Added: 4 years ago
From: TheGreatPerformers
Views: 34,439
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (54)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Well, I can tell you call that I heard this singer in concert. She not only sang but cast a spell over her audience - a magic that perhaps her recordings cannot achieve. - John Austin, Australia

  • Lovely and exquisite. Singers today have no concept of technique and artistry as exemplified by Vallin and artists of the Golden Era.

  • the articulation of the consonants is so perfect.she was perfect,what legato,what colour, what a voice.

  • très belle, merci.

  • ...beautiful

  • I love these recordings. I had no idea there were recordings of Hahn's playing. I love Ninon Vallin's singing.

  • J'adore, merci.

  • What's with the relentless plugging of this Spanos guy on every page of the great songs? And from different identities - or are they? Jeez - people are actually able to make up their own minds!

  • @elenikiroy Yes,of course, people are able to make up their minds. Are you influenced by the comments you see on a certain video?I'm not, and have my own opinion. I also compared.But YT was created to give people opportunity to express their opinions and compare versions. Don't you think that some Spanos's fans could listen to many other versions and compare?It's not the end of the world.If there were more comments on this video you already wouldn't see at all someone mentioning Spanos long ago.

  • Awesome! TY.

  • Superb

  • Dreadful singing ! But what a piano sound and intelligence ! Who is the pianist ??

  • @DDBconducts

    Not dreadful singing. Amazing singing.

  • Just beautiful....."with the composer at the piano"???  What a rare honour indeed.

  • Una voce semplicemente INCANTEVOLE!

    Tono, delicatezza, grazia...STUPENDA ! Grazie per il post e grazie a Françoise che mi fa partecipe di questa meraviglia!

  • @jeanmolin55 I agree. You might also want to listen to another simply enchanting voice of Nicholas Spanos in L'heure exquise for comparison. Also tone, delicate sound, grace. Another wonderful version IMO.

  • @tamerlano236 barf.

  • @tamerlano If you don't like Vallin you can not listen to her. Tastes differ. What is your favourite version?

  • @tamerlano236 My issue is certainly not with Vallin, who is heavenly, but with your constant need to espouse the glories of Spano at every chance. He is a fine singer, great, let it go...it just starts to verge on trolling after a point.

  • @tamerlano It's very subjective what sounds more heavenly to different people. For me Spanos's version is the very best. You are entitled to your own opinion as much as me and can think in a different way. But if my comments irritate you so much you can merely not read them. What's the problem? Happy New Year to you!

  • Thanks for this great clip. It's a real treat to hear Hahn play these unique pieces and to hear Vallin as well. I never heard of her before, but the Hahn songs are treasures to me.

  • Versi, Musica e Voce: paradisiaci !

    Reynaldo Hahn ha scritto davvero una musica divina.

    Stupendi i versi di Verlaine.

    La voce della Vallin è emozionante anche in Tyndaris.

    frabru-Italia

  • I like Graham and Vallin. How can you compare really.

    I think Graham's recording is impeccible. The only other artist that does recordings like that that I know of is Elly Ameling. I mean artists who when you hear you don't really think anything should be changed. Vallin's voice is fascinating. Such a direct use of the words. Not that she sounds like a tenor, but the direct diction reminds me of Caruso actually.

  • Merveilleux, merci. Et vive Youtube qui permet de tels échanges entre les époques et les pays

  • Magical! The piano gives me shivers!!! I haven't wanted to buy recordings in years, but now I know I want to get Hahn's complete recordings. I was only familiar with the recording where he sings and accompanies himself. You can tell they took the time to rehearse this thoroughly.

  • La belle époque de la chanson française... Un contrôle, une articulation parfaits!

  • Comment removed

  • Beautiful lyrics and performance. So delicate and sensitive. Brava.

  • Un grand poète... une voix magnifique... Quelle merveille!

  • Really beautiful.

  • All these Hahn-accompanied songs were in Romophone's complete compilation of the recordings of Reynaldo.

    This Vallin side is, of course, supreme. She particularly catches the quiet rapture of the piece. Magnifique!

  • RAPTURE! le mot juste!!!

  • I sing this song, I think the singer could incorporate a little more feeling, not that it isn't a beautiful voice & song. I melts me into the ground.

  • these two songs are so beautiful. Thank you very much to make me discoverReynaldo Hahn! I already knew that vallin was marvelous.

  • J'aime cette voix.

  • Many thanks ! Very beautiful song and voice ! I love it !

  • L'Heure exquise is breathtakingly beautiful and utterly divine when Ninon Vallin sings! It sounds so very 30s and it's authentic and heartfelt so it is great to listen to it at any age! I recently heard this song performed by a mezzo soprano, Susan Graham and it's just as beautiful too.

  • l prefer Susann Graham

  • thanks so

    much 4 posting

  • Because of you - I now have a new favorite! I love her so much! What lush legato. Intonation perfect. She is new to me. I love her! Vive la Vallin!!! I want to hear everything she has recorded. I hope she recorded much.

    Merci!

  • Ninon Vallin was the supreme French soprano of the inter-war years. All her recordings are wonderful.

  • Merci pour ce document

  • la mejor interpretación posible de ambas mélodies.

  • Sur mon 78 tours, il y a "Si mes vers avaient des ailes" de l'autre côté de "l'heure exquise". Je n'ai pas obtenu un son aussi bon quand je l'ai repiqué (mais peut-être que mon disque est plus usé) Quel logiciel utilisez-vous ?

  • I just dubbed this from an LP copy I have (Ninon Vallin - Airs d'Opéras and Melodié - References LP 2910023) with a cheap USB turntable.

  • Many thanks for your answer. I'm sorry to have written in french, but I didn't notice you were not french. I have two sets for digitizing 78rpm, a recent turntable adapted with a 1955 Philips cell, and a big one from the 1930' coming from the U.S. (with needle).

    Regards.

  • Thanks for uploading these beautiful songs!!

  • Certainement la reine du chant français

    Merci

  • Je suis d'accord. Il n'y a pas d' autre chanteuse qui peuve chanter la chanson francaise tel exquisitement comme Ninon Vallin.

  • tellement... tellemment... "d'époque"

    à fermer les yeux on entendrait presque le fume-cigarette à embout d'ivoire taper contre le guéridon.

    Excellente idée que cette archive :)

  • thank you for sharing this is beautiful I agree!

  • thank you. such an evocative song. we've all experienced it- that magic of twilight. merci mille fois.

  • Beautiful and thanks so much for the tranlations, it is so kind.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more