@MisterNifty Yeah if you guys ever actually sang anything. I don't know about you, but all the white people in my ward don't sing- all I ever hear is *mumble mumble mumble* when it comes to singing hymns.
@Bananianiown Indeed. Yet, what if we didn't sing? What if we just lived harmless instead? What if we pulled up our pants and showed up to work everyday and on time? And what if life was like a beautiful suburb with the pretty birds singing and fluttering about as every good boy and girl said "Yes Mam, I will do my homework! And, yes Sir, I will eat my brocolli!"
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Typical Mormon plagiarism--Growing up in Utah as a mormon, and since moving away, I have seen so many situations where mormons try to take credit for others works. Hints of Spading perhaps???
I don't think they're trying to take credit for this song. It's a very old, beautiful song that John Rutter arranged for choral. I think this version is lovely.
@spintobear I think you are generalizing unfairly. I'm a member and my experience is that we appreciate the works of our own certainly, but also of the great ones outside of the church, like Rutter, Wilcox, and the like. Just because a few bad apples exist doesn't mean the entire batch is spoiled. I'm a huge fan of all composers and arrangers.
Wilberg did NOT write it! The hymn originally appeared in the second edition of Songs of Praise in 1931 to the tune "Bunessan", arranged by the composer Martin Shaw. Eleanor Farjeon had been "asked to make a poem to fit the lovely gaelic tune". A slight variation on the original hymn, also written by Farjeon, can be found in the anthology Children's Bells, under the title "A Morning Song. Stevens included an acoustic version on his 1971 album Teaser and the Firecat.
basically what he is telling you is that this song is not a Hymn and it was not written by Mac Wilberg- it is a Cat Stevens Folk song, that was arranged (by permission) by Mac Wilberg.
Cat Stevens did not write "Morning Has Broken." It is a hymn sung in the United Kingdom. The lyrics were written by the English poet, Eleanor Farjeon, and set to an old gaelic tune "Bunnessan." (That's a town in Scotland)
Nothing beats listening to a choir sing a hymn
Larrygallis 4 months ago 2
shit
IKILLANGELZ 7 months ago
I really like being a white person. When we sing, we sound harmless.
MisterNifty 7 months ago
@MisterNifty Yeah if you guys ever actually sang anything. I don't know about you, but all the white people in my ward don't sing- all I ever hear is *mumble mumble mumble* when it comes to singing hymns.
Bananianiown 7 months ago
@Bananianiown Indeed. Yet, what if we didn't sing? What if we just lived harmless instead? What if we pulled up our pants and showed up to work everyday and on time? And what if life was like a beautiful suburb with the pretty birds singing and fluttering about as every good boy and girl said "Yes Mam, I will do my homework! And, yes Sir, I will eat my brocolli!"
MisterNifty 7 months ago
What a wonderful hymn...well sung and well created!
GreatSamoana 1 year ago
Too controlled...what I'd expect from a Mormon arrangement.
shalom43 1 year ago
Calm thy heart and mind. Peace be with you.
coronet72 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Typical Mormon plagiarism--Growing up in Utah as a mormon, and since moving away, I have seen so many situations where mormons try to take credit for others works. Hints of Spading perhaps???
spintobear 2 years ago
I don't think they're trying to take credit for this song. It's a very old, beautiful song that John Rutter arranged for choral. I think this version is lovely.
joshstoph 2 years ago 2
praise God you have left, only one in 40 do. don't like this version either. Looking for one.
epitt22 2 years ago
@spintobear I think you are generalizing unfairly. I'm a member and my experience is that we appreciate the works of our own certainly, but also of the great ones outside of the church, like Rutter, Wilcox, and the like. Just because a few bad apples exist doesn't mean the entire batch is spoiled. I'm a huge fan of all composers and arrangers.
eltrompo83 1 year ago
Wilberg did NOT write it! The hymn originally appeared in the second edition of Songs of Praise in 1931 to the tune "Bunessan", arranged by the composer Martin Shaw. Eleanor Farjeon had been "asked to make a poem to fit the lovely gaelic tune". A slight variation on the original hymn, also written by Farjeon, can be found in the anthology Children's Bells, under the title "A Morning Song. Stevens included an acoustic version on his 1971 album Teaser and the Firecat.
1950Bob 2 years ago
Could be wrong, but sounds an awful lot like the melody Cat Stevens (now Yusuf Islam) wrote for lyrics by Eleanor Farjeon.
Maratini 3 years ago
Cat Stevens did not write the music either. It is a gaelic tune called "Bunessan".
Hubbub9999 2 years ago 5
It is the same song, but Cat Stevens did not write it. It had already been around for a long time.
joshstoph 2 years ago
Actually is: A beautiful rendition of the hymn by MACK WILBERG
symplemplam 3 years ago
Credit has been given . . Thanks.
CarpentersCh 3 years ago
basically what he is telling you is that this song is not a Hymn and it was not written by Mac Wilberg- it is a Cat Stevens Folk song, that was arranged (by permission) by Mac Wilberg.
obviologist 2 years ago
Cat Stevens did not write "Morning Has Broken." It is a hymn sung in the United Kingdom. The lyrics were written by the English poet, Eleanor Farjeon, and set to an old gaelic tune "Bunnessan." (That's a town in Scotland)
Hubbub9999 2 years ago 9
This is way better than any other rendition! Credit!!!
TheMattgaulke 1 month ago