you know i dont care if this is a lipsing,, because its still her voice right... so we just need to appreciate that...... but i still think that its not lip singing..
yes, but there is some talent to lipping as well... but mariah is a notoriously horrible lip syncer but is forced to because she no longer has the voice she had in the 90s.
Well she at least lipped some of it. I think the whistle was her though. I'm not really sure about any of the long notes on any of the live performances of this song. I think that the artist can pick and choose what they want to sing. Plus I hear they have software the auto-corrects whatever they sing. So if the note is off key then it will come out pitch perfect. Gotta love technology. Regardless, of whether it's lipped or not, it's her.
@homoalways1 mariah most likely arranged the vocal arrangements so its still a compliment to her......plus the background mikes are too loud.....but then again remember mariah did do backup......and mariah aint greedy for the spotlight as she should be....so many times in duets she lets the other partner take the lead
2 every1 who has sum thing 2 say bout MC U may b entitled to ur own opinion but no 1 can deny that she is blessed with the gift of song, creative writing skills, composer & music producer. No other artist will or has the power of all these gifts like MC. MC is not the Top Selling female artist of all time by accident. Can U bet those accomplishments? Believe it or not that sound is comin out of a person & that person is MC. Let her be!
Not really. Mariah's style of "live" performances is layered most of the time. It gives it an angelic voice. So basically, she is singing but in the background she has a prerecorded thing going on.. Kinda weird but the whistle comes so easily to her, its her belting ability that is slowly going.
@Filipina1Cutie It's not the belting that is affected, it's the middle that thinned out. She can belt fine, just not as much or as often as she did before.
@labellocereza1976 I see what you mean. I think the whistle was her though. I'm not really sure about any of the long notes on any of the live performances of this song.
@marianacostaw se vc fosse fa dela mesmo saberia que o refrao ela nao canta ao vivo pq as back vogais cantam ao vivo ai ela deixa elas catarem ai vivo
very very very exciting, with song mariah can touch hearts more sensitive, and the highest cloud in the sky
Ouvir
Ler foneticamente
Dicionário - Ver dicionário detalhadosubstantivo0.sightadjetivo0.plaguyadvérbio0.very0.much0.too0.a lot0.quite0.highly0.so0.greatly0.too much0.plenty0.a great deal of0.a good deal0.awfully0.exceedingly0.precious0.mighty0.rare0.deadly0.jolly0.passing0.ripping
I don't think anything has gone wrong with her vocally...i think it's more to do with the singles she chooses to release. Songs like her latest release with nicki nianj (spelling) don't showcase all of her vocal stregnths. But if you listen to her latest 'memoirs...' alum (esp 'angel's cry, my personal fav) you'll sing her vocals, range and strength is still as strong as ever.
I fear it's more about jumping the commercial bandwagon than nething else. Dont loose ur faith!!!!!
I suspected as well at 2.17...but it was just the shadow of her hand that covered her mouth briefly...but i think this is defo live. The way she is singing here is difficult to be mimed because it is quite spontaneous
@nono1182 heard bout NODULES>.thats her main prob..she dont want to remove it trough surgery..cause shes afraid that she will lost her trademark whistle register....have u heard bout what happen to julie andrews..she lost her singing voice after went for surgery to remove her nodules
when musical people like Malcolm Walker, Stephen Holden, Jeannette Lo Vetri, Sasha Frere-Jones, Jim Faber, Ron Givens praise her voice, you say what?? She is one of the best....n you should be gratefull. Coz you live in the same era.
@flirtycious I disagree!!! She always sings slightly differently when she's singing live. Shows that she doesn't need to mime her songs like so many artists these days. I think she's really taken good care of her voice
Makes me sad for people like Whitney who though she can still sing, can't sing like Whitney anymore. A really tragic loss :(
@bbnne1 wtf u talkn about i said shes a diva when da fuk did i say she was lip syhcn u fkn twit read what i sad...u must be on crack 4 real!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@nono1182 I don't think those women, as great as they all are, toured even half as much as Mariah did, and continues to do. She's been making hits her whole career and she needs a long, long break but her fans demand so much from her. The thing that gets me is all the haters who say Mariah is a hasbeen when she does take a short break even though she is one of the best selling artist of all time, yet I haven't heard any hits from divas like Aretha for at least 10 yrs and they still praise them.
@Lerlialen ummm mariahs last number 1 hit was in 2008
and her other last hit was in 2009 in late 2009 called obsessed and i dont know what planet you live in because im not even reely a mariah fan but she makes good songs and everyone thats alive and 13-40 knows about it like they always have.
@JulianDaniEmilyShow I don't get the point your trying to make then. I was saying that Mariah continues to make hits throughout her career even though the haters keep saying she is a hasbeen. I have never hated on this girl because she is one of the best. She's a music icon.
DAMN! listen to those backup singers they are pro! listen to them overlay there harmonies... these girls mean business! for anyone who is musically gifted listen from 2:10 im without words...
shes not singin after the whistle at 2.16 cuz the background singers are singin..they sung the whole thing along with her. she aint lip synch anythingg
@awmsantos i agree with you rusdion your a retard celine is alright but to feel your heart pump out of your chest when you hear mariah now that is a voice!!! mariah is amazing to still be here today and sing like she does
Wow shes awesome. Amazing, its awesome when she whistle when she sings. She has a habbit of raising her hand, or putting her fingers near her ear. lol
Ve nada mas que mujer tan guapa. Y canta con madre
joeymanuel 1 month ago in playlist Mariah Carey
This has been flagged as spam show
(Posted by Youtube Stream for iPhone (yst.me) on behalf of @strokinawa at twitter)
ystme 2 months ago
perfect!
al3xacat 2 months ago
you know i dont care if this is a lipsing,, because its still her voice right... so we just need to appreciate that...... but i still think that its not lip singing..
TheBeaganda 2 months ago
who can change of tone so quickly during singing, as she does ... she so amazing , definitly great !
maleek68 4 months ago
2:15 clocked...caught lipsyncing for eternal life but I don't care, I don't do it.
Kingmidus86 4 months ago
GET LOST TO THOSE WHO DESTROY THE IMAGE OF MARIAH CAREY! THE MORE YOU DO IT< THE MORE SHE BECAME FAMOUS! LONG LIVE MARIAH CAREY!
simplymealexis1 4 months ago
I BELIEVE THAT THE GODDESS OF MUSIC- MARIAH CAREY CAN STILL SING!
simplymealexis1 4 months ago
@simplymealexis1 SHE DEFINITELY CAN.
vangoghmatisse1 4 months ago
Chorus is very loud...
quake1qq 4 months ago
I love this song! now when I walk under the rain i'll sing it! <3
kami55junior 5 months ago
the best!
danielvai03 5 months ago
I love this song so much, combined with gospel! amazing! Mariah, you're so talented!
kami55junior 5 months ago 2
0:12 OMG .. she is amazing
trybeeMUSIC 5 months ago
1:55 to 2:08 is lip synch!
rich2992 5 months ago
hapi bday..!!!
MrRockersahead 6 months ago
ads me on facebook jhaztineabad@yahoo.com thank you !!
scarlexxify 6 months ago
its august 16 its my birthday !!!
scarlexxify 6 months ago
whata beatiful song !!
scarlexxify 6 months ago
SANE <3
Navizurc123 6 months ago
wow nice i love ur all song.. i always sing that wen il go videoke bar with my friends....
19891genevieve 6 months ago
is lipping another way of cheating?
dynatech13 7 months ago
@dynatech13
yes, but there is some talent to lipping as well... but mariah is a notoriously horrible lip syncer but is forced to because she no longer has the voice she had in the 90s.
KyleKleef 5 months ago
It's obvious that she's lip syncing..check between 2:15 and 2:18
kiskiak02 8 months ago 3
@kiskiak02 yea the belting parts are lipped but i dont think its the entire song.
lambychop98 8 months ago
@kiskiak02 Can I know How to highlight the Second and Minutes? which u did for "2:15" and "2:18"??
kyo1223 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you won't listen to this.. if it is not Mariah carey!!..
Awannano 8 months ago
Well she at least lipped some of it. I think the whistle was her though. I'm not really sure about any of the long notes on any of the live performances of this song. I think that the artist can pick and choose what they want to sing. Plus I hear they have software the auto-corrects whatever they sing. So if the note is off key then it will come out pitch perfect. Gotta love technology. Regardless, of whether it's lipped or not, it's her.
19bigdaddy87 8 months ago
Can i just hear the background singers? o_O
They sound more interesting then mariah carey herself, no disrespect lol
homoalways1 8 months ago 2
@homoalways1 mariah most likely arranged the vocal arrangements so its still a compliment to her......plus the background mikes are too loud.....but then again remember mariah did do backup......and mariah aint greedy for the spotlight as she should be....so many times in duets she lets the other partner take the lead
alastarification 8 months ago
2 every1 who has sum thing 2 say bout MC U may b entitled to ur own opinion but no 1 can deny that she is blessed with the gift of song, creative writing skills, composer & music producer. No other artist will or has the power of all these gifts like MC. MC is not the Top Selling female artist of all time by accident. Can U bet those accomplishments? Believe it or not that sound is comin out of a person & that person is MC. Let her be!
ajrlaws 9 months ago
2:15 SHE'S SOOOOOO LIPPING
labellocereza1976 9 months ago
@labellocereza1976
Not really. Mariah's style of "live" performances is layered most of the time. It gives it an angelic voice. So basically, she is singing but in the background she has a prerecorded thing going on.. Kinda weird but the whistle comes so easily to her, its her belting ability that is slowly going.
Filipina1Cutie 9 months ago
@Filipina1Cutie It's not the belting that is affected, it's the middle that thinned out. She can belt fine, just not as much or as often as she did before.
rekupp 9 months ago
@labellocereza1976 I see what you mean. I think the whistle was her though. I'm not really sure about any of the long notes on any of the live performances of this song.
19bigdaddy87 8 months ago
Meuu Deuss ..isso que e é cantoraaa eos backs nem se fala...Emocionei!!
LAURENHA24 9 months ago
mariah is so awkward.
oinkidoodle 9 months ago
@oinkidoodle define awkward cause i might be able to agree
Zondafreak93 9 months ago
8 people died in the rain
rohaishah 10 months ago 11
@rohaishah" Through the rain " or " through the flood"?
RusDion 2 months ago
this is obviously live..... nice... not bad!
hotjames2000 10 months ago
LIPPED
Tanginamosorian0 10 months ago
Mariah carey melhor cantora da historia sem duvidas....
leleuvp2 10 months ago
noossa sou muito fan dela mais fala serio hein ela só sabe dublar o refrão :/ lamentável
marianacostaw 10 months ago
@marianacostaw se vc fosse fa dela mesmo saberia que o refrao ela nao canta ao vivo pq as back vogais cantam ao vivo ai ela deixa elas catarem ai vivo
milarn2010 10 months ago
Comment removed
SlackerSince85 10 months ago
es la mejor interpretación en vivo que he visto de ella en esta canción, excelente, la amo es lo mejor!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
facamoy1979 11 months ago
i think the light was bothering her lol
livendlaugh973 11 months ago
My point proven i love you but chritina aguilera cant hit a note like her not that she sucks mariah is better end of story
Zondafreak93 11 months ago
she still a very very very good singers in all seasons i love you mariah carey....
maabelarde01 11 months ago
linda canção,letra que mexe com qualquer coração,além de uma bela voz.Parabéns Mariah!!!
cdupin1 11 months ago
This is PERFECT!....
ErrolGlenn 11 months ago
I don't know why it wasn't a HIT!!!! it's even better than we belong together!!!
juanruff013 11 months ago
@juanruff013 agree
kelvinpyaeko 11 months ago
nice
jlatifmusic 1 year ago
8 people need to get they ears checked fo real
lovelybre123 1 year ago 23
@lovelybre123 9 people!
TheLyricKidd 7 months ago
@lovelybre123 hearing impaired
RusDion 2 months ago
Mariah Carey I love you.
Mia12C 1 year ago 2
Breathtaking! And So Emotional! :')
91Xander91 1 year ago 2
very very very exciting, with song mariah can touch hearts more sensitive, and the highest cloud in the sky
Ouvir
Ler foneticamente
Dicionário - Ver dicionário detalhadosubstantivo0.sightadjetivo0.plaguyadvérbio0.very0.much0.too0.a lot0.quite0.highly0.so0.greatly0.too much0.plenty0.a great deal of0.a good deal0.awfully0.exceedingly0.precious0.mighty0.rare0.deadly0.jolly0.passing0.ripping
muitoralado 1 year ago 2
she sung this so amazingly, this woman never fails to amaze me
shaunaLOVESmimi 1 year ago
I love everything in this performance: her voice, the Whistle, her hair LOL
She's perfect!!!
MariahCareyAngel1 1 year ago 4
i have goosebumps :]
ilovemarz 1 year ago
speechless
abacagefighting 1 year ago 4
@nono1182
I don't think anything has gone wrong with her vocally...i think it's more to do with the singles she chooses to release. Songs like her latest release with nicki nianj (spelling) don't showcase all of her vocal stregnths. But if you listen to her latest 'memoirs...' alum (esp 'angel's cry, my personal fav) you'll sing her vocals, range and strength is still as strong as ever.
I fear it's more about jumping the commercial bandwagon than nething else. Dont loose ur faith!!!!!
voiyce 1 year ago
...is she not wearing a bra?
Frafty 1 year ago
@Frafty lol
bibizoca1000 1 year ago
Is it live?.....you never know with mariah sometimes she mixes pre recorded part in the song....
darrin1701 1 year ago 3
@darrin1701
I suspected as well at 2.17...but it was just the shadow of her hand that covered her mouth briefly...but i think this is defo live. The way she is singing here is difficult to be mimed because it is quite spontaneous
voiyce 1 year ago
simply the greatest voice in history...anyone who doesnt shed a tear after watching this is devoid of humanity n a heart mariah 4 ever
littlemissinnocen 1 year ago
@nono1182 heard bout NODULES>.thats her main prob..she dont want to remove it trough surgery..cause shes afraid that she will lost her trademark whistle register....have u heard bout what happen to julie andrews..she lost her singing voice after went for surgery to remove her nodules
nassrol 1 year ago
2:09 y 2:10 what a note
THEBABECOCACOLA 1 year ago
Beutiful...... just dont like the backup singers :S
Mariah alone please <3<3
94082206528 1 year ago
i can always tell what kinda note shes gonna sing because of her hand movements lol True lamb !
BigRoy0824 1 year ago
when musical people like Malcolm Walker, Stephen Holden, Jeannette Lo Vetri, Sasha Frere-Jones, Jim Faber, Ron Givens praise her voice, you say what?? She is one of the best....n you should be gratefull. Coz you live in the same era.
nicodemouz 1 year ago
she cant sing her own song the way it used 2 be...
flirtycious 1 year ago
@flirtycious I disagree!!! She always sings slightly differently when she's singing live. Shows that she doesn't need to mime her songs like so many artists these days. I think she's really taken good care of her voice
Makes me sad for people like Whitney who though she can still sing, can't sing like Whitney anymore. A really tragic loss :(
voiyce 1 year ago
@bbnne1 wtf u talkn about i said shes a diva when da fuk did i say she was lip syhcn u fkn twit read what i sad...u must be on crack 4 real!!!!!!!!!!!!!
littlemissinnocen 1 year ago
amazing! as always! legend!
CyprusHot 1 year ago
wow, her breasts are a little too big for her to not be wearing a bra!
marinasvoice 1 year ago
D____I_____V______A
littlemissinnocen 1 year ago
She was definitely lipping at 2:17 the mic wasn't even close to her mouth.
MusicallyUbiquitous 1 year ago
@MusicallyUbiquitous
i suspected as well but mics can pick up sound when they're not glued to the lips :)
voiyce 1 year ago
1:52
eduzinhoxvre 1 year ago
she doesnt have an underware
luwiboyet 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
so glad she was in Precious!
WishesSailorMoon 1 year ago
she is trying to hid her face so bad during the climax
Crzymofo69 1 year ago
best
dtamato 1 year ago
i dont care what you say, she hit my fav part live " i hold tighter to my faith" she rules!
bigsteel 1 year ago 36
wow! luv Mariah
MiccaLamcka 1 year ago
so really high notes of mariah carey.. I love her voice....
lolqueto 1 year ago
is someone heard her "falsetto" its amazing
jayvi2 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lip sync
argel696 1 year ago
@argel696 fuck no!
bigsteel 1 year ago
Legend!
JCGandMe 1 year ago
@nono1182 I don't think those women, as great as they all are, toured even half as much as Mariah did, and continues to do. She's been making hits her whole career and she needs a long, long break but her fans demand so much from her. The thing that gets me is all the haters who say Mariah is a hasbeen when she does take a short break even though she is one of the best selling artist of all time, yet I haven't heard any hits from divas like Aretha for at least 10 yrs and they still praise them.
Lerlialen 1 year ago
@Lerlialen ummm mariahs last number 1 hit was in 2008
and her other last hit was in 2009 in late 2009 called obsessed and i dont know what planet you live in because im not even reely a mariah fan but she makes good songs and everyone thats alive and 13-40 knows about it like they always have.
JulianDaniEmilyShow 1 year ago 2
@JulianDaniEmilyShow I don't get the point your trying to make then. I was saying that Mariah continues to make hits throughout her career even though the haters keep saying she is a hasbeen. I have never hated on this girl because she is one of the best. She's a music icon.
Lerlialen 1 year ago
what with that hand? xd
tahminelovesibrahim 1 year ago 2
I looove the bridge in this song. It's so beautiful!
MCLambDahling3000 1 year ago 5
Wooow, amazing performance as usual! =)
She's the BEST!
JCGandMe 1 year ago
what happened at 2:17 she's not singing but you can hear her...singing....
yesAudis4 1 year ago 2
@yesAudis4 because the backing track vocals come in and out and she got mixed up with the parts she's singing live and the parts she is lipping to.
tatufan 1 year ago
@yesAudis4 she is singing, just that you can't see it in the video?
BBQJester 1 year ago
@yesAudis4
means Mariah is not singing live??
homeboy1980 1 year ago
love her voice,also those whisles,those freaky hand movements.lol.LOVE HER!
ocirej101193 1 year ago
wow with the whistle warm ups!!
brownclown1309 1 year ago
still Mariah's the best!
ashrafd1 1 year ago
I'm dying over the background vocalists. SO f.ing sick.
Katajazz 1 year ago 3
ARIES : mARIAH ,GENIAL
rodryeminogue 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sometimes she lips her song too much , so it looks even more fake !
lockritahchicqk10 1 year ago
1 love this song it makes me cry
luvmariahcarey03 1 year ago 2
DAMN! listen to those backup singers they are pro! listen to them overlay there harmonies... these girls mean business! for anyone who is musically gifted listen from 2:10 im without words...
kahaman247 2 years ago 77
@kahaman247 yes they are especially mary ann tatum...just fabulous
1dreamlover1 1 year ago
@kahaman247 They are DARN GOOD!!!!
aiswarya83 1 year ago
@kahaman247 I would so love to sing for Mariah!
AustinWilliam2009 1 year ago
This song is live completly. She sings like an angel. She's the best diva in the worls. She's Mariah Carey.
Davidprogressista 2 years ago 4
check out 2:16/17/18 her lips arent moving!!! hahahahaha caught her miming he hard shit.... and people slate whitney :O
cantbelieveitsnotemo 2 years ago
@cantbelieveitsnotemo her lips are moving.
jason1012063 1 year ago
@cantbelieveitsnotemo Her shadow is blocking her mouth u moron! look closely and you'll see her lips move
voiyce 1 year ago
She really should have wear a bra!Her boobs are hanging real bad here!!
RiPcOrDz83 2 years ago
It's partly live, partly lipped. Sure!! I have listened to this song for thousands times..
hiareuok 2 years ago
It was totally live, she was hoarse, just that. When we are hoarse, it´s easier to sing the high notes and whistles.
blessedhearted 2 years ago 2
I love this song...
Paburo14 2 years ago 2
the choir is too damn louddd it's great performance though
Abstractionant 2 years ago
her voice cracked a lot, i wish she sang this song completely live and without the choir, thatd just be fantastic
AnnieThelen14 2 years ago 3
that was great
msbond700 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
pause at 2:35, look at her boobs, it's on her hips already!
bobumer 2 years ago
LOVE HER,HER VOICE AND THIS SONG....
TheStarlightbaby89 2 years ago 5
that's definately live... Her voice is amazing..
yammb 2 years ago 4
its completely LIVE!!! her voice is just so great and pure that it sounds like her original record! take tht
Princesslingling911 2 years ago 5
shes not singin after the whistle at 2.16 cuz the background singers are singin..they sung the whole thing along with her. she aint lip synch anythingg
CUTESWEETPETiTE 2 years ago 6
Comment removed
RusDion 2 years ago
such an imbecile comparison. u have nothing left to do really, huh? celine.....immature mooron.
awmsantos 2 years ago
@awmsantos i agree with you rusdion your a retard celine is alright but to feel your heart pump out of your chest when you hear mariah now that is a voice!!! mariah is amazing to still be here today and sing like she does
leviano2004 2 years ago
your a f@$%kwit, maybe that helps
anarukaa 2 years ago
i am a mariah carey's biggest fan.but mariah carey LIP SYNCH of some part of songs.but stil she sings it.duh!
LOVE MIMI
kalogs0708 2 years ago
mariah doesnt have to lip sing idiots...
othman26 2 years ago 4
this is totaly live !!Are you guy deaf or what !you can tel that with closed eyes
emma86100 2 years ago
It's partly live, partly lipped. You can very obviously see that she's not singing after the whistle at 2.16. Oops.
cloudwalker86 2 years ago
@cloudwalker86
I saw that part too, especially at 2:16-2:18 ;<sad to say that ;<
homeboy1980 1 year ago
sooo live.. her voice is just that fine that you think it's a lip sync
dotyann0827 2 years ago
LIIIIIIIIIVEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
iluvmylay 2 years ago 5
GOOSEBUMPS! OMFG... AMAZING! ;D
ayhk1988 2 years ago
live,mariah is totally AMAZING~!!
love her much....n oso,the back up singers r great as well=)
PoPppp17 2 years ago
She's lipsyncing. Maybe not the whole song but half song is playback at least
charlie14784 2 years ago
No shes not
anamariaaa33 2 years ago 2
Wow shes awesome. Amazing, its awesome when she whistle when she sings. She has a habbit of raising her hand, or putting her fingers near her ear. lol
cool7654321 2 years ago
I Really love her so much.I love english language because of her.Thank Mariah. ^_^
moonok555 2 years ago 3
incredible voice!!!..but what happens at 2:16???
86deepblue 2 years ago
She forgets to lip synch.
cloudwalker86 2 years ago
Great! I love that song and of course Mariah!!
Sternenprinzesschen 2 years ago
amazing i almost cried :(
ayshay5656 2 years ago 2
Great performance of this amazing song !
xpt612 2 years ago
u can tell if u are a musician that she is not lypsinging
Ninaki13th 2 years ago 5
wasnt it lipsynching?
DanielCMM 2 years ago 2
Are you a musician? Let's put it this way: if you're DEAF, she's singing LIVE! Bye
charlie14784 2 years ago
tahts what i said u idiot..she is singing live
Ninaki13th 2 years ago
and if you're BLIND, she's lipped... It's live.
Feehily81 2 years ago
i think it's the cam's fault...it's no lipsync
ursuioana 2 years ago 5
I love this song I just love it
Learta1 2 years ago 4
1:53 WOW
Did yu se that? Her face adn she used her whole body to give that note meaning...WOW she was living this sing right thur on stage! WOW! WOW!
SJEEZUS 2 years ago 32
@SJEEZUS
leona lewis never will be MARIAH CAREY
got it simon?
NEVER
MARIAH IS ONE OF THE BEST SINGER IN THE WORLD
eduzinhoxvre 1 year ago 4
@eduzinhoxvre correction she aint one of da best shes da best thats it no touches her whitney lost it its been all mariah since da 90's
littlemissinnocen 1 year ago
she is fucking good
eaglelifezz 2 years ago 5
die beste auf der ganzen wellllllllllttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt i love you mariah carey forever
hachim456 2 years ago 3
ich liebe dich
hachim456 2 years ago 5
I think the backup singers are too strong, but Mariah still did an amazing job.
b30owna 2 years ago 7
i love mariah, but i think she is lipsync in here.=[
sweet13prettyheart 2 years ago
Check out 2:17 LIVE? Whatever. I love Mariah but this is lipsync and it is not the first time for her. WAKE UP, PEOPLE!
fulldelight 2 years ago 2
only part is lipped
XforeverlongingX 2 years ago