If she had sang it the way she did on the cd she may not have been the 1st to go. It was much better there. Her 'dips' to the lower chord are way too deep.
It's a pity....she has a GORGEUS voice, but my god she didn't know what to do with it...to this day, I'm like what the hell was she thinking with the songs she picked!?
@curlingiron7658 its hard to judge crap vs crap, but it seems this crap is more tolerable than that crap Kimberly Caldwell was singing. she wouldnt even be able to make it on Glee
@curlingiron7658 No, i would imagine the reason it took her 5 years to find someone who would release her CD has nothing to do with the fact that she was a worse singer than Lindsey. Its more likely the reason is Kimberly was just a bad singer to begin with, thus needing the 5 years to work and train on it. as i havent heard her since Idol, i do not know if she succeeded or not.
How could she be so completely clueless that this song was COMPLETELY wrong for her. It wound up being really bad -- not sure if she was trying to put too much of her own spin on the performance -- but it sure didnt work.
to be honest, this was horrible performance in terms of vocals. this was NOT the right song for her AT ALL. her voice is wayyyy to deep for this song and therefore, the entire performance was flat. she didn't hit any of the right notes. she was trying to, but failed miserably. her voice sounded strained as well. and to be completely honest, she sounded constipated when she sang the song.
she had good energy, but it doesn't mean anything if your vocals are downright bad. horrible song choice.
You don't see anything wrong with it? The whole thing was a trainwreck. With voters like you, I can see why the results are so bad sometimes. No ability to distinguish good from bad. The voters got it right this time.
Lindsey had every right to leave that week. She sounded okay but not great and she did not stand out. I felt Anthony or one of the other white men should have left the next week. And whoever said my bro Nikko should have left that week need to shutup!!!!! This girl was horrible!!
she 100% should have made it through this week,i was really upset with her and Mikalah not making it to top 10,i wanted Nikko and Scott to be the first 2 off
poor lindsey. bad song choice for a great voice.
drew3486 11 months ago
this got her eliminated. right? it wuz a while ago
RandomManSam 1 year ago
Definitely not her best song choice. Lindsey was very pitchy.
GutsandHeartGuy 1 year ago
When she says that its frightning i think shes talkin about this performance because this was terible!!!!
crazedchimpmunk123 1 year ago
If she had sang it the way she did on the cd she may not have been the 1st to go. It was much better there. Her 'dips' to the lower chord are way too deep.
Corsina 1 year ago
i've not heard her before, so i don't know about her voice, but this performance is terrible.
KrisAllisonKelly4evr 1 year ago
She desered to make it much much further, she should've traded spots with Scott Savol.
JakobTennisMB 1 year ago 2
I Love her!!(:she is from louisiana she use to work with my sis love u lindsey(:
lilmissfrenchy16 1 year ago
It's a pity....she has a GORGEUS voice, but my god she didn't know what to do with it...to this day, I'm like what the hell was she thinking with the songs she picked!?
stefgi32 2 years ago
She's even cuter than Carrie Underwood
arashjan 2 years ago
Lindsey's cute but this performance was forced and dreadful.
cbotten106 2 years ago 7
the live version was terrible. but i think the studio recording was good.
HappeeMusic 2 years ago
shes so hot should have stayed longer
chocolatelicorice 2 years ago
Umm...Kimberly Caldwell sang this song better to say the least.
curlingiron7658 2 years ago
@curlingiron7658 its hard to judge crap vs crap, but it seems this crap is more tolerable than that crap Kimberly Caldwell was singing. she wouldnt even be able to make it on Glee
squirreludecker 1 year ago
@squirreludecker Is that why her album is due in around 2 months?
curlingiron7658 1 year ago
@curlingiron7658 No, i would imagine the reason it took her 5 years to find someone who would release her CD has nothing to do with the fact that she was a worse singer than Lindsey. Its more likely the reason is Kimberly was just a bad singer to begin with, thus needing the 5 years to work and train on it. as i havent heard her since Idol, i do not know if she succeeded or not.
squirreludecker 1 year ago
How could she be so completely clueless that this song was COMPLETELY wrong for her. It wound up being really bad -- not sure if she was trying to put too much of her own spin on the performance -- but it sure didnt work.
krbcan 2 years ago 3
This is a lot better than the most perfomances of the german idols - i watch it every saturday and in germany this would be a great perfomance :)
turnaround345 2 years ago
Mikalah sucked
ReturnOfBGA 3 years ago
OMG my last name is CARDINALE!!!!
DEMI88888 3 years ago
should've done a patsy cline country song, suited her better
osahju914 3 years ago 2
to be honest, this was horrible performance in terms of vocals. this was NOT the right song for her AT ALL. her voice is wayyyy to deep for this song and therefore, the entire performance was flat. she didn't hit any of the right notes. she was trying to, but failed miserably. her voice sounded strained as well. and to be completely honest, she sounded constipated when she sang the song.
she had good energy, but it doesn't mean anything if your vocals are downright bad. horrible song choice.
dtotheavid87 3 years ago 2
Comment removed
imlance 3 years ago 2
You don't see anything wrong with it? The whole thing was a trainwreck. With voters like you, I can see why the results are so bad sometimes. No ability to distinguish good from bad. The voters got it right this time.
jimmyboyd 3 years ago
Mikalah should have gone not Lindsey
cardude527 3 years ago
she was way better than mikalah gordon
angiehey19 4 years ago
holly crap this gurl is gooddd =]
partaymusic89 4 years ago 3
I wanted Amanda Avila through instead of her. I think Amanda was a bit better.
MattyJamesM 4 years ago
OMG this is not her style at all. Wrong song choice.
bbtcrt56 4 years ago 9
I liked when Nikko and Scott sang On Broadway
punkytay101 4 years ago
Lindsey had every right to leave that week. She sounded okay but not great and she did not stand out. I felt Anthony or one of the other white men should have left the next week. And whoever said my bro Nikko should have left that week need to shutup!!!!! This girl was horrible!!
jerel09385 4 years ago
i want him gone cause he didnt get the votes to be there in the first place.
aidean88 4 years ago 2
OMG thank u so much for this <333
Abberrzz 4 years ago
she 100% should have made it through this week,i was really upset with her and Mikalah not making it to top 10,i wanted Nikko and Scott to be the first 2 off
aidean88 4 years ago
Why the HELL would you want Nikko off first?? Can you not hear when Nikko sings or something? What's the deal? Nikko has a phenomenal voice!!
YaminFan07baby 4 years ago
thank you sooo much for posting this:)
aidean88 4 years ago