, I respect the work.
pdxplaydoh 2 years ago
billy joels has entertainment init. psycho, catcher in the rye, beatles. + entertainment is historical value. how is it not?
dont be so critical. its just a vid on youtube. its good.
dizi90lizi 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm sorry but... terrible. The singing was off and a lot of stuff mentioned does not need to be immortilized in a song (Coldplay? seriously? when did they do something the whole world noticed?)
SeigiChoujin 2 years ago
well see if you can do better this guy had the guts to try something if you dont like something fix it. GOD
Dontjudgeme0822 2 years ago
pretty dead on 5 stars
avidracer26 2 years ago 4
This is very good 5 stars
CrimsonFlareFox 2 years ago 3
funny
oomphrammsteinrulz 2 years ago 2
hey this is pretty good.
redtree6767 2 years ago 3
that was terrible the real song was about events that changed the world not events that changed your mood
crazpla 2 years ago
Exxon? Lithuania? Cold War? Desert Storm? That's just from the first verse.
EnduWolf 2 years ago 2
solid, that was sweet!
sweetassugar3239 2 years ago 3
Good job! bravo!
13495 2 years ago
ummmm no comment my brother made me listen to this and i must say just the fact that he likes it scared me but its actually pretty good
icrytearsofblood1 2 years ago
mate tht was pretty gud!
top!
BobbyDrake00 2 years ago
despite the sound quality not being great, i thik you've done a really fantastic job
PrincessFatorechi 2 years ago 2
poor sound quality on this one colleen. i love this song ,but it could have been dont a lil better. thanx = )
praiznhym4ever 2 years ago
november rain!!!!!!
good lyric ;)
frenchfry612 2 years ago
CLASS!
denis1501 2 years ago
lol, "de-pech-E-mode." Nice recognition, though, of a fabulous group of musicians.
Brigham007 2 years ago
Great Job!
Bears08 2 years ago 2
lol i had to do this same assignemnt for world history class
1111jony11 2 years ago 2
Me, too.
brittanycgonzalez 2 years ago
me three
SuperFinkle 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
DUMB ASS THE COLD WAR WASN'T IN THE F***ING 90s!
XxJoHn117xX 2 years ago
there are some debate about when the cold war truly ended. Some say it ended in 1990, so it fits.
sunnybird16 2 years ago 4
it officially ended in 1991, so yep
npc223 2 years ago 3
Cold War: 1945-1991, from the end of WWII to the collapse of the Soviet Union.
(dumbass)
firemastrr 2 years ago
Gotta ask... was there no spot for Lord of the Rings?
mazrimtaim10 2 years ago
:) In Colleen's defense, it's really tough to write a song like this, and when you're doing it, you really don't try to hard to fit one single thing in, you just try to make it rhyme where you can and have the syllables match up. The content is less important. I didn't realize this until I tried to do the same thing myself, and I'm in the middle of it right now. I'll try to fit LOTR in, but it may not fit. We'll see. Look for my version in a little while.
firemastrr 2 years ago 3
we did this in my us history class we got to choose the time period and we did the same time period. yours is better though
sbucksfanatic 2 years ago 3
i like it.. creative.. good job
askdoctormoose 2 years ago 3
this is very talented
deathgodd789 2 years ago
Good, but I think you should add in Obama to it.
No matter your politics, this is a huge event. :P
southparkgtaca 2 years ago
Obviously by the title it doesnt count as he wasnt president till 2009.
strey101 2 years ago
Actually, I love it so much, and being less than a year away, it should be included. A few changes to the lyrics, and a quick recording would accomplish this.
I'm not saying it needs to happen, but to leave that event out, when it's so close, would be a missed opportunity.
And it doesn't matter, his historical election happened in 2008.
Check mate.
southparkgtaca 2 years ago
The video was posted January, 10 months before the election. Shut up.
HomicidalDonut 2 years ago 16
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I just explained myself, you shut up.
Eat a pee pee, asshole.
southparkgtaca 2 years ago
You all lose because, there's a picture of obama at 4:06
bsrj22 2 years ago
Why would she reupload it? It's already up, before Obama was president.
PumaOPumaOPumaO 2 years ago 2
Forget the critics, this is amazing! A teacher's dream! Wish they could have been in consecutive order, but it was an excellent depiction of the last nearly 20 years!
cachaa5219 2 years ago 2
EUUURRRNNNHHHAARRDDDTTT
vettedude418 2 years ago
LoL There Is Croatian Version TOO...
Markonim 2 years ago
badass
ANDRESBAGC 2 years ago 2
I guess "Armstrong's seventh straight" doesn't count.
JP4645 2 years ago
"KISS Returns"
AWESOME!
yoman5664 2 years ago
didnt realy sound like the original but good idea i think joel would be proud to hear his song living on thru the years
kasjdhl 2 years ago 8
Awsome remake but u didnt mension anything abought are chimpanzie president george bush XD
aguiar800 2 years ago
1st verse dumbass
kirkom45 2 years ago
That's Bush Sr.
SOADunplugged 2 years ago
hahaha you are awesome kid. Thanks a lot for this song !!!
BalvanCity 2 years ago 2
You pronounced "Depeche Mode" incorrectly.
ExplodingBacon 2 years ago
that was really good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
80sgirl007 2 years ago
Decent song...
FWYGINOND 2 years ago 2
Wow..... This is incredible after seeing this i think i'd like to take a shot at this my class is doing a project on this song I think i'll take a swing at this. And to think i remember more than half of that..... I'm getting old.... any way I LOVE IT!!!
chatqueenpr 2 years ago
audio quality is poor but other than that it's really good
NSICLOPDA 2 years ago 3
hell i'm using this for school. THANKS
DavidGrantGrey 2 years ago
you know that is the best billy joel remake i have evr heard in my life......thumbs up, 5 stars.
Fthefrench123 2 years ago 3
Excellent job!! It's amazing to think what all has happened in what? 19 years? It's incredible to think about it being that long ago. But if you look at it the first gulf war was in 1990-1991 when I was 23 and that seems like just yesterday. Incredible. You never realize you get old so fast!!!
ktm2844 3 years ago
Very good!
Powerfulone1 3 years ago
Good Work
jhertz89 3 years ago
WOW!!!! great Job Bro!!!!!! WELL DONE, HATS OFF 2U, BOTTOMS UP!!!
DeltaTeamSniper 3 years ago
very good - you should send this song to Billy - lirics is ready :) gl in mtv grats one more time:) respect
dlugi32 3 years ago
Very nice.
I think some things might need changing, just to help the lyrics flow. But it's really good. Send it off.
Insane1385 3 years ago
Write down lyrics.
sell to Billy Joel
?????????
Profit
PUPPYKICKER111 3 years ago 3
Nice job VERY nice ur no billy but still very nice
CentralCatholicpv2 3 years ago 4
your no billy joel but still very good
scorp532 3 years ago 2
hmmm north korea is in the original too! interesting...
i like the new lyrics! its just.. quality of sound and some of the like stressed syllables were off.. but great job!
Lisnotforloser 3 years ago
Awesome! This is the best version of the updated lyrics to We Didn't Start the Fire on YouTube!
mrraffel 3 years ago
depache mode??..... its depeche mode (depesh mode)
WoxBAZZAxoW 3 years ago 2
i like it ;)
0Colo0 3 years ago
really good job
PrimeMonkey13 3 years ago
this was awesome! great job
marcellabella84 3 years ago
I've found out about "Don't ask, don't tell." in Wikipedia. Cheers all, and Merry Christmas.
TCSC47 3 years ago
oh! and I have to apologise for Simon Cowell!
Look up "Simon Cowell" in "The Oxford English Dictionary" generally deemed to be the definative guide to the English language, and the will find "Pillock".
TCSC47 3 years ago
What does "Don't ask, don't tell refer to? I seem to have missed it here in the UK?
TCSC47 3 years ago
it's the policy that the US military uses for homosexuality,
since gays are allowed in the military if they are openly gay, they can only serve if they don't tell that they are gay.
i think it's messed up!
XxFiredemonxX 3 years ago 2
I couldn't believe it when the USA voted in Bush a second time and I couldn't understand why we Brits voted Blair ( or B.Liar as we call him) in for a second term either! What sort of people are we? How do you sleep Tony? I find it difficult.
TCSC47 3 years ago
I couldn't believe USA voted in Bush the first time
Bumblebeeiscute 3 years ago
Well,-- did they? The rest of the world watched and could not believe what appeared to be something of a voting scam! Conspiracy or cock-up? Who knows?
But we consoled ourselves that he wouldn't get in a second time! Oh, well!
And we held our breath over Sarah P! But thank goodness, sense was seen!
TCSC47 3 years ago
well for the some people who didn't like it that's too bad good job! i really liked this i like your new version
cartoonluva11 3 years ago
Well done ColleenBaird. I enjoyed this! Excellent!
TCSC47 3 years ago
Ans. Tony Blair was the spawn of Thatcher. God will judge them.
TCSC47 3 years ago
And who was Tony Blair?
TCSC47 3 years ago
Spawn of satan
glaked23 3 years ago
Who was Margret Thatcher?
TCSC47 3 years ago
the ORIGINAL is sooooooooo much better!
beckygirl1994 3 years ago
that was actually really good, you got the rhyming down, which is difficult.
zainyk 3 years ago
No Iraq???
hrashid14 3 years ago
it had "mission accomplished" with Bush. that is a close reference to Iraq.
nick773 3 years ago
gulf war!!
greeners500 3 years ago
haha john stewart pwns all!
freespeech4u2 3 years ago
+retards this suck is the worst hahahahhaha stupid retards you cant sing
bjk1795 3 years ago
ehh
jackinthebox1313 3 years ago
i apologize that our arguement with these people had to be on your video. I liked it. Once again, i'm sorry.
intem333 3 years ago
too high pitch!
youmanwhore 3 years ago
great job.
milemarkerfilms 3 years ago
depeche mode is pronounced de-peSH mode just fyi
rgsilver1 3 years ago
ok yea this video sucks, it has crappy sound and who ever is singing needs to take some leasons because their voice is making my ears bleed
ziblade666 3 years ago
sounds like it was played down a microphone off a cheap mobile phone
asukapyro 3 years ago
I'm not sure what prompted the argument about American arrogance, but here are my two cents. A 95%-5% split and an 80%-20% split are both inaccurate. Just because you haven't had a chance to leave the country doesn't mean you are an ignorant, arrogant American. I'm a bit wary of using the term "greatest country on Earth", but historically, America has been a force for good in the world and is a huge player in global affairs. Look what the recession in our country is doing to world markets....
mindlessdrone1991 3 years ago 2
You need to change the sound so its not so awfully treble high and such. Just a bit of equalizing.
MasterOfChaos 3 years ago
very well done
retardedpirate66 3 years ago
I'm American, but I don't think that we're the greatest country in the world. I hate it when people do that, when they glorify America so much that it seems like they think that there's no wrong that America can do. America has its problems, just like every other country in the world.
I suppose I'm part of the "five percent" that has stepped out of the country.
ANYWAY, good song, though I think that maybe you could have chose better topics for some of the lyrics. But awesome nonetheless.
charismaticrain 3 years ago
I've gotta say, though I'm not always happy about being an American, however you are, so deal with the country. And, usually (until about 2000) we have a good influence on the world. Also to all those non-Americans reading this, what's with the attitude? Sure America's fucked up right now, but its not like everyone in it is.
rebgurl15 3 years ago
I dont no y everyone is fighting about america and britain its true amercians have self arrognce but its not 95 % of us its only the bunch of assholes who ended up living in america which is about 80% i am in the 20% that realizes that America is fucked up really bad and things are going down the shitter
iLoveFamilyGuy123 3 years ago
they should edit this, remember yeaterday? the no-hitter for the cubs since 1972????? CUBS RULE
maddawg989 3 years ago
Type in Dumb Arericans and go to the goegraphy one, just shows how self involved and unaware of the world outside thier own borders America is. also v funny.
framarkham 3 years ago
P.S love this video and Billy Joels song awesome stuff, well done :D
framarkham 3 years ago
ya not guna lie but the rest of the world did contribute to music lol if america sucks like you say how come all the international bands you listed came to america once they became or to become famous?
mike12mph 3 years ago
The Beatles became famous here (in Britain), and spent the majority of there time in the UK, as have Oasis and many others. yes they've toured America, but they've also toured france, germany, japan, australia, south afria etc etc etc. So don't think you're something special. If you wanna use the "they come to us when they're famous or to become famous" line then a lot of countries could make the smae claim. Pretty much every big, or trying to be big band or muscician has come to the UK to tour.
framarkham 3 years ago