Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (199)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • What's Levine doing playing Bach??!! Go back to Wagner or Mozart James!

    These players are good alone by themselves, but when you get 4 together, the styles clash and you get a mediocre performance.

    The sum is lesser than the addition of all the participants in this case and almost all the time when they try to have a "satr studded" cast of characters on stage performing a piece together.

    Voting down.

  • I suggest every one yo listen to the english concert version of this work using harpsichords and other original instruments. This video is fun only for the famous artists playing but the english concert version is a real one.

  • Who are the orchestra members? I see Gideon Keener, Mischa Maisey, Maxim Vengerov.

  • Oh god.

  • They're faces looking like a children playing with a toy, it's amazing.

  • Great Artists!!! and Kissin is soooooooooo beautiful!!!!!

  • I think I've discovered this piece a week ago now, and I listened this piece at least 30 times after this discovery. Due to the splendid performance I must listen to this piece at least once a day. Especially the second part, Largo, is beautiful.

    Thanks Argerich, Kissin, Levine, Pletnev and of course the string orchestra!

  • Greatest hommage of J>S Bach to Antonio Vivaldi transcribing his Concerto for four violins (from L' Estro Harmonico) to four Harpsichords, and here with this constellation of stars, mainly Argerich, Pletnev etc.

  • Four Grand Pianos.

    Four Master Pianists.

    Fifteen-some Strings.

    One Bach Concerto.

    Nope, notheing can go wrong here.

  • @MrJoel397 But everything did.

  • @PiroozAzDirooz How so?

  • stalone on 5:50 with afro curly hair!!!

  • 4 PIANOS! LOL This just doesn't happen every day... in fact, decades... centuries LOL

  • LOL 4 PIANOS!? EPIC!!!!

  • I think it's much less fun for us to watch and listen them than it is for them to perform it. OH WELL...

  • what a fun to hear this!

    the same wonderful piece runs also as

    vivaldi: concerto for 4 guitars /

    vivaldi: concerto for 4 violins,

    bach: concert for 4 pianos ---

    can anybody tell me how it's possible? has bach an existing piece from vivaldi transcripted? (i know, in baroque they used to copy)

  • @liligr21 Bach was a huge fan of Vivaldi's work, and transcribed a bunch of vivaldi's pieces to new arrangements, specially the L'Estro Armonico!

  • On ne change pas une équipe qui gagne !

  • Power house!!!

    All the big names in classical music!!!

  • 6 idiotas que no conocen nada sobre música, sobre su esplendor, sobre lo que fue, es y será Bach, unos de los mejores compositores de música en la historia.

  • I like this music, the musicians as well, and their beautiful interpretation but what to say about the beginning of the second mouvement. Minutes 5 to 6 !?!

  • Astounding.TY meneltar for posting

  • wow,fantstic..where was it and when?

  • ¡Kissin debería interpretar más Bach!

  • @losberju Él no está tocando a Bach! Está Vivaldi! Este es un arreglo del Concierto de Vivaldi para cuatro violines y cuerdas en si menor!

  • @JupiterIV Sí, sí, sí, sí...

    

  • Vaya! No faltó nadie a este cocktail! Están todos los que tienen que estar... aplausos más

  • Wow! All Star cast playing BACH... speechless... and the string players seem to be enjoying themselves too! Bravo!

  • I don't understand the hatred of those who "dislike" in most of youtube's videos. In this one I really do. Who the fuck can.. Oh never mind, this is what heaven must be like...

  • Magnifique, genialissime, parfait. Ne me lasserai jamais de ce concerto...

  • I've been in heaven for 12.45 minutes.

    meneltar, чувак, СПАСИБО!

  • what a pity they couldn't get a decent piano tuner there in verbier... apart from that brilliant interpretation!

  • Traumhaft schön!!

  • Magic.

    

  • Four masters at their craft, Bach's inspiring concerto, the Swiss Alps. What a great video.

  • Very very beautiful music .... i LOVE it

  • Can't imagine how expensive the ticket to this concert might be...(??)

    so many great masters in a hall, at the same time...

  • El mejor concierto de Bach.

  • I say it's a paradise ensemble. :)

    And paradise music...

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • grand class of pianists... the most perfect people in the world...

  • 9:00 :)

  • did i see vadim repin on violin??

    

  • @ossiacadenza1 was just going to post this comment lmao!

  • This is divine!

  • That is Sarah Chang, am i correct?! In the beginning.

  • That is Sarah Chang, am i correct?!

  • Wonderful! But don'tt forget Bach itself!

  • @byng still it is fantastic!! I wish I would have been there listening live!!!

  • It's wonderful to see these musicians together. I enjoyed the performance; however, there were problems staying together - even starting and ending movements at the same time. I guess they didn't worry about spending much time rehearsing it. Still, it's great fun to watch those geniuses play. Bravo for doing this project at Verbier.

  • What score, or more precisely, what edition, did these great musicians use?

  • I love this Bach's concerto!!!!

    Check out also BWV 1044! ;]

  • Brillant!

  • ikiarria joxean

    

  • Great. That's the way it has to be played. Make Bach sing. The absolute polyphony singing. Like a wave. A powerful wave. Pure happiness!

  • @ehttsinaip Argerich!

  • woh it must be incredibly hard to play in perfect syncro like they do.

  • @gouloum2222 doubt it

  • @gouloum2222 doubt it... at least for them.

  • so nice, these giants playing for the sake of music, unlike lang(2x), who plays for the sake of acrobatics

  • @ehttsinaip LOL

  • @ehttsinaip ma tu chi ti credi u.u mamerto!

  • we have 6 deafs here....

    10:57

    SHE LOVES BACH

  • Comment removed

  • this is VIVALDI concerto for 4 Violins B Minor. not Bach

  • @tayrone2001

    Sorry, you're wrong: It's an adaption made by Bach himself.

  • @beruh0483 well that doesnt make it Bachs piece anyway. a transcription is a transtripction. u could do the same with flutes or cellos. it doesnt make it your piece though. so if u mention bach u have to mention vivaldi 3 times!

  • @tayrone2001

    Anyway. I think there is quite a SMALL difference between 4 violins and 4 pianos / harpsichords. And before you do the transcription you have to risk it. And Bach risked it and succeeded. 4 violins are nice but nothing special.

    BTW, I don't understand your mathematical logic. ^^

  • this is gorgeous, i love the four pianos!

  • Wow, this is truly an all-star game...

    2:40 Sarah Chang

    3:42 Vadim Repin

    4:23 Yuri Bashmet

    And others, plus the soloists... Holy @&^%!

  • Cool de voire une brochette de solistes !!! Zu viel des Guten.

    En fait ce n'est pas garantie d'émotion musicale, mais ça impressionne toujours. Welcome to Bach in the Open Space Office !

  • They are terribly not together....

  • @ehttsinaip Ella é una Dea, la piu Grande...e tu...un cazzune!!!

  • My favorite part was Martha's trill. :D And how they all listen so carefully and look at each other. Good example for other musicians.

  • it is awesome! I could also see Gidon Kremer & Mischa Maisky

  • This is so beautiful and special! There are no words to find!

    And all these celebrities together in one concert! Totally unique!

  • @ehttsinaip "Enfin il n`y a pas un seul de ces critiques qui ne se croie juge de l`univers, et écoute de l`univers.  Eh! l`ami, qui te savait là?" Dictionnaire philosophique, Article Critique, Supplemént de 1771.

  • @ehttsinaip AND WHAT ABOUT YOU? WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE? ARGERICH IS ONE OF THE BEST PIANIST IN THE WORLD, WETHER YOU LIKE HER OR NOT. LET US ENJOY THIS BEATIFUL MUSIC AND DO NOT BE SO IMPULSIVE AS TO SAY SUCH NONSENSE! GOOD MUSIC IS BEYOND WHAT YOU AND ME CAN SAY!

  • @ehttsinaip

    -- But who the heck is supposed to be Argerich?

    She's the only lady pianist there!!

    -- E 'il pianista donna solo lì!!

  • This is really fantastique!!!!!!

  • it's my first time watching so many superstars together~a-m-a-z-i-n-g!

  • Това малко азиатско момиче, толкова ме дразни как свири! Като я гледам имам чувството, че изпълнява новото парче на Bond! Ужас! Самият концерт е повече от великолвпен!

  • La descripcion lo dice todo ... ninguna descripcion disponible, no tiene palabras esto, todos los musicos de talla que hay ahi ! Argerich, Kissin, 10:18 aparece Mischa maisky, y en los violines anda por ahi Gidon Kremer si no me equivoco ...

  • La descripcion lo dice todo ... ninguna descripcion disponible, no tiene palabras esto, todos los musicos de talla que hay ahi ! Argerich, Kissin, 10:18 aparece Mischa maisky, y en los violines anda por ahi Gidon Kremer si no me equivoco ...

  • No, no, no This is such a great tune and its supposed to have lots of overwhelming flare and energy -I think thats one of the best bits about it. What they've done is just taken it all out using pianos. and made it soft and twinkly

  • this is just genius, well it´s bach played by creme de la creme: 4 wtf pianists, gidon kremer, mischa maisky

    but where is alexej igudesman? :)

  • @ehttsinaip perchè cosa fa di così particolare?

  • And not so important to be happy forever. Above all, be happy now.The happiness has been lasted for 12 minutes 45 seconds.The trick is- you can play, watch, listen it again and again.And your condition of absolute happiness will stay with you..

  • martha i love you

  • This is absolutely amazing, and I thought it was so awesome that the ensemble was made up of so many leading classical soloists:) I have one question, though. Isn't this a concerto for four harpsichords?

  • @HahnPotterishFowlnut Technically, yes. But, where can you find four harpsichords? It is hard enough to get four grands on stage! :)

  • Ok, the soloist is super stars, but did you see the "orchestra" musicians.....My God....Kremer, Repin, Bashmet, Mayski and so on......

  • @dmytropiano Dear Dmytro I agree with you, they need glasses! But I think that they don't even know Kremer (:

  • STUPENDO!!!!

  • buenísimo!!!!!! GRANDE ARGENTINA, siempre aportando joyitas a la cultura!!!!!

  • such a dream to see this. Thanksssssssss-- for posting

  • слабо со звуком, ё-маё! сильно с игрой!!!

  • @usertyfoon Ничто не слабо ...

  • @meneltar

    я имею в виду в видео, выложенном здесь, на YouTube... к примеру, отрезок записи Каприччио из партиты До-минор Баха в исполнении Аргерих звучит куда громче (сильнее)

  • @usertyfoon Ах, да, но, возможно, что-то конкретное на эту запись. Я нашел партиты 2 Марта фантастика!

  • This is Bach concerto, written after Vivaldi concerto and transported from h-moll to a-moll

  • ***** Muito Bonito *****

  • Verbire音樂節...

    這種陣容...世紀之交呀~!

    讓我想到世界杯足球賽,巴西隊出場的菁英銳氣~

  • WOW! incredible! Argerich, Kissin, Levine, Pletnev! Paying together! And look at the strings as well; there is Gidon Kremer, Vadim Repin, Sarah Chang and Mischa Maisky!!! Seriously, that is a dream ensemble!!!

  • 4 pianos!! Looks like fun

  • I think this is not a Bach but a Vivaldi concerto, a transcript of his concerto for 4 violins in B minor RV 580. I have the CD to prove it! And of course it sounds like a Vivaldi

  • Comment removed

  • she's bored to death!

  • I wonder how people stay on their places and don't burst into ovations :)

  • un placer verles. gracias.

  • Mediocre. Such great performers.... too bad. And that vibrato in the strings.. aarrrggh!!

  • lots of stars :)

  • Comment removed

  • This is a Vivaldi concerto though (in a Bach arrangement) ;-) You should listen to 1) the original for 4 violins (Op. 3 in B minor by Vivaldi), and 2) the Bach transcription for 4 harpsichords, not pianos... Cheers!

  • amazing~! amazing!!!!!!!! reli amazing!#@

  • beautiful people...sigh

  • Thank you for this... :)

  • Dream team!

    thank you!

  • This is a wet dream. Argerich, Kissin, Levine and Pletnev together. Wow!! Thank you.

  • @dotcom97 And other great names: Kremer, Repin, Biondi, Sitkovetsky (1st. violin); Chang, Sznajder, Capuçon and ... who is the 4th second violin (I can't see so well), Nobuko imai and Yuri Bashmet (violas), Mischa Maisky ... Woaw!!

  • @1donpizarro Where are the Violin 2's?

  • ...sublime...

  • Dear God ... listen to the thousandth time, again and again and say: Is this possible ...? Absolute infinite beauty ......................

  • Absolutely wonderful, absolutely beauty, the sound of the Only God...

  • Perhaps the nicest thing of this video is the great JOY the performers transmit to the auditorium. Thanks!!

  • awesomee ^^

  • Martha Argerich, Yevgeni Kissin, Levine, Pletnev, Misha Maisky, Sarah Chang, Gidon Kremer and co... rien que ça... Ils sont géniaux!

  • Comment removed

  • la Argerich è una delle migliori pianiste al mondo ed è risaputo che bach copiò l'intero pezzo da Vivaldi

  • @maruskaitalia Yes, but he had major arrangments in the original score by Vivaldi; if you listen to Vivaldi's concerto and compare it to Bach, the scores are, at many times, quite different!

  • WOW!

  • How Glorious!!

  • c est du luxe pure d avoir tant de musiciens de qualitè reuni....

  • o forse è stato trascritto da bach??non conosco questa versione wow

  • ma questo è il concerto di vivaldi in si minore per 4 violini e orchestra non è nessun bwv...è vivaldi per 4 violini archi e cembalo.

  • I wonder how many millions of dollars worth of stringed instruments are represented here..

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @1donpizarro Could you clarify the context of my comment so that I may respond cogently to yours? It is 6 months and a mere two words.

  • The slow movement is very difficult to play in the same timing for all 4 pianists. And even they failed in the beginning. So a conductor would have been helpful but there isn´t.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • This is more than allowed!!!!!!!

    Some people really do need to take a chill pill when it comes to bach & modern piano!

    Bach himself would approve.

  • @darkworld8 Who knows? Maybe yes, because some years before his death, he played on Silbermann pianos. First he was reluctant because of the harshness of the keyboard, but after Silbermann had brought major improvements on the keyboards, Bach really enjoyed them!

  • C'est beau, c'est séduisant et bien construit entre les participants, il manque peut-être juste un peu de mordant dans le final

  • C'est beau, c'est élégant et séduisant mais cela manque peut-être juste un peu de mordant dans le final.

  • a Schirmer edition in use ?

  • Comment removed

  • hi there. there are sites where you can download the scores ... IMSLP / Petrucci Music Library ... probably has the Bach Gesellschaft edition of this piece.

  • Beautiful!

    Do melhor que há!

  • Comment removed

  • Kind'a like having the 1927 "Yankees" playing "Bach" !!!

  • Wow fantastic, is this concerto availeble on CD

  • perdon 39 ._.

  • si me casaba con argerich no me importa que me lleve 30 años ._.

  • mm suena a vivadi ._.

  • De hecho, bueno, no sé la diferencia concreta entre el concierto para 4 violines de Vivaldi y el de 4 harpsicordios de Bach... Creo que Bach hizo esta versión a partir de Vivaldi, así como otras piezas de Vivaldi

  • It's totally true

  • è emozionante vedere tanti grandi artisti assieme .anche il grande cellista misha maiscky .....è già un problema avere a disposizione in sale concerto un pianoforte a coda ,qui addirittura quattro .volere è potere !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Haha, the other violinist and cellists are all guest stars!!! Sarah Chang, Gidon Kremer and others!!!

    That's just the classical dream team and they seem to have so much fun!

  • Comment removed

  • Che meraviglia,non lo conoscevo.Mille grazie

  • prestigious

  • They shouldn't gather at one place like that. What if a bomb goes off or the roof collapses or something?

  • heehee I always thought the same thing

  • Bach é outra música!

    Fantástica interpretação.

    J.