Added: 2 years ago
From: NettwerkMusic
Views: 71,376
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (189)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • looks like a Loreale commercial

  • I have to say that I love this version. She is a brilliant singer and the video is great. But I do miss the rock touch to it from Evanescence.

  • Majority of listeners like the type of music of the original and maybe that's why they don't like it. But I love it.

  • no comparison to the original come on Amy

  • Love her voice but where the hell did that coat thing come from she wasn't wearing it at the start then when she gets off the boat she is wearing it weird

  • hat nichts mit dem original zu tun. klasse stimme aber ich finde das is nur prommi geschmack macherei.

  • her voice and preformence deserve all the apload and credit that you could ever give because her work is amazing here and her voice is amazing even more so stop judging by the way its different and start listening to how she sings it, and how well her voice is

  • Fuck the haters. She did a pretty damn good job.

  • Alcuni rocker prendono pezzi classici o vecchie canzoni e le riadatano anche il rap fa lo stesso non vedo perchè si debba criticare chi opera al contrario. Se una cosa non ti piace non la ascoltare, punto e basta

  • Comment removed

  • Better singer than amy lee, but I miss the more "rock" feel in the chorus.

  • awa die singt voll geil mir gefallen beide versionen :D

  • fuck i would love to fuck her! o.O

  • Not very good without linkin park in it.

  • @fockwolf189

    what linkin park? Linkin park was not in the original Bring Me to Life.....that was the lead vocalist of 12 stones.

  • @saizobacon look this song up with linkin park and you will see what i am talking about.

  • WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • A beautiful voice and no soul. Just great... And the video? OMG! How can she sing this song and wear such ridiculous clothes? Totally inadequate. I'm sorry but she ruined the song.

  • O.o WTF is this shit?

  • fair enough she sings opera but this song was amazing allready and she made it suckish ... and she even sang the linkin park bits which she made poo, so overall opera singer trying to sing a rock song = horrible outcome

  • this is total bullsh*t, evanescence is soooo much better, she ruins the song

  • I think both versions are great. Also people should know that Katherine does not 'shout' just to express herself more. Her cover is simply kind of her interpretation of the song same as e.g. Hallelujah, which is - again - very good in her version, but different to any other versions you are about to find.

  • This sounds a lot like the original ... So what's the point?

  • This music isn't supposed to be pretty, it's supposed to be real. Evanescence makes it sound like it's a cry from the heart. Katherine is too pretty in the video and is trying to make the whole thing pretty..it just doesn't feel right!

  • It's funny... I like this version better than the piece of crap Evanescence made...

  • Yeah this is horrible!

  • this version suks

  • mi sbaglio o questa è la canzone degli evanescence??

  • @PiccolaDark483 non ti sbagli ;)

  • like original version not this one

  • she sings it very well though :)

  • OMFG i hate this song it is a disgrace to evanescence my favourite band i hate cathrine jenkins anyway shes too perfect

  • by far this is the worest song she RUINED so far.....

  • R.U.I.N.E.D song.

  • :-j the original is the best!!!:X

  • evanescence was the best obviously

    this is a good version too :)

  • You can't compare this to the evanescence version...it's a completely different, beautiful style of music.

  • I like the end

  • Voll die NACHMACHE VON EVANESCENCE

  • I love this song!

  • she rocks...°°

  • This cover sucks. Evanescence rocks. (:

  • The whole song lost its beauty!!

  • Like the original better. obviously.

  • I hate her!! I can't stand her!!! How can she copy this amazing song !!! Evanescence is so much better!! She ruined it!!

  • WOW...!

  • I think I would have liked this version just as much as the Evanesence version if the chorus had been a little more foreceful. As it was, I felt a bit let down.

  • fack you lady jenkins

  • it's beuatiful but he original is already sung by an amazing singer..amy lee is as good as her in my mind

  • she shouldnt sing this song lol

  • yeh who the fuck is this bitch fuck off an get back to where yu belong

  • I love her high heels !!! :P...

    and to be frank was waiting for that sound of the electric rock metal guitar to come .. but sadly there was not...

    her voice is crystal clear though.. i loved it !

  • the evanescence version was better

  • Beautiful...Beautiful.....Beau­tiful!!!!!!!!!!

  • It's just like a "piano version"... :(

  • Honestly, a very uninteresting cover. She could have done so much more with a voice like that, but frankly it was a bit dull.

    And on a less serious side, it needs a guitar solo =P

  • Fans of Evanescence should be Grateful a true Goddess has decided to honour and cover the track as the lead singer of EV...is opera/classically trained....she hasnt killed the song stupid she made it her own style and it should be heard differently one sided minded people...blimey....

  • I heard it with an open mind. I'm not an evanesence fan and I agree that she killed the song. It's a boring cover. The original is so much powerful and energetic. This cover is missing some umf... (if you know what I mean :P). More power, especially since she has such an amazing voice and probably the potential to sing anything :P

  • how come ur soooo gorgeous like ur made from the GODS who need goddessess like Athena and Venus when u have Katherine Jenkins no other can be compared to the beauty that is her.

  • damn...this one is kinda classico

    Even's version is Gothic-metal :|...

    how come you guy compare :|...damn

  • Wie kann man einen so schönen Song nur so verhunzen. Die Stimme ist ja nicht mal schlecht, aber es braucht einfach die Gitarre und das Schlagzeug dazu.

  • Die Trulla is ne künstliche Schönheit *ätzend -.-*

    Evanescence zu covern geht unter die Gürtellinie von wahren Musikfans -.-'''

  • she killed the song evanessence sang it bettar

  • She has a nice voice, but honestly; i dont think this is a good song for her to sing, i LOVE Evanescence, so i'm very biased right now cuz i think their song's shouldn't really be sung by others mainly cuz NOONE can beat the original :S

  • the singing is great but i think that the original song is much better sinmply because in this version the feeling and the original style of the song is completely missing it's gothic-rock or metal however you'd call it and not this kind of music

  • yeah i know i was sitting waiting in anticipation for the guitar it just doesnt work without it

  • exactly... at 0:51 I heard the guitar in my head but it wasn't there in the song in my opinion the song can't work without the Rock or Metal part

    \m/ Xuri

  • TO CLEAR UP ANY CONFUSION THIS SONG IS ORIGINALLY FROM A LEGENDARY BAND CALLED EVANESCENCE :) good version tho me thinks

  • it says that in the side bar.

  • yeah, but most people dont bother reading the side bar

  • sie hat einen netten 70s look! aber Gothik-Rocksongs sollten nicht gecovert werden um daraus schickeria zu machen... Is ähnlich mit dem Song Eisblumen von Subway to Sally in der Coverversion von der Band Eisblume (dass man sich auch noch so nennen muss...).

  • I wouldn't mind seeing a duet with Amy on this one, there are parts where each could take the song into its own, but alone, both seem to be missing styles and traits to really let this song shatter soulbinds

  • She's OK. But why couldn't she SPOIL some OTHER SONG?

  • Katherine is very Haunting here, not at all the rock and metal vibe of Amy, but Katherine does bring a very classy kind of fey quality to this - the other side of gothic music than Amy? I kinda like this, but Kath tries uses operatic too much in parts for continuity of style and expression.

  • **************

  • She's pretty and has a pretty voice, but there's no way she can compete vocally with Amy Lee's powerful soaring voice.

  • Excellent, subtle yet powerful rendition of this already popular and overplayed song. I would love to see this version featured in an opera show / musical.

  • HoPeRi0t1 i totally agree with you!!!!

  • wtf...? she ruined the song!! -.-"

  • shes really pretty, but this song is not for her. amy lee and ben moody made this song its an original keep it this way. maybe a song to sing at a show, but not make it yours and have a music video for it.

  • omg...

    she ruined the song!!!!

  • she killed one of the best songs there is its a rock song and shes a classical artist yeh fair enough good singer but it need more than a bit of lead guitar mixed with violin listen to the evanescence version it will lighten you up not make you feel the dark and before you comment yes i dont give a crap what you think of my comment

  • Gr8 ^_^ , But NoT Batter Than EvA <3 !!

  • blondes are not allowed to sing this song

  • you are right !!!!

  • @TheLilIdiot Well.. I'm Singing It.

  • : I love it !!

  • I like this version better. The power chords get old.

  • STOP COMPARING KATHERINE AND AMY'S VERSON!!

    Just appreciate the song and katherine singing it..

    It is alright to like both katherines and amy's yano? no1's asking anyone to take sides here.. bloody hell..!

  • she is HOT!

  • great voice, pretty hot, but she only sang half the song evanessence did. the soft half.

  • its prety much the same in the verses and then the chorus is just lacking in the angst that it needs. So really its a pointless copy coz she hasnt brought anything new to it and it doesnt change much. Which is a shame coz she has a wonderful voice!

  • i thought it was good

    mainly because miss jenkins is a rapid tidy

  • i loved it! :D

  • gazfrost should learn to spell

  • Really not sure what I think of this.... I LOVE Katherine Jenkins but I really don't think this was a very good idea......

  • why all these people try to sing evanescence songs?:S only amy can sing them

  • GO BACK TO YOUR DARK PLACE

  • actually amy's voice is much more advanced than katherines no matter what you think, and tbh although i admit thet jenkins is an amazing singer, this song dont suit her, cus hers is more of a floaty and angelic voice, whereas the song is a more frantic plea kinda if ya get me... so although catherine is amazing, she should hav left this song alone really

  • This song is meant to be sang with power not soft like Katherine. The beginning was fine however i want more screaming or strong with a high pitch voice!

  • Bloody hell ppl. Calm down!!! Once again ppl in this world take things farrr too seriously!!

    We should be here to apprecaite how amazingly beautiful and talented Katherine is. All she's doing is covering a song, there's 100's of artists that do that now. Its no big deal!!

    I personally LOVE this virson. Im nt usually into this kinda music but i must admit, i love Katherine!! She's just amazing.

    So enuf with the stupid pointless comments, and enjoy the song. Dont like it, dnt watch it..!

  • she isnt trying to sing like Amy...and just because a singer covers a song doesnt mean they want to copy the original

  • This is all right, but I definitely prefer Evanescene's version better.

  • Dude are you fucking kidding me? Bars and yachts and glamor? This chick is a slut; she doesn't even have a soul, why the fuck is she singing this? You can feel how fake her singing this. She isn't feeling the music.

    Amy would be disappointed.

  • This woman is a Opera singer who is trying her hand at a more "pop" type music. She is a very talented singer, has a few more years till her voice matures for true opera, but she is good. Too bad you talk out your 5th point of contact though.

  • Until Katherine has actually sung an opera role-- in a full-length production-- without microphones-- she CANNOT be called an opera singer! Merely a "classically trained" singer.

  • This is true. I actually know little about opera now days. Last time I went to a opera was 18 years ago.  Not because I havent wanted to... but because I have never been in a place the same time as any I have wanted to see.

  • Where does it say she's an opera singer? Go on her website and nowhere does she claim to be one. She's a mezzo-soprano who sings a variety of music.

  • people assume because your classically trained that automatically you are an opera singer...although this might be true in some cases (particularly mine) this isnt the case for her

  • agreed! finally someone with common sense!

  • not an opera singer...just classically trained...and just because you are classically trained doesnt automatically mean you are an opera singer

  • evanescence was so much better she should do something proper with her voice because i like the rock version

  • I have to agree

  • her voice is good but the video sucks. they cannot even make the rain look real.

  • I really like this version, and she's so nice to talk to in person.

  • I would sell my soul for you Katherine Jenkins!!!! I'm your slave!!!!

  • love it

  • I think Istanbul is jealous. Cause im sure it has not seen such a beauty before. I hope her magician beauty and voice visit our land again!!

  • i think she does a good cover of this song i am not a fan of her style of music normally but she does a good job

  • she's got an amazing voice and she's very pretty but i like the evanescence version more than this one.

  • AWFUL dont steal songs from Amy She is FAR more talented the u(YUCK!)

  • Amy has a ways to go before she has matured vocally as well

  • ok me queda claro que las rolas de evanescence son para el uso exclusivo de la hermosa vos de amy

    xD

  • She is as beautiful as Istabul :)))) WOw, i was amazed by her voice and her look and ,of course, Istanbul

  • It's called a remake for a reason. Be respectful, guys.

  • gaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay copied and sucked, horrible chours(and everything else) thumbs down

  • I love David Foster's productions usually, but this one is so convoluted and unfortunately attempts to cash in on the Evanessence sound - the beginnings are identical - doing this song as a softer ballad doesn't sound right & it's also waaayyyyy too soon from the hit version of this to remake it and expect it to hit, especially in the US.

  • what a freaking barbie.

  • Orginial <333333333333333333333333333

    this </3

  • so beautiful and wonderful rendition!!

  • the beggining was nice, nice voice, the chorus is awfull sorry....

  • All I can say is "Wow!"

  • beautiful version good music dont need nudity or stupid dancing

  • this is bull shit i hated this

  • Comment removed

  • ...rather Evanescence!!!!

  • great voice, no doubt - but i think they should do something about the music, anyhow it still reminds me of evanescence's version of this number.

    make it something that'll make people won't forget katherine jenkins' version of this number.

  • I agree with Int3rl0per and if Amy Lee did a cover of "Bring me to Life" by herself (Or at least without that guy) it would be loads better than both this cover and the original.

  • Amy cant cover this song because it belongs to her

  • hmm nice song .. for a cover its cool .. i always loved this songgg

  • evanescence is way better! I hate when they do this! x( nice voice so she better writes her own songs!

  • Not quite original enough; but the song does sound a lot better without a rapping retard getting in the way.

  • I had to watch this to believe it. This is a wonderful cover :) Such a colourful and gorgeous voice.

  • What´s up with NettwerkMusic. They´ve been taking a dump in my ears these last couple of weeks.

  • True that!

  • she is amazing ! and so so pretty ! :)

  • Not at all a bad cover, I must admit! She has a good voice, and I especially love the ending :)

  • great voice!

  • no niezła przeróbka

  • God I'm getting Fucking Sick and Tired of This Song.

  • Original is way better.

    But good job.

  • she looks just like bridgitte bardot!

  • worst thing i've ever heard.

  • really, really bad! :( original rulezz..

  • and the original is with who?

  • evanescence

  • okay hehe thanks :-)

  • Its a cover from Evanescence.

    But its good.

  • i actually enjoyed this version, i am supprised :) she sings it well, i guess it works because opera has a gothic quality :)..thats just my opinion x

  • Bring me to the Life is technically a duet song isnt it? i mena the video is good but im not happy that shes trying to sound like amy lee. good video though.

  • SHE IS NOT TRYING TO SOUND LIKE AMY! man Ive said this a million times so Ill make it a million and one...she is just covering the song...by her covering it by no means she trying to copy anyone

  • yes but isn't it technically a duet song? i know its just a cover but the least she could have done was cover it properly.

  • this is strictly her take on this song and her interpretation...

  • well no offense its not that good of one to me but that's her interpretation and i respect that but that doesn't mean I have to like it.

  • Im not saying you have to like it but what I am saying is at least give a more educated opinion other than "I don't like it because its Amy's song"

  • Not a bad job. Good sound, good video editing.... Good cover, but that's all it is.. a cover.

    Evanescence absolutely destroys all with their version.

  • agreed :D

  • ok? maybe this singer should stick to her own songs and leave everyone elses songs alone.

  • great cover evanescence rules!!!

  • this isent her song o.0 how is it her new single D: im so lost -.- dammit