M AN i love them!!!!!!!!!!!! these guys really rock!! their like the best and i kinda really like them more than the BEATLES!! WIERD but i really love them more than the beatles!! PS. sorry beatles!
I don't see why you feel the need to be such a pessimist. If you like it, great; leave an enouraging comment. If you don't like it, (like yourself) then why not listen to something you do like? Why even bother?
i think you're a pessimist for thinking that i have negative intentions. i'm an optimist because i want people to expand their minds and realize how bad these lyrics are.
"anyone who likes this song is a special type of idiot... "took the bones of me" is the most retarded lyric ever written"
Because that's not negative at all...
People have different tastes in music. Some like this, Norwegian death metal, country, indie, folk, etc... There's no need to call people who enjoy things that are different than the things you enjoy idiots. It's futile.
you're missing the point. it's not about music, it's about LYRICAL CONTENT. i actually don't mind the musical style of this song... but the lyrics wreak of stupidity. i appreciate and accept diversity, but i denounce weakness and false art. if it is futile to assert oneself and ones opinions, then life is pointless.
Some can argue that it is. But that's an entire argument in itself. The point is, that a lot of lyrics don't make sense. Some are there purely for the way they sound- not the point they get across. Case in point, Andrew Bird. I'm aware when a lyric isn't amazing and don't need you to inform me. Music doesn't ALWAYS have to make sense. Sometimes it can just sound nice. Know what I mean? I think we can agree on that at the very least. On a lighter note, you're very fun to argue with.
just because "some lyrics don't make sense" doesn't mean that these lyrics are not horrible. i agree that if i didn't speak english, this song would be very pleasant to hear.
You just failed completely. There is no such thing as false art, in saying that, you just destroyed your entire argument. Any form of self-expression is art, by saying their art is false, you're saying that their expression is false, which isn't possible. You obviously have a very narrow-minded sense of art.
As a reply to your comment about a dump being art, if you would take a moment to look at the Guggenheim Museum gallery in New York City, they have on display a can which reportedly contains a piece of crap, it is registered as modern art by an authority with much more credibility than you. So yes, taking a dump can be a form of art. Thank you and goodbye.
You just gave my argument new ground. "The contents are irrelevant". In saying this, specific lyrics of the song are irrelevant, because when looking at the sound of the song in general and its overall meaning, regardless of what words are utilized to get that meaning across, this song is great. The song has a very good sound, upbeat but still smooth, and the meaning of the song which is finding a someone who makes his life extraordinary, is a meaningful and relevant topic to anyone.
you just gave my argument new ground. the fact that this song is upbeat, smooth, and has a good overall musical composition is actually a testament to how HORRIFIC the lyrics are. i actually love this type of music, but the chorus lyrics in this song are beyond stupid. they are not abstractly good, they are not creatively good... they are plainly dumb.
First off, how you see that as a testament to the lyrics being horrific makes no sense. And the chorus lyrics aren't stupid for what they are trying to say. He is making the point that the entrance of the woman into his life "shook his bones". Why you see about that as stupid makes absolutely no sense to me.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
It's a testament because despite the song being musically good, the lyrics are so bad and stick out so dramatically that they cause me to think this song is bad overall. The message of 'I like a girl' is totally cliche, though bearable, if the lyrics "Shook the bones of me" and "Took the the bones of me" weren't idiotically placed in the chorus. The "bones of me" sounds like a retarded person trying to form a sentence.
If you weren't historically ignorant you'd know that forming sentences with the direct object before the pronoun is a common structure in shakespearean english. Not the sentence structure of a retard.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
shakespearean english is extremely outdated and sounds totally strange to normal people today. any intelligent person would say "my bones", not "the bones of me". nobody goes around saying, "wow, the hair of you looks really good." it sounds totally idiotic.
Outdated it may be, but that doesn't take away from the fact that it is a language of art. It's built to work with the artist's needs, and that is what it does. It wouldn't have made any sense rhythmically to say "you shook my bones", but it worked perfectly to say "you shook the bones of me". Now if you can come up with another articulate way to say that, that you don't consider to be stupid, I'd love to hear it.
of course english can be interpreted, but that doesn't mean that every permutation of words is intelligent. good examples of creative english would be stevie wonder's twisted sentence: "hello children jesus loves you of america", or just the general kookiness of phish's lyrics. but carbon leaf's little bone fetish is absurd... it just sounds dumb. i really don't have much more to say... you think the lyrics are good, and i think they are a puke-inducing example of idiotic songwriting.
these guys r so good live and not many people on the chart r good at all it's just computers so these guys REALLY! should have more gigs and be more reconized!!!!!!!
Carbon leaf is one of the few softer rock bands that still appeal to a metalhead like myself. i didn't say they were soft rock, they're just laid back and mellow for a rock band. mellow alternative. AWESOME BAND ANYWAY!!!
thanks so much for posting this. i was at this concert with three of my best mates and it's a good memory, esp this song. and if you know where to look, i think you can see our heads... sarah will be overjoyed, being as she's sarah...
this video's been up 6 years and no dislikes. That has to be some kind of Youtube record
excel04 1 month ago
terrys my cousin
biebgirl18 7 months ago
terrys my cousin
biebgirl18 7 months ago
I like this band, song.
amurican35 10 months ago
M AN i love them!!!!!!!!!!!! these guys really rock!! their like the best and i kinda really like them more than the BEATLES!! WIERD but i really love them more than the beatles!! PS. sorry beatles!
coolboy3056cp 1 year ago
This is the first song I ever heard by them. The rest is history. :) And this song makes me extremely happy. :D
kuliimjulischreiben 1 year ago 3
Love this song =]
Reminds me of my baby Ryan :P
musiclovinggurl123 2 years ago
LOVE LOVE LOVE THESE GUYS!!! Fell in love with their music years ago when they were on Dr Phil.
smubamagirl 2 years ago
I just discovered this band, kind of like them--why did you have to say they were on Dr. Phil! You ruined it! How can I like them now?
tomcat13claws 1 year ago
Barry You look super happy! Love the smiles!
Augustdow 2 years ago
Didnt this song have an MTV video? I think I had it on DVD when it first came out and lst it.
Augustdow 2 years ago
Comment removed
llt2112 2 years ago
I love these guys. Definitely my favorite.
ItsReallySteve 2 years ago
Carbon Leaf live at the Soiled Dove Underground on 4/15/09 was awesome! Great band at a great venue!. ps: gth mattcaps :)
mls633 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Such an amazing song!
Xqcblues10X 3 years ago
anyone who likes this song is a special type of idiot... "took the bones of me" is the most retarded lyric ever written
mattcaps 3 years ago
And I suppose what's in your playlist is the most profound thing ever written?
TheHumanFact0r 3 years ago
Comment removed
mattcaps 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i don't claim to have located the best song ever, i'm just very aware of when i step in dog feces... unlike fans of this song.
mattcaps 3 years ago
I don't see why you feel the need to be such a pessimist. If you like it, great; leave an enouraging comment. If you don't like it, (like yourself) then why not listen to something you do like? Why even bother?
TheHumanFact0r 3 years ago
i think you're a pessimist for thinking that i have negative intentions. i'm an optimist because i want people to expand their minds and realize how bad these lyrics are.
mattcaps 3 years ago
"anyone who likes this song is a special type of idiot... "took the bones of me" is the most retarded lyric ever written"
Because that's not negative at all...
People have different tastes in music. Some like this, Norwegian death metal, country, indie, folk, etc... There's no need to call people who enjoy things that are different than the things you enjoy idiots. It's futile.
TheHumanFact0r 3 years ago
you're missing the point. it's not about music, it's about LYRICAL CONTENT. i actually don't mind the musical style of this song... but the lyrics wreak of stupidity. i appreciate and accept diversity, but i denounce weakness and false art. if it is futile to assert oneself and ones opinions, then life is pointless.
mattcaps 3 years ago
*reek, typo
mattcaps 3 years ago
Some can argue that it is. But that's an entire argument in itself. The point is, that a lot of lyrics don't make sense. Some are there purely for the way they sound- not the point they get across. Case in point, Andrew Bird. I'm aware when a lyric isn't amazing and don't need you to inform me. Music doesn't ALWAYS have to make sense. Sometimes it can just sound nice. Know what I mean? I think we can agree on that at the very least. On a lighter note, you're very fun to argue with.
TheHumanFact0r 3 years ago
just because "some lyrics don't make sense" doesn't mean that these lyrics are not horrible. i agree that if i didn't speak english, this song would be very pleasant to hear.
mattcaps 3 years ago
You just failed completely. There is no such thing as false art, in saying that, you just destroyed your entire argument. Any form of self-expression is art, by saying their art is false, you're saying that their expression is false, which isn't possible. You obviously have a very narrow-minded sense of art.
shmina1 2 years ago
by your argument, taking a dump is art.
mattcaps 2 years ago
As a reply to your comment about a dump being art, if you would take a moment to look at the Guggenheim Museum gallery in New York City, they have on display a can which reportedly contains a piece of crap, it is registered as modern art by an authority with much more credibility than you. So yes, taking a dump can be a form of art. Thank you and goodbye.
shmina1 2 years ago
first of all, that display is a CAN. the contents are irrelevant. you are really looking at the outer layer of the art... the can itself.
and we are getting away from the point, anyways:
this song has idiotic lyrics.
mattcaps 2 years ago
You just gave my argument new ground. "The contents are irrelevant". In saying this, specific lyrics of the song are irrelevant, because when looking at the sound of the song in general and its overall meaning, regardless of what words are utilized to get that meaning across, this song is great. The song has a very good sound, upbeat but still smooth, and the meaning of the song which is finding a someone who makes his life extraordinary, is a meaningful and relevant topic to anyone.
shmina1 2 years ago
you just gave my argument new ground. the fact that this song is upbeat, smooth, and has a good overall musical composition is actually a testament to how HORRIFIC the lyrics are. i actually love this type of music, but the chorus lyrics in this song are beyond stupid. they are not abstractly good, they are not creatively good... they are plainly dumb.
mattcaps 2 years ago
First off, how you see that as a testament to the lyrics being horrific makes no sense. And the chorus lyrics aren't stupid for what they are trying to say. He is making the point that the entrance of the woman into his life "shook his bones". Why you see about that as stupid makes absolutely no sense to me.
shmina1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's a testament because despite the song being musically good, the lyrics are so bad and stick out so dramatically that they cause me to think this song is bad overall. The message of 'I like a girl' is totally cliche, though bearable, if the lyrics "Shook the bones of me" and "Took the the bones of me" weren't idiotically placed in the chorus. The "bones of me" sounds like a retarded person trying to form a sentence.
mattcaps 2 years ago
If you weren't historically ignorant you'd know that forming sentences with the direct object before the pronoun is a common structure in shakespearean english. Not the sentence structure of a retard.
shmina1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shakespearean english is extremely outdated and sounds totally strange to normal people today. any intelligent person would say "my bones", not "the bones of me". nobody goes around saying, "wow, the hair of you looks really good." it sounds totally idiotic.
mattcaps 2 years ago
Outdated it may be, but that doesn't take away from the fact that it is a language of art. It's built to work with the artist's needs, and that is what it does. It wouldn't have made any sense rhythmically to say "you shook my bones", but it worked perfectly to say "you shook the bones of me". Now if you can come up with another articulate way to say that, that you don't consider to be stupid, I'd love to hear it.
shmina1 2 years ago
of course english can be interpreted, but that doesn't mean that every permutation of words is intelligent. good examples of creative english would be stevie wonder's twisted sentence: "hello children jesus loves you of america", or just the general kookiness of phish's lyrics. but carbon leaf's little bone fetish is absurd... it just sounds dumb. i really don't have much more to say... you think the lyrics are good, and i think they are a puke-inducing example of idiotic songwriting.
mattcaps 2 years ago
Haha ok, it's been fun.
shmina1 2 years ago
Gonna have to agree with mattcaps. Good song, awesome chorus, but the cliche lyrics make this song kind of lame to me.
BlaculasSmellyFro 2 years ago
I agree with you - the entire song is great...gives me chills when I hear it...
llt2112 2 years ago
Oh, i'm from Brazil and adore Carbon Leaf! They are so amazing!!!!
vickgallagher 3 years ago
Yeah....me too!!!
chuckyck9 3 years ago
these guys r so good live and not many people on the chart r good at all it's just computers so these guys REALLY! should have more gigs and be more reconized!!!!!!!
JonasBroFan69 3 years ago 2
The McShep shippers anthem
moarajuliana 3 years ago
I LOVE THEM!! OMFGGG! i know most of their songs and all the words xD
Singer is hawttt <3
musiclovinggurl123 3 years ago
I so love Carbon Leaf!
dacursednlucky 3 years ago
ALSOME lOVE IT
swimmergurl759 3 years ago
wheeooooohhhhhh.... grateful to hear this piece
gebzhoe 3 years ago
Dang, these guys are really good. Kinda sad though, when those people tried to clap along. In the quiet part. And failed. Great song though
Jorgejones31 3 years ago 8
Ahhh, his voice is so beautiful! Cannot get enough.
Ohh. If a band sounds good live, then they are TRUELY good!
Ohh yay.
seafoam121 3 years ago 3
Carbon leaf rocks!!! I remember when they opened for Blues traveler, I didnt even know these guys back then. it was such a pleasant surprise!
Brunoaz2000 3 years ago
my favorite song! this rox!
2jewtube 3 years ago
Carbon leaf is one of the few softer rock bands that still appeal to a metalhead like myself. i didn't say they were soft rock, they're just laid back and mellow for a rock band. mellow alternative. AWESOME BAND ANYWAY!!!
RageAgainstIraq 4 years ago
this looks like it was a GREAT show.
amazing recording thanks!
karioeo 4 years ago
dang thses guys are bigger then i thought
way to represent virginia!
Jster2000 4 years ago
oh my gawd, i love carbon leaf sooooo much! theyre shamazing!
gr33ngummibear 4 years ago 2
<3 <3 <3
khachatour 4 years ago 6
very glad this works,...try my parody of sting-----carbonpictures!
carbonpictures 4 years ago
My youngest brother and sister told me about Carbon leaf ... they even got to go see them perform in Wausau, Wisconsin .. two ? years ago ?
I am so glad they did, Carbon Leaf is one of my favorite groups now.
RazberrieTart 4 years ago
ah, i love barry's voice, cant get enough of it
weeeehaw 4 years ago 3
they played at the art fair
G27dude 4 years ago
Where was this song at??? Now I keep on walking through life with no problem. This is now my favorite song.
barrioat 4 years ago 2
I love there live sound its so amazing
yorker54220 4 years ago 4
I LOVE THIS SONG!!!
srhirst333 4 years ago 3
Saw Carbon Leaf a couple of summers ago. Best live performance I have seen in a long time.
sepowell 4 years ago
you shook the bones of me!
ljpw93 4 years ago
great song and performance
nivbri 4 years ago
Diggin' the Carbon Leaf!
alumba 4 years ago
lol
gem14fourteen 4 years ago
thanks so much for posting this. i was at this concert with three of my best mates and it's a good memory, esp this song. and if you know where to look, i think you can see our heads... sarah will be overjoyed, being as she's sarah...
tongzhiyuxin 5 years ago