i've listened to several covers of this song and not one of them can light a candle to yours. your cover has a pureness about it that the others don't. yours has emotion. this is beautiful.
hello, i wonder if i can make an mp3 out of this for my ipod? i love it much more than the original! i can send you the file after some noise reduction and such?
There are a couple of harmonic tricks in the "people you've been before" section that you missed, but with a voice like that, you don't even need them. :D
YOU'RE JUST FUCKING JEALOUS YOU DON'T HAVE SUCH AN ANGELIC VOICE YOU DUMB FUCK. KEEP TO YOUR FUCKING SELF YOU FUCKING LOSER AND DON'T YOU EVER SAY A GOD DAMN THING ABOUT MY BEST FRIEND.
I hope you die and rot in HELL. Get a LIFE and stop busting on people to make yourself feel better. YOU'RE THE CUNT.
nice job. piano is simple, as it should be for this song. I hate it when people do covers for an irregular instrument for the song, and they just over-do it, however you didn't.
I think it's your voice that makes this cover more than the keyboard, the keyboard is really simplistic. Don't get me wrong, it's nice, but it's definitely your voice that sets this apart from the rest. My joint favourite cover on youtube.
but for real, that was amazing, i did a cover of this song on guitar, but listening to the way you covered it made me feel all beat up inside, in a good way if that makes sense. anway, good job! RIP Elliott Smith
This cover is absolutly amazing, I believe you and TheBrooke are the only people that did the, Elliot Smith "Between The Bars" that I can accually stand. I like it alot with the piano, And you're voice is so melodic. It accually looks as if you're looking to the sky and singing to him. R.I.P. Elliot Smith.
Bravo!!!, amazing version, your voice are so full of fantasy, and the feeling that you put in to the piano, make this cover one of the best for this song, Elliott Smith is great!!! R.I.P.
HonoreYuhas, Your piano version comes from the soul, and therefore a beautiful tribute to Elliott. I've been learning to play piano on my own and have learned most of your version by watching and listening but I'm having trouble seeing the chorus from this angle. Any chance you could tell me which keys to play? Anyway, it's been fun listening to your song over and over again, and I still enjoy it every time.
I really enjoy your music, I have to say that the people that are ignorant enough not to look at a piece of music entirely on its own to to realize that this is a cover of another song, but is a song on its own. That means if it is not exactly like the original it can still be good and in this case amazing. Keep playing and shoot for your dreams for you will surely achieve them.
Wow just realized how completely idiotic my reply was and would like to clarify. I meant that because this is a "cover" it is best to look at as the the singers interpretation of the song. Don't criticize it because it is not identical to the original. Look at it as its own song.
You aren't over singing. It sounds very nice! I had covered this song, but took down the vid because all of the flack I got. Some of Elliott's other fans found it offensive that anyone would dare to cover him. Don't listen to them like I did...
i totally disagree with that bullshit. she has the most beautiful voice on this earth. and i think that it's bullshit that you think she was 'over singing'. she did an amazing job. -cassy
You totally have the voice for it, but your missing chords on the piano, play the "Chris" version of this song and repost it will sound so much better. You already have the vocals for it.
Something about your voice is mesmerizing and it is dulcet yet extremely compelling. I want to hear more.
pinkpiratemomma 3 months ago
do you have music sheets for this? if not you should make some! i'm interested! <3
chadvilla1 5 months ago
do you have tabs? o: so lovely.
JackieFuckedup 10 months ago
Do you have this sheet music?
thorpa01 1 year ago
that was pretty
and wish you did more of his songs:)
TheCHILDRENofTV 1 year ago
i've listened to several covers of this song and not one of them can light a candle to yours. your cover has a pureness about it that the others don't. yours has emotion. this is beautiful.
wpe2007 1 year ago
I personally love your keyboard version. That's the amazing thing about music; it can be translated to and from any instrument. :] Good job.
oOKimbaOo 1 year ago
beautiful! I love it! you've got a pretty voice!
MsHermione2 1 year ago
look up chris garneus cover
AlexManningSL 1 year ago
i know this video is long ago but hopefully you still check up on it, do you have the sheet music for this?
dmx1910 2 years ago
great cover. one of these days someone is going to make it big on an elliott cover
tripsounds010rhcp 2 years ago
hello, i wonder if i can make an mp3 out of this for my ipod? i love it much more than the original! i can send you the file after some noise reduction and such?
BlackScarletLove 2 years ago
It's very pretty.
But girl... be careful with your vocal folds... You should get singing lessons, for you wont hurt your beautiful voice !
Nice arrangements, I thought it would be too simple, but in fact, it's soft, pretty and sober !
paulolegrand29 2 years ago
a dream
just perfect
jumpinlove 2 years ago
i think you'd much rather prefer Chris Garneau's version of this song.
Just putting that out there.
Emericanization 2 years ago
really really good job =)
pedronurmi 2 years ago
Actually it turned out really nice.
Cheers! :)
maurabazzarelli 2 years ago
There are a couple of harmonic tricks in the "people you've been before" section that you missed, but with a voice like that, you don't even need them. :D
keelan111 2 years ago
Really like this. Piano sounds great, especially as you haven't tried to overcomplicate the song.
mcgeorgiecle 2 years ago
here's an idea. . . don't compare yourself to others. . . just sing.
JadedMax 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
top five indie bands
1. elliott smith
2. bright eyes
3. mountain goats
4. fleet foxes
5. kevin m. kirker
but elliott smith will always be #1! we miss you and love you elliott! we'll never forget you! rest in peace
astonishing00 2 years ago
T'was Beautiful.
Thankyou for not ruining my favourite song in the world. You did good, and if Elliot was still alive i think he'd of loved it.
(:
x
Edwards3Carrots 2 years ago 7
thanks for not ruining my fav song! good job
musicismyysalvation 2 years ago
still amazing. better than the original. you're beautiful and your voice is haunting and incredibly soothing. makes me wonder how you hug.
BlackScarletLove 2 years ago
that was really good... i dont comment much...but i had to for you..
rlew5 2 years ago
well done! ^_^
jumpinthevolcano 3 years ago
i love this so much
you have done an awesome job on this cover and
your is truly amazing
mcmcgee 3 years ago
Nice
evhan55 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
......you cunt
ravenluver23 3 years ago
YOU'RE JUST FUCKING JEALOUS YOU DON'T HAVE SUCH AN ANGELIC VOICE YOU DUMB FUCK. KEEP TO YOUR FUCKING SELF YOU FUCKING LOSER AND DON'T YOU EVER SAY A GOD DAMN THING ABOUT MY BEST FRIEND.
I hope you die and rot in HELL. Get a LIFE and stop busting on people to make yourself feel better. YOU'RE THE CUNT.
youarenotchicken 3 years ago
that was to ravenluver23...
again, FUCK OFF.
youarenotchicken 3 years ago
wasnt me my mate sorry i dont have a prblem with it
ravenluver23 3 years ago
amazing version, i like it, seems really timeless
well done ;)
Flavien 3 years ago
perfect.
sashaaaaaaaha 3 years ago
beautiful
StSchouten 3 years ago
love your voice. very soothing.
xatwsx 3 years ago
Interesting cover!
This kind of reminds me of "Pheurton Skeurto" by the band Sunny Day Real Estate.
Your voice is haunting; I like it!
Paradoxinol 3 years ago
I listen to this like everyday lol, more than that
treehamallama 3 years ago
lovely!
treehamallama 3 years ago
flawless.
XRVAEDGEX 3 years ago
nice job. piano is simple, as it should be for this song. I hate it when people do covers for an irregular instrument for the song, and they just over-do it, however you didn't.
:D
noragene 3 years ago
I think it's your voice that makes this cover more than the keyboard, the keyboard is really simplistic. Don't get me wrong, it's nice, but it's definitely your voice that sets this apart from the rest. My joint favourite cover on youtube.
Connayyyy 3 years ago 5
@Connayyyy sorry, but I don't think the keybard is that simplistic...
but it's tru the voice makes the difference!
MsHermione2 1 year ago
i just posted a piano version of this song today, but i definitely like yours more
its nice to see it done differently
this was rly good!!
RevolvingDoors01 3 years ago
amazing song beautiful voice, the piano adds to the emotion of the song, great cover hope to see more
JayT11 3 years ago
beautiful voice!
lykndamuzic 3 years ago
i loved it also i write music if you want to check it out
ndargatis 3 years ago
great job and voice.
j42justin 3 years ago
THIS IS SERIOUSLY MY FAVORITE COVER ON YOUTUBE!!!
but for real, that was amazing, i did a cover of this song on guitar, but listening to the way you covered it made me feel all beat up inside, in a good way if that makes sense. anway, good job! RIP Elliott Smith
pln573 3 years ago
perfect, and good job, he would have loved it... congratulations, seriously
HardDayKid 3 years ago
soooooo goood!
xoxjenaxox 3 years ago
Your voice is amazing!
ruxboeu 3 years ago
Oh my god this is so amazing.
sk8tolive123 3 years ago
You have an amazing voice!
Your piano is rather nice, although I like the guitar better :)
Johnsoniscoolandya 3 years ago
Wow. The piano actually is really interesting. It takes the song into a whole different realm, gives it a haunting quality. Great job.
mattjay503 3 years ago
This cover is absolutly amazing, I believe you and TheBrooke are the only people that did the, Elliot Smith "Between The Bars" that I can accually stand. I like it alot with the piano, And you're voice is so melodic. It accually looks as if you're looking to the sky and singing to him. R.I.P. Elliot Smith.
KingOfFools135 3 years ago
My fave Between the Bars cover - I love your voice.
lister1nePaz 3 years ago
Great Job!
solonakatierap 3 years ago
Comment removed
pharmacy4thewell 3 years ago
Similar to Feist's voice, I like it.
Really good, props to you on the piano work.
This song's my favorite!
Lorsbloodytask 3 years ago
Very beautiful.
Elliott Smith has always been my favorite.
:D:D
lovelikeabodybag 3 years ago
I'm in love with you.
UtBDan 4 years ago
this is a great cover, this song sounds amazing on piano
falcostrife 4 years ago
Bravo!!!, amazing version, your voice are so full of fantasy, and the feeling that you put in to the piano, make this cover one of the best for this song, Elliott Smith is great!!! R.I.P.
madaco05 4 years ago
Cute and jazzy, I like this a lot, keep up the good work. Do you think you could send me the sheet music/tablature for your cover? ^_^;
theasianyee 4 years ago
This is the best Elliott Smith cover I've heard.
I feel like other covers sound too much like lounge music or that people are trying to over sing/sound too proper.
I think yours best reflects Elliott's kind of understated voice. Lovely!
(Power to us who cover songs on the piano!)
truncatedsymphony 4 years ago
wow
aulrich 4 years ago
Your voice is so smoky and mysterious - like Feist meets Fiona Apple. (:
caithead 4 years ago 2
love it
HellBent1337 4 years ago
wow.
you're really, really talented.
this is incredible.
keep up the good work.
if you ever get the chance, check out my videos... let me know what you think =]
xAnastasiaMarie 4 years ago
wow, very well
Railwayii 4 years ago
my cousin RAE RCHARDSON HATES YOU but i think you rock keeep up the good work (she is retarded)
chrystalblossom 4 years ago
2LOL
What kind of a comment is that?
BlackScarletLove 4 years ago
be proud my friend.
few people can sing elliot smith songs and make it sound good.
good job.
cannyzilla 4 years ago
This is very nice, and is a very good piano interpretation, like it :)
asiankatie 4 years ago
It sounds good. You have a great voice. HOORAH.
TheShizzlest 4 years ago
what is to be said??
cool manipulation of tha song.
love ur voice with tha body rythm>>
:]
zhaf90 4 years ago
you are very talented,this song really speaks to me
chrystalblossom 4 years ago
great work I love it.
dwooley 4 years ago
Good adaptation. Be proud.
confiscator 4 years ago
this is very good. i've watched many covers of this on youtube, and for me, you're one of the few that make it your own.
asbfo 4 years ago
AUWSOME!!!! I think you should try to do some bass notes when "the people youve been before" It would really add resonance.
Swamy456 4 years ago
You are beautiful, your voice is beautiful, your interpretation of this song is sad and beautiful, and this is a beautiful song, to boot.
Beautiful...
ModestMousekateer 4 years ago 2
u have a good voice, u shouldnt whisper so much but u picked an awesome song to cover
renoufarnold 4 years ago
çok yeteneklisin ;) ı'm a turkısh
dreamgirldidem 4 years ago
I never knew it was guitar.. pretty cool.
rupest 4 years ago
you spelled his stage name wrong. it was elliott, not elliot.
but good job anyway.
LegendaryAdrenaline 4 years ago
Wow , cool ..
And you did it your self ?! ö
Fiierne 4 years ago
I get the feeling this song means as much to you as it does to me...
Brad208 4 years ago
so beautiful, i think ur cover is the best one on youtube ...
NoxNoctisUmbra 4 years ago
hi i like your sincere qualitites.
c1h2e3s4t5e6r 4 years ago
fucking great
googoogagmouth 4 years ago
wow...that was just perfect, don't know what else to say; )
Oneeyedmusic 4 years ago
That was beautiful, I wish Elliott could hear it.
brightckyeyes 4 years ago
Great cover... stunning. Do you have the chord progressions? I'd love to look at them.
tresayan 4 years ago
uve gave me goosebumps n one tear in my eye... just amazing, a lot better then the Metric cover. well stop before i cry my azz off soon :(
NoxNoctisUmbra 4 years ago
Beautiful cover, amazing song. My favourite one ;)
BlakeKorbinian 4 years ago
You know, I just had a very lousy day , but seeing this just makes it all okay, thank you for that.
Love Tom
teinashu 4 years ago
love it
jmendeza 4 years ago
Beautiful cover
comawhite54 4 years ago
Wow! Amazing!! Congratulations! Do you have any sheet music for the song or something like that? Please I would really like to have it :)
Thanks*
coldlove8 4 years ago
you made this song 10x more beautiful sad. you have a great voice. thank you. i love it.
two13sixty1 4 years ago
beautiful & sad. whoops.
two13sixty1 4 years ago
you have a great voice
falcostrife 4 years ago
i wish this song lasts forever
yeahyeah911 4 years ago
sounds good. nice job
Rooiebert 4 years ago
This was an amazing cover...you really captured the fragile beauty of the song...
TesseractRose 4 years ago
damn, you make this song sound amazing
I taped myself playing this too, maybe watch it and tell me what you think?
inwarddeathgrowl 4 years ago
play I Didnt Understand and you will win the love of everyone.
chipdevourer 4 years ago
HonoreYuhas, Your piano version comes from the soul, and therefore a beautiful tribute to Elliott. I've been learning to play piano on my own and have learned most of your version by watching and listening but I'm having trouble seeing the chorus from this angle. Any chance you could tell me which keys to play? Anyway, it's been fun listening to your song over and over again, and I still enjoy it every time.
sawyertwo 4 years ago
lovely job, do you happen to have the sheet music to this ??
wellprunedcunt 4 years ago
Canada is over-rated eh?
dupreyj 4 years ago
I still love this.
How have you been? lol how was your Canada day?
BlackScarletLove 4 years ago
Lovely voice,
I really enjoy your music, I have to say that the people that are ignorant enough not to look at a piece of music entirely on its own to to realize that this is a cover of another song, but is a song on its own. That means if it is not exactly like the original it can still be good and in this case amazing. Keep playing and shoot for your dreams for you will surely achieve them.
~~Brenon
Brenonm 4 years ago
Wow just realized how completely idiotic my reply was and would like to clarify. I meant that because this is a "cover" it is best to look at as the the singers interpretation of the song. Don't criticize it because it is not identical to the original. Look at it as its own song.
Brenonm 4 years ago
Lovely, every bit as good as Mr. Smith. =D Want to collaborate on a song maybe? Send me a message if you're interested. Cheers, Dave.
xylopolist 4 years ago
beautiful
johnfrusciante420 4 years ago
loved it. :]
servicelight 4 years ago
Let me be the first to offer buying the first record you put out... I have faith whatever your album consists of will be beautiful.
Seedr0 4 years ago
You aren't over singing. It sounds very nice! I had covered this song, but took down the vid because all of the flack I got. Some of Elliott's other fans found it offensive that anyone would dare to cover him. Don't listen to them like I did...
coffeescup 4 years ago
I love that song and your cover is sincerely very good.
MyNameIsTherese 4 years ago
didn't liked it
i hate "over singing"
Stillillgal 4 years ago
i totally disagree with that bullshit. she has the most beautiful voice on this earth. and i think that it's bullshit that you think she was 'over singing'. she did an amazing job. -cassy
youarenotchicken 4 years ago
Well done. I love this song and actually covered it on the piano (vocals and guitar), too.
MNash87 4 years ago
Yep, I've watched this four times consecutively so far.
BlackScarletLove 4 years ago
Bravo!!!!!!A great interpretation of the song...a great new life to it...once again, BRAVO!
arash402003 4 years ago
!!!! Good voice and sweet playing! Love your voice!
reedloliver 4 years ago
You totally have the voice for it, but your missing chords on the piano, play the "Chris" version of this song and repost it will sound so much better. You already have the vocals for it.
zdlite 4 years ago
You are gorgeous and your voice is likewise. ;)
A beautiful song too, I recorded it with my software and added it to my playlist. =)
+fav!
BlackScarletLove 4 years ago
beautiful voice, and great cover!
Nefertiti375 4 years ago
Awesome! You have a great voice.
jtbnin 4 years ago
yep good
Kleasone 4 years ago
I'm very happy to see you put more vids up....good job once again....and hope you are doing well.
Loonykillaz 4 years ago
Great job 5 stars!
jimmydushku 4 years ago