The mistakes are just making the song your own. It sounds like a reprise of the original and the fact that what you call your "mistakes" just phrase together without missing a single beat?...
Well, that is merely the mark of a truly gifted player. Give yourself more credit dude. You play a great deal of this with your eyes closed! Amazing cover, one of the best on YT.
@imStrucK see...the point of a cover isn't to play LIKE somebody...the point is to make it your own...much more respect goes out to a person who interprets something in their own way rather than just being a robotic follower who copies and pastes with their own fingers...it's the expression and creativity
@cedricwai If anyone were to think like that they wouldnt make covers, ruining the whole point. Write your own crap if you wan to be creative, dont bend somebody elses work to your liking
tempo wise I personally like the original better, however performance is all 100 out of 10 points! Very emotional. Compared to Sungha Jung's playing.... What can be said.. If judging by the utube videos his (Sungha's) play is robotic and emotionless whilst here is a total flight of the heart and soul in the sky of feelings and emotions. IMHO of course.
This is the first cover I've ever heard which keeps true to the original song, but has just enough variation to enjoy it as a new song. Good job! I like the slow approach and the little nuances!
Du joli! la jouer au ralenti te permet de rajouter plein de petites choses sans que cela ne fasse too much! très beaux plans perso en plus (sympa la cassure a 4'40)! j'aurais peut être un poil speedé l'intro mais pour le reste, niquel :p
screw what everyone else is saying. the slower tempo gives the melody more feeling and is more mood-inspiring. sure it isn't better than the original, but it's as good for sure.
Juste oublié de saluer ton choix de réduire considérablement le tempo : humilité intelligente et sage astuce pour peut-être maîtriser mieux et pouvoir plus aisément caresser tous les registres du morceau...
Ta reprise est magnifique, empreinte d'une superbe émotion. Ton jeu est souple (malgré tout... :-) ), et la mélodie rendue incroyable. Merci pour le voyage !
Je t'ai vu à la TV un jour, pendant que je me préparais à partir au cégep, pis j'ai dû me tapper la pire course de ma vie pour pas manquer mon bus!
Ta version est est à mon avis de loin la meilleure comparée aux autres sur Youtube. On y sent tellement plus l'émotion, la profondeur et la mélodie! Rylynn est devenue une de mes mélodies fétiches, et si tu sors un jour un cd du genre, je l'achète sur le champs, peu importe le prix!
soo good, it is played live and even andy doesn't play it live without any tiny mistakes...the feeling is important...i can't believe that this video doesn't have 5 stars...only people with no clue of music of jealous persons can give you less than 5 stars...your playing is excellent
Everybody makes mistakes. It's all about the timing and you delivered beautifully. I made it my "mission" to play this and had to give up because I didn't have the skill required and definitely not the talent to get the timing right. I can't believe I am going to say this, but I think you played the outro better than Andy McKee (don't tell anyone I said that).
@PistolPeteQC finding them aint too hard, but that doesnt make this performance less great... the piece is amazingly difficult to master... (even to learn and memorise it is quite the job). well done, and the feeling can be heard, wich is 99% of the song in my opinion. keep it up
@mmarzl as much as i love andy's music and he is one of the few guitarists that still leave me going wow and wanting to get better at guitar; he makes mistakes never think a human can't make a mistake especially with music....no one is perfect
@MusicVampire11 lol i actually thought this was andy playing this song hahahaha thats funny see i made a mistake XD haha but anyways this guy is pretty good too
Étant un amateur de guitare et de classique, n'arrivant pas à classifier votre style des plus agréable à nos oreilles, je dois vous féliciter. Compte tenu de votre jeune âge, vous semblez avoir atteint un niveau de dextérité émérite. Ce style musicale va probablement percer fortement si vous continuer à le forger.
J'ai créé un compte youtube exceptionnellement juste pour vous féliciter.
You make your mistakes sound like genius...lache pas la patate monnomme! I would love to play with you someday..I just moved to MTL for Ottawa..look me up whenever you're in town..je suis fier d'etre quebecois..merci.
hahah complètement fou, je suis tombé par hazard sur la 30e édition de Cegep en Spectacles sur le Canal Vox. J'ai reconnu tout de suite la toune étant fan de Andy, micheal hedges, Don Ross et Antoine dufour etc. Félicitation pour le grand prix sir and keep going!
Je viens de voir ta performance à la télé et je n'ai jamais autant ressenti le besoin de féliciter quelqu'un! Tu ressens ta musique, tu la joue avec passion et t'as tout le talent pour donner un résultat excellent. Tout ce que je te demandes, même si on ne se connaît pas, c'est de continuer. Je t'encourage d'autant plus que tu es de notre belle province! Lâche pas! T'as pas l'droit!
it is played a little bit slow, but that was truely awesome. I really want to try and learn but don't have the time... i hope one day i can play it like that.
you're truely, truely fantastic my friend, keep it up.
@robem10 Sometimes songs just sound so much better when they're slowed down, so you can really hear every note in their own beauty. FanTASTIC cover.
And for the record, covers don't need to be 100%, most GOOD covers incorporate some of the player's own styles. That's what separates good guitar covers from bad ones, creativity and an open mind. 5/5.
Salut, je sais pas si c'est toi le vrai Pierre mais bon ... juste dire que j'ai bien aimé ta prestation, ta musique, ta façcon d'être en entrevue et dit toi que le contacte avec les fans est bien important surtout au début, j'aimerais bien voir un show de toi ! je viens de voir le show a Vox et bravo ! je t'encourage à répondre à tes fans !
Tu aurais pu donner un coup de pledge sur ta Stonebridge avant le show! Serieux, c'est vrm bien ce que tu fais Pierre. Lâche surtout pas et Félicitation pour ta première place. J'suis vraiment déçu d'avoir manquer ce show-là dans mon cégep!
Hey je t'ai vu à la finale régionale à Valleyfield et tu m'as vraiment épatée wow tu étais excellent et t'as l'air tellement en amour avec ton instrument c'est fou! Pis félicitations pour ta première place à la finale nationale! Lâche pas t'es vraiment bon! ;)
Your video is a favorite on Afghanistan
urtismcdona13c 1 month ago
Your video is a favorite on Manila
jessehaley615 1 month ago
6:32 what was that rock fingers ? i cant see any heavy music here ...
useronuralp 4 months ago in playlist Andy Mckee
looks like someone should clean their guitar....
willyparkk 4 months ago 9
Comment removed
darknlorde2day 4 months ago
Comment removed
darknlorde2day 4 months ago
I got the same Capo ;o
darknlorde2day 4 months ago
The mistakes are just making the song your own. It sounds like a reprise of the original and the fact that what you call your "mistakes" just phrase together without missing a single beat?...
Well, that is merely the mark of a truly gifted player. Give yourself more credit dude. You play a great deal of this with your eyes closed! Amazing cover, one of the best on YT.
121jigawatts 4 months ago
Very tastefully done :)
armaandua 5 months ago
good cover bro. Is that an ewan dibson model?
pierceman1212 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great job. Check out my cover of this song on a classical guitar
paprykus 7 months ago
Nice Cover.
Lumix65 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please watch my Cover on this song on my channeL!!
mlaguna07 8 months ago
Hey mate, awesome playing, is that a Breedlove?
FastWieJesus 8 months ago
@FastWieJesus stonebridge
DavidStead94 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
please watch my take on this song!!
please go to my channel!
mlaguna07 9 months ago
Nobody plays like Andy.
imStrucK 10 months ago
@imStrucK see...the point of a cover isn't to play LIKE somebody...the point is to make it your own...much more respect goes out to a person who interprets something in their own way rather than just being a robotic follower who copies and pastes with their own fingers...it's the expression and creativity
cedricwai 8 months ago 7
@cedricwai If anyone were to think like that they wouldnt make covers, ruining the whole point. Write your own crap if you wan to be creative, dont bend somebody elses work to your liking
pinsent07 1 month ago
At a about 2 minutes in listen to the sick syncopation twist. Favorite part. Love the interpretation man!!!!
trewdab3 10 months ago
You're great man... you put so much feeling into this cover... Andy himself would be proud of your interpretation ... Is that a Stonebridge?
chacorionegro 11 months ago
The best cover i've seen! The original is of course better, but this is very close perfect! ;) I subscribed you!
ChrisBrandsborg 11 months ago
I hope you announced this was andy's song
tbsdrummer87 11 months ago
tempo wise I personally like the original better, however performance is all 100 out of 10 points! Very emotional. Compared to Sungha Jung's playing.... What can be said.. If judging by the utube videos his (Sungha's) play is robotic and emotionless whilst here is a total flight of the heart and soul in the sky of feelings and emotions. IMHO of course.
beazone 11 months ago
perfect
YoanSegot 1 year ago
Excellent ! beaucoup de travail pour arriver la ! Déjà sur la traces d'excellents guitaristes, McKee, Ross, Bensusan etc etc ... mmm continu !
n45w73 1 year ago
Fuck man tu vas a quelle ecole??!???!???
Laflamme120 1 year ago
Man, you're an artist. Great work and great inpsiration.
TransitionRu 1 year ago
This is the first cover I've ever heard which keeps true to the original song, but has just enough variation to enjoy it as a new song. Good job! I like the slow approach and the little nuances!
00melo00 1 year ago
I like this cover much but it's nowhere near Andy's perfomance to be honest...
You can hear here and there some minor mistakes (sure it's live perfomance but...)
RussianFabjan 1 year ago
hey what capo do u use for this song?
thisisazn 1 year ago
You'd make andy proud!
poetlocked 1 year ago
im not the only one who puts the capo like that! (since i dont have a partial capo) xD but wow, that sound is beautiful... its so clean
NoodleStroodel 1 year ago
wauw! <3
Alicccc 1 year ago
It is great, You are the fuckin man!. But there will never be another Andy Mckee.
devastator1316 1 year ago
Du joli! la jouer au ralenti te permet de rajouter plein de petites choses sans que cela ne fasse too much! très beaux plans perso en plus (sympa la cassure a 4'40)! j'aurais peut être un poil speedé l'intro mais pour le reste, niquel :p
tazief 1 year ago
Excelente Amigo !!!!!! los errores no se notan, la música es una forma de expresar nuestro estado de animo y lo que sentimo de corazón.. EMILIO
MultiEntrar 1 year ago
screw what everyone else is saying. the slower tempo gives the melody more feeling and is more mood-inspiring. sure it isn't better than the original, but it's as good for sure.
haproductions01 1 year ago
best guitarists in the world!
gotosleepu 1 year ago
tabs????!?!?!?!
kevbe144 1 year ago
Wonderful, great, awesome :D
2:07> Nice sound!
Wish i could play it too...just don't know where to start and where to get tabs (without paying for it?).
FreaksterXXX 1 year ago
seriously, what kind of school is this? I love your videos!
phphphphphphph 1 year ago
foot douce sa figui
AznVi3tx 1 year ago
The 11 dislikes are dickfaces. thumbs up? ^^
Ortegala 1 year ago
i don't care if its slow, its still nice ! cheers ;)
and what guitar type is it ? :)
D4vidP0c4r 1 year ago
@D4vidP0c4r Stonebridge guitar I believe. Andy plays them, too. However, I don't know which model.
fatfredthe28th 1 year ago
Some people are morons. YOU go and try playing this song even half as well as Pierre has here. Great cover, amazing feel.
weakfingers 1 year ago
agree with mmarzl...i don't think many people have tried to play this song! IT"S FRIGN HARD!! SO kudoos to u bro
poopduck11 1 year ago
omg, ur so good, i thought u were the actually andy mckee
bboyairstep 1 year ago
Oh man !!! C'est vraiment bon !! Tu as vraiment full de talent sérieux, c'est malade :P. Vive le talent au Québec !!!
DJLeh7959 1 year ago
i like your cover so much. bravo from russia
kalashpiter 1 year ago
Juste oublié de saluer ton choix de réduire considérablement le tempo : humilité intelligente et sage astuce pour peut-être maîtriser mieux et pouvoir plus aisément caresser tous les registres du morceau...
Salut
Chiquitness 1 year ago
Ta reprise est magnifique, empreinte d'une superbe émotion. Ton jeu est souple (malgré tout... :-) ), et la mélodie rendue incroyable. Merci pour le voyage !
BEN
Chiquitness 1 year ago
okay, not as good as the original.
xxbluejay21 1 year ago
Excellent cover dude!
ProcureEminence 1 year ago
I love how all musicians looks like they're making love when they play! <3
JoRiProduction 1 year ago
It's alright. Nothing to compare to the working professionals, though.
Neptunade 1 year ago
kkkkkkkkkk
alvarexxxx 1 year ago
i wish i could play like that with 100 mistakes never mind two or three tiny ones! great job man you should be proud!
xbernicex94 1 year ago
fuck man that was amazing. im subscribing
xXshermanaterXx 1 year ago
so slow...but its good....well done...
joanarriba 1 year ago
Je t'ai vu à la TV un jour, pendant que je me préparais à partir au cégep, pis j'ai dû me tapper la pire course de ma vie pour pas manquer mon bus!
Ta version est est à mon avis de loin la meilleure comparée aux autres sur Youtube. On y sent tellement plus l'émotion, la profondeur et la mélodie! Rylynn est devenue une de mes mélodies fétiches, et si tu sors un jour un cd du genre, je l'achète sur le champs, peu importe le prix!
Continue de nous offrir cette magie auditive!
SimOmega47 1 year ago
watch his face and body, he is feelin' that song...amazing
Odorwyn 2 years ago
this one isnt as good and andy's one but is still good
JOSEPHCRUST 2 years ago
Didn't even really notice any mess ups. Beautiful Song, Beautiful Version.
davisthepirate 2 years ago
HAHAHAH Jetai un des cameraman! bON SHOW !
felix151 2 years ago
this version has got more hold n power...compared to....the original one...it just my opinion but andy is still gr8....
tiwariification 2 years ago
Very nice.
maganashi 2 years ago
the best thing is that you didn't rush the song, you actually played it a little slower than the original and that is very wise! to keep control :)
very good version, and who cares about the little mistakes , I heard them, but they didn't ruin the mood or song !
GREAT JOB!
K1LL14N 2 years ago
exellent , EXELLENT !!!!! XD
dolfsih 2 years ago 2
J'y étais ! C'était trop bon !
Djoubox1 2 years ago 2
good work men. You're absolutly fantastic ;) see YOu soon !
JakubKrystyan 2 years ago 2
Wow, absolutely beautiful playing....Keep up the great work...
Veliaria 2 years ago 2
what guitar he uses please ?
Extasie31 2 years ago
I think its a stonebridge 23-CR.
with a fishman rare earth blend pick-up.
3245james 2 years ago
soo good, it is played live and even andy doesn't play it live without any tiny mistakes...the feeling is important...i can't believe that this video doesn't have 5 stars...only people with no clue of music of jealous persons can give you less than 5 stars...your playing is excellent
mmarzl 2 years ago 7
Thanks a lot man I appreciate it! Though there IS a lot of mistakes in this hehe... just gotta find'em :-)
PistolPeteQC 2 years ago 3
i know but that doesn´t matter because there are no bad mistakes (except of the wrong cut in the bridge part^^)
mmarzl 2 years ago
i agree =D a few "accidental" mutes but no biggie...he played well...that song is awesome
s0mdum9uy 2 years ago
@PistolPeteQC
Everybody makes mistakes. It's all about the timing and you delivered beautifully. I made it my "mission" to play this and had to give up because I didn't have the skill required and definitely not the talent to get the timing right. I can't believe I am going to say this, but I think you played the outro better than Andy McKee (don't tell anyone I said that).
GoldenGeode 1 year ago
@PistolPeteQC finding them aint too hard, but that doesnt make this performance less great... the piece is amazingly difficult to master... (even to learn and memorise it is quite the job). well done, and the feeling can be heard, wich is 99% of the song in my opinion. keep it up
Pookz1985 9 months ago in playlist Favorite Acoustic Guitar Players
@mmarzl as much as i love andy's music and he is one of the few guitarists that still leave me going wow and wanting to get better at guitar; he makes mistakes never think a human can't make a mistake especially with music....no one is perfect
MusicVampire11 1 year ago
@MusicVampire11 lol i actually thought this was andy playing this song hahahaha thats funny see i made a mistake XD haha but anyways this guy is pretty good too
MusicVampire11 1 year ago
@mmarzl i hear a couple but its still very very great job
dudeXIMXkla 1 year ago
nice ending! so much better than the fade out
tonyshawk 2 years ago
next time wash your guitar!!! sinon c'est parfait
fredjezzar 2 years ago
NON
Ça montre qu'elle du vécu ;)
Vraiment bon, smoot pi vraiment bien joué !
BigButeau 2 years ago
Smoooooooottttthhhhhhhhhhhhh
I like it. Great job. Nice transitions
oSOLJA4CHRISTo 2 years ago
you play like andy mckee and you look like jesus!!! (if after that you're not bless...)
rastatouf2225 2 years ago
3:03 got Andy McKee head bob goin on lol
amazing guitar though
racketman90 2 years ago
Excellent =)
kiminoverdoze 2 years ago
Stonebridge Guitar :-O!!!
GadgetAddicted 2 years ago
Marry me Pierre :P
Une tite game de perfect dark sul 64 srait cool... sten pense
metalBGfan 2 years ago
great cover
guitar4794 2 years ago
Amazingly done, although it was a liiittle slow maybe. :P
jagvillintevaramed92 2 years ago
Congratulations
MrCaioguitar 2 years ago
i think the slower tempo makes the song lose a lot of melodic flavour.
stdermeister1 2 years ago 28
I'd have to agree with you. But it's still a good job nonetheless. :) Better than what I can do at the moment.
TwiztedMister 2 years ago
@stdermeister1 I dunno about losing flavour. Perhaps changing flavour yes, but not losing it.
ImTheMetal 1 year ago
great job!
Darkulla 2 years ago
Comment removed
contactlewis 2 years ago
very very very well performed thanks for uploading your cover I'm sure andy would agree you did great.
hydrabeast 2 years ago
Étant un amateur de guitare et de classique, n'arrivant pas à classifier votre style des plus agréable à nos oreilles, je dois vous féliciter. Compte tenu de votre jeune âge, vous semblez avoir atteint un niveau de dextérité émérite. Ce style musicale va probablement percer fortement si vous continuer à le forger.
J'ai créé un compte youtube exceptionnellement juste pour vous féliciter.
albumburger 2 years ago
You make your mistakes sound like genius...lache pas la patate monnomme! I would love to play with you someday..I just moved to MTL for Ottawa..look me up whenever you're in town..je suis fier d'etre quebecois..merci.
SLSheehan 2 years ago
Congratulaciones, la interpretación es magnifica, desde colombia un saludo
blanquETAdu 2 years ago
hahah complètement fou, je suis tombé par hazard sur la 30e édition de Cegep en Spectacles sur le Canal Vox. J'ai reconnu tout de suite la toune étant fan de Andy, micheal hedges, Don Ross et Antoine dufour etc. Félicitation pour le grand prix sir and keep going!
Simili84 2 years ago
Je viens de voir ta performance à la télé et je n'ai jamais autant ressenti le besoin de féliciter quelqu'un! Tu ressens ta musique, tu la joue avec passion et t'as tout le talent pour donner un résultat excellent. Tout ce que je te demandes, même si on ne se connaît pas, c'est de continuer. Je t'encourage d'autant plus que tu es de notre belle province! Lâche pas! T'as pas l'droit!
Zotsar 2 years ago
5/5
Good job Pete ;)
InFlamesHell 2 years ago
awesome cover ... you're like a metronome itself
great tone !
33shin33 2 years ago
it is played a little bit slow, but that was truely awesome. I really want to try and learn but don't have the time... i hope one day i can play it like that.
you're truely, truely fantastic my friend, keep it up.
robem10 2 years ago
thanks man!
I find that it has more emotion that way, and I now play it even slower.... thanks for the comment
PistolPeteQC 2 years ago
@PistolPeteQC Agreed
tpritchas14 1 year ago
@robem10 Sometimes songs just sound so much better when they're slowed down, so you can really hear every note in their own beauty. FanTASTIC cover.
And for the record, covers don't need to be 100%, most GOOD covers incorporate some of the player's own styles. That's what separates good guitar covers from bad ones, creativity and an open mind. 5/5.
OfForceAndChaos 1 year ago
Bravo pour ta prestation au FIMU !
jaclaffite 2 years ago
merci beaucoup!
PistolPeteQC 2 years ago
Good cover... I personally think its being played a little too slow though.
eddyfunkboy 2 years ago
Salut, je sais pas si c'est toi le vrai Pierre mais bon ... juste dire que j'ai bien aimé ta prestation, ta musique, ta façcon d'être en entrevue et dit toi que le contacte avec les fans est bien important surtout au début, j'aimerais bien voir un show de toi ! je viens de voir le show a Vox et bravo ! je t'encourage à répondre à tes fans !
j'attend des dates de shows
Jean-Matthieu Latour
infinity0087 2 years ago
Tu aurais pu donner un coup de pledge sur ta Stonebridge avant le show! Serieux, c'est vrm bien ce que tu fais Pierre. Lâche surtout pas et Félicitation pour ta première place. J'suis vraiment déçu d'avoir manquer ce show-là dans mon cégep!
GibsonMarco 2 years ago
hahaha un coup de pledge
Simili84 2 years ago
amazing!!!could you send me the tabs? thanks oxo
xbernicex94 2 years ago
Hi 5*!!!
lip333 2 years ago
J't'ai vu au Gala de la vie étudiante au Cégep.... Tu es incroyable... C'est vrm vrm vrm magnifique.... Continue srx!.... xxx
DarkChakotay 2 years ago
Hey je t'ai vu à la finale régionale à Valleyfield et tu m'as vraiment épatée wow tu étais excellent et t'as l'air tellement en amour avec ton instrument c'est fou! Pis félicitations pour ta première place à la finale nationale! Lâche pas t'es vraiment bon! ;)
sweet0romance 2 years ago
Almost got it...missed a few notes..but great job at Andy's song..wooTwooT
Jastababe 2 years ago
est-ce que tes grands-parents habitent à ste-marie bce?
valerieforgues 2 years ago
lol... oui? :P
PistolPeteQC 2 years ago
Je les connais, j'ai grandi dans la maison de ma grand mère à côté de chez eux. Je t'ai même connu quand tu étais ptit.
valerieforgues 2 years ago
hey, nice cover ;) is this a Stonebridge 23-CR? what pickup-system are you using? Fishman Rare-Earth blend?
fipdalips 2 years ago
Yes, and yes! :P
PistolPeteQC 2 years ago
hehe, kinda Antoine Dufour style :D i like it
fipdalips 2 years ago