Beyond Reality - American Idol 8 Recap 3/4/09

[kylerayner70]

I think the group song was off because of Scott. I'm not saying this to be mean, because I think the guy is awesome. But because of his blindness, he can't do the choreography like everyone else, so many of them were forced to sit during the whole thing and I think it threw people off. It makes me wonder how future group songs will go. Also I noticed that not all 27 eliminated contestants were there for the pick of he Wild Card, so I wonder how they narrowed the group down to who was there.

[obsessong]

I love the expression Maddie gives her doggie at the 3:10 mark.

[obsessong]

Your pooch is adorable. Bring him back again!

[ohnotnatalia]

could anyone tell me who the last person was who made it on wildcard,

i missed it.

[JulianTheGreat01]

My top 12 Danny Gokey Alexis Grace Anoop Desai Adam Lambert Kris Allen Allison Von Smith Lil Rounds Felicia Barton Matt Giraud Ricky Braddy Jasmine Murray

[WhiteBull]

I hate the group singing!

This isn't America has talent! This is a solo contest.

[LadyMatsuyama]

group singing was very weird and ackward, anoop all the way. u guys sooo rock.

[Masterxazer]

I want all the girls in the wild card round to go to the top 12. =/ But my favorite is still Megan, and I'm actually pretty sure that if she's not awful tomorrow, they'll pick her.

Out of the guys (If they even pick one) I hope Anoop gets picked.

[ladytarheel1]

Go Anoop! UNC pride baby :)

[Poker115]

So does this of the 9 so far there are SIX guys and ONLY 3 girls???

Will be between DAnny and LiL and maybe the buy with the funny haircut.

[ShawnS917]

That wasn't scotts g/f in the balcony it was his sister. The whole family actually sings pretty good. The sister sings better than he does. There is video of her here on youtube.

[Idoljunky32]

Hey Maddie, hope your cold gets better. Some herbal tea with lemon and honey might help. Also some Vicks Vapor rub on the thoat wrapped with a warm towel use to help me when I lost my voice.

Much love Ladies

[shadforth1]

lots of people develop asthma well into adulthood....very normal.....

[flgrad91]

Please vote off Tatiana again America. Can't stand that drama queen

[rainylandscape]

Hey guys, I wish Maddie to get well. :)

I really want to see Megan, Jesse and Matt Giraud to get through.

I think that this year's way of picking the top 12 is not so good, because there are lots of good singers who don't get through because of popularity votes (AKA Adam Lambert), and that's too bad.

Most of the 9 people who are already in the top 12 aren't my picks, so that's a little bit disappointing.

I hope that at least the wild card round will do the justice.

[loccotony]

You guys praise Jasmine Murray but critisize the judges for picking Tatiana? Like do you really consider Jasmine to be a better vocalist than Tatiana?

[sultan1122]

Uhhh yeah?? lmao Jasmine is amazing just a wrong song choice but her vocals outshine tatiana by a mile

[loccotony]

I've seen Jasmine's audition, then her performances at hollywood (one of which the judges thought it was horrible) and she hasn't impress me at all. People can say all they want about Tatiana's personality (or tv persona) but she's one of the best female vocalists on this season and Jasmine does not come even closer.

[JulianTheGreat01]

It's not all about vocals believe it or not. Your personality plays a big part in it as well.

[loccotony]

Oh I know that, but if you re-read my comment I never talked about anything else. I'm not getting into who's better or has better chances of winning. I'm strictly talking about their voices, and Tatiana can sing a lot better than Jasmine.

[sultan1122]

oh well guess what :) Jasmine made it and tatiana did it.. I GUESS I WIN :)

[loccotony]

Indeed but not based on vocals though. ;)

[sultan1122]

Oh no i think it was after all this is a singing compeition :) but thanks for admitting Jasmine has better looks and a better personality than tatiana as well :-)

[loccotony]

LOL, w.e. let me mourn in peace dude. Jasmine does have the looks and personality but she does not have a better voice than Tatiana ;)

[sultan1122]

w\e helps u sleep at night :) jasmine still has a better voice

[pibaki]

it should have been felicia instead of scott!

[vickyvicks0]

ANOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOPPPPPPPP!!

cute dog btw!! haha

[whitecaribou23]

lol during the hot and cold song, alex totally had no idea what the words were! i was so upset that tatianna got the wild card spot

[Authorfan]

Tatiana makes good TV, and her singing is not bad at all. C'mon, you sweet people, give her a break.

[foulmouthfromsouth]

Why are you such a Tatiana hater?

[xkon89]

haha i love maddie's voice =D LOL

get well soon anyway

[marc0angel0]

i appreciate your recaps since I don't usually watch the result shows. i'm happy with lil, scott & jorge since they were my top 3 of the night (that makes 8 of my 9 favorite performances making it to the top 12). Great wild card picks.

I could definitely see any of them making it through to the top 12!

[xkon89]

shouldve been felicia instead of JESSE STUPIDSETH

LOL

ANYWAY!

[jyc604]

it seems to me that the reason why there were 8 wild cards announced was because the judges still need to decide who would get wild card spots from semifinals group #3.

the eight wild cards announced so far are all from the first 2 groups. so imo look for 4 more wild card announcements tomorrow before the show begins.

[xkon89]

erm... no

the first wildcard pick was von smith

from group...3?

lol

[Screengems1]

Thanks for the great recap... always love watching your videos. My favorite this year is Von so I hope he gets in. Your dog looks like my dog Lucy, except she is a Miniature Pinscher. Hope you feel better soon Maddie!

[stevenash1386]

cute dog cuddly

[stevenash1386]

my picks were right get well soon maddie i think meg anoop tata shes back lol

[sergeantkitty]

So how does this work tomorrow? Do we get to vote, or do the judges pick the final three themselves?

[dollywood48]

Glad to see Lil Rounds, Scott, and Jorge make it through. Very disappointed that Felicia Barton was not given a wildcard spot.

Hope you feel better soon Maddie!

[CwickVB]

Great video, thanks for doing what you do. Keep the dog out next time

[MrsJasperHale08]

the three that i want to go through tomorrow are Megan, Matt, and Anoop

[karesenbe77]

get well soon maddie. the ryan(the chihuahua) was distracting. nice job girls! thank you for the video.