A Close Shave

[bluehairedgirlstudio]

nice use of fishing wire ^_^

[BritishRailways60163]

Excellent vid with those great models! Liked & Faved! :)

[1986zls]

way to go man I love Duck and have found memories of watching this from my childhood.

[x00001]

what do you use to put the track on?

[LegoNJRemakes]

good job

[speedracer456v]

where did you get the coaches james was pulling?

[LEGOMasterMicahTron]

did you use hornby duck?

[Robtheredengine]

@LEGOMasterMicahTron Yes that is a hornby duck as bachmann have not made him yet

[thomasfan6020]

im impress

[thomasfan6020]

i love this remake

[thomasfan6020]

how in the world did create the barber shop

[NeiyonSpyder]

Awesome remake. Its like im watching the original thing

[Robtheredengine]

@NeiyonSpyder XD thanks but i would not say that, i could make a better one now that ive got more skill, look out in future for V2.

thanks for the comment anyway^^

[thomasandfriends1000]

GO DUCK GO!!!!!!! THE TRUCKS ARE COMING!

[thomasandfriends1000]

could you draw me some troublesome truck faces?

[MrLuckySInner]

should have messed up Ducks face with shaving cream for real that would have been sweet :)

[ScottishRails]

Awesome!

[MOESEGGS]

that what i like to see. you rule.

[Robtheredengine]

thanks

[Bunker0224]

I am so HAPPY to finally see this again after a LONG time! This is one of my favorite remakes! Great work!

[TehShadowMeerkat456]

that one van with the big red x on it is a gunpowder van isnt it

[Robtheredengine]

yes it is

[flyingkipper811]

Good job.

When i was a child,I loved this episode.

[darthkirby9]

very good

[sscthomasfan10]

you'll see the string on the part of the cars moving

[sscthomasfan10]

he used string

[sscthomasfan10]

i know how he made the cars move

[stingrayfan2007]

How did u get the trucks to move in the scnes where they chase Duck?

[FanToAll]

Say, Rob, first time doing this did Duck ACTUALLY crash into James by accident?

[Robtheredengine]

no, at times he was not on the rails.

[LeonSKennedy828]

awesome!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks =D i'm glad you like it, version 2 will be coming soon.

[Zorran202]

With the Bachmann Edward?

[Robtheredengine]

yep.

[LegoLandVide0s]

@Robtheredengine It's actually Hornby Edward

[Robtheredengine]

@LegoLandVide0s ¬¬yes i do know that

[LegoLandVide0s]

@Robtheredengine but you replied to that guy that yours was a bachmann edward.

[Robtheredengine]

@LegoLandVide0s That comment was a reply to another user who asked if i was going to make V2 of this video and then another user asked if I was going to do it with my bachmann edward and I said yes or yep

I know the diffence between a bachmann engine and hornby engine and I know

which one is which >=

[LegoLandVide0s]

@Robtheredengine Ooooohhhhhhh. K ;)

[railwayfan32]

good job dude

[Robtheredengine]

thanks man, =D glad you like it, version 2 will be coming soon.

[choochooguy63601]

Lookin forward 2 it!

[choochooguy63601]

Wow! The best remake i've seen so far! 100/5 amazing! Well Done Rob!

[Robtheredengine]

thanks, i'm glad you like it =D version 2 will be coming soon.

[GZA92]

You remade one of my all time favs! Thanks! So, what's next?

[Robtheredengine]

i'm not planning to do any remakes until i get bachmann edward and mavis after xmas.

[Klurty34]

Great Models!

I always loved this episode but when I was much yonger I had it on video and I always got confused about why he was talking about Diesel at the beginning; but now I know that the episode is made up of 3 parts including "Pop goes the Diesel," "Dirty Work," and this.

5/5!

[Robtheredengine]

yeah i love this ep too, it was the first one i ever saw. I first saw the clip with duck pushing edward up the hill, i had to wind it back and watch it. thats how i got in to thomas.

[Klurty34]

Intresting...

[Robtheredengine]

thank you i'm glad you like it. ^_^

[GZA92]

yay!

[NVR1800]

Cool!!

[reak7835]

you pulled the runaway cars with a string

[Robtheredengine]

yes i did

[reak7835]

that's okay

thomas and friends did the same thing

[Arthur12336]

Robtheredengine you've done a good job on all of them!

[Robtheredengine]

thank you, i'm glad you like them.

[7Lightening]

Did you print out truck faces and stick them onto the end truck and the brakevan?

[Robtheredengine]

yes i did

[NorwichArlesey]

Brilliant. This is one of my fave eps and you've done a great job of it!!!!

[tombraider247]

you have made this reali well, its just like an original episode, well done :P

[familyguy95]

percy and thomas have nothing to be sorry for they weren't barely in the story

[erasermotorlizard]

... that sounds like ringo. is it?

[startug]

Yes.

[TheBeatles15]

awesome! great work!

[AdamsWii]

LOL

[su57ds1]

I could say this was just about show accuracy awesome

[FanToAll]

i luv it!!

I didn't think he'd make it after that near-missing collision with James! I mean, that was just too close!

Good Video!!!

[FunnehVids]

I love it so much its great!!!!!!!!!!!!

[ThessaTheCat]

wow, I remember watching thomas the tank engine as a kid (as in, from the moment I was born til i was 9 XD)and I'm happy to see that people still enjoy watching thomas the tank engine, now, I'm happy

[KrustyBurritoVideos]

Awesome job!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Gojira73rules]

I like how you combined techniques together in certain spots.

It gave this "remake" as sense of realism compared to those who'd try stop-motion throughout the who film.

[stepneyfan]

how do you do re-makes? please tell me

[Coffeeshop246]

Can somebody tell me how to put videos on youtube? I tried it before by importing something from movie maker, but it didn't work.

[meerkater]

I import mine by using a record program like FRAPS or Hypercam 1 or 2 and select the view screen and start recording the movie there!

hope this helps...

[Coffeeshop246]

Yeah, I posted that comment a while ago, and I've already figured out how to put videoes on, but thanks anyway.

[rhysicus]

briliant video dude!

[barnellyo]

wow this is sooo kwel its just like the real thing! great work!

[JUSTINCUETO]

Hello

Are you only getting those of your hornby thomas and friends trains or your parents?

[Robtheredengine]

what do you mean?

[trainzvideo08]

try making actual sets, make backgrounds and such, I like your models

[thomasfan15]

what were those coaches that james were pulling

[Robtheredengine]

caledonian coaches

[siberiabear]

I'm making my own thomas series,but with new engines as soon as I get my wagons for the series

[siberiabear]

was it an earler model?

[Robtheredengine]

no i don't think it is

[siberiabear]

was it the red oxide van?

[Robtheredengine]

yes it is the red oxide van but a little bit lighter

[siberiabear]

I mean what company was the van by.

[Robtheredengine]

it was a hornby thomas van.

[siberiabear]

what company?

[Robtheredengine]

what do you mean what company

[siberiabear]

where did you get the light brown van with the face on it?

[Robtheredengine]

i got a normal van and then printed off a face and stuck it on the van

[RailroadMan14]

Great remake of a great episode!

[ethanstein]

awesome remake! the best one i have seen yet!

good luck with your other remakes!

[mjboomer11]

how'd you get edward?

[Robtheredengine]

I got him from a model shop, he's the hornby edward

[thomasredwallfan]

Cool remake. Btw is this the UK audio?

[thomasfilippo96]

of course it is!!!!!

[mjboomer11]

how'd you get edward?

[GordonLover04]

it's the hornby one.

[Isaacsac2]

Cool video!

[Isaacsac2]

Can you upload more videos like this one?

[Robtheredengine]

sure when I get the time

[Isaacsac2]

Thank You

[calparjay]

no! 11 stars

[captstar1]

That was a good reinactment. I love how u did the angles, reminded me of the actual ep!

[AlexKouhiFan]

Excellent.

[Headbanger14]

I love how you stuck faces on the trucks. I wish I was able to do that with my trucks when I was younger. But I didn't have Internet back then! :(

[sparkshot]

I like the way you have tried to stay faithfull to the original camera angles, as well as Duck being pulled out 'juddering', nice touch  :)

[thomasfan4]

Awsome! 10 stars

[thomasfan4]

Awsome! 10 stars

[TobyandThomasFan]

This is good Renacment. 10/10

[missoliverandblossom]

Nice work.

[x00001]

10 out of 10

[mjboomer11]

awsome!

[lolguy543]

oh thank you thank you thank you thank you!!! i all ways ALL WAYS wanted to see this in HO

[lolguy543]

sorry 00

[lolguy543]

sorry 00

[lolguy543]

im british u see

[donaldengine9]

HO and 00 guage are the came.

[donaldengine9]

I mean the same. Excuse the typo.

[StanierJack]

Very Good

[StanierJack]

Very Good

[RobertHew]

good reenactment

[tmurphy828]

cool

[Disneylover89]

Well done replica of the actual episode.

[Bladez636no2]

That was Awesome Man. It was very Good!

[ThomasUKepisodes]

brilliant well done rob this is donaldthescotsihtwin this is my account for uploading uk thomas episodes

[Robtheredengine]

Thanks you for the comment

[trainxing100]

Why do all the people who use hornby have bachmann james?!?!?!

[thomasredwallfan]

I think it's because the bachmann version looks more like the TV kind.

[trainxing100]

your right