Shame you didn't check the chords before going to all this trouble. As everyone else pointed out, the reason it sounds so so strange, is that you're playing and F where it should be a D minor. It's so obvious just listening to the original it's not in a major key. Why upload such amateurish work?
@EdwardPaulMusic "you didn't check the chords" well, the song's sheet music I got does not contain any chords, just C-G-C for the C-Part and D-A-D for the D-Part in the accompaniment and in the descant I was not able to figure out whether there is a minor or a major third. Due to that, I think it is NOT "so obvious" as you say. "Why upload such amateurish work?" Because I AM a amateurish misician who likes to share his own instrumental interpretations with other people ;-)
@applestudio well, if you had listened to the original, it's pretty obvious that it is a minor triad in the beginning.. The little melody thing clashes with the major.
@tOtAlLyInLoVeWiThEd Yes, that's right. But fortunately only the guitar plays the wrong major chord and thus it has not such an big inluence on the song's main harmony.
cool, but the guitar doesn't play the right accords, i think, (sorry for my english) the first accord of the guitar is ok, but the second must be D, F and A :)
Well done! I like your fishes :D
xZoSix 1 week ago
It needs to be played in D minor indeed...but that dinn't stoped me from enjoying it!
Well done & keep it up(loading)! :)
Dp
Koningballie 1 week ago
wenn man dabei noch sing wäre geiler
GrosseWolke 3 weeks ago
Shame you didn't check the chords before going to all this trouble. As everyone else pointed out, the reason it sounds so so strange, is that you're playing and F where it should be a D minor. It's so obvious just listening to the original it's not in a major key. Why upload such amateurish work?
EdwardPaulMusic 3 weeks ago
@EdwardPaulMusic "you didn't check the chords" well, the song's sheet music I got does not contain any chords, just C-G-C for the C-Part and D-A-D for the D-Part in the accompaniment and in the descant I was not able to figure out whether there is a minor or a major third. Due to that, I think it is NOT "so obvious" as you say. "Why upload such amateurish work?" Because I AM a amateurish misician who likes to share his own instrumental interpretations with other people ;-)
applestudio 3 weeks ago 2
@applestudio well, if you had listened to the original, it's pretty obvious that it is a minor triad in the beginning.. The little melody thing clashes with the major.
tOtAlLyInLoVeWiThEd 4 days ago
@tOtAlLyInLoVeWiThEd Yes, that's right. But fortunately only the guitar plays the wrong major chord and thus it has not such an big inluence on the song's main harmony.
applestudio 4 days ago
really good duuude !!!
check out my cover ...
PatMeruseye 4 weeks ago
cool, but the guitar doesn't play the right accords, i think, (sorry for my english) the first accord of the guitar is ok, but the second must be D, F and A :)
beatproduktionML 1 month ago
@beatproduktionML You mean, instead of a major D chord there must a minor D chord be played? Mmh, thanks for that advice ;-) I'll try it!
applestudio 1 month ago
@applestudio Yep, it definitely needs a D Minor. The whole thing's written in D minor haha.
Richo18 1 month ago
what program did you use to make this video???
guardianmo 1 month ago
@guardianmo Adobe Premiere CS5.5 Professional
applestudio 1 month ago
Cool <3
good job
GooHaraNumber1 1 month ago