Obv all the haters are gonna talk shit, nobody had heart for eli and the gmen but us giant fans,and we got it done,so this video should be deleted bc its obsolete manning is without question in bradys "class" numbers arent everything
Everytime Tom Brady gets the ball back with less than a minute to go, and behind, the commentators start to talk about how many times in that situation Tom Terrific has led his team down the field to win the game. I think it is a myth -- one of those urban legend things. I have never seen it happen. I have seen Eli, however, do it at least a dozen times.
To all you fag bandwagon giants fans... Eli Manning will never be as good as Tom Brady...he is talented though.. but no better than tom brady... @ Superbowl 46 Tom brady was on fire. its the receivers fault... Deon Branch, Aaron Hernandez, and Wes Welker in particular...
it's not about who is better, i would probably say that Brady is better...but in terms of class/neighborhood. i'd say yeah. hard to say a QB that beat Brady's team twice in the super-bowl isn't.
In any professional sport, winning the championship matters the most. If a team dominates the regular season, posting incredible stats, but fails to win the big game, they are forever damned as underachievers. If an underdog wins it, they are forever praised...
Eli has won the Big Game- twice now- over Brady`s bunch. That has to be taken into account.
hey dickheads i been looking for a video like this tom brady finna get his tonite and everyone will have to retract wat they said about eli merely 5 months ago!!! go big blue
This season, take away a couple bad drops by hakeem nicks and victor cruz that could have gone to the house, Eli got over 5000 yards up there with Brady and Rodgers. He is in their class whether you like it or not. Give Eli Danny Woodhead and Wes Welker and see if he doesn't come up with the same stats. Eli makes ANY tight end look good.
@4Dpatricio Wow your obviously very ignorant as danny woodhead is not even that important or talented of a player the Pats would be the same without him they havea terrible run game. and rodgers wasnt in the 5000 yard club moron that was brees and i beleive stafford
@4Dpatricio Looks like a dick rider to me. Tight ends make eli look good idiot. And take away Victor Cruz and eli doesn't throw for more than 15 TD's and stays under 4000 yards. Idiot
Eli may not be in Brady's class stat wise but maybe its cause his O-Line is so freaking horrible and his receivers and tight end have nothing on Brady's. Still he's doing a hell of a job. Honestly if Eli had the luxury of just sitting back in the pocket for 30 seconds and ripping it out to Rob Gronkowski or Wes Welker, he would be putting up Brady's stats. Not to mention the Giants schedule rapes the Patriots'.
So yeh, he totally has the right to call himself an elite QB.
@acmilankaka21 Uh..... Sitting back in the pocket for 30 seconds? More like 5 at the most. Also, Welker is almost never open(double covered). Any good defense makes the so called "amazing oline" look like shit. And Gronk is a TIGHT END, he is NOT a deep threat. Brady's arm and accuracy MADE him a deep threat.
@ItzDSD typical colts fan your comment screams IGNORANCE! brady calls his own plays and switches plays at the line of scrimmage based on what he sees the def is doing and he has been running no huddle much like a peyton this year with good results. [no im not saying he is equal to peyton in running no huddle]
@EriK9Shep Tom Brady is one of the greatest. No insult to be not as good. Eli belongs in the second class of Qbs. Tier 1: Brady, Brees, Rodgers, Peyton. Tier 2 Eli, Ben, Rivers, Romo. No specific order. I know Rivers is having off year, and I hope he sucks like this forever... but he's still good.
Rodgers should be first after his performance this year. He's unstoppable. I don't know where Peyton should go. I haven't seen him play in a while and he's getting old. Brady will always be one step ahead of Brees, even though they are close.
@RealMcCoy1011 Rodgers is amazing. Not trying to knock him. I just want to see what Brady would do with GB's weapons. But I do wonder how Rodgers would do if he got to play with Randy Moss.
Eli is in the class of Elite QBs. 1 Superbowl Win! 1 Superbowl MVP. So far this Season he has a QBR of 105.6. QBs are judged by what they've WON, & lost. Did you see him last week in that thrilling 4th Qtr comeback? Anyways... QBs with the highest % in games decided by 8 or fewer points since 2007: 1. Peyton Manning - 26W-8L/76.5% 2. Eli Manning and Matt Ryan - 19W-7L/73.1%. 4. Tom Brady -13W-6L/68.4%. No QB is perfect. WINNING is the bottom line. Elite QBs are WINNERS; period.
Lastly, do not take away from Eli Manning. Do some research on him in the 2 minute warnings. His percentages and stats go way up. Superbowls obviously are part of the equation, but let's be real. Tom Brady won Superbowls with possibly the top or near the top rated defenses in the league at that time.
Not to mention He had one of the best receivers of all time, and one of the best slot receivers in the game at that time. Let's be real. Tom Brady is no Peyton Manning, he isn't even a superior quarter back. He's just a highly efficient qb, who's stats explain what he does. TE and slot receiver dump-offs with accuracy. He's been in the league a number of seasons. His TD's stand around 26-28 normally, and interceptions are normally in the 9-14 range.
Eli Manning is no Tom Brady. I will say this. Don't quote Tom Brady's stats as 50 touchdowns, and 36 touchdowns 4 interceptions. If you do this, I get the impression you don't watch much football. Tom Brady is thrown on a pedestal he doesn't belong on. Tom Brady's super star 50 touchdown season came due to a Coach Bill Belichick that refused to run the ball with Laurence Maroney, refused to punt the ball even on 4th and 4's, and play Brady aggressively, even when the games in the bag.
i dont' have a top 10 cause i don't think there is 10 outstanding QBs in the league. you can see my top 6 have won a ring, eli is not a top 5 but yeah i make him my 6 best QB in the league. i mean back to back 4000 passing yards & over 20 plus TDs. if Rivers & Vick win a SB, then i might put them ahead of Eli.
@eCRO47xx what does having an opinion have to do with someone's IQ. reason why i put peyton ahead is because without him, his team would be an under .500 team. we saw what happen when brady got injured & his team went 11-5.
@jc72la5stout How does that come in effect? All that means is that the patriots have a good back up QB. Matt Cassle was the back up and he is good. It only means the patriots have a better offense and D then the colts. It doesnt matter whos team is better. its between brady and manning. and cleary by stats and experience that brady is n.1 on everyones list
yea i disagree with elis comments but like u said jr its good he has confidence in himself now that he says this all thats left is for him to prove it thats all i got to say
Eli is good, but he has to do what Brady has done first before he can make that a legitimate statement. Match Brady's championships then you can make the comparison....
@sherman546 im sure you 4got vick accidently but heres my order: 1.Peyton 2.Vick 3.Brady 4.Rodgers 5.Brees 6.Ben 7.Rivers 8.Ryan , idk much about Matt Schuab but i think Eli's better than Romo and Flacco
@sherman546 stay healthy - hes stayed healthy just like the other qbs, out of trouble - really? cmon man that was like 2yrs ago from the dogfighting (the end of it), more than 1 good year - remember when he was on the falcons??? but really even though throwing is the main thing the qb needs to do, vick just brings more weapons including his ability to evade pass rush and run for a gain and tackle polamalu besides id still call him a tier 1/2 qb in throwing abilities
@21bronxbombers Ya know what. I did overrate Vick a bit. I can't make a top 10 though b/c 1.Rodgers 2.Brady 3.Brees 4.Big Ben 5.Vick. I am putting Vick as 5 b/c Rivers is overrated.
@21bronxbombers No Peyton because he's not playing this year, right? Big Ben is very good, and i think he and Eli, this year, are sort of interchangeable. I think Eli is working with much less tho. 32nd ranked rush game, make-shift o-line and WRs in-and-out. I have to argue against Vick. I think he's a top 10 QB only because of his legs. This year, Eli has to be top 5. 30 td, 15 int and 4900 projection is top 5 stuff.
@sherman546 Eli's defenitely better than Romo and he racked that many interceptions becuase his recievers kept on bouncing the ball up, instead of catching the ballm, and letting defenders get easy catches. That being said I don't think he's as good as Brady and I believe it was a stupid comment.
@sherman546 Im a cowboys fan but i believe that flacco should be where romo is Schaub should be replaced by Sanchez because shaub hasnt even made it into a play off game were as all of the other qbs have and sanchez has with help gone to the AFC champion ship 2 times Schaub is only good because of Andre Johnson and there good running game when was the last time you here Schaub Airs it out to (insert random Texans WR name here) and they catch the ball for a 45yard td. all of S's HiLites r with AJ
@sherman546 Matt Ryan and Tony Romo dont even belong on this list.1st off Matt Ryan hasnt been playing that long and is playing pretty shitty so far plus no ring,2nd Tony Romo was 1-7 as a starter last year and is playing like garbage this year,has only 1 playoff win and is known too be a choke artist in the playoffs,plus no ring.
@sherman546 im nt sayin this bcuz ima giants fan but u cannot! say eli isnt in the top 10. dude got a passer rating of 101.1 and he's number 3 this year with stats...only people with better is tom brady (#2) and aaron rodgers (#1) so dnt even sit there and say he's not good. giants got rid of our reicever problems and now u dnt even see the interceptions being thrown
@sherman546 The Mannings' call their own plays. Eli started calling them in 2007 - 2008 season right? You see what happened? Being an elite quarterback is not all about accuracy tbh.
@sherman546 wait, did you REALLLY put Eli below Shaub, Romo & Flacco?
I disagree. I disagree. He's not Tom Brady because he hasn't got Brady's body of work. That is NOT debatable, but no way in hell is he below Shaub & the rest of the others you put.
@sherman546 Lol@romo, Flacco, Ryan, and Schaub over Elite Manning. Shit cray(no typo) son. Only 5(Peyton playing Madden 12 at home) active QBs have a SB ring. Elite Manning is one of them.
Whaddup JR! Eli doesn't even think that he's in the same class with Brady, but you can't expect him to say that when the interviewer put him out there like that. I give him props for the confidence...and the Giants made my day when they beat the Pats in the Super Bowl. Eli might not be on the top teir, but he nowhere near the bottom when talking about QBs.
Peyton & Brady are both going to the Hall of Fame for sure. Eli on the other hand sux. Maybe what he should have said is that's he's in Romo's League. Nah, nevermind... Romo really sux. :p
I'm a giants fan, Eli isnt as great as Brady and Peyton but he is an elite qb, he has won a superbowl, he has been to playoffs many years in a row, he understands how to win.
@nabilion he is AMERICAN. This is for AMERICAN viewers, if you dont like american sports, dont watch his channel u retard. Im english, I would never go to an american site for football (soccer) news in the same way I wont go to BBC Sport for news on NFL. Saying no-one cares is fucking delusional.
@fulatl111 *facepalm* I enjoy Jr's vids on soccer and basketball. Also he doesn't say his channel is exclusively for american viewers. My comment was just a suggestion to him that he would get more viewers with those sports. So now, i shall suggest to you to be quiet you complete dipshit.
@fulatl111 my problem wasnt as much about suggesting other sports, but the fact that you say no-one cares about NFL. Im guessin that ur from australian, right? im half australian and 5 aussie rule punters are in the nfl and your channels are filled with nfl programmes. The NFL is massive outside the US too, just because you nor of your friends like it doesnt change that. Behind soccer, american sport is the biggest sport in the world.
5 QBs in "Brady's Class" just off the top of my head...
Brady, of course
Vick, if last season wasn't a fluke, was an absolute monster
Rodgers
Rivers
Brees
Hell, Eli isn't even the best QB in his family! The only good thing I can say about Eli where others may see him as better Brady is his superbowl performance over Brady. Even then, Brady has won more of those big games than Eli will probably even get to.
Eli Manning is a very good QB but saying hes in the same class as Tom Brady...is going too far smh. Sit down Eli and fans who actually think Eli manning is better than Brady. Youre in COMPLETE and UTTER DENIAL!!!!!
Put it this way Tom Brady is the type of quarterback that is expected to make it to the superbowl or far in the post season no matter how much he team changes around him. Can we say the same for Eli? Not really.
Plus, if you remember, Eli Manning beat Tom Brady in the Super Bowl to prevent the perfect season. No other quarterback in NFL history can say that. Thus proving that Eli Manning Is Better Than Tom Brady
@Ocelllian2 ... See now, there's no need for name calling. Yes, obviously there were other players playing in that Super Bowl. But he and that offense drove down that field and scored to take the lead and eventually the win right when it mattered with everything on the line. I can't argue stats, but head to head when it really counts, sorry friend, Eli got him. I will just say this, Brady gets a free pass a lot of the time. While Eli gets a lot of undeserved negativity even though he's great.
@feelgood6 And Tom did the same thing in the Superbowls he was in. You remember them scoring with 00:00 on the clock against the rams? You remember the playoff game against the Raiders?
Manning scored on the Pats defense in a clutch situation.
Brady scored on the Rams, Panthers, Raiders, and Giants defense in clutch situations.
The point is yes, Manning did score. But there was nothing that Brady could do to stop him, so its really not Brady's fault.
Eli Manning gets a lot of crap for no reason. He has had back to back 4,000 yards passing seasons with his top two receivers injured for significant time. With the exception to the past two years, gets his team into the playoffs. He is a Super Bowl Champion and Super Bowl MVP. He plays the game the right way and I am proud of the fact he is the quarterback of my favorite team. We'll see who's better when it's all said and done. You wanna know what? ELI MANNING IS BETTER THAN TOM BRADY!!!!!!!!
There is absolutely NO way that Eli Manning is even close to as good as Tom Brady. Tom Brady is Tom Brady & Eli Manning is Eli Manning. So what is Eli beat Brady in the Super Bowl in '07, that's just one ring. Tom Brady won 3 super bowls with the Pats. I mean he's good & he's knows what he's doing, but he DAMN SURE ain't better than Brady. End of Story.
bradys the greastest of all time cuz he carried the pats 2 the superbowls and he made no named WRs better meaning hell make anyone good and better than eli.but peyton got 2 giv him props tho
I apologize I wasn't talking strictly stats so much as success but you are right. And true his INT total for last year should have been around 15 had it not been for the tipped passes of his receivers. His mental game is not nearly where it should be to be put in such an elite class of QBs
Maybe this is because I'm an eagles fan but I would not put Eli in the top 5 Qbs right now. He is overrated and nothing without plax to catch his poorly thrown passes
@utleyphils26 couldn't be more wrong. His two best passing seasons were without plaxico. Like JR said he only threw 25 INTs this year because his receivers screwed him.
@KnuckleWhisperer ya... brady didn't do shit to you except become a dynasty and absolutely own the AFC east until rex got to the jets... don't tell me that you just hopped on the jets bandwagon...
@KnuckleWhisperer ya... brady didn't do shit to you except become a dynasty and absolutely own the AFC east until rex got to the jets... don't tell me that you just hopped on the jets bandwagon...
to the "eli beat tom" thing ya id say thats a ridiculous thing to use to compare as well. I mean... phillip rivers beat peyton manning in the playoffs and usually always beats peyton yet i wouldn't hear a soul say that rivers>peyton. imo the top echelon of qb's last yr was brady, vick, Peyton manning, Rivers, Rodgers, Brees. Eli was just below that. at least eli>crappy jay cutler rofl.
Eli manning aint tom brady. thats obvious. He has immense talent but i swear its like he's slow in the head sometimes. He PANICKS in the pocket, throws into double/triple coverage a lot and imo isn't that great of a leader either.
eli manning is like a tony romo. good god why couldnt the giants have kept phil rivers man. the giants would be a vaslty netter team than we are now. sigh. but hey things happen for a reason
Obv all the haters are gonna talk shit, nobody had heart for eli and the gmen but us giant fans,and we got it done,so this video should be deleted bc its obsolete manning is without question in bradys "class" numbers arent everything
nickjr27 5 days ago
My nigga Eli Manning was right that nigga talking doesnt kno shit
uncleben50 5 days ago
All you people who think Eli is as good as Brady or better than Brady are idiots.
Any NFL expert will tell you this. You're all just fans. Fans are idiots that have no idea what they're talking about.
myles755 6 days ago
All the way pats Tom but petyon manning is way better then Eli and brady
XxSuperXxmaniaxX 1 week ago
well who's laughing now, eli beat tom twice hahaha :-)
thejohhny69 2 weeks ago 3
With spygate, Brady is better
Without spygate, Eli is way better
PS3XBOX360GUY 2 weeks ago 2
what u got to say nw fuc face?
householddelaney 2 weeks ago
Everytime Tom Brady gets the ball back with less than a minute to go, and behind, the commentators start to talk about how many times in that situation Tom Terrific has led his team down the field to win the game. I think it is a myth -- one of those urban legend things. I have never seen it happen. I have seen Eli, however, do it at least a dozen times.
pegcage 2 weeks ago 2
To all you fag bandwagon giants fans... Eli Manning will never be as good as Tom Brady...he is talented though.. but no better than tom brady... @ Superbowl 46 Tom brady was on fire. its the receivers fault... Deon Branch, Aaron Hernandez, and Wes Welker in particular...
xXDeadMan9612Xx 2 weeks ago
Eli isn't as good as Brady.....He's better!!!
Tralman1965 3 weeks ago 13
Huh, what do you know? He was right after all
feelgood6 3 weeks ago 5
it's not about who is better, i would probably say that Brady is better...but in terms of class/neighborhood. i'd say yeah. hard to say a QB that beat Brady's team twice in the super-bowl isn't.
rotelfan2000 3 weeks ago 3
In any professional sport, winning the championship matters the most. If a team dominates the regular season, posting incredible stats, but fails to win the big game, they are forever damned as underachievers. If an underdog wins it, they are forever praised...
Eli has won the Big Game- twice now- over Brady`s bunch. That has to be taken into account.
Infofan 3 weeks ago
eli manning beat him brady twice***
mvpxqbx14 3 weeks ago
@mvpxqbx14 Correction 3 times.
pegcage 2 weeks ago
BEAT TOM BRADY TWICE***********
mvpxqbx14 3 weeks ago
BEAT TOM BRADY TWICE***********
mvpxqbx14 3 weeks ago
hey dickheads i been looking for a video like this tom brady finna get his tonite and everyone will have to retract wat they said about eli merely 5 months ago!!! go big blue
TtiRred954 3 weeks ago
2-0. Eli doesn't go to Super Bowls to lose like his brother and Tom Brady do.
jsimpson626 3 weeks ago
hell yeah bitch he is better than brady i belive in eli
Mr123Yoyoyy 3 weeks ago
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaand Eli is in the Super Bowl sharing the stage once again with Tom Brady. Funny how everything worked out.
NYG4LIFE123 3 weeks ago
no
yomothaWHAT 3 weeks ago
Great to watch this video again today. Alex Smith and Eli both proved the majority wrong. props.
deppenb1019 3 weeks ago
YES!!!!!!
coolkidowen214 1 month ago
If Tom Brady beats Eli in the Super Bowl, which he won't. Then maybe we can consider Tom Brady in Eli Manning's class.
21bronxbombers 1 month ago
@21bronxbombers If you admit you were under some sort of influence when you wrote that, then maybe we can consider your IQ to be normal.
3ownsu 1 month ago
You still having trouble believing?
jfreiday 1 month ago
"I believe in Eli" - deion sanders
marksantoianni 1 month ago
no, but he will be u stupid dick rider
kingcamilo 1 month ago
Yes Eli is in the absolute upper echelon of QB's in the NFL.
jsimpson626 1 month ago
@jsimpson626 No he is not.
3ownsu 1 month ago
its not funny anymore bitch. eli has proven himself to be in the top 5 of the league.
XxxxExclusivexxxX 1 month ago
@XxxxExclusivexxxX Psych, The top 5 is 1.) Brady 2.) Rodgers 3.) Brees 4.)Roethilsberger 5.) Michael Vick/Matt Ryan Yes, vick over eli.
3ownsu 1 month ago
This season, take away a couple bad drops by hakeem nicks and victor cruz that could have gone to the house, Eli got over 5000 yards up there with Brady and Rodgers. He is in their class whether you like it or not. Give Eli Danny Woodhead and Wes Welker and see if he doesn't come up with the same stats. Eli makes ANY tight end look good.
4Dpatricio 1 month ago
@4Dpatricio Wow your obviously very ignorant as danny woodhead is not even that important or talented of a player the Pats would be the same without him they havea terrible run game. and rodgers wasnt in the 5000 yard club moron that was brees and i beleive stafford
ThyKingOfKingz 1 month ago
@ThyKingOfKingz That was Brees, BRADY, and Stafford. Stafford barely broke 5000, Brady blew it out of the water along with Brees.
3ownsu 1 month ago
@4Dpatricio Looks like a dick rider to me. Tight ends make eli look good idiot. And take away Victor Cruz and eli doesn't throw for more than 15 TD's and stays under 4000 yards. Idiot
3ownsu 1 month ago
Eli may not be in Brady's class stat wise but maybe its cause his O-Line is so freaking horrible and his receivers and tight end have nothing on Brady's. Still he's doing a hell of a job. Honestly if Eli had the luxury of just sitting back in the pocket for 30 seconds and ripping it out to Rob Gronkowski or Wes Welker, he would be putting up Brady's stats. Not to mention the Giants schedule rapes the Patriots'.
So yeh, he totally has the right to call himself an elite QB.
acmilankaka21 2 months ago
@acmilankaka21 Giants have the top recievers in the league!
HelpMeSkatePlease 1 month ago
@acmilankaka21 Uh..... Sitting back in the pocket for 30 seconds? More like 5 at the most. Also, Welker is almost never open(double covered). Any good defense makes the so called "amazing oline" look like shit. And Gronk is a TIGHT END, he is NOT a deep threat. Brady's arm and accuracy MADE him a deep threat.
3ownsu 1 month ago
eli is with romo and cam and andy dalton now brady is with the best drew brees and rogers
MrTrollercoasterlulz 2 months ago
@ItzDSD typical colts fan your comment screams IGNORANCE! brady calls his own plays and switches plays at the line of scrimmage based on what he sees the def is doing and he has been running no huddle much like a peyton this year with good results. [no im not saying he is equal to peyton in running no huddle]
Kunglao63 3 months ago
Comment removed
Kunglao63 3 months ago
Being a scrawny bitch with a bobble head =
-15 out of a possible 10 points.
jwlafferty 3 months ago
i am Giants fan. Eli and Tom are completely different styles, both have amazing arms, but Tom is way better.
EriK9Shep 3 months ago
@EriK9Shep Tom Brady is one of the greatest. No insult to be not as good. Eli belongs in the second class of Qbs. Tier 1: Brady, Brees, Rodgers, Peyton. Tier 2 Eli, Ben, Rivers, Romo. No specific order. I know Rivers is having off year, and I hope he sucks like this forever... but he's still good.
Harker911 2 months ago
Oh, and Eli is a stinkypoo!!!
RealMcCoy1011 3 months ago
Rodgers should be first after his performance this year. He's unstoppable. I don't know where Peyton should go. I haven't seen him play in a while and he's getting old. Brady will always be one step ahead of Brees, even though they are close.
RealMcCoy1011 3 months ago
@RealMcCoy1011 Rodgers is amazing. Not trying to knock him. I just want to see what Brady would do with GB's weapons. But I do wonder how Rodgers would do if he got to play with Randy Moss.
Harker911 2 months ago
Dieon Sanders-"I BELIEVE IN ELI!" Michael Erving-"Yeah I believe in him now too. But you know what else?" Wha-"CAAAMMM!"
LMAO Erving and Dieon great pair
9tailNARUTOYAHH 3 months ago
and yes i think he's in the same class as tom bardy..not better than tom brady. but same class, yes
done2010 4 months ago
Mannnnnn Fuck Tom Brady....Go Get Em Eli!!!!
IBRFamT3 4 months ago
@IBRFamT3 fuck you too buudyy
SuperLions7 3 months ago
Eli is in the class of Elite QBs. 1 Superbowl Win! 1 Superbowl MVP. So far this Season he has a QBR of 105.6. QBs are judged by what they've WON, & lost. Did you see him last week in that thrilling 4th Qtr comeback? Anyways... QBs with the highest % in games decided by 8 or fewer points since 2007: 1. Peyton Manning - 26W-8L/76.5% 2. Eli Manning and Matt Ryan - 19W-7L/73.1%. 4. Tom Brady -13W-6L/68.4%. No QB is perfect. WINNING is the bottom line. Elite QBs are WINNERS; period.
MisturrD 4 months ago
ahaha this video is so true
TheGbaby001 5 months ago
Comment removed
sherman546 5 months ago 2
I say bradys a joke, and Eli doesnt have the mind of billicheck.
Rasrow1 6 months ago
Eli Manning > Tom Brady
NewLeatherface 6 months ago
@NewLeatherface AHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHA FUNNY I hate Brady, but he's so much better than Eli
jetsfan3333 6 months ago
eli didnt cheat thow
ederftl 6 months ago
Brady has been the starting quarterback in the probowl with nobody receivers
colossalko 6 months ago
@sherman546 What about vick he is better than ryan romo schaub and flacco
kassemgisamazing 6 months ago
2010 Comparison -
Tom Brady = 37 Touchdowns, 4 Interceptions, 3,900 Yards
Eli Manning = 31 Touchdowns, 25 Interceptions, 4,002 Yards
Seems like it could take a long time for Eli to be on Brady's level when you look at the statistics...
Fiddlewinks 6 months ago
I suppose. He took way less than they were willing to pay him though. I agree that team needs work though.
xdeg123 6 months ago
KFC chicken
MrCrazyman206 6 months ago
Joe Montana
Tom Brady
Eli Manning
One of these things don't belong, lol.
1bounce23456 6 months ago
1.Brady 2.Manning 3.Rodgers 4.Brees 5.Rivers 6.Roelisberger 7.Vick 8.Josh Freeman 9.Matt ryan 10.Romo....Not even in the top 10...
PoliticalBoy97 6 months ago
Lastly, do not take away from Eli Manning. Do some research on him in the 2 minute warnings. His percentages and stats go way up. Superbowls obviously are part of the equation, but let's be real. Tom Brady won Superbowls with possibly the top or near the top rated defenses in the league at that time.
xdeg123 6 months ago
Not to mention He had one of the best receivers of all time, and one of the best slot receivers in the game at that time. Let's be real. Tom Brady is no Peyton Manning, he isn't even a superior quarter back. He's just a highly efficient qb, who's stats explain what he does. TE and slot receiver dump-offs with accuracy. He's been in the league a number of seasons. His TD's stand around 26-28 normally, and interceptions are normally in the 9-14 range.
xdeg123 6 months ago
@xdeg123 maybe the colts shouldnt make peyton the highest paid player and use the money to find good players to play for their team.
syafiqyazid 6 months ago
Eli Manning is no Tom Brady. I will say this. Don't quote Tom Brady's stats as 50 touchdowns, and 36 touchdowns 4 interceptions. If you do this, I get the impression you don't watch much football. Tom Brady is thrown on a pedestal he doesn't belong on. Tom Brady's super star 50 touchdown season came due to a Coach Bill Belichick that refused to run the ball with Laurence Maroney, refused to punt the ball even on 4th and 4's, and play Brady aggressively, even when the games in the bag.
xdeg123 6 months ago
Do you guys smell that?
toua88 6 months ago
1.Peyton 2.Brady 3.Roethlisberger 4.Brees 5.Rodgers 6.Eli 7.Rivers 8.Vick 9.Ryan
i dont' have a top 10 cause i don't think there is 10 outstanding QBs in the league. you can see my top 6 have won a ring, eli is not a top 5 but yeah i make him my 6 best QB in the league. i mean back to back 4000 passing yards & over 20 plus TDs. if Rivers & Vick win a SB, then i might put them ahead of Eli.
jc72la5stout 6 months ago
@jc72la5stout no i think ur dumb. brady is clearly number 1. what makes peyton better then tom? all his commercial ads? NO
eCRO47xx 6 months ago
@eCRO47xx what does having an opinion have to do with someone's IQ. reason why i put peyton ahead is because without him, his team would be an under .500 team. we saw what happen when brady got injured & his team went 11-5.
jc72la5stout 6 months ago
@jc72la5stout How does that come in effect? All that means is that the patriots have a good back up QB. Matt Cassle was the back up and he is good. It only means the patriots have a better offense and D then the colts. It doesnt matter whos team is better. its between brady and manning. and cleary by stats and experience that brady is n.1 on everyones list
eCRO47xx 6 months ago
Comment removed
sherman546 6 months ago
yea i disagree with elis comments but like u said jr its good he has confidence in himself now that he says this all thats left is for him to prove it thats all i got to say
FRArognetwork 6 months ago
Hell yeah manning is in brady's class peyton manning
DigitalPhenomenon 6 months ago
@DigitalPhenomenon brady is in manning's class
FeintBlade 6 months ago
Eli is good, but he has to do what Brady has done first before he can make that a legitimate statement. Match Brady's championships then you can make the comparison....
zillzultraboy 6 months ago
lol he is not even close to being tom brady. he isnt even in romos class and romos a way better quarterback than sheli
CowboysOwnEagles 6 months ago
@CowboysOwnEagles i like how your name is cowboysowneagles. hahahaha what a joke
FeintBlade 6 months ago
@FeintBlade im glad you like it
CowboysOwnEagles 6 months ago
(romo is 12 stay healthy then talk to me)
Mynameisrobry 6 months ago
1-Peyton 2-Brady 3-brees 4-rothelisberger 5-rodjers 6-rivers 7-matt Ryan 8-Matt schaub 9- mike Vick 10-Eli manning
Mynameisrobry 6 months ago
If Tony romo is in your top ten then Eli must be in because he is better
Mynameisrobry 6 months ago
Comment removed
sherman546 6 months ago 7
@sherman546 im sure you 4got vick accidently but heres my order: 1.Peyton 2.Vick 3.Brady 4.Rodgers 5.Brees 6.Ben 7.Rivers 8.Ryan , idk much about Matt Schuab but i think Eli's better than Romo and Flacco
21bronxbombers 6 months ago
@21bronxbombers Vick number 2??? I'm not talking fantasy football here. He needs to stay healthy,out of trouble and have more than one good year.
sherman546 6 months ago
@sherman546 stay healthy - hes stayed healthy just like the other qbs, out of trouble - really? cmon man that was like 2yrs ago from the dogfighting (the end of it), more than 1 good year - remember when he was on the falcons??? but really even though throwing is the main thing the qb needs to do, vick just brings more weapons including his ability to evade pass rush and run for a gain and tackle polamalu besides id still call him a tier 1/2 qb in throwing abilities
21bronxbombers 6 months ago
@21bronxbombers Ya know what. I did overrate Vick a bit. I can't make a top 10 though b/c 1.Rodgers 2.Brady 3.Brees 4.Big Ben 5.Vick. I am putting Vick as 5 b/c Rivers is overrated.
21bronxbombers 3 months ago
@21bronxbombers No Peyton because he's not playing this year, right? Big Ben is very good, and i think he and Eli, this year, are sort of interchangeable. I think Eli is working with much less tho. 32nd ranked rush game, make-shift o-line and WRs in-and-out. I have to argue against Vick. I think he's a top 10 QB only because of his legs. This year, Eli has to be top 5. 30 td, 15 int and 4900 projection is top 5 stuff.
Harker911 2 months ago
@sherman546 Eli's defenitely better than Romo and he racked that many interceptions becuase his recievers kept on bouncing the ball up, instead of catching the ballm, and letting defenders get easy catches. That being said I don't think he's as good as Brady and I believe it was a stupid comment.
PACiaccio1056 6 months ago
@sherman546 Where the heck is Micheal Vick
zapata456 6 months ago
@zapata456 he'd be #6 or 7 prob
J2theK123 6 months ago
@sherman546 Vick had one good season in 10 years and is way too fragile to make my top ten.
sherman546 6 months ago 2
@sherman546 wow.. i dont like vick at all, but wheres vick???
royalrumblewinner 6 months ago
@sherman546 Joe Flacco? What drug are you on.
IPrefer2Win 6 months ago
Comment removed
sherman546 6 months ago 3
@sherman546 Im a cowboys fan but i believe that flacco should be where romo is Schaub should be replaced by Sanchez because shaub hasnt even made it into a play off game were as all of the other qbs have and sanchez has with help gone to the AFC champion ship 2 times Schaub is only good because of Andre Johnson and there good running game when was the last time you here Schaub Airs it out to (insert random Texans WR name here) and they catch the ball for a 45yard td. all of S's HiLites r with AJ
Xadanar 6 months ago
@sherman546 Matt Ryan and Tony Romo dont even belong on this list.1st off Matt Ryan hasnt been playing that long and is playing pretty shitty so far plus no ring,2nd Tony Romo was 1-7 as a starter last year and is playing like garbage this year,has only 1 playoff win and is known too be a choke artist in the playoffs,plus no ring.
dougiefreshny 4 months ago
@sherman546 im nt sayin this bcuz ima giants fan but u cannot! say eli isnt in the top 10. dude got a passer rating of 101.1 and he's number 3 this year with stats...only people with better is tom brady (#2) and aaron rodgers (#1) so dnt even sit there and say he's not good. giants got rid of our reicever problems and now u dnt even see the interceptions being thrown
done2010 4 months ago
@sherman546 The Mannings' call their own plays. Eli started calling them in 2007 - 2008 season right? You see what happened? Being an elite quarterback is not all about accuracy tbh.
ItzDSD 3 months ago
@sherman546 peyton is number 1 not brady.. how do you mess that up?
mylusernameslJustin 3 months ago
@sherman546 wait, did you REALLLY put Eli below Shaub, Romo & Flacco?
I disagree. I disagree. He's not Tom Brady because he hasn't got Brady's body of work. That is NOT debatable, but no way in hell is he below Shaub & the rest of the others you put.
mellaLee21 3 months ago
Comment removed
DStyles2345 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@sherman546 Lol@romo, Flacco, Ryan, and Schaub over Elite Manning. Shit cray(no typo) son. Only 5(Peyton playing Madden 12 at home) active QBs have a SB ring. Elite Manning is one of them.
DStyles2345 3 months ago
Whaddup JR! Eli doesn't even think that he's in the same class with Brady, but you can't expect him to say that when the interviewer put him out there like that. I give him props for the confidence...and the Giants made my day when they beat the Pats in the Super Bowl. Eli might not be on the top teir, but he nowhere near the bottom when talking about QBs.
Later!
GetWittedSports 6 months ago
Ur all stupid Eli is a top 5 quarterback, before you respond look at my earlier post
Mynameisrobry 6 months ago
@Mynameisrobry
What has Eli done, besides fluke out in one playoff's???
BishopRealTalk98 6 months ago
Sheli Mannning is not in the same class with Tom Brady
buster60341 6 months ago
No he doesn't the more interesting debate is what would Roethlisberger do with the Pats O-Line? What would Brady do with the Steelers O-Line?
beamerball666 6 months ago
Peyton & Brady are both going to the Hall of Fame for sure. Eli on the other hand sux. Maybe what he should have said is that's he's in Romo's League. Nah, nevermind... Romo really sux. :p
koalaswrath 6 months ago
@McYankees23
so many people have rings not many of them are in the hall of fame
awang7822 6 months ago
Does he possibly mean like same class as in popularity, not so much in statistics? I haven't heard the actual quote I suppose.
kikiochiachi 6 months ago
He did beat Tom Brady. It doesn't matter if you football game by a point or 40 points. A win is a win.
Novemberrain81 6 months ago
The only top 5 Eli is in is top 5 new York qbs 1-Sanchez 2-Ryan fizpatrick 3-mark Brunell 4-Eli 5-greg McElroy
Mynameisrobry 6 months ago
I damn near died laughing when I saw this on first take. Eli isn't even in the same ball park
greenbay357 6 months ago
I'm a giants fan, Eli isnt as great as Brady and Peyton but he is an elite qb, he has won a superbowl, he has been to playoffs many years in a row, he understands how to win.
Smyth1122 6 months ago
i thought that the kfc kernel died a long time ago..
Kingspade808 6 months ago 2
@Kingspade808 he did you idiot
metjet4 6 months ago
@Kingspade808 No KFC makes you live forever!
dynamitemike65 6 months ago
I think that they need to check him for head trauma.
arustedspork22 6 months ago
Never, maybe Peyton Manning, but not Eli Manning.
wel2myworld 6 months ago
eli isnt even the best qb in his family
SuperZiggyboi 6 months ago 31
@SuperZiggyboi He's the 3rd best
KevinLikesBergers 6 months ago
@SuperZiggyboi that's not fair to say..no one is better than Peyton
volunteernation16 6 months ago
@marrsteele2000 Just because his not better than him, does not mean his trash.
TxBeastProject 6 months ago
HELL NO eli must be smoking some good crack. because he will never be as good as brady.
goku27son 6 months ago
JR don't do NFL videos no-one cares. Instead report on cricket or the Rugby Union world cup
nabilion 6 months ago
@nabilion GTFO.
jr4chargers 6 months ago
@jr4chargers umm no but you can.
nabilion 6 months ago
@nabilion he is AMERICAN. This is for AMERICAN viewers, if you dont like american sports, dont watch his channel u retard. Im english, I would never go to an american site for football (soccer) news in the same way I wont go to BBC Sport for news on NFL. Saying no-one cares is fucking delusional.
fulatl111 5 months ago
@fulatl111 *facepalm* I enjoy Jr's vids on soccer and basketball. Also he doesn't say his channel is exclusively for american viewers. My comment was just a suggestion to him that he would get more viewers with those sports. So now, i shall suggest to you to be quiet you complete dipshit.
nabilion 5 months ago
@nabilion im not on my own uve already been told to gtfo
fulatl111 5 months ago
@fulatl111 my problem wasnt as much about suggesting other sports, but the fact that you say no-one cares about NFL. Im guessin that ur from australian, right? im half australian and 5 aussie rule punters are in the nfl and your channels are filled with nfl programmes. The NFL is massive outside the US too, just because you nor of your friends like it doesnt change that. Behind soccer, american sport is the biggest sport in the world.
fulatl111 5 months ago
@fulatl111 Lol, now i know you don't know what you are talking about. Cricket is the biggest sport outside soccer everyone knows that.
nabilion 5 months ago
5 QBs in "Brady's Class" just off the top of my head...
Brady, of course
Vick, if last season wasn't a fluke, was an absolute monster
Rodgers
Rivers
Brees
Hell, Eli isn't even the best QB in his family! The only good thing I can say about Eli where others may see him as better Brady is his superbowl performance over Brady. Even then, Brady has won more of those big games than Eli will probably even get to.
LoneRanger10540 6 months ago
Comment removed
Kenaich 6 months ago
eli's 4 years younger than brady, he still has time to prove himself
ArdPulaStudios 6 months ago
hell no! numbers say it all...
Junkbox09 6 months ago
Best QBs: Peyton Manning, Drew Brees, and Tom Brady. Let's just leave it at that.
critterboy9 6 months ago
Eli Manning is a very good QB but saying hes in the same class as Tom Brady...is going too far smh. Sit down Eli and fans who actually think Eli manning is better than Brady. Youre in COMPLETE and UTTER DENIAL!!!!!
bslclarke3 6 months ago
Put it this way Tom Brady is the type of quarterback that is expected to make it to the superbowl or far in the post season no matter how much he team changes around him. Can we say the same for Eli? Not really.
MFGBeefy 6 months ago
Just tell me wtf is Eli supposed to think? Hes the worst? Eli said in his own opinion.
dxclusiv94 6 months ago
WTF Eli just when the Osi situation ends you come and say some stupid shit to bring more negative attention to the Giants organization.. THANKS!
NewEraNYK 6 months ago
Plus, if you remember, Eli Manning beat Tom Brady in the Super Bowl to prevent the perfect season. No other quarterback in NFL history can say that. Thus proving that Eli Manning Is Better Than Tom Brady
feelgood6 6 months ago
@feelgood6 ...Except for the fact that other players besides Eli and Brady played in that game...
You sir, are a dumbass.
Ocelllian2 6 months ago
@Ocelllian2 ... See now, there's no need for name calling. Yes, obviously there were other players playing in that Super Bowl. But he and that offense drove down that field and scored to take the lead and eventually the win right when it mattered with everything on the line. I can't argue stats, but head to head when it really counts, sorry friend, Eli got him. I will just say this, Brady gets a free pass a lot of the time. While Eli gets a lot of undeserved negativity even though he's great.
feelgood6 6 months ago
@feelgood6 And Tom did the same thing in the Superbowls he was in. You remember them scoring with 00:00 on the clock against the rams? You remember the playoff game against the Raiders?
Manning scored on the Pats defense in a clutch situation.
Brady scored on the Rams, Panthers, Raiders, and Giants defense in clutch situations.
The point is yes, Manning did score. But there was nothing that Brady could do to stop him, so its really not Brady's fault.
Ocelllian2 6 months ago
Eli Manning gets a lot of crap for no reason. He has had back to back 4,000 yards passing seasons with his top two receivers injured for significant time. With the exception to the past two years, gets his team into the playoffs. He is a Super Bowl Champion and Super Bowl MVP. He plays the game the right way and I am proud of the fact he is the quarterback of my favorite team. We'll see who's better when it's all said and done. You wanna know what? ELI MANNING IS BETTER THAN TOM BRADY!!!!!!!!
feelgood6 6 months ago
Here's what's funny to me, Eli had 25 INT, but Drew Brees had 22, and no one mentions a peep about that.
PUNKem733 6 months ago
Tom Brady>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Eli Manning
FDASARO 6 months ago
Eli manning,better, and Tom Brady shouldn't even be in the same sentence unless ur saying Brady is a million times better than Eli
IWAX21 6 months ago
There is absolutely NO way that Eli Manning is even close to as good as Tom Brady. Tom Brady is Tom Brady & Eli Manning is Eli Manning. So what is Eli beat Brady in the Super Bowl in '07, that's just one ring. Tom Brady won 3 super bowls with the Pats. I mean he's good & he's knows what he's doing, but he DAMN SURE ain't better than Brady. End of Story.
JF192 6 months ago
bradys the greastest of all time cuz he carried the pats 2 the superbowls and he made no named WRs better meaning hell make anyone good and better than eli.but peyton got 2 giv him props tho
TheAlmada54 6 months ago
I apologize I wasn't talking strictly stats so much as success but you are right. And true his INT total for last year should have been around 15 had it not been for the tipped passes of his receivers. His mental game is not nearly where it should be to be put in such an elite class of QBs
utleyphils26 6 months ago
Maybe this is because I'm an eagles fan but I would not put Eli in the top 5 Qbs right now. He is overrated and nothing without plax to catch his poorly thrown passes
utleyphils26 6 months ago
@utleyphils26 couldn't be more wrong. His two best passing seasons were without plaxico. Like JR said he only threw 25 INTs this year because his receivers screwed him.
FreshKiNg27 6 months ago
Mike = Tom Brady
TheUniverseStudios 6 months ago
Eli Manning states he's in the same class as Tom Brady, once again proving how dangerous concussions really are.
TeriyakiB0i 6 months ago
Tom brady is not bettr than peyton. And im a jets fan. He tered apart our defense in 09 brady didnt do shit against us
KnuckleWhisperer 6 months ago
@KnuckleWhisperer ya... brady didn't do shit to you except become a dynasty and absolutely own the AFC east until rex got to the jets... don't tell me that you just hopped on the jets bandwagon...
MrJeckel 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@KnuckleWhisperer ya... brady didn't do shit to you except become a dynasty and absolutely own the AFC east until rex got to the jets... don't tell me that you just hopped on the jets bandwagon...
MrJeckel 6 months ago
I am a Giant Fan but Tom Brady is way better QB. Great confidence but get better than your brother Peyton before Tom Brady
TheQBoogie 6 months ago
to the "eli beat tom" thing ya id say thats a ridiculous thing to use to compare as well. I mean... phillip rivers beat peyton manning in the playoffs and usually always beats peyton yet i wouldn't hear a soul say that rivers>peyton. imo the top echelon of qb's last yr was brady, vick, Peyton manning, Rivers, Rodgers, Brees. Eli was just below that. at least eli>crappy jay cutler rofl.
MrJeckel 6 months ago
Eli manning aint tom brady. thats obvious. He has immense talent but i swear its like he's slow in the head sometimes. He PANICKS in the pocket, throws into double/triple coverage a lot and imo isn't that great of a leader either.
MrJeckel 6 months ago
no
Stroup50 6 months ago
eli manning is like a tony romo. good god why couldnt the giants have kept phil rivers man. the giants would be a vaslty netter team than we are now. sigh. but hey things happen for a reason
combat2thearms 6 months ago
@combat2thearms I agree to the fullest with your comparison.
MrJeckel 6 months ago