Let's get the facts right: the Poles gave the British and French what they knew about Enigma, but Dilly Knox had already been working on breaking Enigma for almost two years - the Poles information was one more piece in the puzzle. The Bombe machine was named after the Bomba but was light years ahead of it in the way it worked and that was Turing's design, the Poles had no input into it. The Poles failed to tell the French that they had broken Enigma in 1932, breaking the agreement they had!!
Let's get the facts right: The Poles gave British & French intelligence what they knew about Enigma in July 1939 but Dilly Knox (a great British codebreaker) had been working on Enigma for 2 years prior to that. The Poles' information simply supplied another piece in the puzzle that allowed Knox to break the military Enigma in Jan 1940. The Poles had been locked out in 1938 when the Germans changed the design! Turing's Bombe machine was light years ahead of the Polish Bomba in concept.
@ScrumptiousStrat bullshit. Read more sites, books about Enigma. Not british. One reason why Poles where locked in 1938 were funds, money. In 1939 Germans attacked Poland, so there wasn't way to work on it in Poland.
Read more, read....
twicb blogspot com/2007/01/who-really-broke-enigma-code html
"The Codebreakers comprehensively chronicles the history of cryptography from ancient Egypt to the time of its writing. It is widely regarded as the best account of the history of cryptography up to its publication. William Crowell, the former deputy director of the National Security Agency, was quoted in Newsday as saying "Before he (Kahn) came along, the best you could do was buy an explanatory book that usually was too technical and terribly dull."
Brits hate to admit that the Poles gave them and to the French the key to the broken by the Poles 3--wheel Enigma. Moreover, the Bombe was named after the Polish "Bomba" used by 3 Polish mathematicians;
to read more go to:
en . wikipedia . org/
wiki /Biuro_Szyfr%C3%B3w#Enigma_sol ved the British take all the credit for solving the Enigma, and the Poles are made to appear as the nazi collaborators....winners write history.
Not only enigma... Poles give Brits "Polish mine detector" for free. They used it first time on El alamein battle where it doubled allies speed in crossing mine fields. Poles defended British impire for Polish money (for all airs and weapons payed the Polish gouverment)... and after that Brits sold Us to Soviets who murdered Warsaw Uprising Insurgents as fascists, and members of Home Army who 5 years fought with Nazis. What We call that?
Operation Enigma was the greatest secret of World War II after the atom bomb.
Atom bomb people see in the terrific holocaust of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Press, media, films. Operations Enigma-Ultra save million people. The secrets of the Enigma remained hidden and unknown to the public for the next almost three decades.
keirfree Polish-made replicas of the apparatus (the Enigma-"doubles to the French and the British during a tripartite conference in Warsaw in July in 1939.Befor WW2. Not only "analysis"!Hitler's Nazi Germany invaded Poland on 1st September 1939. Respect to Allied: Poland, United Kingdom, France, USA, Australia, Canada other. David Kahn this is famous and prominent American historian of cryptography. My respect for him. Are you a historian? Send me your book, please;) BTW: D. Kahns- not "Khans"!
Polish cryptologists: Marian Rejewski, Jerzy Różycki and Henryk Zegalski finished in Poznan the department of mathematics of University. In 1932, the most working in Office of Codes of Staff Main Polish Army it pretended them to break the codes of code of German Enigma, perfect wówczas the coding machine and they helped to alter fates II world war making possible with the same the British interview the decoding of intercepted German orders
@keirfree: Historian David Kahn writes, "was Rejewski's own stunning achievement, one that elevates him to the pantheon of the greatest cryptanalysts of all time". Rejewski used a mathematical theorem that one mathematics professor has since described as "the theorem that won World War II".
@keirfree: President George Bush's Remarks at the Solidarity Workers Monument in Gdansk July 11, 1989, where he mentioned the Polish contribution to the Victory in giving to the Allies the Enigma Cipher Machine solution.
@keirfree:"Before Poland fell - said George Bush while addressing his huge audience in Gdansk in August 1989, on the eve of the 50-th anniversary of the outbreak of World War II - you gave the Allies Enigma the German Nazi's secret coding machine. Breaking the unbreakable Axis code saves tens of thousand Allied lives, American lives; and for this, you have the enduring gratitude of the American people. And ultimately, Enigma and freedom fighters played a major role in the winning the 2World War
"this information was so Secret, that we would not allow the USA to understand,its full ramifications" The UK made many decoded messages available to the USA. This information was shared freely. Again, you have your facts wrong. If you should ever READ a book, try "Operation Drumbeat" by Michael Gannon.
i'm from poland and i know who broke enigma and i'm praud ! the main members of this team was Marian Rejewski ,Henryk Zygalski ,Jerzy Różycki. people hwo spes otherwise are ine the mistake and dont know history! TO BYL JEDEN Z NAJWIEKSZYCH NASZYCH NARODOWYCH SUKCESOW PODCZAS WOJNY
not only Enigma but also "Polish mine detecor" was invented by polish officer Józef Kosacki who gave this invention to British army for free before El Alamein battle.
"Enigma Code, what Winston Churchill called the most important weapon against Hitler and his armies code-breakers who Normandy,Polish forces joined together to liberate this continent,It has been said that if it were not for the people of Poland, democracy might have perished on the continent of Europe a half-century ago. For it was the Polish mathematicians from the laboratories of Poznan who broke the secrets of the Enigma Code"
What a wonderful country Poland is !!! This is a nation that will not die. Decent, honourable people are the Poles. I love the Polish spirit, sense of humour, Polish films and of course the beautiful Polish women. I love Chopin's "Revolutionary Etude".
Poland is one of the finest countries i have ever seen, that is why i live here now, if u look up other vids the level of antiPolish sentiment is disgusting, the Poles were a major help in WW2
Encouraged by Rabbi Israel Singer's, the General Secretary of the World Jewish Congress, statements in 1996 such as " If Poland does not satisfy Jewish claims, it will be publicly attacked and humiliated in the international forum." So it is a plan to deliberately slander Poland's name and manipulate the American public's opinion against Poles. It was permitted to slander Poles now
In Poznań there is beautifoul monument or Różycki Rajewki and Zygalski!
they were my people!!! Im proud of them!!!
olekman12 11 months ago
yes, the Poles first broke the Enigma and shared their discovery with England.... Its history
RTWEO RTPPM DWEK JGHWE XMNXX KHSDI SDFLO YHDQS SDVNB SDLOI NBSDG RYUQX HYKLC=
nnnn
papoocanada 2 years ago
Poles decoded enigma and thats a fact!
FRANKyyyyy100 2 years ago
Comment removed
FRANKyyyyy100 2 years ago
POLAND FOREVER! I LOVE MY COUNTRY!!!
FRANKyyyyy100 2 years ago
Comment removed
FRANKyyyyy100 2 years ago
Comment removed
FRANKyyyyy100 2 years ago
Let's get the facts right: the Poles gave the British and French what they knew about Enigma, but Dilly Knox had already been working on breaking Enigma for almost two years - the Poles information was one more piece in the puzzle. The Bombe machine was named after the Bomba but was light years ahead of it in the way it worked and that was Turing's design, the Poles had no input into it. The Poles failed to tell the French that they had broken Enigma in 1932, breaking the agreement they had!!
ScrumptiousStrat 2 years ago
Let's get the facts right: The Poles gave British & French intelligence what they knew about Enigma in July 1939 but Dilly Knox (a great British codebreaker) had been working on Enigma for 2 years prior to that. The Poles' information simply supplied another piece in the puzzle that allowed Knox to break the military Enigma in Jan 1940. The Poles had been locked out in 1938 when the Germans changed the design! Turing's Bombe machine was light years ahead of the Polish Bomba in concept.
ScrumptiousStrat 2 years ago
@ScrumptiousStrat bullshit. Read more sites, books about Enigma. Not british. One reason why Poles where locked in 1938 were funds, money. In 1939 Germans attacked Poland, so there wasn't way to work on it in Poland.
Read more, read....
twicb blogspot com/2007/01/who-really-broke-enigma-code html
OSTRify 2 years ago
@ScrumptiousStrat Poles first broke enigma in 1932. In 1934 Rejewski invented cyclometer. In 1938 Rejewski invented first cryptologic bomb.
licicaviki 4 months ago
it was the Polish that did this
nietzscheADHD 2 years ago
David Kahn
"The Codebreakers comprehensively chronicles the history of cryptography from ancient Egypt to the time of its writing. It is widely regarded as the best account of the history of cryptography up to its publication. William Crowell, the former deputy director of the National Security Agency, was quoted in Newsday as saying "Before he (Kahn) came along, the best you could do was buy an explanatory book that usually was too technical and terribly dull."
Yoetah 2 years ago
Brits hate to admit that the Poles gave them and to the French the key to the broken by the Poles 3--wheel Enigma. Moreover, the Bombe was named after the Polish "Bomba" used by 3 Polish mathematicians;
to read more go to:
en . wikipedia . org/
wiki /Biuro_Szyfr%C3%B3w#Enigma_sol ved the British take all the credit for solving the Enigma, and the Poles are made to appear as the nazi collaborators....winners write history.
Sad that only nazi were deafeated & not both AHJS
ironlionuk 2 years ago
Not only enigma... Poles give Brits "Polish mine detector" for free. They used it first time on El alamein battle where it doubled allies speed in crossing mine fields. Poles defended British impire for Polish money (for all airs and weapons payed the Polish gouverment)... and after that Brits sold Us to Soviets who murdered Warsaw Uprising Insurgents as fascists, and members of Home Army who 5 years fought with Nazis. What We call that?
ferdovit 2 years ago
actually that was the ysanks that sold u out, altho we certainly didnt help any thats for sure
nietzscheADHD 2 years ago
Comment removed
ironlionuk 2 years ago
Operation Enigma was the greatest secret of World War II after the atom bomb.
Atom bomb people see in the terrific holocaust of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Press, media, films. Operations Enigma-Ultra save million people. The secrets of the Enigma remained hidden and unknown to the public for the next almost three decades.
skalskipilot 3 years ago
keirfree Polish-made replicas of the apparatus (the Enigma-"doubles to the French and the British during a tripartite conference in Warsaw in July in 1939.Befor WW2. Not only "analysis"!Hitler's Nazi Germany invaded Poland on 1st September 1939. Respect to Allied: Poland, United Kingdom, France, USA, Australia, Canada other. David Kahn this is famous and prominent American historian of cryptography. My respect for him. Are you a historian? Send me your book, please;) BTW: D. Kahns- not "Khans"!
skalskipilot 3 years ago
Polish cryptologists: Marian Rejewski, Jerzy Różycki and Henryk Zegalski finished in Poznan the department of mathematics of University. In 1932, the most working in Office of Codes of Staff Main Polish Army it pretended them to break the codes of code of German Enigma, perfect wówczas the coding machine and they helped to alter fates II world war making possible with the same the British interview the decoding of intercepted German orders
zbyn777 3 years ago
@keirfree: Historian David Kahn writes, "was Rejewski's own stunning achievement, one that elevates him to the pantheon of the greatest cryptanalysts of all time". Rejewski used a mathematical theorem that one mathematics professor has since described as "the theorem that won World War II".
skalskipilot 3 years ago
@keirfree: President George Bush's Remarks at the Solidarity Workers Monument in Gdansk July 11, 1989, where he mentioned the Polish contribution to the Victory in giving to the Allies the Enigma Cipher Machine solution.
skalskipilot 3 years ago
@keirfree:"Before Poland fell - said George Bush while addressing his huge audience in Gdansk in August 1989, on the eve of the 50-th anniversary of the outbreak of World War II - you gave the Allies Enigma the German Nazi's secret coding machine. Breaking the unbreakable Axis code saves tens of thousand Allied lives, American lives; and for this, you have the enduring gratitude of the American people. And ultimately, Enigma and freedom fighters played a major role in the winning the 2World War
skalskipilot 3 years ago
"this information was so Secret, that we would not allow the USA to understand,its full ramifications" The UK made many decoded messages available to the USA. This information was shared freely. Again, you have your facts wrong. If you should ever READ a book, try "Operation Drumbeat" by Michael Gannon.
a0e0roberts 3 years ago
i'm from poland and i know who broke enigma and i'm praud ! the main members of this team was Marian Rejewski ,Henryk Zygalski ,Jerzy Różycki. people hwo spes otherwise are ine the mistake and dont know history! TO BYL JEDEN Z NAJWIEKSZYCH NASZYCH NARODOWYCH SUKCESOW PODCZAS WOJNY
tiptas 3 years ago 3
not only Enigma but also "Polish mine detecor" was invented by polish officer Józef Kosacki who gave this invention to British army for free before El Alamein battle.
ferdovit 3 years ago
Former president Clinton
"Enigma Code, what Winston Churchill called the most important weapon against Hitler and his armies code-breakers who Normandy,Polish forces joined together to liberate this continent,It has been said that if it were not for the people of Poland, democracy might have perished on the continent of Europe a half-century ago. For it was the Polish mathematicians from the laboratories of Poznan who broke the secrets of the Enigma Code"
PolishAmericanDC 3 years ago 3
Poland save 500.00 lives of British and American soldiers Enigma was broken by Polish Scientist 1932
Address to the Polish parliament in Warsaw
PolishAmericanDC 3 years ago 3
What a wonderful country Poland is !!! This is a nation that will not die. Decent, honourable people are the Poles. I love the Polish spirit, sense of humour, Polish films and of course the beautiful Polish women. I love Chopin's "Revolutionary Etude".
SillyGrandpa 3 years ago 5
POLSKA STO LAT, Nie MILLARD LAT
Poland is one of the finest countries i have ever seen, that is why i live here now, if u look up other vids the level of antiPolish sentiment is disgusting, the Poles were a major help in WW2
nietzscheADHD 3 years ago 6
Thank You very much for watching movie and comment. Thank You nietzscheADHD.
skalskipilot 3 years ago
Encouraged by Rabbi Israel Singer's, the General Secretary of the World Jewish Congress, statements in 1996 such as " If Poland does not satisfy Jewish claims, it will be publicly attacked and humiliated in the international forum." So it is a plan to deliberately slander Poland's name and manipulate the American public's opinion against Poles. It was permitted to slander Poles now
PolishAmericanDC 3 years ago 7
Thanks for watching movie and comment.
skalskipilot 3 years ago
czesc
Im grateful to express my thanks to Poles for
their gallantry in WWII...
Britain was pushed aside at Yalta
and bad policy left us unprepared for the World war we should have been much better equipped to face.
Know that the sacrifice of Poles was taught in our
schools and moved me deeply. Know that your people settled here during the war,
and that your wargraves and communites are thriving and respected by
ordinary people here. 68 years on we salute our brothers in arms. An Englishman.
anglofriendofpoles 3 years ago 9
Thanks for your comments!
skalskipilot 3 years ago