@perfectpickleman is correct. Good comment, but this rendition is nowhere near the beauty and love that is felt when Wayne sings it. I believe when Wayne sings it his entire body wells up inside with nothing but love..
don't be haters. it's true the flaming lips and beck have had a tumultuous relationship, but everything has been reconciled. watch this video and realize that beck is paying tribute to one of the greatest songs ever made.
Guys, this was just 50 seconds amongst an hour or so of music. If you look on the web, he has a better rendition of this song then even the flaming lips. Check it out. Then go eat my penis. It's in the microwave.
@perfectpickleman this would have been a good comment if you didnt say it was "better than the flaming lips" yeah fucking right, super soulful song and the words only sound right coming from waynes mouth. i love beck but its not "better"
This less than a minute clip is all I need to hear to judge Beck on the many, many albums he has produced, not to mention the influence he has had on music since the early 1990's. It's obvious from the comments that people agree that a :50 clip from one of hundreds of shows is all that's needed to judge the remainder of his discography.
tight little version. got the point across in less than a minute using the departure from melody and serious compression. haters gonna hate. lovers love. REALIZE!
well, i think that this is the worst version of beck. i saw him in buenos aires when a i was 12, the midnite vultures era. AWESOME, totally different from this gig. I believe that, like everyone does, he became a little bit nut, but in a antisocial way.
I believed that Beck dont have a perfect live show but his albums are perfect. i wish to see this beck singing Sea Change completly in a intimate atmosphere.
Boy that sucks! His pretty singing is atrocious, and emotionally totally disconnected from the song and the FlamingLips and pretty much from the world actually. Yuck!
good comment! After your post, this video got a few haters on his singing.
I'd say Beck does a great job here, with a tasteful choice of notes in departing from the 'original'. And his 'off-keyness' is him adding TFL flavor! also, when it's less apparent, it may be just warping by the digital camera.
i love this video and this song and recently directed a video of another cover of the song by Gretchen Lieberum which I just posted here on YouTube...hope you will check it out...
Wonderful! Good work Beck! -And Puppet Beck Backup Dancer! Good Taste. Nice Style. Boogie On Wooden Waxwork! Waste and Whittle did Gimble and Gyre in the Wabe.
@perfectpickleman is correct. Good comment, but this rendition is nowhere near the beauty and love that is felt when Wayne sings it. I believe when Wayne sings it his entire body wells up inside with nothing but love..
hooskerdu1 5 months ago
. . . sounds like chris cornell
wreklessabandon 6 months ago
Ew?
C'mon, Beck. I know you can do better than that.
joethulhuz 8 months ago
Which song goes between Lost Cause and Do you realize?... the one that he cut!
salvadorcabezon 10 months ago
This sucks.
elfspice1337 1 year ago
@elfspice1337 Seriously? OK. What rock songs do you prefer over this. I'm not kidding. I want to know where you're coming from.
skrason 1 year ago
don't be haters. it's true the flaming lips and beck have had a tumultuous relationship, but everything has been reconciled. watch this video and realize that beck is paying tribute to one of the greatest songs ever made.
RobizziJames 1 year ago
@RobizziJames
one of the greatest songs ever ???
you must have a limited catalog
meatazzsandwich 1 year ago
@meatazzsandwich the lyrics are perfect, tell me what you think is one of the greatest songs ever
RobizziJames 1 year ago
@RobizziJames
definitely one of the greatest songs ever
TheWillLockwood 1 year ago
wut. beck. doing. the. flaming. lips. shouldnt. happen.
i mean cmon, he cant even do it, and the flips opened for HIM on a tour once.
deepinswim 2 years ago
Guys, this was just 50 seconds amongst an hour or so of music. If you look on the web, he has a better rendition of this song then even the flaming lips. Check it out. Then go eat my penis. It's in the microwave.
perfectpickleman 2 years ago 10
hahahahhahhahahahahaahhahahaahahaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa god your penis was delish.
beaverB0B 2 years ago 4
@beaverB0B well played good sir
joe190 2 years ago
@perfectpickleman this would have been a good comment if you didnt say it was "better than the flaming lips" yeah fucking right, super soulful song and the words only sound right coming from waynes mouth. i love beck but its not "better"
deadsilense 1 year ago
This less than a minute clip is all I need to hear to judge Beck on the many, many albums he has produced, not to mention the influence he has had on music since the early 1990's. It's obvious from the comments that people agree that a :50 clip from one of hundreds of shows is all that's needed to judge the remainder of his discography.
averyellis 2 years ago 3
this is messed man. not right. beck should not sing that again, ever
BusGusisaMust 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Beck is such a schlub
NiggaTubeDotCom 2 years ago
tight little version. got the point across in less than a minute using the departure from melody and serious compression. haters gonna hate. lovers love. REALIZE!
sickwater 2 years ago
wtf, he ruined the song, wtf
mp15tc 2 years ago
well, i think that this is the worst version of beck. i saw him in buenos aires when a i was 12, the midnite vultures era. AWESOME, totally different from this gig. I believe that, like everyone does, he became a little bit nut, but in a antisocial way.
I believed that Beck dont have a perfect live show but his albums are perfect. i wish to see this beck singing Sea Change completly in a intimate atmosphere.
i love you beck, you are my hero!
leoacosta88 2 years ago
Jesus Christ! I love Beck but I'm finding it hard to defend him here, that wasnt very good at all
StupidShinigami 2 years ago
Agreed.
rolf1304 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
HE SUCKS HE SUCKS HE SUCKS HE SUCKS
thejakk 2 years ago
you can say that again!
teamhowdy 2 years ago
Boy that sucks! His pretty singing is atrocious, and emotionally totally disconnected from the song and the FlamingLips and pretty much from the world actually. Yuck!
mantra3000 2 years ago
Epic view
pandarenwise 2 years ago 2
I wonder if this is why Wayne Coyne thinks Beck is a douche.
mrgreyshadow 2 years ago 4
dude beck and the flmaing lips are pretty close knit, im pretty sure beck used them as his backing band for a tour or so
facefacerson3 2 years ago 2
he looks like david spade here
m0destm0useisg0d 3 years ago
I saw this tour. The Flaming Lips were opening for Beck. Beck stunk badly.
closetiguana 3 years ago
Finally someone sung this song on key. Too bad the singer that wrote the song can't sing it for shit.
ciyean 3 years ago
oh wow beck covering this is lovely :)
dumbartist 3 years ago
The Flaming Lips are probably my favorite band out right now besides Radiohead... but Beck sings better than Wayne. =D
redraiderdude187 4 years ago 2
hell no.
Dude421 3 years ago 32
i disagree!
holzy4565 3 years ago
hey cool, those are my favorite bands too, aprt from tom waits and frank black.
katkal3 3 years ago
but the whole point of wayne coynes voice is that its not perfect. i wouldnt listen to them as much if he had everything pitch perfect.
SO LA! hehehehe <3 flaming lips.
Leemanlyness 3 years ago
good comment! After your post, this video got a few haters on his singing.
I'd say Beck does a great job here, with a tasteful choice of notes in departing from the 'original'. And his 'off-keyness' is him adding TFL flavor! also, when it's less apparent, it may be just warping by the digital camera.
ItaniuMatrix 2 years ago
i love beck
goneblogging87 4 years ago 2
i love this video and this song and recently directed a video of another cover of the song by Gretchen Lieberum which I just posted here on YouTube...hope you will check it out...
jacobaaronestes 4 years ago
Wonderful! Good work Beck! -And Puppet Beck Backup Dancer! Good Taste. Nice Style. Boogie On Wooden Waxwork! Waste and Whittle did Gimble and Gyre in the Wabe.
ezekieloak 4 years ago
I really love this song and I love Beck and his voice... I heard him playing it in a show last year and I almost cried... thank you so so so much!
daveaddicted 5 years ago