i love the original to this song so much more, but theres something mystical about this one, i love it too! (although i do miss the 20 minutes of noise)
i bet they couldnt mimic more of the effects layers upon the basic song structure and thats why they made it that way... no band can cover SY's effects plus they didnt do the minimalist part.. trying that would have just been impossible. oh and the YYY are the mass media's pre-digested generic version of SY.
Hear them just in case u have minimalistic/atonal noise intolerance
@dalegrett i have but im just saying... they couldnt cover the album version if their lives depend on it...
lets just face that SY are bolder wilder and worked so much harder to get where they are: SY are "music" in the highest sense of the word... and YYY make records for "X" record company so they can sell it to a certain "Y" market audience
@watashiwanachodes I don't agree at all! This is a beautiful cover, although the original of course is better. YYYs make awesome music. Karen O is her own character, she isn't a processed cardboard musician, so it's not fair to say that.
@DeadGummiBear ok maybe its alittle rough but since the music SY make comes from techniques they developed themselve i guess i think they disserve more credit than a band that just play songs and u HAVE to accept that YYY kinda sounds like SY but without those techniques im referring to
im a guitar player myself for 15 yrs + and i cant even figure out how to play most of their songs
so flat where is the vocal changes that make this song this cover is a good example of a band wanting to be another band and failing miserably yeah yeah yeahs always wanted to be the new sonic youth but they dont even scratch the surface
Why do bands have to cover songs? How can they add something to other's people songs? If SY was ment to write this song in a certain way , it should remain that way.nuff said
they get plenty recognition... they must have influenced thousands of bands. the only reason they aren't played on the radio is because there's too much autotune rubbish on there.
I don't see any need to fight people, c'mon, lets just get along. I've never heard this version before, and I love it. Personally, I still prefer the original, but this one's really good as well.
Both versions, Sonic Youth's and the Yeah Yeah Yeahs' version have merits...I prefer this one because it showcases the YYYs talents. But Sonic Youth is gorgeous in their own right.
I grew up listening to Sonic Youth and I love them but I have to say that I like this version better. The way they transformed the song really gives focus to the heart of the lyrics.
And BTW, I'm not really sorry if this comment offends mentally challenged fools who think that they have the right to tell me what to like and not to like.
for the idiots who say this version is better/sonic youth sucks...you can't have a cover without the original so saying that sonic youth blows or whatever, remember that a cover is just an adaptation of the song so they didn't do really anything but transform it to acoustic and vocals, big deal, imbeciles. now it's fine if you like it better, but don't say the band that truly did all the work and made the actual song sucks.
Its just personal opinion brother, just because someone likes one version over the other does not make them an idiot. However, I do agree with you that saying that one version sucks is just being ignorant.
Me gusta, pero sin dudas es una canción de Sonic Youth, esta versión me dan ganas de llorar y esta es una canción feliz, maravillosa, que crea reflexión.
Sonic youth le da el real sentimiento a la canción. La voz en este cover es maravillosa,pero esta canción no está compuesta sólo por voz.
Actually this is a very good cover. Nobody would guess it's from SY. I rather listen to this cover than a crappy wannabe-SY version with kids attempting to make the same guitar riffs and noises. If I wanted to hear the same song I just listen to the original. This is the point of the cover, to make it sound different and as good.
I'm a huge Sonic Youth fan and to say without the noise, sonic youth wouldn't exist is bullshit, it's a good cover, leave the noise version to Sonic Youth and let the Yeah Yeah Yeahs do their more melodic version. If they were to copy the song just like SY did it, it would be a complete rip off and kind of defeat the point of a "version" of a song.
True a lot of SY is noise, but the lyrics in this song is truly beautiful, doesn't matter if its played with a bunch of feed back and distortion or with single notes and acoustically u still get a beautiful song if its done right.
i don't think anyone ever will be able to improve on the original. there can maybe, and i highly stress maybe, be an equal, which this clearly is not, but never a successor, or a better Daimond Sea.
karen o has the most beautiful voice =]
Nicklovin28 1 month ago
Sonic Yeah Love!!!!!!!!!!!
gaiseric666king 1 month ago
Amazing cover. Love Karen O & Sonic Youth
israelmendozar 3 months ago
2:19 deep throat :D
michmeister2 5 months ago
fuck this band.
molecularash 6 months ago
exelente banda, exelente cover
pablolerat 7 months ago
I ove this song,I first heard it when I was 13 yrs old on the seattle air waves back in 1995.Great cover!
HumboldtDan420 8 months ago
Such a beautiful song
buddyfishduck 8 months ago
wow thats really good
seifukusha 9 months ago
Epic!
flywest26 9 months ago
sonic youth is probably one of my favorite bands. I think this is the best cover ive ever heard.
crystalmonday80 9 months ago
just started listening to every album this one is anti climatic to what ive heard of the yyy's amazing all around.
themamaslapper 10 months ago
buen cover
cartografos 10 months ago
i love the original to this song so much more, but theres something mystical about this one, i love it too! (although i do miss the 20 minutes of noise)
katiejz524 11 months ago 4
uh.... i didn't know covers had to sound exactly like the original ;-;
*shot*
deisempai999 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Epic fail!, this cover sucks...
i dont have anything againts yeah yeah yeahs, but i think they miss choosing a song to cover.
Where is the noise part?!?!
antropoidex 1 year ago
@antropoidex Can't make much noise with an acoustic guitar.
dark3rbol 1 year ago
AMAZING COVER.
thab91 1 year ago
omg my lord harycristinna ala buda this monkeys gone to heaven
frankenstienen 1 year ago
wow, thank you, that is beautiful....
i didnt think ever anyone could do this song again,
but you have... thank you,
RIP nathan 1973 -1995.
Queensland , Australia.
inbred0232 1 year ago
I'm loving the coverl love both bands
deanscarecrow 1 year ago
i love this its a great cover but it is the yeah yeah yeahs! karen 0 is awsome!
LAURAM0822 1 year ago
This is a really good cover! :D
benjaminherbst1986 1 year ago
i bet they couldnt mimic more of the effects layers upon the basic song structure and thats why they made it that way... no band can cover SY's effects plus they didnt do the minimalist part.. trying that would have just been impossible. oh and the YYY are the mass media's pre-digested generic version of SY.
Hear them just in case u have minimalistic/atonal noise intolerance
watashiwanachodes 1 year ago
@watashiwanachodes You have obviously not heard the other, restrained, acoustic, softie, corny, watered down SY version of this song.
dalegrett 1 year ago
@dalegrett i have but im just saying... they couldnt cover the album version if their lives depend on it...
lets just face that SY are bolder wilder and worked so much harder to get where they are: SY are "music" in the highest sense of the word... and YYY make records for "X" record company so they can sell it to a certain "Y" market audience
watashiwanachodes 1 year ago
@watashiwanachodes I don't agree at all! This is a beautiful cover, although the original of course is better. YYYs make awesome music. Karen O is her own character, she isn't a processed cardboard musician, so it's not fair to say that.
DeadGummiBear 1 year ago
@DeadGummiBear ok maybe its alittle rough but since the music SY make comes from techniques they developed themselve i guess i think they disserve more credit than a band that just play songs and u HAVE to accept that YYY kinda sounds like SY but without those techniques im referring to
im a guitar player myself for 15 yrs + and i cant even figure out how to play most of their songs
watashiwanachodes 1 year ago
@watashiwanachodes You are very right :) Thank you for not trying to tear me a new asshole disagreeing.
DeadGummiBear 1 year ago
@DeadGummiBear haaa sorry if i can come out as an a-hole sometimes
have a nice day :)
watashiwanachodes 1 year ago
It's a great cover! Bands cover other bands because they like the song and would like to put their own spin on it. This is a cool version.
Whiskey150 1 year ago 5
so flat where is the vocal changes that make this song this cover is a good example of a band wanting to be another band and failing miserably yeah yeah yeahs always wanted to be the new sonic youth but they dont even scratch the surface
mattysixx 1 year ago
agreed.
i think people who were not born when sy was out do not understand why this cover is flat and soulless.
Bonesoda 1 year ago
agreed.
Why do bands have to cover songs? How can they add something to other's people songs? If SY was ment to write this song in a certain way , it should remain that way.nuff said
anaonxtc 1 year ago
@anaonxtc Music is a form of art and people can do whatever the fuck they want with it. "nuff said".
pencildives 1 year ago
no se puede hacer cover de sonic y
pero bien vale la intencion
SWEETANGELUX 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
que cover tan mas malo
SonicSpield 2 years ago
Yeah Yeah Yeahs do justice on this song.
Catch22ish 2 years ago 11
exelente cover
mexux 2 years ago 3
Great Cover. Yeah Yeah Yeahs did a great job covering this song.Sonic Youth
is one of those Bands that doesn't get the
recognition it deserves.
Punshr 2 years ago 48
they get plenty recognition... they must have influenced thousands of bands. the only reason they aren't played on the radio is because there's too much autotune rubbish on there.
greatrayray 2 years ago
@Punshr
Maybe it's better off this way.If they became popular they may have gotten all screwed up,Like Placebo,look where they were,look what they became.
placeboloverrrrz 1 year ago
@Punshr what do you mean ? do you live in Azerbaijan or sth? We were raised with sonic youth...
glaukus666 11 months ago
@Punshr Yeah they do. Plus they're not after it anyway
pyurmassacur 6 months ago
My soul is squirming with happiness =)
I <3 sonic youth
I <3 the Yeah yeah yeahs
and this song is just beutiful =)
obsesivefunatica 2 years ago 6
I'm surprised at how good this is
keeblin 2 years ago 6
malisimo cover, dejame de joder.
caride66 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Doesn't sound very good, most in part due to the fact that the Yeah Yeah Yeahs have no talent at all.
5timesuperbowl 2 years ago
It's no bad, but I preffer SY!
likearollingstonee 2 years ago 6
it's not bad? Thats exactly what it is
sunchild90 2 years ago
i like both versions big fan of YYYs and Sonic Youth =)
AnnieTran87 2 years ago 3
of course the o.g. is better but this was not so bad. still gonna play the sonic youth version just remind myself how great this song really is.
sleupold 2 years ago
ruined a great song
xsjadoking 2 years ago
Beutiful, beautiful, beatiful.
robertahoth 2 years ago
dicks
paulhankwillyjeeps 2 years ago
this is far less emotional. Making it acoustic doesn't nessicarily make it more emotionaly impacting. It just sounds silly on acoustic.
MisterMisanthropy 3 years ago
i preffer SY but its a cover
nirvanaluso 3 years ago 2
This is a great cover, I went looking for the original but I'm digging this one just as much.
weenedo 3 years ago 7
i´m impressed, pretty good cover
Metalogicc 3 years ago 7
I don't see any need to fight people, c'mon, lets just get along. I've never heard this version before, and I love it. Personally, I still prefer the original, but this one's really good as well.
LeeTheAgent 3 years ago 6
beautiful.
pikachukitten 3 years ago 6
Both versions, Sonic Youth's and the Yeah Yeah Yeahs' version have merits...I prefer this one because it showcases the YYYs talents. But Sonic Youth is gorgeous in their own right.
JiggersGenius 3 years ago 4
lovely karen0
graciiiiiiiiiiiiii 3 years ago 2
Triste o alegre...
lo mejor de esta canción es esa sensación
que no se pierde en ambas versiones... un tiempo sin tiempo...un viaje.
jessicamedea 3 years ago 2
this is definally my prefered song from sonic youth, listening from them make me feel goosebumps as the original one make me feel
amazing
thanks for shearing
fanfejao 3 years ago
this is brilliant
wow
she did a great great job here....
julietavalon 3 years ago
I grew up listening to Sonic Youth and I love them but I have to say that I like this version better. The way they transformed the song really gives focus to the heart of the lyrics.
And BTW, I'm not really sorry if this comment offends mentally challenged fools who think that they have the right to tell me what to like and not to like.
BoBlackheart2 3 years ago
for the idiots who say this version is better/sonic youth sucks...you can't have a cover without the original so saying that sonic youth blows or whatever, remember that a cover is just an adaptation of the song so they didn't do really anything but transform it to acoustic and vocals, big deal, imbeciles. now it's fine if you like it better, but don't say the band that truly did all the work and made the actual song sucks.
JinPanda 3 years ago 3
don't even care about those coments, use to be people that listen 2000's music, aaron carter subfans that have grown.. seriously..
OnBetamax 3 years ago
Its just personal opinion brother, just because someone likes one version over the other does not make them an idiot. However, I do agree with you that saying that one version sucks is just being ignorant.
millskill23 3 years ago
She has a beautiful voice, I like this version better. Sorry!
Britzxo 3 years ago 2
bonito cover ,pero los sonic son ... guitarras osea , de echo sacar sus canciones es muy dificil
machineguns0 3 years ago
sonci youth es sonic youth
buien cover
pero incomparable con la original
J3AMPYX77 3 years ago 2
prefrero mil veces a sonic youth
aldepra 3 years ago
Me gusta, pero sin dudas es una canción de Sonic Youth, esta versión me dan ganas de llorar y esta es una canción feliz, maravillosa, que crea reflexión.
Sonic youth le da el real sentimiento a la canción. La voz en este cover es maravillosa,pero esta canción no está compuesta sólo por voz.
Saludos!
muycordial 3 years ago
This is an amazing cover and the way a cover should be made; taking someone else's song and making it your own.
Bagmen3 3 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is, I imagine, more how the song would have sounded originally had Kim done the vocals instead of Thurston.
And I'm sorry, Mr. Moore, but there are a lot of songs on which your voice is a bit annoying.
NovemberXXVII 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hahaha, I remember in Juno she disses Sonic Youth. but anyhoo, YYY's version to me = better than the original.
Cooleyx3 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sonic youth is about sucking hardcore.
more importantly..
She does this song beautifully. i really wish she'd do more songs like this.
Brit6543211 3 years ago
Actually this is a very good cover. Nobody would guess it's from SY. I rather listen to this cover than a crappy wannabe-SY version with kids attempting to make the same guitar riffs and noises. If I wanted to hear the same song I just listen to the original. This is the point of the cover, to make it sound different and as good.
GoreFreak08 3 years ago 9
I'm a huge Sonic Youth fan and to say without the noise, sonic youth wouldn't exist is bullshit, it's a good cover, leave the noise version to Sonic Youth and let the Yeah Yeah Yeahs do their more melodic version. If they were to copy the song just like SY did it, it would be a complete rip off and kind of defeat the point of a "version" of a song.
thebigfatyoyo 3 years ago 11
lovely...
andrearusso89 3 years ago 2
and also, what indication is given that this is in standard tuning? for all you know it could be the same tuning sonic youth use.
kcinf 3 years ago
to be fair, she doesn't play any notes at all, she just sings.
there's a separate person in charge of the guitar in the yyy's.
living up to your name mr. noobenstein.
kcinf 3 years ago
Sonic Youth are the best band ever!!
migmuff 3 years ago 6
nice
superloserus 3 years ago
True a lot of SY is noise, but the lyrics in this song is truly beautiful, doesn't matter if its played with a bunch of feed back and distortion or with single notes and acoustically u still get a beautiful song if its done right.
deon565 3 years ago 3
Amazing
enterherebeware 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
also check out
watch?v=RsZARnf6uAY
theMAXX81 3 years ago
when was it?
oskremma 3 years ago
how does yor mirror grow
rebeccamykitten 3 years ago
Sonic Youth is the shit. i DO like this cover tho.
astrofunkyness 3 years ago 7
i think the yyys shud cover drunken butterfly and electric, i think it does have a yyys groove
rayolacer 3 years ago 4
Amazing!!! Thank you for sharing this beautiful version!
eieui 3 years ago
yeah yeah yeah!!!!
VladimirMarch 3 years ago
is this available on a YYY album?
FQuezo 3 years ago
It's only available through Itunes.
Wow, That was a great cover version of Diamond sea
KiLL3rDragon 3 years ago
i don't think anyone ever will be able to improve on the original. there can maybe, and i highly stress maybe, be an equal, which this clearly is not, but never a successor, or a better Daimond Sea.
punkguyrich 3 years ago
quality band and a quality cover but all credit to sonic youth! brilliant
northcountrybhoy 3 years ago 31
but she left the last verse out
look into his eyes and you will see.. why everything is quiet and nothings free
i wonder how hes gonna make her smile
when love is running wild on the diamond sea :)
ant1christsuperstar 3 years ago
great cover... love both bands.. but the original happens to be like my favourite song ever
ant1christsuperstar 3 years ago 3
I play this song all night. It speaks to my soul.
pharphing 3 years ago
OMG I LOVE THIS SONG THNX 4 DA VID!
SourNotHardcore 3 years ago
This is...amazing. It had me from the first listen. And I've never heard the Sonic Youth version.
indigoranch 3 years ago 3
Well, you should listen to the Sonic Youth version also. Sonic Youth is the Yeah Yeah Yeahs roots. :-)
walkup15 3 years ago
Ughhhhhhhh you can't be serious.
JHVH1 3 years ago