Added: 3 years ago
From: NathanielMarshallFan
Views: 21,609
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (180)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • to 02nicka

  • i met him in real life and yes hes gay...?

  • @02nicka just cuz he sings amazing doesn't mean hes gay?

  • nice voice.. uumm is he gay ??

  • I love it!! but do u know why they only time i hear songs that talk about praying is when they are hurt bull crap ppl should pray every night i doooooo

  • he STINKS:(

  • i really liked him :l i was sad when he got voted off... Adam Lambert<333

  • I LOVE IT

  • im sorry but i really dont think he messed the song up, i liked it. and so what if he changed the pitch? its still really good and hes got talent.

    oh yeah, and...girl song? -_- let me remind u guys that first of all... theres no "girl" song or "boy" song, thats crap, cause all songs can be sung by a guy or girl. and that supposidly girl song was the one dany gokey chose, and he was good enough to make it to the final three.

    which shows a guy can sing a "girl song" as u people call it.

  • He switched his pitch for the chorus.. like he couldn't sing that high.

    Didn't like it much. :\

  • i dont think he messesd up, :)

  • yeah im modest so what i dont like him so what lol he needs to sing dude songs if he is going to sing at all sorry just my opiton

  • @skylerparker16 _Look here.... I really don't give two flying F_bombs about if it's a good or boy song. Really if you think about it, no "Song" is a girl or boy "Song" because, you can just change little key words around and, bam!... It's a boy/girl song. Now, on another note.... If you're going to take a (girl song) as you said it and, sing it like a girl in a crappy half-man/half-woman/half-elmo sounding voice, noone but, other toneless half ear wanna be fat groupies will like it.

    He's crap

  • @hellokittyo1o Girl This is what happens when you don't re-read your work. :_: good Girl* or boy song

  • @hellokittyo1o you're right.. this guy can't sing at all.

  • @hellokittyo1o did you really just say that nathaniel is crap?

  • duuuuuuuude this guy is reallyyyyyyyyyyyy good!

  • this is reallllyy old.

    ...he added in his own key change. xD

    I don't like singing without music though.

    I would've probably messed that up, too.

    I mean, he must've been like my age in this er something.

    but he's a good actor.

    haha.

    p.s. I feel special because I have his phone number. xD

  • can i please have his phone number, i tihnk he is amazing, and if you could give it me, well, idk, but he is my biggest insporation, and he has given me so much support, please tell me, if you do thank you, if you dont god bless yooooh, thank you (p.s. pleaseeeee)

  • Oh wow that is kinda stockerish. Like not to be mean or anything, but like if someone randomly called him he might get kinda pissed lol. And yes i know he would cuz i know him lol.

  • i wasnt that big of a fan of him..but he didnt do too bad in this vid...until 54 he messed up

  • yeah that wasnt too pretty

  • the chorus is soooooooooooooo bad......

    that´s not even the right note!!!! bad, bad

  • Comment removed

  • modest are we

  • Comment removed

  • he is so amazing. i got to meet him today at my 8th grade picnic and he was sooo amazing and we got to hear one of his songs hes been writing!!!!

    it was cool!!!

  • HAAH! I think we have a problum here... LOL! He shoulld stop taking a breath to fix his hair.

  • I takee that backk :S

  • he was cute

  • Comment removed

  • you do no hes gay right

  • Or actually he should just listen to danny's version, he'll jump off a cliff himself or on second thought he is shameless so please someone ? Kill him.

  • He should die.

  • this is during one of the producer auditions right?

  • soooooooo mediocre.. he's got NO range whatsoever!

  • gawd he is so amazing and gorgeous!!!!

  • he looks like someone i know except my buddy is asian. an asian looking Nathaniel Marshall!! :D

  • he looks so different!!

  • horibble i've heard people on youtube better than this

  • alright change keys in the middle of the song....

  • how old is he there?

  • wow he looks so different in this video.

    i love his voice though. :D

  • you are awesomeeeeeeeeee! why arent you on american idol????

  • he was on idol..

    but he had tew go homee :(

  • he's good...

  • no i meant the other guy that commented. He said that he thought Nate looked hot and that he was a guy:O

  • haha im cammie marshall he used 2 live in malone where i live hes my cousin. I know everyhitng about him.

  • he has GREAT voice for a guyy

  • hi Nathaniel fans..come over to Nate's new fan club. I had to close the old one at forumsland.. The new one is 2natemarshall.forumcabdotcom (replace dot with a period) or go to forumcab and click on hosted forums at the top and then scroll down to tv/movies, click and then click on nate's headbanders. C'mom over, everyone . Just transferred it all and need Nate fans posting

  • i loved him so muchh on american idol and i still do. he was my favorite!! him and alison and danny, and now only danny's left. *sigh*. and i dont care if he's gay but i wouldnt be surprised lol

  • This is wierd because it sounds like it's at a normal tempo, but he sings it within 1:28. Did he miss some of it or what?

  • he changes key in the middle of the song... bad nate... bad nate...

    at first i thought it was cody sheldon, and a fan posted the video with nathaniel's name...

    he looks better with short hair...

  • that doesnt look like him

  • he is hot. to me. :) and i am a guy.

  • you know what. i am. and. your lucky he marked this as spam. because. i am not up for a comment fight. i dont engage in those. so. peace out.

  • ur a GAY guy??? :O

  • umm not....he has a g/f i kno his family

  • he doesnt have a gf hes fricken gay i have known him for a long time!!!! so shut up and he had a gf a realllyyy long time ago her name was brooke and he broke up w/ her after he figured out he was gay. so shut up u are just trying to pretend like u know him. =P

  • he has a good voice. hes flaming gay though. lmao

  • lOl ahahaha I so agree...(what a diva...)

  • he has great diction!

  • GOD HE WAS HOT!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • He is very good the poor boy has been throught hell. I think he did a very good job

  • And for the record, I don't think he's gay.

  • lOl...Are you kidding...You can spot his ass from the 5 mile marker...Look at his sway, the flicker in his eyes..the swoosh in his hair. PLEASE...

  • I've seen pictures of him making out with a GIRL, So I don't know.

    I just said I DON'T THINK he's gay.

  • If you know what he'd been through, you wouldn't call him gay for being dramatic.

    He's perfect, and there's nothing wrong with that.

  • eh, not too bad.

    the chorus was a bit pitchy tho, but it wasn't bad =)

    haha i love nathaniel, he doesn't look too great with long hair tho xD

  • danny gokey sang that song much better

  • he's great!

    message me for his fansite on myspace

  • This seems really old?

  • Okay. Ningetai, that's bullshit.

    You didn't hang out with him.

    So just stop.

    Anyway, I think he has a good voice, but he didn't deserve to stay on American Idol.

  • its actually not bs.nate was at that show.

  • he is really out of key.

  • he is a bad singer what are you all talking about

  • this guy is amazing. I hung out with him last night at the underOATH concert!

    he may be gay, but I'm not sure, he was making out with a girl and a guy. he could be bi?

  • just because he is a good singer doesnt mean he is gay?

    :|

    like easy.

  • He is really good, but what makes him seem gay is that he is really nasally. He is really good (again) but he also needs a haircut.

  • tell him a small town girl is head over heels for him

  • He's gay :(

  • he's gay. sorry.

  • he is really ugly but really good singer

  • He is actually moving to my state. I hung out with him downtown last weekend. I know him through a friend. Really nice guy, very big ego.

  • hey can you tell him i love him and i kept voding for him thats all i ask.

  • Comment removed

  • pleez tell him that a grl in washington is like in LOVE with him

  • Uh, no?

  • Tell him he's awesome!

  • I love Nathaniel! I really want to meet him. I was so sad when he didn't make it. I just stopped watching. I was so mad. He is so good and his personality is awesome.

  • I live in the sanme town as Nate. Hes really amazing and i hope and pray some recording company calls him.

  • He has alot of different styles:).

    I love his voice, He kept getting

    better on american idol and now hes

    not on their:/.

  • i dont think that is him but it sounds like him

  • It IS him, he jsut is younger.

    rofl.

  • OMG he looks so different

    CUTE but different

    his hair looks good long

    he is such a cutie

  • AHHH

    he looks so different, but i still love him :)

  • lol no kidding

    younger i would guess

  • His hair looks really good!

  • if i were a guy i ttly be like him

    he he has my name in guy form and everything LOL

    he shouldve made itt hrough on american idol but hey...he's only 19 and theres always next year

    I LOVE YOU NATE!

  • hey manchesterlad1717,if you cant sing as well as him,dont critisize.thankyou.

  • he sounds better here than now on american idol but omg!! i love him and voted for him like 20 times!!!

  • how could u not chose him hes amazing and y the heck tatianna

  • YA.fuck it mans,wanted him in so baddddd ):

  • i am so sad he didnt make it. i screamed when he got eliminated.

    its ok, i hope this happened for the best, and that he does well with his music career.

  • im gunna marry him one day! lolz he is so good!! i watch this video once a day!

  • i stayed up all night voting for him :]

    but sadly he didnt make it :[

    i wish he did though i loved himm!!

    <33

    and he sang wonderfull :D

  • dont say that!

    He is good ,very good.

  • awhhh i loveee you but i couldent vote cuz u cant vote in canadaaaa :( ;ove u

  • Nate! IM still so pissed he didn't make it.w tfz. when he gets back here imma hug him. lawlz

  • i knoww himm!

    im sooo sad he didnt make it through!

    hes soooo good.

    he should've sang Bleeding Love.

    he sounded amazinggg

  • Wow! He sang better here than he did on American Idol, particularly that Meatloaf song. I think country is his thing, rather than pop. He actually sings a little, I emphasize A LITTLE, like Gary Levox of Rascal Flatts.

  • i totally voted for him! hes my favorite!! i just love him! ♥

  • one of my faves on american idol!!!

  • I voted for him too! like 250 times!

  • i voted for him like a billion times last night he is my favorite ever hes so amazing

  • his hair was adorable. :3

    he is such a hottie now.

    i agree withTrueWeirdGirl, i <3 his red pants. :3

  • i feel so bad ,his mom is in jail... I want him to do well..

  • hes better now than then i think? but i cant wait to see more from him next time!:D

  • omg hes soooooo cute!!!!!!!!

  • he changes keys like 5 times throughout

    but good begining tho

  • im not ganna lie he is a babe

  • i like how he dresses now, it makes him unique. love his red pants :)

  • he should have kept this look... he loks better here then on the show but his voice is amazing

  • Not***

  • they are note pitch problems...he is making the song his own... you know like a guy version because you know he is a guy..

  • Ow Ow sexay

  • he's one of my favorites :)

    along qith Danny and scott

  • josiah leming???

  • he looks like Josiah Leming here. Nate is awesome, sometimes pitchy but i love his voice

  • OH MY GOD I LOVE HIM HE IS AMAZING!

  • Woah! He looks completely different now! o_O Complete transformation!

    I really like his voice. Hope he does well next week. :)

  • i wish i had his voice!!! i love nathaniel

  • I love him and it was all going well until the chorus..it was baaad.

  • I think that if he picks the right song next week, that he could definitely make the top nine (if not, the top twelve.) As far as coming all the way and winning though? Adam Lambert and David Gokey will definitely beat him out in the competition along with a few other people. =/

    Love him though. =D

  • the last thing you want to do wen ur spinning out is let go of the wheel and start praying for jesus to steer you out

  • It's called faith..!

  • its DANNY gokey not david gokey! and its gonna be him and adam in the top 2... I HOPE

    danny's good but america (u have 2 admit) at some point stops caring about the voice. like david archuleta's case.

  • Lmfao, sorry about the whole wrong name thing! xD But yeah.... Adam has the whole fashion thing going on, but Danny's wife passed away (showing he might deserve it more, and people might be able to relate to him), and I think that Danny really appeals to America too in a lot of other ways. However you look at it, they both have pretty great shots.

  • My opinion is that he is really good....I mean I don't know him personally but i was there when he tried out for Mayors Cup...because so did I.... We sung the same thing although he did it better... I know his friends he was sitting with....

    I really hope he wins....We need people from small towns like this to make it BIG!!!

  • Good like how? Her voice is so breathy that it hides a lot of the off-pitch phrases, and he cant sing chorus at all. When he has jump more than 5 tones he goes off pitch. I do not think that he will pass the first round.

    Though I was already surprised by a lot of people.

  • his hair is better now

  • he's really not that good :/ just my opinion.

  • I agree... :/

    I'm not being mean, but... I think he's a bit generic and tone deaf...

    :3 but whatever sounds good to him I guess

  • oh I love the headbands but I really like his hair this way too

  • he sings good but i like tht danny guys voice tht sang hero better! but nathanial is my fave.

  • I love his voice.... ok he can be a little ott sometimes but he has a great voice!

  • if you people think that this is star material, think again! it was pitchy in a thousand places. Yes, people improve, but i just don't see him fitting in with kelly, david, jennifer, etc. good luck though...

  • he is very good but i also like that michael guy

  • hes our nxt american idol!! hes rely goood!

  • i lov em if he doesnt win i will die

  • i love him and i hope he makes it all the way this year on American idol(:

  • I like his hair on this video but i hate it right now i dont understand y he changed it

  • Amazing! He's my favorite this season, without a doute!

  • hes gay

  • ummmm... yes...

  • omg i love this guy. he is the best. <3 KEEP SINGING NATHANIEL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • hes soo cute! like this and now! either way! who cares if hes gay?! i love you nathaniel! you my favorite! (: you've got this! :D

  • he is soo good on american idol.

    i love him and he's so gay, i love it<3

    vote for him, please!(L)

  • he needs to wear his

    hair like that now.

    he would be adorable.

    :]

  • aww.

    look at his little hairs.

    :]

  • i think he is over sensitive but he is a good singer

  • i like his hair now. his still amazing

  • he looks so young! how old is he on this video? love the hair tough.

  • i think he was about 16

  • love his hair like this!

    hes def. my boy this year on Idol.

  • How cute is this? Seriously. <3

  • what was the problem?

    you look good in long hair!

    can you get him to sing disturbia again?

    i really want a version with video and the whole song!

  • yessss. get him to sing disturbia!!!! like the full thing!!!