Added: 3 years ago
From: aizatkill
Views: 427,361
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (354)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Música extraordinária! Amei, amei e amei...

  • hahahahahah LMAO JERRRRIIIIIITTTT yyyyyYEAH

  • i mean i have this movie ;)

  • i love this song i have the song!!!! :)

  • Comment removed

  • omgosh first i was like omg i dislike this song, but than i heard Kelly C. Singing, i was like woooowww , i love this omg i so adore this one ) ♥

  • kelly clarkson really shined in this song, she is just as good as the original chinese female singer

  • Love it love love it!

  • Love it!! Thanks for posting this!! :))

  • yang korean lebih feel.*belagak mcm faham bahsa korea.

  • @royalnot i agree with you :)

  • Omg this is the song timeless by xiah and zhang liyin!

  • haha. jerittt!!

  • this is the best song ever i cryed after it.

  • simply perfect,cant find right words to describe this..oh my god..so real song.

    

  • i LOVE this song!!!!!!!!!!! to touchhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

  • very pretty song, they r both talented

  • Cute song

  • What ever happend 2 Justin?

  • I love the 2 version but I love more Korean

    Of course junsu is really good singer and he voice is amazing

  • no,this version is much better,kelly clarkson rock!!!

  • Comment removed

  • i prefer korean version....

  • Justin is so Gorgeous!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I don't care what u people said I like Both Version!!! So shut up! XD

  • menangis kot tengok vid clip timeless versi

    korea

  • he dedicated this song to me ! and i absolutely felt in love with it..

  • this song is beautifull. Who know from what movie is this song????

  • @jadzia030303 from Justin to Kelly movie

  • hahaha! aku tgh2 feeling tibe2 je 3:17 jerit!! LOL

  • I really prefer Junsu's voice over Justin's.. Idk... Junsu's voice seem to fit better with the song..? :/ plz no hates :'( just preference :D

  • i wish kelly clarkson and junsu could sing together....

  • awesome !!

  • Kelly is fabulous as always! 

  • I just listened to the two versions of this song and I think I'll stay with the Korean version...

  • omg this song is just one of my favs XD Love it <3<3<3

  • at first i found the korean ver. way better

    but now i don't know why i felt that this song has a very strong passion in it

    i love this song

  • watch?v=uSwh2twSWPU : )

  • the only reason why cover version might SEEM better than the original.. might be the fact that the voices of cover guys are not as strong and unique as Justin's? then the girls' voices pop out more, and her melody is all ppl hear...

  • Naaaas

  • Those people who said that the Korean version are much better are obsessed of Korean stuff too much.

    To me, I personally think the English version are much better. Kelly Clarkson and Justin have more emotion because they wrote this lyrics and they know about how emotional it is. To the Korean version, all Jang Ri and Junsu did was translating the song and sing it. I don't think they know how emotional the song is. SM should seriously need to write their own song instead of buying songs.

  • @masakijamie since the song is in korean don't you think they would be able to understand the emotion behind it? to me it doesn't matter if a person like this or the other version better but i think they did very well for the korean version. fyi SM does write their own songs too (coming from a person who is pissed at SM) but give them more credit cause every company does that.

  • @jussmittin Of course they do write their own songs. I already know that. I'm pissed that SM fans compares to the original songs to the Korean songs. They always say that SM artist are way much better than the original artist on the original artist's music video.

    I'm supporting them on the original songs that they sang, not on the SM artist's video.

  • @masakijamie im not sm biased or korean biased either. i take things for what they are. i think some ppl r too biased towards their fav so they think they can sing better than everyone else even to a lot of american singers. most idol singers aren't that good. lets face the facts. i don't get caught up in the artist or the company. i just listen to the song and judge from there.

  • @jussmittin Or some of the fans are really stupid in my opinion. I've seen many other fans who thinks that American artist are stupid which made me piss because I'm American and it's not true.

    I just the support artists, not judge them.

  • @masakijamie i don't get drawn into nationalism,but it does get on my nerves when fans think that korean singers are automatically better than US artists. Im sorry but the majority i've heard even tho i liked them, cant really hold up against the best in the US. sorry but different league. it has nothin imo to do w/them bein american or nething, jus they're better singers.

  • @jussmittin Which shows that they're really stupid. They have a bigger chance that they'll become a dumb fangirls. In my opinion, they are dumb Kpop fans. What I'm saying is that the US singers are much better than Korean singers because of how many awards they have and how famous they are around the world based on my opinion. Don't judge on everyone's opinion. Just leave it alone.

  • @masakijamie are you telling me not to judge everyone's opinion? you yourself just called some people dumb kpop fans. that is quite judgmental if i say. also because someone wins more awards and is more famous doesn't mean anything. before you tell people to stop judging, look at yourself and also come up with better reasons.

  • @jussmittin You told me to give the Korean singers a chance and stating that they put emotion on it but that's in my personal reason. If you don't like what I said, leave it alone. Don't go replying on someone's comments about their opinion. Everyone has different opinions. I'm not judging people and I don't call all kpop fans dumb. Only some of them who doesn't know how to respect people. And now you're arguing about someone who is famous and wins more awards which is really annoying.

  • @masakijamie i cn comment on anyone"s opinion if i want. jus like u cn give urs i cn give mine. who do u think u r? i think u need to check urself b4 commenting bcuz u rly do sound like an idiot rite now.

  • @jussmittin What if I comment something to piss you off? You comment in someone's ass. And besides, the one who needs to double check the comments is your face.

  • <.< asian fanatics are obsessed..

    I personally this this has more emotion to it. The only reason why i would find the korean one a slight more emotional, is coz it has a music video that represents it.

    This is the original btw.

  • Just listened to the korean version and im mildy impressed but still Kelly smashes all tho

  • Please check:

    Alif Satar & Julia Abueva (15yrs.) "Timeless" : Sony Music Entertainment

    Peace : )

  • this version is much more better than the korean...

  • yeay,finally i found this song!!

    I love both the voices! i love it!!

    Truly touch me!

  • I dedicate this to my ex Tabitha even though we aren't together anymore I still feel like we're meant to be. </3

  • i love this song 

  • can i plz have the downloadd link

  • The korean Version is much better.. but thats great and Sad too ;)♥♥

  • @mrssrklove agreed :]

    

  • HE DEDICATED THIS AWESOME SONG TO ME AND I DIDNT REALLY PAY TO MUCH MIND TO IT! BUT NOW THAT I SIT DOWN AND ACTUALLY LISTEN TO IT..THIS SONG MELTS MY HEART!! ITS AMAZING!!! I LOVE THAT BOY!!! AND MISS HIM SO DEARLY!!!!

  • nice song......like this...

  • best love song eva^^

  • love this song the best

  • i'sorry bur i have to ask u ... have u seen the movie ??? this song is amazing ... the movie to ...... enjoy the music and stop talking abaut the korean version ..... if u like more the ather version go and leave a coment in ther song ......... ..... :)

  • I love this song...it's so sweet.

  • i prefer this original version !! :D i cnat undertsand korean & mandarin so.. MORE THUMBS UP FOR THIS !!

  • @MsRaeco625 fyi this is not the original version. The original is in korean

  • @DunKaoPeiMe Actually, this is the original version. The English version came out at 2003 while the Korean singers remake it at 2006.

  • i think the voices of the korean version are even more beautifull ^^

  • dayum.. im in love with this song, and its 2011? WOW. <3

  • i really want see Junsu and Jang ri in sing it again

  • Justin was my first crush.

  • I REALLY PREFER KOREAN VERSION AND XIAH'S VOICE <33

  • @TaniLPA i absolutely agree!!!!!!

  • I will. And did. I just noticed it's the featured video of this one. I feel even dumber now. But I can't sing the Korean version because it's in romanization! It's hard to translate to Korean in my head. Do you know a vid with Korean lyrics?

  • @StarCatcher3721 see in my video list..its already have

    i cant post link here :)

  • i love this song

  • this version is so good but i realy love the version oj junsu ..

  • did justin and kelly ever date?

  • VERY NICE SONG!

  • This is such a beautiful song. I can't stop listening to it :(

  • I like Kelly's voice more than Liyin's. The high notes are much smoother when sung by Kelly. Kelly + Junsu = Heaven.

  • ilove thing song and i can sing it very well too

  • the song's pitch is too high. It doesn't really give it that feeling like the Korean one does. and it also depends on the singers too. Junsu and Jang Ri In's voices give that true message & moves those people who take the time to understand the meaning of the Korean song. I like the English version too, but I think the should've put more effort into it.

  • awesom

  • i like jason chen and jenny version more ~ haha!!

  • love it

  • haahahhahah ttibe ada part jerit iyeah.. ye iye he..iyeah,.hahhaah klakar2 anyway nice job!!!!

  • hahahhahahahaah ttibe ada part "jerit!! yeah..ye iye he iyeahh..klakar2.anyway..nice job!!!

  • I think the korean version is wasy bettter!!!! 

  • ur rite u & i have the same wish, i can sense that too, tho i haven't seen u for a long tym, tym will tell

  • just get away I HATE U 

  • just timeless, is that what u can say to Her ?

  • i'm Sailing myself ,don't want u x

  • i know we do have both a Secret Wishes x i hate u with Passion ,u took my heart away, yup, it's Timeless

  • i Hate u xxxxxxxxxx Gx pls. get away , the more u remind me of u , i get upsetx

  • wow!

  • i loveee the movie from justin to kelly!!

  • Comment removed

  • what.

  • if only kelly and junsu would do the song together ..., Then this would be AMAZING !

  • korean version's really amazing~~ *O*

  • Kelly clarkson voice is magic angelical!!

  • I like this version

    I LOVE JUNSU'S AND RI IN'S VERSION lol !!

  • I think Kelly has expressed her feelings slightly better than Liyin. However, Both Junsu's technique and feeling are better than Justin.

  • Hmmm

  • i love the chinese/korean ver and i'm gonna love this :DD so beautiful :DD

  • my fave is the chinese version with Zhang Liyin, but i'm glad to hear this version, too. it's a beautiful song in any language. :)

  • peter sandor a lucka horvatova lasko nezapomen ze te milujji a odpust mi co sem ti udela ale to se stava gdis nevis kudi dal a nezapone na tu noc jak sme posluchali taditu skladbu lasko moje chibis mi zimal tim vic tvuj kigik caw purynko moje

  • daniel..this is our song...

  • oh i love this song...this i dedicate to my love Daniel....

  • ahahaha....ada part JERIT!...ahahaha

  • i agreed with sapphire100=)

  • I really like both versions...

    but i think junsu's and yi lin's is slightly better...

    Did you know there was a viet version?

    here's the link if you want...

    i dont think it is as good though...

    though linda is amazing....

    /watch?v=KfygPRiE02E

    just put the youtube.com in front

  • this version is not bad at all.. but when i listened to this, i can't really feel the meaning.. i know the meaning because i understand the words. but when i listen to Junsu's and Riin's, i could feel the intense longing even though i understand no korean.

  • @liqx we're seriously the same about this ..^^

  • @liqx gotta to agree....

  • @liqx I liked Jang Ri In & Xiah Junsu (Korean) version. It was polished and very pretty!

    Kelly Clarkson's version has an emotionally stirring flare that I, personally, adore. The way she slightly lilts her voice at the end of this song moves me. Either way, both versions are extremely impressive.

  • @liqx emo much?

  • i feel the meaning when i hear it i feel it in my heart :) i love this song very much

  • this sounds so spanish. love it<33

  • love this song. 

  • i wish junsu & kelly could sing together just once. i think their voices would be absolutely amazing together <3

  • I like the korean version as well as this one. I have my favorites, of course. From the korean version, Junsu's voice is nice, and he could have done better in a higher pitch. And from thisv ersion, Kelly's voice always wonderful.

  • Junsu ftw. Period.

  • I prefer Kelly than Zhang Li Yin (but she's good too) but I dont really like Guarini's voice

  • Ni a los talones!!! me qdo Jan Rin in y Xiah ellos cantan muchisimo mejor esta cancion con mas sentimiento!!!

  • This version is sooo much better !! I love xiah junsu and jang ri voice but kelley n justin and much much stronger and the korean version of this song is a lower key than what kelly and justin sang soo... u can see how strong they r .... and their voice is soo natural while jang ri in it always felt as if it was forced for her high notes while kelly just reach it like that (*clap ) lol

  • Listen to Jenny Suk and Jason Chen's version now that's both chinese and korean singers <3

  • is this really kelly clarkson?

  • i love both versions but honestly i will love the korean version more but hey we all got different taste<3

  • I personally like the korean Version better.

    but this version is really good too.

  • @TechnicolorDodododo I think the same... Junsu and Jang Ri In amazing voices =)

  • @TechnicolorDodododo THERE'S A KOREAN VERSION?!?!?!

  • @StarCatcher3721 Yep. The Korean is the original with Xiah Junsu and Jang Ri In. It's beautiful you should look it up

  • Edzgvneba kvelas visac Sikvaruli sheudzlia :)

  • Magaria,Cool :) Saghooooollllllllllll!

  • DZNNN Magaria,COOL! :)

  • DZNNN Magaria,COOL! :)

  • Cool :)

  • beautiful song

  • This some makes my heart melt

  • Its a beautiful love song...Loveit so much!!

  • I wish Junsu would sing this Eng ver with Kelly LOL

    I wanna hear his Engrish again haha..

    Now THAT'd be an epic duet..!!

  • I also don't like Justin, when you hear the voice of Kelly Clarkson everything dissapears, it's relaly like an angel ;)!

  • can someone post the moive on youtube<3 i really want to watch it

  • i dont care who sing this first ... all i am care about is kelly clarkson !!!!

    that girl have a voice of an angel !!

  • This song is softer and pretty, but the other one is just vocally stronger. And I'm a big fan of Xiah Junsu.

  • i <3 this song sooo much! 

  • did the korean version come first or the english one?

    just wondering...thanks!! (:

  • @MsFrozenyogurt "Timeless" is Zhang Liyin's debut single, released on September 8, 2006 in South Korea and featuring Xiah of boyband TVXQ. The song is a remake of Kelly Clarkson and Justin Guarini's duet, originally recorded in 2003; it has also been remade by Tina Arena and Kane Alexander in 2006. A Chinese version of the single was released in 2007 in Taiwan. - from wikipedia

    So basically this one came out first and the Korean one is just a remake but I love both of them ^^

  • I LOVE THIS SONG. Good Job on the Lyricx :D

  • i love this song

  • This had to be one of the most epicly beautiful songs that I've ever heard <3

  • kelly and justin..both of them have such a wonderful voice..i like it sis...thanx for the lyrics...the most part that i like is 'jerit ' ....hahhaha LOL....

    TERBAEK!!!!!

    the original version also good and the best..i'm enjoying the timeless song..

  • for me the version korean is better but this is so beautiful *Q* I love the voice of kelly

  • Both versions korean and english are beautiful. i can not choose, but if I had to, i would choose the korean just because I love Xiah.

  • I like J&K's original version better. The Koreans used K&J's original vocal stylings but sound slightly forced instead of romantic on the softer parts of the song. I ADORE that J&J remade this song though and their video is much better than J&K passively singing a romantic song to eachother on a boat.

  • I LOVE THE KOREAN VERSION BETTER IT SOUNDS BETTER

  • which is the first version of this song ? English, or korean ??? I'd prefer the korean version...

  • amazingg

  • perfect

  • i would never had guessed it was kelly clarksons song :O

  • i loved the korean version, and i think they did a great sub doing this version :)

  • @shesafingninja haha wat? this version came out way before the korean version. =)

  • @maygeryang ahhh! did it? then my bad, but i still enjoy both versions :D

  • I never thought Kelly's voice was that great until I heard this.

  • this song has become one of my favorites!!! perfect duet!!! good job!

  • The korean version is more touching, it makes your heart race actually. I'm sorry! You know why I don't like translations? Because people pay more attention to the translations instead of the original and people think that the translations are the originals when it is actually the other way around.

  • Was this translated from Korean? The English lyrics is a bit awkward in some parts, but the Korean version does have English in weird places.

  • Kelly tu chantes beaucoup trop bien ....je t'adore :P:P:P:P:P:P:P:P...Que de souvenir avec cette chanson :)

  • de széééép ez a szám, tetszik nagyon:):);)

  • junsu's voice is better than junsu, but kelly and zhang liyin are equal in talent. I feel that Zhang liyin in the korean version holds back- i think she couldve have sang higher notes, but was prbly asked not to

  • @Sushe92 also maybe because of her age at that time.she was only 16 years old when back then.

  • i'm about to break up with my bf,i keep on listening to this song.love it