It is rare for me to return to post a 2nd comment on someone’s video; however, the exceptionally excellent quality of this performance deserves it. After first having heard this recording, I listened to many others of this same air. None approached the high quality of musical understanding, sensitivity to text, and beauty of voices of this video. One performance was so inappropriately and badly performed that I actually was shocked.
@jorgecurioso Yes, the whole of this Messiah recording was released on DVD by the ABC - I saw it all the way through a couple of years ago and it's brilliant! You can find it in the online shop through the ABC website (in Australia).
A remarkably fine performance by both singers. Beautiful tone. Focused voices with no heavy vibrato, no sliding or scooping to the high notes. Great musicality and sensitivity. Appropriate vocal ornamentation. Worth hearing many times.
Thank you for posting this. This lovely song gave me strength to carry on through some dreadful times of trial and persecution. These ladies sing it beautifully.
I have to admit that I am not a fan of soprano voices, generally speaking, but Sara MacLiver might just change my mind on this matter. Absolutely beautiful!
@WagnerFan25 Yes, she is wonderful. If you have the chance, listen to Sylvia McNair sing this piece. Beautiful. And Anne Sofie Von Otter, who sings the mezzo soprano, has an exquisite voice as well.
@grandadpoppyable I concur with you. I wrote to another poster that: I think Sylvia McNair and Anne Sofie Von Otter have the best rendition. However, this is definitely a beautiful version. The next best that I have heard. Both the soprano and mezzo soprano have exquisite voices....gorgeous timbre and no excessive vibrato.
There is nothing wrong with the pitch. The recording was fully compressed to avoid artificial sound interference. The voices and instruments were original. Good work from the sound engineer.
What a mistake I made! I wanted to rate it at five starsa, and didn't know that i had to click dreclty on the fifth star! This is a very nice rendition. Thank you and I apologise for the one star rating, it is very frustrating!
I agree with Grandadpoppy, you must see Syliva McNair and Anne Sofie Von Otter's rendition of this beautiful part.
zzznguyen 1 week ago
That is the BEST alto I ever heard in my life.
Liyht 4 weeks ago
I love this aria ... :)
baiba4 1 month ago
Wow! This is the purest verision I've ever heard!
dopanne 3 months ago
It is rare for me to return to post a 2nd comment on someone’s video; however, the exceptionally excellent quality of this performance deserves it. After first having heard this recording, I listened to many others of this same air. None approached the high quality of musical understanding, sensitivity to text, and beauty of voices of this video. One performance was so inappropriately and badly performed that I actually was shocked.
sfkcbf 3 months ago in playlist Favorite videos 3
Wow, this is a great performance. Grazie, caro saxone! Do you know if this is on DVD?
jorgecurioso 3 months ago
@jorgecurioso Yes, the whole of this Messiah recording was released on DVD by the ABC - I saw it all the way through a couple of years ago and it's brilliant! You can find it in the online shop through the ABC website (in Australia).
pilgrimess1980 3 weeks ago
A remarkably fine performance by both singers. Beautiful tone. Focused voices with no heavy vibrato, no sliding or scooping to the high notes. Great musicality and sensitivity. Appropriate vocal ornamentation. Worth hearing many times.
sfkcbf 3 months ago
What a beautiful piece!! Please do not remove this!
ArachnaeNonafel 3 months ago
Impossible to concieve this kind of music without the grace of God and the Holy Ghost.
helmuthoorn 3 months ago
Thank you for posting this. This lovely song gave me strength to carry on through some dreadful times of trial and persecution. These ladies sing it beautifully.
realzoomy 3 months ago
This is so beautiful. Thank you for posting this carosaxone!
Jdsimone05 4 months ago
how beautiful! She sings it so lyrically. I wish I had been at this performance... everything I've heard from it so far is so perfect!
AgnesRegina 6 months ago
@kietara101 eh i got a 2 on my solo but my ensemble got a 1 and we went to state how'd you do?
stormieism 8 months ago
elas fazem uma cara estranha mas o k sai da boca delas é mesmo o maximo
marilyhot 10 months ago
This is so beautiful. All of these crappy pop singers of today should sit down and take notes♥
Gemanj 11 months ago
Alexandra Sherman performance is outstanding. I have goose bumps listening to her. What a rich refreshing instrument she has!
latitudeCheck 1 year ago
I have to admit that I am not a fan of soprano voices, generally speaking, but Sara MacLiver might just change my mind on this matter. Absolutely beautiful!
WagnerFan25 1 year ago 2
@WagnerFan25 Yes, she is wonderful. If you have the chance, listen to Sylvia McNair sing this piece. Beautiful. And Anne Sofie Von Otter, who sings the mezzo soprano, has an exquisite voice as well.
MALP1231 2 months ago
im singing this in solo and ensemble gunna doa lot of practice to get rady by feburary
stormieism 1 year ago 5
@stormieism so am i! Good Luck :D
brunettesarebest1995 1 year ago
@stormieism So did I. How did you do?
kietara101 8 months ago
He shall feed His flock like a shepherd; and He shall gather the lambs
with His arm, and carry them in His bosom, and gently lead those that are
with young. (Isaiah 40:11)
Come unto Him, all ye that labour, come unto Him that are heavy laden, and
He will give you rest. Take His yoke upon you, and learn of Him, for He
is meek and lowly of heart, and ye shall find rest unto your souls.
(Matthew 11:28-29)
gibberth 1 year ago 10
@gibberth herrlich warm gesungen, eine ruhig geführte Stimme, danke
ahnungsvoll 2 months ago
Beautiful soprano voice!I have to sing this song for competition.
shashante93 1 year ago
@shashante93 Best of luck with your comp. This is a magnificent aria to sing.
knuckey63 1 year ago
Sylvia McNair did possibly the best version but this is rather nice. The version where she has support from Sophie Anne vo Otter
grandadpoppyable 1 year ago
@grandadpoppyable I concur with you. I wrote to another poster that: I think Sylvia McNair and Anne Sofie Von Otter have the best rendition. However, this is definitely a beautiful version. The next best that I have heard. Both the soprano and mezzo soprano have exquisite voices....gorgeous timbre and no excessive vibrato.
MALP1231 2 months ago
Wonderful voices, sung with such sweetness and sensitivity - EXCELLENT performance
cerrri 1 year ago
Sara Macliver: stunning voice, stunning woman!
axelfalk1 1 year ago
Nice pure voice coming from Sara MacLiver!
Zorica12 1 year ago
There is nothing wrong with the pitch. The recording was fully compressed to avoid artificial sound interference. The voices and instruments were original. Good work from the sound engineer.
isiazuhenry 1 year ago
sounds like its lower than the original key?? is that just me?? a semitone??
anyway its a beautiful rendition nethertheless
monicaxix 1 year ago
@monicaxix they are playing in the baroque pitch of 415Hz instead of the modern 440hz
8497289 1 year ago
@monicaxix - its in the correct key...they are spot on and fantastic!
jess420haze 1 year ago
What a beautiful performance, thanks for uploading this concert :)
VoyagerSouth 1 year ago
I think the soprano is marvelous!
mozart0559 1 year ago
Pure delight - pure pleasure - pure peace !!!
Glenmed 2 years ago
Comment removed
anedmure 2 years ago
The best rendition I've heard up to now!
magicprepy 2 years ago
What a mistake I made! I wanted to rate it at five starsa, and didn't know that i had to click dreclty on the fifth star! This is a very nice rendition. Thank you and I apologise for the one star rating, it is very frustrating!
loredinusa 2 years ago