Added: 4 years ago
From: Tgunn115
Views: 128,393
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (279)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Matthew 2:6! In my heart I am Israel! Shalom Israel!

  • Anyone ever notice that the most evil ppl in the world have died in.. "painless" ways? Hitler shot himself in the head, Stalin I believe died in his sleep (although that is only what I had heard), an Osama bin Laden was shot in the head by an elite Navy SEAL. Why don't u ever hear about the most evil people dying painful or humiliating deaths? Simple, because the good in people prevailed over vengeance.

  • This should have been number 1. Sure, the Godfather and Citizen Kane are both fantastic, but this deserved the number 1 spot.

  • This film should be viewed by every person at least once in their lifetime, because the moment we deny and forget that this ever happened; it's the moment we run the risk of allowing such a thing to happen again.

  • This is like Steven Spielberg's Raging Bull

  • @Fredwilson45 Um no. Martin Scorsese's did Raging bull and that movie sucked. It's wayy overrated. Yes, I am the minority. However, Raging Bull was as boring as hell & it's just about some douche bag boxer.The movie keeps dragging on and never really goes anywhere. I think that most people like it because it's vastly different from anything else. That's true. However it's vastly different in a very BAD way. Schindler's List was WAYYYYY better and not boring even though it was longer.

  • @09tranm It didn't suck; you just can't appreciate great filmmaking.

  • @ANOMALY1ate Well that's my opinion. If you want to watch a movie that's seriously is about 1 douchebag who's not even cool like Hannibal, Darth Vader, or even the Zodiac Killer(another true story "Zodiac" was actually quite good) then go ahead. I won't stop you enjoy whatever film you want. However(mild spoiler), I found raging bull to be boring, slow, and it seemed to go nowhere except from a guy beating his wife, accusing his brother, and getting fat & ugly.

  • @09tranm Schindler's List is a greater film that's defiinitely true but saying Raging Bull sucked is just stupid. Have you seen it more then once?, because maybe a re-watch could let it sink in it would be brilliant if Raging Bull swaped places with this though but it didn't suck in anyway, i'm suprised your comment actually got some thumb up's....1.The Godfather.2.2001: A Space Odyssey.3.Schindler's List.4.12 Angry Men.5.Citizen Kane imo... Raging Bull is top atleast top 10

  • @EnterTheWuTang1 Sorry but I honestly don't care. If you liked that movie I'm cool with it, but for me it sucked. I hated that movie and found it very overrated. I'm not saying Martin Scorseses is a bad director I really liked Goodfellas,Taxi Driver, and Shutter Island was great too. However, Raging Bull come on a douchebag boxer who gets fat at the end. I paid close attention to that movie & really tried to like it, but if a movies really that good you shouldn't try to like it.

  • @09tranm Well yea ive seen my fair share of "masterpiece's" which I didn't think were masterpieces but Raging Bull was just so powerful and SHutter Island is his worst film imo lol i'm glad you liked those other two though. Have you seen The King Of Comedy,Mean streets,Alice Doesn't Live here Anymore,The LAst Temptation Of Christ,Casino or The Departed? hopefuly you would like those. I think he's easily one of the top 3 best directors

  • @EnterTheWuTang1 Well I thought Shutter Island was just pretty good. Anyways, I've never seen any of those. I've seen the Departed though and I'm sorry to say I didn't like it.I mean Martin Scorses has a slight problem of making his characters cuss wayyyy too much. I mean I don't mind if a character cusses alot it makes them bad ass but every 5 seconds makes it annoying. I mean I just didn't get into the departed. I later saw Infernal Affairs(the original) which was much better.

  • @09tranm I see what you mean about the cussing, I usually find it funny alot of the time to be honest. Ive still gotta see Internal Affairs

  • @09tranm Raging Bull is a better made film than Schindler's List.

  • @spxeli I disagree. It's all a matter of opinion, but I think that Raging Bull SUCKS!! and it's overrated. There, I said it. I'm sorry if I offended you. If you liked Raging Bull that's totally cool with me. I don't care. All I know is that, I hated it, and I don't give a FUCK about Jake because he's a douche, but I care more about Oskar. Schindler saved people, but Jake beat his wife. I didn't find Raging Bull entertaining in any sense. I just found it dull.

  • @spxeli Don't start a debate with me on which movie is better because it's all a matter of opinion. I was merely expressing my opinions out loud. So, I'll just say this again. I'm sorry if I offended you, but I really don't want to get into this. If you really like Raging Bull that much go on the Raging Bull page and say how it's a lot better than Schindler's List. I don't care. Just don't try to troll me. Peace out.

  • @09tranm Okay... But I have to ask, if that's the case, why did you go on Raging Bull's video to say the exact same thing?

    Responding to your other post: I don't see why disliking the central character in Raging Bull should influence how it's a better crafted film...

  • @spxeli I was merely pissed off. For me watching Raging Bull was a chor. A movie should be enjoyable and entertaining. It should touch a person. That's what a great film does. Raging Bull literally pissed me off. I don't care how original or how good the acting is in Raging Bull it was still a bullsh*t movie in my book. Again, sorry for pounding on your movie. If you love it then go ahead and enjoy it. Now, I know Martin Scorseses is a great director I really enjoyed Goodfellas.

  • @Fredwilson45 But this is more serious.

  • Comment removed

  • :14 - :31 Goeth was as dry as a desert.

  • Anyone else hear the Lawrence of Arabia theme at the end?

  • @supermario0527 Lawrence of Arabia was the next film discussed so it was just about to carry over.

  • Angels Anyone? Based on real human compassion in a time of horror. Oscars earned his wings. Brilliant movie.

  • Genius film.

  • this is about movies not whether or not you think the holocaust happened

  • @stalkervision Why do you have to say this? What is your goal? What is wrong with you?

  • I did look into it and it is as flawed as they come

  • Of course nothing is a hundred percent accurate and its a movie so it takes libirty with it but the holocaust my friend is not B.S.

  • spielberg even though he is a master at his art,is blind when making films.His families traumatic time under the nazis,has will be shown in his films.To view this ,i sudgest you go to saving private ryan,and look at a critics point of view,its very interesting and very thought provoking

  • I can safely say that this movie is better than Lawrence of Arabia.

  • @stalkervision (cont.) ne. Now gimme evidence that the holocaust didn't happen. Don't cherry pick or skip my question with rants or circular reasoning. I know it will be diffucult for you doing something this hard work but please try. You said there's plenty of these suppose facts, then offer them. They also have to be verified too okay so no consparicy junk. If you have alot just PM me.

  • @stalkervision (cont,) But lets say spieldberg fabricated that scene. Does that somehow dismiss the whole holocaust. No not even close. Your against experts who look at documents and transcripts during WWII where they are facts not bogus youtube vids. Your against eye witnesses have you seen them? You "pawned" me lol wow this clearly shows you never had a real debate in your life. Pawned me with such exxagerated claims? Did you even pass college because I be embarrassed if you graduated from mi

  • @stalkervision What fact? Lol now I really doubt you had straight A's in history in college. You have to gimme a better link because yours was poorly constructed that I couldn't search it. But to me it seems your cherry picking some events. Were discussing the holocaust not the movie accuracy, You advocated that the holocaust didn't occur and I say it did. When I ask for evidence of why you think it didn't happen, you gimme poor laughable sources like youtube and assertions.

  • @stalkervision (cont.) holocaust happen. People who refuse this events are making fun of because of their ignorance. Again you have to show your position is valid first. Where is the document or transcript that supports your claim like the hill between veranda or the false eye witness account. Where is it? Is clearly self-evident that you read haven't read a book about the holocaust or even WWII.

  • @stalkervision Where are your sources?! I'm tired of repeating myself and you only offer a long rant of how ignorant I am. Seriously have you ever research anything in your life or do you just believe things with no evidence? And people don't look at both side because if the other side offers no evidence and sounds incredibly stupid they won't even look at it. Do you think experts actually investigate the claim that the moon landing was a hoax? Of course not because it did happen just like the

  • @stalkervision Now please where are this stone cold facts? You shouting saying is true doesn't it make it true. If you don't provide me with facts with sources then I see nothing in the world would make you change your mind.

  • @stalkervision (cont.) I'm not playing your game. You haven't yet presented any facts for which you claim there is plenty of facts supporting your theory. Then where are this so called facts? Youtube? Pal in college you be making fun of. I also did research papers and you have to present at least 20 sources of your material. Holocaust supporter? Oh yeah because I just loved what happened to the jews right? Please that was a childish ad hominem attack.

  • @stalkervision (cont.) Seriously have you? I give no evidence for my side lol really? Get a book in your local library about the holocaust there is the evidence. Then look at the back of the book where they cite their sources. I will refute your oppossiton until you actually come with a reliable source. Do you know what reliable means? Please say you do because it has become self-evident that you don't know what facts, evidence, and reliable means.

  • @stalkervision Can you please decrease your rants please? It gets annoying reading your reply while is all rants and ad hominem. What facts have you presented? Seriously pal where? All I read was exxagerated claims and just saying its true just because you say so or some idiot says that. I told you for sources and you finally give one but seriously thats your source into your crazy thought that the holocaust didnt happen wow. Have you read a holocaust history book?

  • @stalkervision (cont.) shown me that what your saying is true. I'm going to ask again where are your sources! Show me!

  • @stalkervision (cont.) nocide of combodians under Pol Pot or Josef Stalin's mass extermination of his own people. I don't get how you have gotten straight A's in history with denying the holocaust. I mean the facts were in front of you, the books has plenty of sources, evidence, and even pictures! And yet you still deny it? And don't use circular reasoning on me to try to blame the burden on me. I asked you first and you ignored my request. You haven't even

  • @stalkervision Where are your sources! From which documents or transcripts shows that your claims are true? Please I wanna where you get your information? I wanna know if there reliable, because you only shown me youtube where there are plenty of wacky consparicy videos here. Also if you did actually got straight A's in college, you would have known that there is irrefutable evidence that the holocaust did occur. To deny that is like denying the ge

  • @stalkervision Do you know the definition of facts and reasearch? I don't think you do. Please provide sources! Where can I find these information where its been proven right? Your spouting exxagerated claims with no evidence and yet you want to be taken serious? No way pal. Look up the defintion research, then you actually do it okay? If you keep doing rants instead of facts then im wasting my time.

  • @stalkervision (cont.) ging their story each time. 

  • @stalkervision Youtube is not a realiable source. Do you know what is evidence or even facts mean? Its mean fact checked and proven to be accurate. Stop being gullaby into B.S. consparicy junk. Now im going to ask again gimme evidence real evidence that the holocaust didn't occur? Actually do reasearch you know read books and hear experts. Oh yeah experts busted by holocaust skeptics? haha yeah right. Holocaust deniers are the ones getting corrected each time. Thats why they keep chan

  • @stalkervision What real evidence? Is it youtube videos or consparicy websites? Are you actually implying that eyewitness accounts, confessions, and experts who studied the holocaust and did actual research more longer than you and me are simply lying. Please provide actual evidence that the holocaust never happened or was exxagerated. Because experts would say otherwise.

  • can't wait to get this on Blu-Ray

  • @stalkervision watch?v=USZcrMn48Xg

  • @stalkervision Alright. Your evidence may disprove SOME cases we see, but it does not disprove the whole holocaust. Sure there were some gassings and maybe even some overexagerations, but shit still went down. What about the Katyn massacre, thousands of officers and citizens of Poland were slaughtered. I mean, people still died because of the war. I can believe some of your statements, but you werent there either, so keep an open mind and be respectful, thats all

  • @stalkervision You can't disprove the Holocaust. It was very real. Reguardless of how much evidence there is on such specific instances, this was a very real and painfull time. I'd like to see you tell all this to the families who had relatives and lovers massacred.

  • "That's very cruel of you, Oskar; you're giving them hope!"

    Should I be sent to hell for laughing at that line?

  • @stalkervision you should've been there, just proving the truth. so you could see and believe. and you should die for such disrespectful statement

  • throughout WW2 the USA war department "Psychological Warfare Division" conspired with the soviet jew propaganda minister Ilya Ehrenburg to promulgate many slanderous lies about the Germans such as the bogus "holocaust" stories. The novelist Vladimir Nabokov gave this assessment of Ehrenburg who is regarded by many to be the main organizer behind the holocaust fraud.

    -

    "As a writer he doesn't exist, Ehrenburg. He is a journalist. He was always corrupt."

  • @stalkervision the only thing I can say to you is to get out and talk to people. I have my opinion, you have yours. I'm sure we all agree that youtube is an untainted fountain of truth, but if you get the chance, before they all die off, try to get off the damn internet and talk to some of the people who "claim" to have actually been there. Fornicating and reading the papers is much easier though, so don't feel obligated by any means Clamence.

  • @stalkervision perhaps if you gave sources for your counter arguments we could better educate ourselves?

  • @stalkervision cherry picking? is that what you're going to call it? Are you claiming that the holocaust didn't exist simply because of exaggerated (and sometimes extremely exaggerated) testimony and claims at the Nuremberg Trials? Tell me, does your exhaustive research consist of talking to any of the American WWII vets who were among the first to reach the camps? Have you talked to any of the survivors, or should I say "fakers", who still have serial numbers tattooed on their arms?

  • @stalkervision yes, you are correct - the original numbers of Jews slaughtered during the holocaust are being downgraded, but are you implying that smaller numbers make the atrocity any less reprehensible? They quietly changed the plaque at Auschwitz from 4 million dead to 1.5 million. Hell, it may even be lower than that number. I guess that somehow makes it better hunh?

  • @stalkervision What do you mean...."real facts"? Curious.... what's ur belief now?

  • Why is Spielberg discussing his own movie? It's weird.

  • the Americans were so disheveled in 1945 that the zionists easily misled them to believe that the Germans had exterminated jews. In 1939 the author William Dudley Pelley published "The 45 Questions Most Frequently Asked About the Jews With the Answers by Pelley" which documented how the number of jews in America skyrocketed from 4 million to 12 million during the 1930s. Nearly all of the european jews were transported to America before WW2 even commenced. The holocaust story is outright fraud.

  • We will never learn. The only time I see human beings putting our small differences aside and coming together are if little aliens come down and threaten humans and the planet. I cant see this happening. Or if the planet is threatened by a massive asteroid and we only have days to live. This could happen. Or if we are threatened by a disease like bird or swine flu that kills millions of people, and doesnt discriminate agains rich or poor, black or white, young or old, Christian Jew Muslim...

  • making germans look bad: RULE 1: schindlers list...(period)

  • good, those fucking nazi german pussies deserve this shit you fucking cunt

  • Your a loony.

  • schindler was falsely potrayed in spielberg's movie, in real life he did nothing extraodinary and "his" workers when work exhausted ended in crematoriums regardless, infact he changed his teams many times, schindler was just a nazi, relax mate

  • @hzj79 So what are you a WW2 historian or something? or just a stupid inbred prick who lives on hate

  • wow! it doesnt matter what race you are what happened was inhuman! it makes me so sad :( i cant believe that people can do that it really is confusing

  • FUCKING FASCISTS DIE HARD.

  • they did, and it's gone.

    but remember an eye for an eye makes the world blind.

    we shouldn't stoop to their level.

  • You're absolutly right.

  • This is a feature film, not documentary one. Great movie, i've watched the fiilm first time today and i love it. I dont know the truth, my brother said that jews made not only bad weapons they made faultless one that went to the eastern front, if russian soldiers arrested Schindler they would hang him, no offence, just my thought. God bless all jews.

  • actually this movie is great, beautiful and very powerful.. a real piece of art.. i definately agree that it doesn't fully represent the truth and of course the holocaust is made up by jews but do not undermine the film...

  • lol!!! the holocaust is made up? hahaha hey there you delusional moron.

  • ... i am not going to say anything lol you have to be a troll.

  • Some ppl were jealous, yes, but thats not the main reason.

  • Its the best movie ever made...

    Awful and sad story (I cry like a baby everytime I watch it), but a fantastic movie and fantastic actors.

    Beautiful made, with the black & white-colours etc.

    A masterpiece in its on way.

    Unfortunately the story isn´t made up.

  • The Jewish people have been the most persecuted group thoughout history, and they have also been the most successful people throughout history. I am not Jewish, but I admire them as a people.

    Had Hitler not persecuted the Jews, he would have had the bomb first, and you would not know the meaning of freedom.

  • there are good and bad ppl withing all creeds and races

  • of course

  • do not make the mistake to generalize and judge all jews as being egotistical or watever u are trying to say..they were and are still MANY poor jews. but NOTHING any jew or Jewish people could have done as a whole merits the unspeakable things done to them in the holocaust.

  • What's a person worth to you ??? no no no no what's one worth to you ??? Amon you drive a hard bargain !!! haaaahhahaaaa.....the life of a jew,how much is each worth ??

  • Haaaaaaaaaahhhaaa that's cruel !!!!

  • You are probably right. this movie makes you doubt a lot about this film, besides its pretty story.

  • What do you consider a good movie? Who do you consider a good director?

  • So much hate in some of these comments. Folks, arent movies like these supposed to give us more insight to prevent something like the Holocaust from happening again?

  • love schindlers list. terrific scenes and actors.

  • In my opinion, Scindler's list is the best movie of all time - any other film in film making history moves u, touch u, twist u, gets u so emotional involved in the scenes n leaves u so shocked so breathless with impression that doesn't leave u in ur cold dreams like that one. any other movie can influence u in that way that u realize how shocking n vicious hate can b - that's the most important lesson nowadays

  • I do know a malcontent little child who fell in a pile of shit. Loved the taste of that shits so much he is trying to pedal it to make himself feel good. But im guessing you cant feel good. beings like you have no emotions when it comes to killings. You thrive on the most debased vile acts as to get type of a sensation that you call pleasure. You just dont get it. When you lived first hand with people who went through it. Your books are only good for the asswhipe they are.

  • Im just wondering how creatures like you can exist. You walk upright. Have hands to grab and a eyes to see. Your head making lies to a much older world whos familys lived in those times. I feel sorry for you to have such hate to write such things.

  • Im more part of the truth movment then your aware of. but i wont support the denier of the holocaust. Its more then accademic. Its well archived with many goverments having their own film to show the world this happend, When you quote one source in a book is your last name Barbi? As in Clouse

  • Personaly pal, Having eaten at a friends house whos father was one decent man. He had the tatoo of the camps. My Father a ww2 vet. Seen them. What your doing buy quoteing how many so called researches is promoting lies. I would rather get my truth from honest people. As each decade goes by Theres less first hand wittness and victums of the Holocaust. And the association to the Jew made at the end of your comment says your racist with that accusition

  • The tiny tattoos were applied so that one camper couldn't kill another camper and then try to assume his identity in order to escape punishment. How else could the Germans ensure that such a thing wouldn't happen? The tattoos were also applied so that the best-possible medical care could be provided without making any serious ID errors when doing diagnosis, dispensing medicine or doing surgeries. Remember that there were many hardcore criminals in those camps so the tattoos were protection.

  • I cant belive you have the nerve to say that. Man you pathetic. Even a criminal does not desreve to be starved tortured then murderd you little fool, Why cant you finf a girl or a porn flik then go fuckyourself to death.

  • Men, Women, Elderly folk, children and infants.

    Yeah, REAL hardcore criminals right there.

  • They were Displaced Persons who fared far better in the camps than they would have in the streets where German citizens would have targeted them out of revenge for all of their war dead.

  • Lets face some harsh reality here, starting with the fact that you are a moron.

  • You, fellow human, are a disgrace to our species.

  • in 1993 is that movie really made in black and white

  • perche un uomo e cosi bastardo! perche un uomo e cosi vigliaco!

    perche un uomo e cosi infamme!

    perche un uomo e cosi poco uomo!

    e tu dio! dove stavi? ( e gia' sei un uomo anche tu)

  • This was a really good film, shows the reality of the Holocaust unlike any other movie I have seen. They should also make a movie like this about the Holodomor in the Ukraine.

  • thats low

  • One of the things that bother me about this movei is the fact that in reality,Oskar didn't make the list,most of the people in it paid to be there.Schindler just put in the list some people he knew.That scene in the movie of him making the list didn't happen.Plus the ending where he cries saying he could have saved more didn't happen either.He just left with his wife,his lover and a few prisoners.

  • What do you mean most of the people paid to be there? He took on workers he didn't need and paid THEM.

  • Schindler only put in the list some people he knew.Schindler NEVER paid for a jew to work for him.Just do some research on google if you don't want to read the book about the survivors.

  • And the person who made the list was Marcel Goldberg,a man from the jewish police,the OD.People paid him to be in the list,he made the list,Schindler had no control over the list.

    What Schindler did was to protect the people once they were working for him.There were no killings on Emalia,the place the jews worked for Schindler.

  • If they ever bring back a new list The Dark Knight will be on it.

  • No But Watchmen was still good though.

  • I think so too. The Dark Knight was amazing.

  • I must find a site where I can watch the full movie or upload it on to youtube.

  • Titanic is overrated

  • No not really...

  • i watched it in skewl da fuvking jermans !!!!!!

  • what?

  • It's funny how you speak of them as ONE MAN. What kind of justice is that?

  • get a life!

  • Your right, it wasn't 6 million people, it was 11 million Jews, Serbs, Communists, Disabled, Black, and anyone else not Aryan. Now stop trying to hide from a great tragedy. Just accept it. It's people like you the remake events like this in history. You must learn, not run.

  • even though it was 11 million jews. 1 million would still have been unbelievable . it's ignorant fucks like you that keep our country form moving forward

  • it was 6 million jews and 5 million other including homosexuals gypsies and i forgot the rest.

  • Please don't tell me you read that nazi propaganda book called "did six million really die?"

  • and polish? maybe..

  • "i forgot the rest." Then you missed the whole point.

  • Which was? Oh and jehovas witnesses were also targeted and handi caps and old people and mentally disabled people. now i remember!!!!

  • where did you get your facts from tell me what propaganda website you visited.

  • Lawrence of Arabia is my favorite film of all time, but Schindler's List does NOT belong under it.

  • USA sent medical teams led by Major Charles Larson into those camps to do autopsies and they never uncovered even one person who had been murdered by the Germans. All those who died were the result of malnutrition and disease caused by The Allies when they bombed all of the German supply warhouses and railways. Jews undeniably targeted Germans though with communism, hyper-inflation, Morgenthau Plan, Kaufman Plan, Balfour Declaration and the 1933 "Hate Germany!" campaign of boycotts.

  • ummm why did they imprison them in the first place?

  • Same reason the USA imprisoned all of their japanese citizens which was to keep them from gaining the opportunity to undermine their national war effort. Grow a brain.

  • poor comparison , you may need to grow another brain.The Jews were being persecuted even before the " national war effort "even began

  • These facts are absolutely meaningless. They had 'facts' back then for supporting Aryan superiority. There are 'facts' to help you argue anything you want, to prove that every race deserves to be hated. It's a mistake to assume that evidence makes something true. In the end, no one deserves to be hated and that is the only truth.

  • ghoulrasmussen are you still around? Shit, man---I thought the ward commander revoked your internet useage because you kept soiling your pants

  • museum of tollerance fuck you

  • I can't believe people nowadays actually talk like this. The only good part is when the Jews got shot? You do know that everything in this movie is true? Yet you laugh at people getting shot? Do you have no sympathy at all?

  • its only a movie , now get over it

  • This should be higher. The list should be like this:

    1. The Godfather 1 & 2

    2. 2001

    3. Gone with the Wind

    4. Psycho

    5. Schindler's List

  • This movie touched me personally. This is the only movie on the list to do that. The Godfather I &2 are both very entertaining but they don't really make you feel anything much. Not saying that this is better it's just that this should be much higher in the list.

  • I think the list, is based off of more than how it touched people. I think its more... How they were casted, script, directed, acted, sets, budget, story, etc etc... Ya know? I agree though this movie is allways in the back of my mind. As for people who think its funny, let it be, just let it be. They will see someday.

  • I've always believed Schindlers List deserved a No.1 or atleast 2 Spot. Psycho is a classic as all 5 of those are but as far as 2001 goes and I guess your referring to 2001 a space odessey? Then that cant be right. 1.One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest 2.Schindler's List 3.Psycho 4.Scent of a Woman 5.Rudy