You know what? This is a real masterpiece. I watched it for some times but really, I understood how wonderful it is just from the second or the third try. brilliant. How you mix the pieces of video and these visual effects (especially clolors) this matches the song so much!
i was wondering if you could fix the download link from this vid on your livejournal acc. I totally love this and i would like to re-watch it again ((i promise i do not intend into copying the clips or anything is just for enjoyment)) like 'In her Eyes' vid but yeah it says the link's broken :( .
Wow, very well done. The alternating between black and white vs colour was timed exactly right, and the end, with the watch, his face, and her name was the icing on the cake. <3
Oh.. My.. God.. This video is like THE must-see on Youtube in Doctor Who fandom. Seriously. It's just, W-O-W. Yeah, the whole plot and the matching clips is just brilliant as our beloved Ten would say, right? Hehe, amazing job on this one! :D
Wowsa! Thankyou so much! This was the video that really-did-not-get-made, and ironically it has become my highest rater. *shrugs* Life's funny that way. I'm really thrilled you enjoyed it that much, thankyou!
You're welcome! Oh my god. I can relate to that so much. That's the same with my Untouched video, which was like so "boring" to make, but it's my most faved and commented vid. Highest rated, nope. That honour does My Path have. Lol :) Anyways, you're welcome. It's stunning.
This is a brilliant video. The song was beautiful too. It almost brought tears to my eyes it was so sad. I remember almost crying when I watched the episode itself. Great work here!
Thankyou very much. It is a lovely song - I always thought Within Temptation did their best work when they weren't trying to be a rock rip-off. And as you said, the ep itself was such an emotional train ride, I barely had to do anything! :D Thanks again for your lovely comment!
Certainly in my Top Favourite Doctor Who Videos of all time... I would say 2nd. behind Seduff My Immortal!
This video is so beautiful! and I have seen it loads of times and was shocked to see I haven't favourited it (I have now) and 5 stars! Fantastic FANTASTIC video! So beautiful! I love it so much :D xxx Brilliant, the song is amazing EVERYTHING is wonderful!! Love it love it love it =D
Wow! Thankyou very much, that is absolutely amazing feedback for a vidmaker to receive, and I am extremely chuffed to be amongst your top favourites! *beams massively* Thankyou, you have absolutely made my day!
Thankyou! I use Vegas Movie Studio and the version I have is not too expensive cos its the beginners. You should be able to find it in a program store if you're interested. Glad you liked the vid!
Sorry I've been late replying, its exam week (nuf said.) Your comment gave me a lovely buzz, thankyou. Editing is a subject dear to my heart so its an awesome comment :)
I've just begun using Song Vegas platinum. I just starting to get used to it, however, the vid I did with it, did come 1st in a contest. Stargate Atlantis - Fallen Hero: Carson Beckett vid.
Ooh, I'm jealous. I keep saving up for a better version (can't do much with this one at all) but I'm a uni student so I'm always strapped for cash :( Are you out there Santa? *looks around hopefully*
aww im glad my comment made ur day hehe btw piffo! yes i followed ur advice and started watching it today you're right is soo much fun! hehe i thought it wasn't gonna be so good since Rose left :( but still is fun and the Dr hasn't forget Rose at all so i like it :P
Wonderful video. Great choice of clips and all. I loved both the stills at the beginning, and also the voices. You chose great extracts, such as the 'I'm never gonna leave you' bit, with a slight echo. The lyrics really fitted in with your clips: great editing. Very, very good. :)
Thankyou very much! Its great to know exactly what people liked for future reference, so thanks for letting me know. The fact that the lyrics were so groovy was why I did it in the first place :) Thanks again!
I used stills? *thinks back* I haven't watched this vid for a looong time. Oh, right, at the beginning. Yes, they are saturated, I liked the slightly more dramatic effect with the beat. Glad you enjoyed!
OH MY GOD!!! That woz beautiful, amazing, wonderful!! The lyrics to it were facinating and 'across the borders of time' with the rift and Roses eyes there woz awesome!! Ur brill at doing these lol! Cud i ask yooh no where rose is in the tardis and she outstretches her arm and theres a light behind her--is that the parting of the ways?? Enyway well done- 5/5!!
Thankyou very much! I'm glad you liked the eyes of the rift, that was one of my favourite parts :D The scene of Rose with her arm outstretched is from Bad Wolf, when the Doctor suddenly 'remembers' how he ended up in the Big Brother House. Rose is being transmatted.
Loool oh yeh! I fort it wz wen she wz lookin in the heart of the tardis n she got pulled in2 sumat bt i fort-that dow happen!! Loool well done enyway-fantastic!
Thanks! Yeah the idea was that Rose was a large component of the 'dreams' John Smith kept having and part of the reason he was so fascinated by them. There is some great fanfic out there that explores this idea. As to Rose being the girl of the DOctor's dreams - I'll guess we'll see when they meet again next season!
You tease you.X) I hope their reunion is sweet, or at least as memorable as their seperation. (Please sign up for the 2009 spcials Billie! I'll give you candy if you do.)
Thanks! All credit goes to the song, the lyrics were so perfect for the eps that they haunted me for ages even though I was doing a different vid at the time :) Glad you enjoyed!
Wow, thankyou so much! Its a wonderful compliment that you think its that good, I'm grinning like an idiot right now :D (Sorry about the late reply, life has been crazy this last week and I haven't seen a bloody computer that doesn't have homework on it.) Thankyou again for your lovely comment! Really made my day.
it's absolutely brillant the moment when she says "I'm never gonna leave you" with her face zooming up and mixing with the drawing, that's an absolutely intense effect. I've tried to played this song at the guitar cause it's just brilliant.
Thankyou very much! I thought her hair looked the most like the drawing in the Satan Pit. (Sorry for the late reply, uni's just gone back and I haven't stopped all week) Can you play this song at the guitar? Thats really awesome, I've always admired people who can do that. I play the clarinet but I need the sheet music right in front of me!
Thankyou for your lovely comment! Hey its no problem, youtube screws up on me all the time. I'm very flattered you intended to give it 5 anyway! And I'm definitely no genius, just a nerdy fangirl with too much time on her hands ;D
omg that video has sooo much emotion in it that i cried, but its not in the upset kinda way....its something different. I love all of your videos, your like a geniusor something! LOL!
omg is the best way to put this lol this is bloody brilliant!!! its just so wow lol. untill now i never thought i would meet a 10/rose shipper as big as me lol (trust me im huuuuge) lol but you certaintly do, best 10/rose vid EVER!!!!!!
waw, I'm amazed, it's so...waw...I can't find my words, it's so full of emotion, so intensely charged. Really, really well done, it sums up rose and the doctor's love story.
Beautiful. I loved Human Nature also because they used Rose's theme song a few times in the episode(one of them was when John Smith was kissing Joan!!) which made it really sweet. Well done!
well, I sort of thought it was showing the comparisons between the two and what it would be like between the Doctor and Rose if the Doctor could ever settle down and how the doctor still loves Rose etc - I guess I'm a bit of a hopeless romantic when it comes to 10/Rose though...:)
Hey, nothing wrong with being a hopeless romantic, especially when it comes to a pair as legendary as these two. :) Had Rose been there, I imagine John Smith would have been even more intense and loving...
And since I didn't say this before, piffo, VERY good job on the video! The only thing I think you could have changed would have been the Doctor's whisper of "Rose" at the end...maybe you could have made it a bit louder? *shrug* Just thinking.
I read the most beautiful fic where that exact scenario happened-instead of 1940 the TARDIS dropped them when Rose was 18.She and the Doctor met and fell in love... The most heartbreaking HN/FOB fic I think I read.
Its great to know you liked it!The fact you wouldn't change anything is a great compliment.The reason the 'Rose' is quiet is because of the bloody Doomsday music in the background-I don't have an audio editor so I kept it soft to hide the track.Its the cheat's way ;)
Brilliant! I'm a big fan of Within Temptation and you made great use of this song. The flashes and stitches in this video were just so well done and I really liked the concept! Great work once again!
This has been in my favourite list for awhile. Really love it. I feel like crying now - hope Rose's return will be fulfilling for all her fans, like myself i.e. Romantic! :-P
Me too. I'm so worried about it - RTD's attitude that 'Doctor Who is for kids' seems to spell death for any strong emotional commitment. But then again, VOTD seemed to suggest the Doctor was more open to emotions... I dunno. All I know is that if they've both 'moved on' I will be dusting off my pitchfork and torches.
And really glad you liked my vid! (sorry about the rant ;D )
lovely gem of a video! I've never seen such a dark one about the Human Nature/Family of Blood eps (I mean that in a good way) What program did you use for editing? Obviously not movie maker! XD
Thanks! I'm very angst-vid orientated, tried fluff but it just doesn't seem to take. I have the beginners version of Vegas Movie Studio (not the $800 one!). I started on WMM but wanted to branch out. Its a great program, but now I'm looking at the next one! :)
I know i've already comment.... But i just love this video. really well developed story and beautiful choice in music. i have the song in my car now... hehe. :D Sooo good. xx
You know what? This is a real masterpiece. I watched it for some times but really, I understood how wonderful it is just from the second or the third try. brilliant. How you mix the pieces of video and these visual effects (especially clolors) this matches the song so much!
mariaches1 5 months ago
i was wondering if you could fix the download link from this vid on your livejournal acc. I totally love this and i would like to re-watch it again ((i promise i do not intend into copying the clips or anything is just for enjoyment)) like 'In her Eyes' vid but yeah it says the link's broken :( .
XBadWolfProductionsX 2 years ago
can you upload this video to bam or imeem so i can watch it with audio please?
late
-Billy
sopinkprincess 2 years ago
Rose is so awesome and her relationship with the Doctor is so sweet! <3
Love your vid!
iwasalildifferent15 3 years ago
Brilliant
O.o
[*crying]
TrueTimeLord905 3 years ago
wow that was amazing!
georgiaroxx96 3 years ago
My Guess Is The EAsy / Expensive Way ... Final Cut Pro Or Long lothesome way ... Windows Movie
Maker
thetmyster 3 years ago
WHATT DID U USE ?? TO MAKE IT??
thetmyster 3 years ago
What Did U Use to edit it ?
aasimpson34 3 years ago
Wow, very well done. The alternating between black and white vs colour was timed exactly right, and the end, with the watch, his face, and her name was the icing on the cake. <3
helenluvsboo 3 years ago
Totally BRILLIANT!! Most amazingly editied, well done again. That song just fits so perfectly...really really reeeeeeeally well done!!! :D XD
42LightYears 3 years ago
:]lovesit x
RoseAndDoctor94 3 years ago
oh my god *gets on hands and knees* We Are not worthy this is the best I have seen this is going on my top ten doctor who video! I love your work
aXXoJadie 3 years ago
This vid is amazing. It's brilliant. It's fantastic. It's the best Doctor Who video I ever watched.
KitsuneDragonheartLo 3 years ago
Oh.. My.. God.. This video is like THE must-see on Youtube in Doctor Who fandom. Seriously. It's just, W-O-W. Yeah, the whole plot and the matching clips is just brilliant as our beloved Ten would say, right? Hehe, amazing job on this one! :D
CILLEXD 3 years ago
Wowsa! Thankyou so much! This was the video that really-did-not-get-made, and ironically it has become my highest rater. *shrugs* Life's funny that way. I'm really thrilled you enjoyed it that much, thankyou!
piffo 3 years ago
You're welcome! Oh my god. I can relate to that so much. That's the same with my Untouched video, which was like so "boring" to make, but it's my most faved and commented vid. Highest rated, nope. That honour does My Path have. Lol :) Anyways, you're welcome. It's stunning.
CILLEXD 3 years ago
This is a brilliant video. The song was beautiful too. It almost brought tears to my eyes it was so sad. I remember almost crying when I watched the episode itself. Great work here!
DavidTennantRocks29 3 years ago
Thankyou very much. It is a lovely song - I always thought Within Temptation did their best work when they weren't trying to be a rock rip-off. And as you said, the ep itself was such an emotional train ride, I barely had to do anything! :D Thanks again for your lovely comment!
piffo 3 years ago
Certainly in my Top Favourite Doctor Who Videos of all time... I would say 2nd. behind Seduff My Immortal!
This video is so beautiful! and I have seen it loads of times and was shocked to see I haven't favourited it (I have now) and 5 stars! Fantastic FANTASTIC video! So beautiful! I love it so much :D xxx Brilliant, the song is amazing EVERYTHING is wonderful!! Love it love it love it =D
Beth xx
GenesisArkProduction 3 years ago
Wow! Thankyou very much, that is absolutely amazing feedback for a vidmaker to receive, and I am extremely chuffed to be amongst your top favourites! *beams massively* Thankyou, you have absolutely made my day!
piffo 3 years ago
Wow. Your video took my breath away! It's so amazing, well done :)
centralperkgirl21 3 years ago
*beams* Thankyou for your lovely comment!
piffo 3 years ago
That was so cool and amazing
EternalDolor 3 years ago
Thankyou, glad you enjoyed!
piffo 3 years ago
This Vid Is Soo Sad!! :(:(
bigelephant1 3 years ago
Thanks! (Sad is good? :D)
piffo 3 years ago
this is brilliant i loved it
i wish i had the programmes to do this it was just wow
=]
wishfulthinkdoctor01 3 years ago
Thankyou! I use Vegas Movie Studio and the version I have is not too expensive cos its the beginners. You should be able to find it in a program store if you're interested. Glad you liked the vid!
piffo 3 years ago
i really like this! what is the name of the song?
sommersprechen 3 years ago 3
Thanks! Its "Say My Name" by Within Temptation.
piffo 3 years ago
that was really really beautiful....it was just so perfect...
DWaDDLJ 3 years ago 2
Wow, thankyou. Its lovely to know you feel like that about it.
piffo 3 years ago
OMFSG! thats an amazin vid, really love it. well done piffo, well done :D ;)
tenrosefan 3 years ago
Thankyou very much, glad you liked!
piffo 3 years ago
How fantastic is this. I love the song love the editing. Fantastic..
Piffo you are fantastic at this.
5 Stars
Scampsey88 3 years ago
Sorry I've been late replying, its exam week (nuf said.) Your comment gave me a lovely buzz, thankyou. Editing is a subject dear to my heart so its an awesome comment :)
piffo 3 years ago
thats ok, It nice you replied then, I needed a Rose/10 pick me up...*fav*
Scampsey88 3 years ago
omg, that was beautiful. the song, the editing was brilliant. I loved how you made Rose sort of float into the picture in the journal. wonderful.
desertrose777 3 years ago
Thankyou very much! The Rose/picture has been used many times and I tried to do it a little differently, so I'm glad you liked it!
piffo 3 years ago
So beautiful! I'd almost forgotten how beautiful this but it's so nice to watch again afresh. :) 5*
THEpowerOFme 3 years ago
Lovely to know you're still enjoying it. Its a great compliment to get more then one comment! You've made me all warm and fuzzy *grins*
piffo 3 years ago
OMG now after watching season 3 i understand better your video! hehehe amazingly done and great storyline can't help but to love it even more =]
zoev22 3 years ago
Does help a bit! :D Found it hard trying to imagine watching it without FOB and HN. I still wanted more Rose in those eps though :)
piffo 3 years ago
Really,really lovely. I love that to bits.
DreameQueene 3 years ago
Thankyou very much, glad you liked!
piffo 3 years ago
I loved that it was great to watch and I enjoyed it.
So please keep posting videos like is and I will watch them thank you.
LouLoupet2007 3 years ago
Brilliant vid. What editor do you use.?
keepingthetardis 3 years ago
Thankyou. I use Sony Vegas Movie Studio (the most basic package.)
piffo 3 years ago
I've just begun using Song Vegas platinum. I just starting to get used to it, however, the vid I did with it, did come 1st in a contest. Stargate Atlantis - Fallen Hero: Carson Beckett vid.
keepingthetardis 3 years ago
Ooh, I'm jealous. I keep saving up for a better version (can't do much with this one at all) but I'm a uni student so I'm always strapped for cash :( Are you out there Santa? *looks around hopefully*
piffo 3 years ago
Amaaazing vid! ♥
How did you get the echoed voices? It's really effective.
EyElinER100 3 years ago
I used the 'reverb' effect in my audio effects options. Its a bit of a hit and miss -it works on some soundclips, but not others. Glad you liked!
piffo 3 years ago
omg tht was incredible!!!!!
5/5 and faved!!!
mosesthesecond 3 years ago
Thanks very much!
piffo 3 years ago
wow loved it
wots the song and who by?
xdeexxdeex 3 years ago
"Say my Name" by Within Temptation. I usually put the song name and artist in the credits at the end.
piffo 3 years ago
kwl thanks :D
xdeexxdeex 3 years ago
Is The Song by within temptation and what is the name of it?
SophiieChickee 3 years ago
Yes it is. Its called 'Say my Name'
piffo 3 years ago
aww im glad my comment made ur day hehe btw piffo! yes i followed ur advice and started watching it today you're right is soo much fun! hehe i thought it wasn't gonna be so good since Rose left :( but still is fun and the Dr hasn't forget Rose at all so i like it :P
zoev22 3 years ago
that was absolutely AMAZING. cud u tell me wat rose says at 1:39? cudnt quite catch it...
totallyDT 3 years ago
"Doctor if you can hear me I'm going to get you out of there"
Glad you liked :)
piffo 3 years ago
OMG piffo this video is so totally awsome! i really need to start watching season 3 to understand more hehehehe 5/5 and deff to my faves :P
zoev22 3 years ago
Thankyou very much zoev22. I was having a really shit day and your comment has made me smile :) And you should watch season 3, its lots of good fun.
piffo 3 years ago
That was one of the best doctor who videos I have ever seen. I really mean that.
Nollywonks 3 years ago
Wow, thankyou very much! I'm honoured you think that, thanks for letting me know :D
piffo 3 years ago
I've got chills! That as incredible! Oh my God, I'm literally shaking! That was amazing!
MusicMadSuperAwesome 3 years ago
Thanks! I hope I didn't creep you out or anything :D Twas probably the caffeine *winks*
piffo 3 years ago
Wonderful video. Great choice of clips and all. I loved both the stills at the beginning, and also the voices. You chose great extracts, such as the 'I'm never gonna leave you' bit, with a slight echo. The lyrics really fitted in with your clips: great editing. Very, very good. :)
TellyAddict909 3 years ago
Thankyou very much! Its great to know exactly what people liked for future reference, so thanks for letting me know. The fact that the lyrics were so groovy was why I did it in the first place :) Thanks again!
piffo 3 years ago
Lovely job...I particular like the way you used stills at the end of clips. Did you also change the coloring?
Allawnsy 3 years ago
I used stills? *thinks back* I haven't watched this vid for a looong time. Oh, right, at the beginning. Yes, they are saturated, I liked the slightly more dramatic effect with the beat. Glad you enjoyed!
piffo 3 years ago
Hey, cool vid, where do you get the clips from???? I would love to make my own video. I love editing. Please reply!!!
KTTUNSTALLFOREVER 3 years ago
Thankyou. I ripped them from my DVDs using DVD Decrypter. If you would like further information send me an email.
piffo 3 years ago
This is very good :-)
EllenRebecca3 3 years ago
Thankyou very much :D
piffo 3 years ago
this is a-ma-zing. your so good unlike me
p3ts11 3 years ago
Thankyou very much. I think it is more a case of everyone taking a different approach to vid-making rather then levels of 'good.'
piffo 3 years ago
Wow i love it. A clever plot for a great theme. Well done. Love the fades too.
sirius136 4 years ago
Thankyou very much.
piffo 3 years ago
OH MY GOD!!! That woz beautiful, amazing, wonderful!! The lyrics to it were facinating and 'across the borders of time' with the rift and Roses eyes there woz awesome!! Ur brill at doing these lol! Cud i ask yooh no where rose is in the tardis and she outstretches her arm and theres a light behind her--is that the parting of the ways?? Enyway well done- 5/5!!
jEnNiFeRaNiStOnRoCkZ 4 years ago
Thankyou very much! I'm glad you liked the eyes of the rift, that was one of my favourite parts :D The scene of Rose with her arm outstretched is from Bad Wolf, when the Doctor suddenly 'remembers' how he ended up in the Big Brother House. Rose is being transmatted.
piffo 4 years ago
Loool oh yeh! I fort it wz wen she wz lookin in the heart of the tardis n she got pulled in2 sumat bt i fort-that dow happen!! Loool well done enyway-fantastic!
jEnNiFeRaNiStOnRoCkZ 4 years ago
Wow, that's beautiful editing!
brunettedestiny07 4 years ago
Thanks!
piffo 4 years ago
Oh my god that fade in from The Satan Pit to the journal is beautiful. You rock!
I love this video. It's like Rose is haunting John Smith. But I always believed that Rose was the girl of the Doctor's dreams.X)
RnDFoever25 4 years ago
Thanks! Yeah the idea was that Rose was a large component of the 'dreams' John Smith kept having and part of the reason he was so fascinated by them. There is some great fanfic out there that explores this idea. As to Rose being the girl of the DOctor's dreams - I'll guess we'll see when they meet again next season!
piffo 4 years ago
You tease you.X) I hope their reunion is sweet, or at least as memorable as their seperation. (Please sign up for the 2009 spcials Billie! I'll give you candy if you do.)
RnDFoever25 4 years ago
Its unbeleivable how amazing this video is!
I love this song..its perfect for the couple && your story!
You put it together brilliantly!
5 stars
xx
xxSazxGalxx 4 years ago
Thanks! All credit goes to the song, the lyrics were so perfect for the eps that they haunted me for ages even though I was doing a different vid at the time :) Glad you enjoyed!
piffo 4 years ago
that is AMAZING!!!
well done, i liked the way you manipulated the clips to suit your story
Great job!!
sesaboo 4 years ago
Thankyou very much, great to know you enjoyed it!
piffo 4 years ago
omg!!!!!! FANTASTIC so sweet i love it! 5 stars and faved
BilliePiperForever 4 years ago
Thanks, glad you enjoyed!
piffo 4 years ago
I wasn't expecting that.
I really wasn't.
It was a great storyline,
great editing.
Great everything.
Im being serious I swear, I think this is probably the best fanvid I have EVER seen. (:
PineapplePinyata 4 years ago
Wow, thankyou so much! Its a wonderful compliment that you think its that good, I'm grinning like an idiot right now :D (Sorry about the late reply, life has been crazy this last week and I haven't seen a bloody computer that doesn't have homework on it.) Thankyou again for your lovely comment! Really made my day.
piffo 4 years ago
it's absolutely brillant the moment when she says "I'm never gonna leave you" with her face zooming up and mixing with the drawing, that's an absolutely intense effect. I've tried to played this song at the guitar cause it's just brilliant.
galateeomnibus 4 years ago
Thankyou very much! I thought her hair looked the most like the drawing in the Satan Pit. (Sorry for the late reply, uni's just gone back and I haven't stopped all week) Can you play this song at the guitar? Thats really awesome, I've always admired people who can do that. I play the clarinet but I need the sheet music right in front of me!
piffo 4 years ago
great editing! <3
00runawaysmile00 4 years ago
Thanks!
piffo 4 years ago
great vid wats the song called and who by
SkasasParadigm 4 years ago
say my name by within temptation
00runawaysmile00 4 years ago
cheers for that :D
piffo 4 years ago
that was amazing brill 5/5!
dolphins15 4 years ago
Thankyou very much!
piffo 4 years ago
Beautiful job!
midnightzstorm 4 years ago
Thankyou!
piffo 4 years ago
Awesome job!
midnightzstorm 4 years ago
Thanks!
piffo 4 years ago
wow, i love this video! Good work!
MontyPythonFairy 4 years ago
Thankyou very much!
piffo 4 years ago
ok please ignore that stupid comment i just sent! it says at the end of the video! sorry!
boredofrevision 4 years ago
hey this might sound really daft but who sings this song and what is it called? its a brilliant video though! really amazing! well done!
boredofrevision 4 years ago
Thankyou! Its not a stupid question, I don't think anyone ever reads the small print :) I stick it at the end of most of my vids.
piffo 4 years ago
err i was trying to rate this as 5, but youtube went mean on me and put two!
arr i feel really bad now 'cos its like i rated it bad........grrrr silly youtube! LOL sorry
hattibailey 4 years ago
Thankyou for your lovely comment! Hey its no problem, youtube screws up on me all the time. I'm very flattered you intended to give it 5 anyway! And I'm definitely no genius, just a nerdy fangirl with too much time on her hands ;D
piffo 4 years ago
omg that video has sooo much emotion in it that i cried, but its not in the upset kinda way....its something different. I love all of your videos, your like a geniusor something! LOL!
hattibailey 4 years ago
Omg Thats ULTAMITE
aasimpson34 4 years ago
Thanks!
piffo 4 years ago
that is such a brilliant vid!! so well put together, and the clips and sounds fit so well! its just amazing!! can i ask what program you use?
DarkAngelofGallifrey 4 years ago
Thankyou very much, I'm glad you thought so! I use Vegas Movie Studio (the cheaper version).
piffo 4 years ago
wow! this video made me cry.
it was absolutely amazing
doctorwhoroxmysox 4 years ago
Thankyou very much *hands out more tissues* I seem to upset a lot of people :D
piffo 4 years ago
omg is the best way to put this lol this is bloody brilliant!!! its just so wow lol. untill now i never thought i would meet a 10/rose shipper as big as me lol (trust me im huuuuge) lol but you certaintly do, best 10/rose vid EVER!!!!!!
ash500500 4 years ago
Thanks! I can't wait to see their reunion *is worried*
piffo 4 years ago
Waw, how come I just can't get over this clip, it's so beautiful.
galateeomnibus 4 years ago
Thankyou, sorry I've made you sad!
piffo 4 years ago
all i can say is
oh
my
god.!
that was so good!
it was intense and beautiful.
i love every effect and you couldnt of done a better job!
doctorwhoismylove 4 years ago
Thankyou, your lovely comment has given me a big smile. (Your omg made me laugh too ;D )
piffo 4 years ago
waw, I'm amazed, it's so...waw...I can't find my words, it's so full of emotion, so intensely charged. Really, really well done, it sums up rose and the doctor's love story.
galateeomnibus 4 years ago
Thankyou very much! Its such a lovely story to tell, I think that's where all the emotion comes from!
piffo 4 years ago
You're damn right my friend, it's such a passionate story, I want rose back I want Rose back I want Rose back!
galateeomnibus 4 years ago
Wow that was amazing, absolutely beautiful. *Favourites* *Rates*
PirateTillTheEnd 4 years ago
Thankyou very much!
piffo 4 years ago
Beautiful. I loved Human Nature also because they used Rose's theme song a few times in the episode(one of them was when John Smith was kissing Joan!!) which made it really sweet. Well done!
sibi570 4 years ago
did they.. how dare they lol
nah its a really nice piece of music but i rekon it should be used 4 just rose.. i mean it is called rose's theme.
they could make a new one.. & call it joan's theme lol
laurabatham 4 years ago
well, I sort of thought it was showing the comparisons between the two and what it would be like between the Doctor and Rose if the Doctor could ever settle down and how the doctor still loves Rose etc - I guess I'm a bit of a hopeless romantic when it comes to 10/Rose though...:)
sibi570 4 years ago
lol ye so am i.. thats a good way of looking at it.. i never thought bout it like that
laurabatham 4 years ago
Hey, nothing wrong with being a hopeless romantic, especially when it comes to a pair as legendary as these two. :) Had Rose been there, I imagine John Smith would have been even more intense and loving...
And since I didn't say this before, piffo, VERY good job on the video! The only thing I think you could have changed would have been the Doctor's whisper of "Rose" at the end...maybe you could have made it a bit louder? *shrug* Just thinking.
ghidorah15 4 years ago
I read the most beautiful fic where that exact scenario happened-instead of 1940 the TARDIS dropped them when Rose was 18.She and the Doctor met and fell in love... The most heartbreaking HN/FOB fic I think I read.
Its great to know you liked it!The fact you wouldn't change anything is a great compliment.The reason the 'Rose' is quiet is because of the bloody Doomsday music in the background-I don't have an audio editor so I kept it soft to hide the track.Its the cheat's way ;)
piffo 4 years ago
You know I never noticed that? And I generally rate movies based on soundtrack rather then story! Must have been too caught up in the moment ;)
piffo 4 years ago
brilliant vid.. well done
laurabatham 4 years ago
Thankyou, great to know you liked it
piffo 4 years ago
BBBBrilliant!
madgirl132 4 years ago
Thanks!
piffo 4 years ago
so beautiful truly amazing
mchun 4 years ago
Thankyou, lovely to know you enjoyed it.
piffo 4 years ago
Brilliant! I'm a big fan of Within Temptation and you made great use of this song. The flashes and stitches in this video were just so well done and I really liked the concept! Great work once again!
- Siri
SiriGirl 4 years ago
Thanks! I have most of WT's songs, her voice and style just make them so different. Glad you liked the editing!
piffo 4 years ago
This has been in my favourite list for awhile. Really love it. I feel like crying now - hope Rose's return will be fulfilling for all her fans, like myself i.e. Romantic! :-P
Krystleb7 4 years ago
Me too. I'm so worried about it - RTD's attitude that 'Doctor Who is for kids' seems to spell death for any strong emotional commitment. But then again, VOTD seemed to suggest the Doctor was more open to emotions... I dunno. All I know is that if they've both 'moved on' I will be dusting off my pitchfork and torches.
And really glad you liked my vid! (sorry about the rant ;D )
piffo 4 years ago
This is a gorgeous video, well done! And I just have to say I'll be joining you with pitchfork and torches if the unspeakable happens. I'm scared!!!
gamwyn 4 years ago
Yep, am with you on that one too :) *gets pitchforks ready*
SexcKaz 4 years ago
Oh yes--if the writers decide to screw things up, then...well..."grab your torch and pitchforks!" :)
ghidorah15 4 years ago
We're going to have an awesome protest group going soon! Who's going to make the placards?
(and bring the *cough cough* gunpowder *cough cough*.)
piffo 4 years ago
I dunno about the placards, but I'll bring the gunpowder--oh, and some jet fuel just in case.
ghidorah15 4 years ago
sounds good to me. I have plenty of matches.
piffo 4 years ago
aww that was so beautiful! <3
snazzyjazzy 4 years ago
Thankyou very much, glad you enjoyed it.
piffo 4 years ago
Just a bit yeah. lol
wytchlet 4 years ago
It sounds like Within Temptation? Is It?
wytchlet 4 years ago
Yeah its 'Say my Name' by Within Temptation. Very distinctive, aren't they?
piffo 4 years ago
WOW that vid made me cry it was beautiful, please what song was that?
wytchlet 4 years ago
lovely gem of a video! I've never seen such a dark one about the Human Nature/Family of Blood eps (I mean that in a good way) What program did you use for editing? Obviously not movie maker! XD
sallangel 4 years ago
Thanks! I'm very angst-vid orientated, tried fluff but it just doesn't seem to take. I have the beginners version of Vegas Movie Studio (not the $800 one!). I started on WMM but wanted to branch out. Its a great program, but now I'm looking at the next one! :)
piffo 4 years ago
I know i've already comment.... But i just love this video. really well developed story and beautiful choice in music. i have the song in my car now... hehe. :D Sooo good. xx
seduff 4 years ago
Hehe. Don't tempt me, I might go comment 40 times on your Broken! Actually, I might go watch it now...love that vid to pieces.
piffo 4 years ago
this was so good!!! It made me cry!
doctorwhoismylove 4 years ago
Thanks! Sorry I made you cry, hope it was in a good way :)
piffo 4 years ago
This is so haunting! Amazing job!
sorcha425 4 years ago
Thankyou very much! That was what I was hoping for ;)
piffo 4 years ago
What do you use for editing?
zcatz 4 years ago
Vegas Movie Studio, the beginners version.
piffo 4 years ago
ace brill ace ahhhh!
Rosetylermad111 4 years ago
...thanks? ;D
piffo 4 years ago