x factor 4 Beverley without you showdown

[jennyfer0720]

I'm going to go see this woman perform at my old church tomorrow night and I wasnt aware of how fantastic she is. Really looking forward to it now!

[irishsellerguy]

Shoulda went much further

Sucks that an over-25 will never win the show, seen as they're usually the best by a mile

[Beverley, Nikki, Ruth, Rachel]

[cctps]

Erm...Steve Brookstein was an Over-25...

[mikebenjislove123]

espically Ruth not in final's

[VictorUeberbacker]

@irishsellerguy I couldnt agree more! Its usually my favorite category and its sad to see them eliminated for the wrong reasons

[holder1981]

amazing

[katherinnnnne]

the massiv shock was that she went home that week, i think it was week 6

[cronaldo4evr]

what was the massive shock??

and what week was this?

[l4ur4z3h4ck3r]

the massive shock was the result, it reached deadlock and everyone was expecting beverley to stay in but she didnt, this was week 6

[theN17yidarmy]

i remember her i really wanted her to win love you beverly :D!

[themaster5272]

Leona > Beverley > Alexandra

[BluAngelz7]

Excellent. I couldn't remember until just now the name of the bow legged Scottish bloke who won ex factor until just now when I read it from another poster. He's sooo 'whatever'. Beverley out-classes him out-sings him, everything, every time. Louis looks like his conscience is bugging him in this VT. What a f**king fix!

[mrman890]

@BluAngelz7 his name was steve brookstein he was a decent singer but not capable of winning the x factor i think beverley deffinetly out shone him

[chris7ag]

the song did suit her and she did pull it off it was just very lucky for hope that they stayed in and not beverley

[PinkSugar606]

louis face showed that he liked it not that he didnt. look at the end, he stands up and claps

[JestaJestaJesta]

"Leona Lewis sings without in her audition too and they both did a good job of it. "

She sings Somewhere over the Rainbow..

[captainpringle123]

In one of her bootcamp auditions...she sung without you there

[frazzler9]

did she? i know she sang when you tell me that u love me and natural woman at judges house... but im pretty sure she sang 'I'm a woman'

[JestaJestaJesta]

Final should of been:

Alisha Niki And Beverley...

I cried when those 3 went out.. :(

But, these things happen. :)

[wongwager]

its those stupid rich ppl who votes their favs over n over again on the phone....

its not about talent... its about popuolarity.... ffs.. leon most performance are not as good as others n nervous.. n he wins?? wtf??

[anikanash]

Leona Lewis sings without in her audition too and they both did a good job of it.

[carebear4841]

can anybody please put the judge comment thanks

[markanderson4]

the final 3 should of been rhydian niki and beverley in that order

[Knuxy]

In my opinion, based on pure singing talent, I think that the Final 3 should have been Rhydian, Beverley, and Nikki, in that order.

I actually can't say I like Leona's version better than Beverley's nor the I like Beverley's version more than Leona's. They're so different, yet they both sound outstanding.

Can't believe that Beverley went out after a performance like that.

[JJlilstar]

it was good and all but i luved leona singing this

[BGrade15]

I agree, there was too much of a comparison. In season 3, Leona blew the nation away when she sang this on week 8, so people compared...I think Beverly did amazing though,

[seanhill111]

brenda from xfactor 2 also went home on this song =[=[

[KirstyJo08]

i would LOVE Niki to do her version of this song it would be AMAZIGGG x

[kingwolfman123]

love this woman i was shocked when she went out but thats da general public vote 4 u youve got 2 be eye candi 2 win these days

[wongwager]

that might be why leon won over Rhydian....

n in x factor 2 - Brenda had the better voice but she didnt win!!

[seanhill111]

OMFG , your sooo right

brenda was a legend , i downloaded all her songs =]=]

[BGrade15]

wongwager - the best act has never won on X-Factor apart from 2006.

[baudelaire002]

what an amazing voice

[bozzkub]

that's good , seriously good! but i agree with the comment above....only leona can top that song.

[seanpeterhill]

this song is the bad 1 lol

theres only leona who has sung it an not left

first brenda then beverly

who next ??? LOL

brenda rocks