I was in Warsaw walking at night and a huge lightning storm started and it rained so hard that the rainwater pooled knee-high. Automne en Varsovie reminds me of that.
This etude is really hard because the player has to bring out the melody notes which are the falling leaves and also has to keep the fast notes which make the wind really soft.
@danielchong1234 It is! Haha. If I ever end up playing this, I probably will be practicing it at night quite a bit. Alone in a dark room with a concert grand and one dim light over the music. I'll be waiting for Dracula to show up any second =D
It's difficult to tell because of the quality of the sound and the body language of the performer, but he seems to be playing the chord changes with a little ritenuto, as if it were Chopin. Surely they should change like clockwork? But I would agree that the ghost of Chopin is certainly there, in the clockwork.
People forget, that the only thing that matters in music is the aesthetic result of what has been produced. This is an objectivity housing myriad interpretations; a seeming paradox that is actually proof of its achievement. This piece will spark a wide divergence of reaction, for it expresses no less wide an arc of emotion. It is an enigma that refuses to give up its secret and wields a dangerous ambiguity, the everyman's terror. In a word, stellar.
objectivity housing interpretations, paradox (which is) proof of its achievement, enigma that refuses to give up its secret... blah blah what an accumulation of stupid cliched ideas - in sharp contrast to this amazing music
WOW!! Now that's pretty deep. More than likely to far famished for the average listener. Then again there are people on this planet that can follow along and get what it means. What does it mean? Only the interpetation of the listener can reveal that secret.. Some see butter fly, some see the Figi Islands. Well done!!
Bortkievitch no sabes lo que dices. Ligeti es un gran músico, compositor e incluso más que eso. El hecho de que no sea pianista no significa que no pueda componer estudios para piano, justamente para eso se preparan los compositores, para componer para todo tipo de instrumentos.
Lucky for the music world, and art in general, that opinions like yours never cease artists innovating. People said some pretty nasty things about the composers you listed in their day, and in fact every major artist in the world.
Quisiera saber dónde tenía Ligeti la inspiración.¿Conoce GreekCivilization los estudios de Chopin?, o los de Liszt,Mendelssohn, Brahms,Rachmaninov...?Ellos eran MUSICOS y pianistas...Ligeti fue todo lo contrario...
Slam the god damn keys -- Be treated like genius.
krabkore 3 months ago
I was in Warsaw walking at night and a huge lightning storm started and it rained so hard that the rainwater pooled knee-high. Automne en Varsovie reminds me of that.
zutflutefleur 9 months ago
Wonderful playing of such a wonderful piece! :)
gonrolgonrol 10 months ago
It's got some haunting beauty. But I would never want to listen to this without an accompanying film or context.
sonokosuzuki 1 year ago
Ligeti genio
AleAgosto1973 1 year ago
Wow... that was really good
This etude is really hard because the player has to bring out the melody notes which are the falling leaves and also has to keep the fast notes which make the wind really soft.
Firebird772 1 year ago
this sounds very scary.lols.i won't want to play this in the middle of the night.hahaa
danielchong1234 1 year ago
@danielchong1234 It is! Haha. If I ever end up playing this, I probably will be practicing it at night quite a bit. Alone in a dark room with a concert grand and one dim light over the music. I'll be waiting for Dracula to show up any second =D
AldenHardaway 8 months ago
Mainly I`m the guitarist and double bass player, but I wish I could play this composition one day. Then I`m over.
MISZCZU6 1 year ago
wow how beautiful.....
cesmemael 1 year ago
fucking beautifull piece
andorebajo 1 year ago
wonderful piece of music
1980NewWave 1 year ago
This is sick. I think this is my favorite Legeti thus far...
EuphoricDan 1 year ago
Somehow this piece makes me think of autumn in an East European, maybe Poland.
haha.
baudelaire123 1 year ago
WOW!!
imdbstar 2 years ago
It's difficult to tell because of the quality of the sound and the body language of the performer, but he seems to be playing the chord changes with a little ritenuto, as if it were Chopin. Surely they should change like clockwork? But I would agree that the ghost of Chopin is certainly there, in the clockwork.
rjr1967 2 years ago
great
andreybeci 2 years ago
ooo im playing this
its AMAZING to play!
Slack3ron 2 years ago
awesome
death2empire 2 years ago
Ligeti is the greatest!
manhiemstoned 2 years ago 7
@manhiemstoned ......
jfmjsw 1 year ago
Comment removed
musthatedogs 2 years ago
Wow!
vincecharus 2 years ago
J'adore !!! Je regrette de ne pas être allé à ce concert
mynippon 3 years ago 4
People forget, that the only thing that matters in music is the aesthetic result of what has been produced. This is an objectivity housing myriad interpretations; a seeming paradox that is actually proof of its achievement. This piece will spark a wide divergence of reaction, for it expresses no less wide an arc of emotion. It is an enigma that refuses to give up its secret and wields a dangerous ambiguity, the everyman's terror. In a word, stellar.
cobaltjones 3 years ago 7
objectivity housing interpretations, paradox (which is) proof of its achievement, enigma that refuses to give up its secret... blah blah what an accumulation of stupid cliched ideas - in sharp contrast to this amazing music
ggurks 2 years ago 3
"People forget, that the only thing that matters in music is the aesthetic result of what has been produced."
lol
This is an objectivity"
rofl
twooffour 2 years ago 2
WOW!! Now that's pretty deep. More than likely to far famished for the average listener. Then again there are people on this planet that can follow along and get what it means. What does it mean? Only the interpetation of the listener can reveal that secret.. Some see butter fly, some see the Figi Islands. Well done!!
hickoryou812 2 years ago 3
Um... isn't senza ped. at the end? Boris totally missed the point, I feel.
Aside form that, not a bad performance.
But it's such an amazing piece...
lapsedcannibal 3 years ago
god, that is the most out of control coda ever. I love it!
chaseef 3 years ago 7
Very well played, one of my favorite studies from the entire set.
23BET23 3 years ago
Bortkievitch no sabes lo que dices. Ligeti es un gran músico, compositor e incluso más que eso. El hecho de que no sea pianista no significa que no pueda componer estudios para piano, justamente para eso se preparan los compositores, para componer para todo tipo de instrumentos.
a20008137 4 years ago 2
Chopin,Liszt,Brahms,Rachmaninov...they composed truly piano studies.Ligeti's piano studies are a truly musical rubbish.
bortkievitch 4 years ago
This Etude is actually very powerful.
Still, it's apparent how you're an intelligent, pleasant human being with original, relevant, worth-while opinions (not "rubbish" at all).
Ramatganski 4 years ago 7
Lucky for the music world, and art in general, that opinions like yours never cease artists innovating. People said some pretty nasty things about the composers you listed in their day, and in fact every major artist in the world.
Take a moment to think about that.
GraigRussell 3 years ago 19
Yeah, course, you're right. Fuck progress. Classic FM forever.
Eugh.
Anyway - One of my favourite piano pieces! Thanks for the great upload!
Quoyled 3 years ago 2
@bortkievitch why dont you write a better one
level5elfdruid 1 year ago
Quisiera saber dónde tenía Ligeti la inspiración.¿Conoce GreekCivilization los estudios de Chopin?, o los de Liszt,Mendelssohn, Brahms,Rachmaninov...?Ellos eran MUSICOS y pianistas...Ligeti fue todo lo contrario...
bortkievitch 4 years ago
AMAZING rendition!
cykniz 4 years ago
A stunning performance of a truly daring work based upon a simple chromatic series!
NormanicusDiabolicus 4 years ago 2