I did not realize how badly Sarah Brightman did with this song until I had to learn it. SHE CHEATS! But she's famous enough to get away with it. While this singer also changes the song, she does not change it to make it easier. She changes it so that it is more difficult, and for that I respect her. Because this song is difficult enough as it is. She is amazing.
Patricia petibon? She is just so much fun, full of character and expression!!! Our world needs performers like her to remind us of the wonder of life. She is just beaut... lots of love and admiration....let it flow , you good thing john from australia.
She made the world go round because she is different, everybody keeps commenting about her and giving their opinions...don t you think that she is like Lady Gaga in opera? controverse... unicity...new things brought to a world fool of routine and boredom... i do believe that she is a genious.
écouter la version de lily pons (1972) pour comprendre que l'on n'a nul besoin de faire le pitre et de créer son show pour se rendre original: les moyens vocaux, le bon goût et l'authenticité de l'expression y suffisent largement..
quand on a une vocation de clown, il faut faire du cirque...
ni l'un ni l'autre...ou un peu des deux...c'est une évocation de l'espagne, colorée, imagée, pittoresque, ce qui est traduit par la musique elle-même (couleurs, rythmes, danse). Le texte est très savoureux, très fin ; tradition française oblige, delibes a cherché (et trouvé) une sorte d'équilibre. Une bonne interprétation (voir pons) doit d'abord saisir l'esprit, le contexte, l'esthétique et non pas caricaturer une partition pour se rendre originale...
Je suis desolé de vous dire cela mais je trouve cela GENIAL! que l'opera se mette au gout de jour pour attirer un public jeune et non averti! Les gens en ont marre de la poussiere et des moyens vocaux avec des chanteuses statiques!
je n'ai jamais parlé de poussière ou de chanteuses statiques...je suis jeune, j'apprécie le jeu théâtral, mais lorsque ce dernier s'associe à une musicalité et non lorsqu'il se substitue à elle; jouer, oui, gigoter non; servir un texte oui, se servir du texte non. Nathalie Dessay , par exemple n'est ni statique ni poussiéreuse, et elle fait de la musique (notamment dans cet air, qu'elle chante très bien)...l'un n'empêche pas l'autre.
Rassurez-vous Myrhah : votre analyse est la bonne !
Petitbon devrait faire du baluche...
Ni chanteuse ni même bonne comédienne, tout est tellement faux et exagéré que pour trouver cela intéréssant ou même drôle il doit falloir être ..sourd et vide de sens !
Some of her "eh" vowels are a bit too bright. I also get the feeling that she doesn't always know what she is singing - like when she is saying "Do I have a dainty figure?" The expressions are fun, but don't always go with the text.
good lord^^ Sarah Brightman a good singer? just because she was married to Lloyd Webber doesn't make her good^^ and I agree with previous post about her killing classical songs... no seriously, Particia Petitbon is my understanding of a great soprano, being a trained singer myself, I know how important good acting is in opera, and that's exactly what she is doing. she's bringing fresh wind into the opera business which is absolutely great !
Unconventional, to be sure, but the lady is a true coloratura with an impressive range and technique Her performances are invariably entertaining and always worth viewing. Take her for what is is and not what she isn't. FIVE STARS!
She does a fabulous job with this song. A bit unconventional but soooo interesting. She also has the pipes to back this up. I like her version much better than Netrebko's.
But all Spanish music is beautiful. It's the bad selection of singers and actors that is killing this otherwise beautiful song.
Pero es que toda la música española es muy bonita. Lo que pasa aquí es que la selección de cantantes y actores es pésima y ha matado esta bella canción.
J'adore la musique espagnole (Pas seulement la musique d'ailleurs mais toutes les formes d'art ibérique sauf le flamenco)mais ici dans ce morceau de Delibes, il s'agit pour moi d'une caricature "Pour rire" de musique espagnol (Tout comme Carmen d'ailleurs).
Parlez moi de Cabezon,Ortiz,du Padre Soler,de De Falla etc... Là d'accord.
En outre je connais bien Jordi Savall & Montserrat Figueras (Qui il est vrai ne sont pas espagnol mais catalan comme 1/4 de ma personne).
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
But you did not answer the question about the two black haired idiots on stage. Are they men in Drag?
I don't know if LEO DELIBES is dead, but if he is, he is turning in his grave.
Definitely these people killed the song. And then someone has the nerve to put this on YOUTUBE for the world to see!! I don't regret anything I have said.
I'm a Sarah Brightman fan, but she hardly as the best version. Her classical singing isn't that great when compared to grand divas like Dessay, Sills... even netrebko. And Patricia has a great tecnic to sing this.
Anyway, it was suposed to be funny. Don't be so judgmental.
And who are you to tell me not to judge what I see in YOUTUBE. I can say anything I want any time I want. You come from a dictatorship, that´s why you posted such a rude comment. ¿Así es que vive la gente de Portugal?
I didn't say that you couldn't post or what you could post, Jesus, are you paranoied or something? I was just saying that you made fun of the video and maybe you should respect Patricia Petibon's form of art and how she has fun on stage.
And I honestly didn't see how can you compare Sarah Brightman (which is foremost a pop singer because her bel canto tecnic is not that great) with someone who study and PERFORMED Opera for years (look it up, you'll see that Sarah Brightman only performed in musicals, and The Phantom of the Opera is hardly an opera at all).
A gente de Portugal não vive assim não, por isso não começes a falar mal quando nem sabes como somos.
Finishing, because I will not answer to this post anymore or to you unless you change your attitude.
When I sayed "Don't be so judgmental" I meant "Don't be so serius" because this video is supose to be funny. And what tells you that I was rude? I don't think I was. And if I was well I don't know what you were with the "Halloween post".
Sarah Brightman kills every classical piece she sings in order to sell her albums to ignorant people who dosn't know how a real operatic soprano sounds like and them she calls herself "best selling soprano ever"...that kind of sounds like musical prostitution
¡Fantástico! ¡Muchas gracias!
KaRidder234 4 months ago
@Domnitza3 Thank you so much :) bibes
TheKruelka 8 months ago
I did not realize how badly Sarah Brightman did with this song until I had to learn it. SHE CHEATS! But she's famous enough to get away with it. While this singer also changes the song, she does not change it to make it easier. She changes it so that it is more difficult, and for that I respect her. Because this song is difficult enough as it is. She is amazing.
FamiliaCara 9 months ago
can anyone french write the lyrics after 'La belle aux doux yeux' and before 'jaloux,jaloux',please? I beg you :)
TheKruelka 1 year ago
shes insane
skitzo429 1 year ago
la verdadera diva
brava, bravissima!
wunderwunderbare stimme xD
congrats paty, you're the beeest
KriBlackRoson 1 year ago
Patricia petibon? She is just so much fun, full of character and expression!!! Our world needs performers like her to remind us of the wonder of life. She is just beaut... lots of love and admiration....let it flow , you good thing john from australia.
HaberfieldChiro 1 year ago
i liked it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Milylily4Ever 1 year ago
I just have one word.... LOVE! XD She's fantastic and breathes new life to this song! :P
sesshomarushot 1 year ago
Greaaaaaaaaaaaaat
cantanteporsiempre 1 year ago
...cute
Andurst 1 year ago
jajaja...so hilarius!!!!
AminaBellini 1 year ago
full*
littlebiglion 1 year ago
She made the world go round because she is different, everybody keeps commenting about her and giving their opinions...don t you think that she is like Lady Gaga in opera? controverse... unicity...new things brought to a world fool of routine and boredom... i do believe that she is a genious.
littlebiglion 1 year ago
je pense qu'elle sait très bien que ce n'était pas le style de départ mais c'est tout simplement une parodie, histoire de savoir en rire aussi!!
floberthibaut 1 year ago 2
Fabulous! The most entertaining and well sung version I've heard! :)
Turand0t 1 year ago
good voice , pretty face
sophiemozart 2 years ago
WOW..
meeeshell19 2 years ago
patricia petibon devrait
écouter la version de lily pons (1972) pour comprendre que l'on n'a nul besoin de faire le pitre et de créer son show pour se rendre original: les moyens vocaux, le bon goût et l'authenticité de l'expression y suffisent largement..
quand on a une vocation de clown, il faut faire du cirque...
MYRHAH 2 years ago
@MYRHAH d'un sens oui, mais j'ignore l'intention de Delibes, comedie ou tragedie!
KARINADIVA 1 year ago
ni l'un ni l'autre...ou un peu des deux...c'est une évocation de l'espagne, colorée, imagée, pittoresque, ce qui est traduit par la musique elle-même (couleurs, rythmes, danse). Le texte est très savoureux, très fin ; tradition française oblige, delibes a cherché (et trouvé) une sorte d'équilibre. Une bonne interprétation (voir pons) doit d'abord saisir l'esprit, le contexte, l'esthétique et non pas caricaturer une partition pour se rendre originale...
MYRHAH 1 year ago
Je suis desolé de vous dire cela mais je trouve cela GENIAL! que l'opera se mette au gout de jour pour attirer un public jeune et non averti! Les gens en ont marre de la poussiere et des moyens vocaux avec des chanteuses statiques!
matteoelkhodr 1 year ago
je n'ai jamais parlé de poussière ou de chanteuses statiques...je suis jeune, j'apprécie le jeu théâtral, mais lorsque ce dernier s'associe à une musicalité et non lorsqu'il se substitue à elle; jouer, oui, gigoter non; servir un texte oui, se servir du texte non. Nathalie Dessay , par exemple n'est ni statique ni poussiéreuse, et elle fait de la musique (notamment dans cet air, qu'elle chante très bien)...l'un n'empêche pas l'autre.
MYRHAH 1 year ago
@MYRHAH
Rassurez-vous Myrhah : votre analyse est la bonne !
Petitbon devrait faire du baluche...
Ni chanteuse ni même bonne comédienne, tout est tellement faux et exagéré que pour trouver cela intéréssant ou même drôle il doit falloir être ..sourd et vide de sens !
bien à vous !
KOKAYT1 1 year ago
@matteoelkhodr
???
Niveau pipi caca ! ???
KOKAYT1 1 year ago
c'est genial!
pokethechutney 2 years ago
esta mujer es increible, su talento va acompañado de un fisico hermoso! divina!
Asdruvil 2 years ago
Самое прикольное сопрано!
muzetta100 2 years ago
te amo patricia dificil cancion hee los altos osn lo mas complicado
TheAmelieyann1 2 years ago
Me ha gustado mucho este divertimento, no conocía a Patricia. Que grata sorpresa¡¡
paripe 2 years ago
I love her voice!
TarjaSenpai 2 years ago
ha ha ha she's so funny
1pilloww 2 years ago 4
XXXX Increible
elderarce 2 years ago
WONDERFUL!
josejuanparrasanchez 2 years ago
her face...xD....she signs *wow*
VampireVulturi 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's pretty pathetic to cover up lack of vocal delicacy with silly gimmicks.
zamyrabyrd 2 years ago
and it's pretty pathetic to cover up a lack of intelligence with petty, ungrounded criticism.
missm0j0rising 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's pretty pathetic not to prefer better sopranos like Rita Streich over this bag of tricks.
zamyrabyrd 2 years ago
perfect performance. comme d'habitude. Vraimant marrant, viva patricia!!!! Hahaha
et notez bien que la m u s i q u e ne perd absoluement rien. Alors situation pour rire et larmes à la même fois.
akemilsson 2 years ago 2
J'aime Patricia..!
ptichkagulnara 2 years ago
This is funny and her voice is awesome :)
classicalgal14 2 years ago 6
mon pôvre bouzignac...que ta vie doit être triste et monotone...et que dire de ton sens de l humour...!!
nanard111 2 years ago
Some of her "eh" vowels are a bit too bright. I also get the feeling that she doesn't always know what she is singing - like when she is saying "Do I have a dainty figure?" The expressions are fun, but don't always go with the text.
stiemogo 2 years ago
you do realize...she's french? i think she knows what she's singing.
minirausch 2 years ago 5
C'est une caricature!...
Katiuszkasanda 2 years ago
good lord^^ Sarah Brightman a good singer? just because she was married to Lloyd Webber doesn't make her good^^ and I agree with previous post about her killing classical songs... no seriously, Particia Petitbon is my understanding of a great soprano, being a trained singer myself, I know how important good acting is in opera, and that's exactly what she is doing. she's bringing fresh wind into the opera business which is absolutely great !
iisiimiisii 3 years ago 29
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Trash !!!! Pure trash !!!!
pontedupre009 3 years ago
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
pontedupre009 3 years ago
enchanting, weird, and wonderful! She is making this art come alive again, which is a good thing- stuffy and stale it has been for so long!
rejectionking 3 years ago 5
Unconventional, to be sure, but the lady is a true coloratura with an impressive range and technique Her performances are invariably entertaining and always worth viewing. Take her for what is is and not what she isn't. FIVE STARS!
gmmix 3 years ago 23
She does a fabulous job with this song. A bit unconventional but soooo interesting. She also has the pipes to back this up. I like her version much better than Netrebko's.
NexusBlader 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Crazy Bitch!!!!!!!!111
35windu35 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She and the two clowns killed a beautiful song. Period.
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha !!!!!!!!
Hi hi hi hi hi hi hi hi hi hihihihihihihihihih !!
pontedupre009 3 years ago
Ce n'est pas un beau chant,
c'est une espagnolade!
bouzignac 3 years ago
But all Spanish music is beautiful. It's the bad selection of singers and actors that is killing this otherwise beautiful song.
Pero es que toda la música española es muy bonita. Lo que pasa aquí es que la selección de cantantes y actores es pésima y ha matado esta bella canción.
pontedupre009 3 years ago
J'adore la musique espagnole (Pas seulement la musique d'ailleurs mais toutes les formes d'art ibérique sauf le flamenco)mais ici dans ce morceau de Delibes, il s'agit pour moi d'une caricature "Pour rire" de musique espagnol (Tout comme Carmen d'ailleurs).
Parlez moi de Cabezon,Ortiz,du Padre Soler,de De Falla etc... Là d'accord.
En outre je connais bien Jordi Savall & Montserrat Figueras (Qui il est vrai ne sont pas espagnol mais catalan comme 1/4 de ma personne).
bouzignac 3 years ago 2
those "two idiots" as many refer to them...are in a company of all the other aspects - completely hilarious...cant stop laughin
LevisOrdo 3 years ago
poor spider
podkivanok 3 years ago
sarah brightman? ... she doesn´t know how to sing
EkaterinaTheWise 3 years ago 3
HAHAHA This is so funny <33
Elphaba415 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She has a good voice, but never as Sarah Brightman.
And what are those two idiots on the right doing there? They killed this song.
pontedupre009 3 years ago
wrong,
DoinItClassy 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
But you did not answer the question about the two black haired idiots on stage. Are they men in Drag?
I don't know if LEO DELIBES is dead, but if he is, he is turning in his grave.
Definitely these people killed the song. And then someone has the nerve to put this on YOUTUBE for the world to see!! I don't regret anything I have said.
pontedupre009 3 years ago
Today is October 31st. This video is very appropriate for a Halloween dark and cold rainy night.
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha!!! Hi hi hi hi hi hi!!!!!
pontedupre009 3 years ago
I'm a Sarah Brightman fan, but she hardly as the best version. Her classical singing isn't that great when compared to grand divas like Dessay, Sills... even netrebko. And Patricia has a great tecnic to sing this.
Anyway, it was suposed to be funny. Don't be so judgmental.
creidhe 3 years ago
And who are you to tell me not to judge what I see in YOUTUBE. I can say anything I want any time I want. You come from a dictatorship, that´s why you posted such a rude comment. ¿Así es que vive la gente de Portugal?
pontedupre009 3 years ago
Me from a dictarship? What tells you that I was born here?
creidhe 3 years ago
I didn't say that you couldn't post or what you could post, Jesus, are you paranoied or something? I was just saying that you made fun of the video and maybe you should respect Patricia Petibon's form of art and how she has fun on stage.
creidhe 3 years ago
And I honestly didn't see how can you compare Sarah Brightman (which is foremost a pop singer because her bel canto tecnic is not that great) with someone who study and PERFORMED Opera for years (look it up, you'll see that Sarah Brightman only performed in musicals, and The Phantom of the Opera is hardly an opera at all).
A gente de Portugal não vive assim não, por isso não começes a falar mal quando nem sabes como somos.
creidhe 3 years ago
Finishing, because I will not answer to this post anymore or to you unless you change your attitude.
When I sayed "Don't be so judgmental" I meant "Don't be so serius" because this video is supose to be funny. And what tells you that I was rude? I don't think I was. And if I was well I don't know what you were with the "Halloween post".
creidhe 3 years ago
but certainly nobody gives a fuck about your egoistic oppinion....by by boi...
LevisOrdo 3 years ago
Sarah Brightman kills every classical piece she sings in order to sell her albums to ignorant people who dosn't know how a real operatic soprano sounds like and them she calls herself "best selling soprano ever"...that kind of sounds like musical prostitution
Heartlessiceboy 3 years ago 3
That is truth but doesn't make her bad she is a fab musical soprano
classicalgal14 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Never as Beverly Sills...
luisjose1962 3 years ago
Her hair looks so awsome I love her voice.
texaswhitelobo 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Never as Beverly Sills...
luisjose1962 3 years ago
I prefer her version of Les filles de cadix it's so playful
27twentyseven27 3 years ago
Thank you ^_^
alexandriusgirl 3 years ago 2