Most definitely Casey! She seems like a nice person too! Katrina is much uglier, and she got breast implants! Not only is Casey prettier, but Katrina's a horrible influence on pretty much anybody.
man why wasnt i blessed with a body like caseys???? I dream of having a body like that...lol...impossible i know as much as i am losing weight right now i dont think my body could ever look like that...she is soo pretty not trashy like the other one...
casey seemed a lot more sincere and kind, and she didn't mouth off or pick fights with the judges. but personally, i actually don't like either. and physically casey's prettier etc.
yes casey is physically prettier but what are her moral standards? i personally am not a fan of people who go around in little skimpy clothing and thinking "oh im so hot" it might just be me but its so much hotter when they dont know theyre good looking and are sincere good people
i completely agree. it is way more attractive to be humble and not know how "hot" you are. i don't really like or respect either of them because of these pictures, but if i had to chose, i like casey better because she didn't audition half naked like katrina. but i think it's sad that both of them, who are probably nice girls, go around in bikinis for attention or because they think they're so hot. and it's sad the bikini girl claims to be a Christian.
Casey is one of the most gorgeous, talented, intelligent, and humble people I know. She is MOST definitely not the kind of person that walks around in skimpy clothes wanting people to fawn over her. She makes even the good-for-nothing fat piece of shit people like you feel like you're actually worth something to this planet. Don't talk shit about things you don't know.
And by the way, that's a photo shoot for a calender that gives 100% of profits to breast cancer research.
Absolutely right! I sat behind you guys at Idol auditions in Kansas and you two were the sweetest people I met that day!! Katrina isn't natural- anymore- and definitely cannot hang with Mariah.
I agree with marver... Casey is just a bikini model who actually models for a good cause and Katrina is an ugly hooker who runs around in skimpy outfits for attention.
casey,, is on bikini for a cause. and im inlove with her!! katrina, well, shes kinder that you guys think. you just got a bad first impression with her. but she's cute too, isnt she? casey's a black haired beauty. katrina is beautiful too. and she uses her asset. so dont get mad at her. but im still with team casey.
i like Casey better voice wise but both girls, especially Katrina, look like they have spray on tans or spend alot of time in tanning salons. They look like their trying to hard to look perfect (no offence intended to anyone)
complete opposites! Casey = girl next door, humble, hot and sweet. Katrina = slutty, annoying, conceited. Yes.. you can have the world and a nice girl with a smoking body! Casey all the way!!!!!
i respect Casey, i don't like her but she is taking pics for a good cause. Kat, she is just advertising herself as a whore. c'mon, who wears a damn bikini to an audition when you have to impress the judges, not seduce them.
Neither of them-I cast my vote for Jasmine Murray.Of all the races and genders, white women age the worst-they love the sun, love to smoke,etc.Most white gals, by the time they're in their early 30's they all start getting them lines and crows feet. Many black women look awesome when they approach middle age-Angela Bassett, Halle Berry, Vivica Fox,etc. and I bet you Jasmine will look just as hot 25 years from now.
sure casey is hotter. but all her pics r professional photos.. kat is just nat
weaksauce11 11 months ago
Casey, no shit
Lordgodisgood7 1 year ago
Casey no shit she's amazing and not whorish
Lordgodisgood7 1 year ago
Both look good in a bikini. Katrina Darrell has a much nicer ass.
ALGONQUIN5 2 years ago
casey
Danina92 2 years ago 4
of course casey..
katrina is such a hot slut looser,
chikirout08 2 years ago 2
Casey!!
AIKON0866 2 years ago 3
I just prematured in my pants.
Jmervex583 2 years ago
Casey. 100%
Eastgolf35 2 years ago 4
casey hands down
JoeyChan8788 2 years ago 2
Casey!
Casey=Sexy
Katrina-Slutty
criticalpsyko802 2 years ago 2
CASEY! My mom met her too, and i hope she hooks me up with that
hawxroxsox 2 years ago 2
casey
streetsk8r4ever 2 years ago
I think Katrina is hot, but in a skanky kind of way.
Casey, she is just plain natural. So she gets my vote.
TheManAbove 2 years ago 5
Most definitely Casey! She seems like a nice person too! Katrina is much uglier, and she got breast implants! Not only is Casey prettier, but Katrina's a horrible influence on pretty much anybody.
Lilster111 2 years ago 2
casy!
monanaty 2 years ago
Casey. Models for bikinis....
Katrina... looks like shes just acting like a slut.
:)
Casey all the wayy.
whgoopsgirl37 2 years ago 4
no brainer, casey totally lol. that shit is hot!
Musabre 2 years ago 2
i want my 1:57 seconds back !
Glassblower718 2 years ago
CASEY katrina tries too much 2 be pretty when shes NOT.Casey also didnt acualy wear a bikini to da audition. GO CASEY!
kaka7088 2 years ago 2
man why wasnt i blessed with a body like caseys???? I dream of having a body like that...lol...impossible i know as much as i am losing weight right now i dont think my body could ever look like that...she is soo pretty not trashy like the other one...
polkm90 2 years ago
Work hard. you can do it im sure :)
glamourdoll666 2 years ago
CASEY!!! :D
boogers386 2 years ago
like Casey duh! She doesn't try to be preety she just naturally is. The other, come on she got fake boobs later on.
funkyjenny2891 2 years ago
Casey
Kathryn0505 2 years ago
i no casey she is my friends cousin Kaily knaus
fungirlcat194 2 years ago
casey for sure
LinkinParkFan101tv 2 years ago
dude...CASEY , hands down...
no contest.. casey is friggun hot..
wlshl3one 2 years ago 2
Casey is WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY hotter than Katrina :D hotter body, hotter face, hotter everything and i just love her black hair :P
MortenDrenqen 2 years ago
um totally casey she has a better body face and shes not a bitch
Xxwait4uxX 2 years ago 2
Casey Carlson
21yOsUrEsH 2 years ago 2
I think it's pretty obvious who wins. Sorry Katrina, but there is a difference between sexy and trashy.
pudgeperfect 2 years ago 3
I love Katrina Darrell more
she's hot in here 1:03
BoiFavSongs 2 years ago
casey is deff much prettier and you can tell that
she is a nice girl unlike katrina who is a skank
andd a bitchh (:
ShannonnnAllennn 2 years ago 6
i agree totally
LinkinParkFan101tv 2 years ago
Casey posed for the calender to raise money for the Breast Cancer Research Foundation. She's not parading around flaunting her looks!
mmpotter22 2 years ago 2
definately casey cuz like she can sing
DrewProductionss 2 years ago 3
Casey wins hands down .
KenYakYak 2 years ago
Katrina is ugly compared to Casey. I think Katrina is a ho too who can't take herself seriously. She can't sing either.
BlackDragonOfEgypt 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
copy and paste this on at least 10 videos with your e-mail and you will get a FRED or Shane Dawson tee shirt. you choose!!!!
this is not spam.
you can do it .IF YOU WANT!!!
superblood24 2 years ago
wow. you just go ahead and think that
mickeymouse8494 2 years ago
that cassie chick is fuckin hot!
XxLeMoN17hEaDxX 2 years ago
Casey is wayyy Hotter!!!
R4ever1 2 years ago 3
well.. casey has better boobs.. and katrina better face
imandark0 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
uhmm her new boob job
ny4and26 2 years ago
true but katrina has a more equal body and ass
tsunayoshi987 2 years ago
CASEY by Far!!!
bishdo 2 years ago
this isnt even a close comparison
casey is amazing
the other one has fake tits and is possibly the biggest slut to ever get on a tv show
dafdsf 2 years ago
casey....
cioccopeciocco 2 years ago
CASEY all the way.
caotlinh 2 years ago
its not even a competition casey wins by a mile
casey models for a good cause, and katrina is just a slut
casey is much prettier and classier while katrina is just an attention whore
seyjune 2 years ago 3
theyre both *****
mickeymouse8494 2 years ago
casey is a billion times better, plus she's beautiful on the inside. i hate katrina!
bnemz23 2 years ago
how can someone like her be beautiful on the inside? just asking
mickeymouse8494 2 years ago
casey seemed a lot more sincere and kind, and she didn't mouth off or pick fights with the judges. but personally, i actually don't like either. and physically casey's prettier etc.
bnemz23 2 years ago
yes casey is physically prettier but what are her moral standards? i personally am not a fan of people who go around in little skimpy clothing and thinking "oh im so hot" it might just be me but its so much hotter when they dont know theyre good looking and are sincere good people
mickeymouse8494 2 years ago
i completely agree. it is way more attractive to be humble and not know how "hot" you are. i don't really like or respect either of them because of these pictures, but if i had to chose, i like casey better because she didn't audition half naked like katrina. but i think it's sad that both of them, who are probably nice girls, go around in bikinis for attention or because they think they're so hot. and it's sad the bikini girl claims to be a Christian.
bnemz23 2 years ago 2
thanks. thats exactly what i feel. sums it up really well
mickeymouse8494 2 years ago
Casey is one of the most gorgeous, talented, intelligent, and humble people I know. She is MOST definitely not the kind of person that walks around in skimpy clothes wanting people to fawn over her. She makes even the good-for-nothing fat piece of shit people like you feel like you're actually worth something to this planet. Don't talk shit about things you don't know.
And by the way, that's a photo shoot for a calender that gives 100% of profits to breast cancer research.
oem264 2 years ago
Casey is one of the most sincere, kind, humble people on the planet... She was raised right!!!! I'm her mother!! I should know!!!!!
mmpotter22 2 years ago 2
Absolutely right! I sat behind you guys at Idol auditions in Kansas and you two were the sweetest people I met that day!! Katrina isn't natural- anymore- and definitely cannot hang with Mariah.
KelsieChandler 2 years ago
Thanks Kelsie...I hate when Casey gets bashed!!! Every once in a while I have to comment!! Hope you're well.
Thanks for saying hi:-)
mmpotter22 2 years ago
Yeah, no contest. Casey wins by a freaking mile.
vgamerfive 2 years ago
casey 4 sure she is so fuckin sexy
BlackRockstar13 2 years ago
Definitely Casey...she's amazing!
raymlee1 2 years ago
Casey is talented and good looking, that blonde, forgot her name, is not even in same league as Casey. Casey is awesomeeeee zzzzzzz
m2chaudh 2 years ago 2
CASEYYYYYY COME ON NO COMPARISON
milat87 2 years ago
ive got to say. im a girl and i still agree with many ppl that katrina just looks so fake. casey all the way
drpeppergurl17 2 years ago
casey for sure! katrina tries too hard...she looks so cheesy
alyssalei808 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
take ur middle finger and put on ur nose.
2.say a name of someone u like.
3.that person will ask u out or say they love u tomarrow.
4. heres the thing copy and paste to 2 other vids
dnt read this(cuz it really wrks). u will gt kissd on the nearest frieday by the love of ur life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life
DarkAngel1598 2 years ago
For those of you that think Casey isn't beautiful, I say this...GET SOME FAWKIN' GLASSES!!!
Phasers1a 2 years ago
ahhhhhh this video made me cum my pants
americanidolkid 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out Bikini girl Katrina Darrell on American Idol with a new set of Boob's ....
Kara's Voice was Awesome...
Search for it on youtube :
Katrina Darrell-American Idol Finale 2009 -Bikini Girl Good TV quality
krisIdols 2 years ago
casey's beauty and sexiness is classy, not whore-like at all. she's intelligent looking, too.
deanabxu 2 years ago 3
i say both are eqel but katrina has a nice ass and tits casey has on tits
TripleXXXDudeF0rEvEr 2 years ago
casey wins! :) (nd she wasnt a bitch, thats a plus)
husyoFAJA88 2 years ago 3
Casey is hot. Katrina is an ugly whore.
ssj999666 2 years ago 11
I don't think Katrina has a pretty face, she just has a good body.
titchymcmidget 2 years ago
You were looking at her face? I didn't even notice their face was in the pictures......
apogee1mars 2 years ago
Both of course! At the same time would be even better.
cowhousecreek 2 years ago
katrina now tht she got a boob job
Chrisisasexybeast1 2 years ago 2
yea you saw that to right
ny4and26 2 years ago
haha yuhh how could u miss it
Chrisisasexybeast1 2 years ago
katrina def
mastercrowly 2 years ago
there isnt even a competition its casey no doubt about it lol
Johnsboy23 2 years ago 4
katrina is trash.
baileychandler 2 years ago 4
casey deffinitley casey
loveybabyragoer 2 years ago 10
I agree with marver... Casey is just a bikini model who actually models for a good cause and Katrina is an ugly hooker who runs around in skimpy outfits for attention.
Klaterz22 2 years ago 2
katrina is trashy
casey is classy
theirs a difference
marver116 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Katrina
haji9891 2 years ago
I would say Casey, she's got a prettier face, but I wouldnt' kick either out of bed LOL
MK12082 2 years ago 4
im on the fence
PrimeGex 2 years ago
u can so tell that katrina haz a fake tan. so yea casey.
lizcube 2 years ago
casey carlson wins
liptonstr 2 years ago 4
its SO SO SO SO SO SO SO SO SO SO HARD FER ME
M3GAG33K 2 years ago
oops sed she was like a goddes and an angel ;o lol
HiFudgeBunnies 2 years ago 2
cassey is like a goddess that fell from heaven like an angel...gifted by her talented voice and gorgeous body
HiFudgeBunnies 2 years ago
casey but i love katrina 2
DANIELTHEGREATSTUDIO 2 years ago
casey,, is on bikini for a cause. and im inlove with her!! katrina, well, shes kinder that you guys think. you just got a bad first impression with her. but she's cute too, isnt she? casey's a black haired beauty. katrina is beautiful too. and she uses her asset. so dont get mad at her. but im still with team casey.
chekowlet165 2 years ago 2
casey had nice tits but katrina had a sweet ass
queens2philly15 2 years ago 2
actually casey is beautiful!!!! her face is as fucking hot as her body!!!!
JOrg3r3llOO 2 years ago 2
well, obviously casey looks better since those pics are professional but katrina is better
JOrg3r3llOO 2 years ago
I agree Casey by a longshot!!!
RikWCrlsn 2 years ago 2
casey is pretty and classy ...
katrina is trashy ...
bimysyd 2 years ago 4
gotta say casey
twincutize123 2 years ago 5
casey by far shes smoking
airsoft008 2 years ago 3
casey is just a natural beauty
Jmmag91 2 years ago 3
katrina is a stupid skanky slut and kind of a bitch...casey is actually a sweet girl.
nanobanano12 2 years ago 3
id do em both.
metalmaniac58 2 years ago
Casey....BY FAR! Casey is not only beautiful, but very likeable. Katrina was cheap, nasty, and skanky.
ThreeD2007 2 years ago 2
Casey For Sure..
LinzyBby 2 years ago 3
Casey by far! She's classy and naturally beautiful where Katrina looks like a .. well .. slut honestly.
jcpowell2 2 years ago 2
i like Casey better voice wise but both girls, especially Katrina, look like they have spray on tans or spend alot of time in tanning salons. They look like their trying to hard to look perfect (no offence intended to anyone)
shannonbug18 2 years ago
complete opposites! Casey = girl next door, humble, hot and sweet. Katrina = slutty, annoying, conceited. Yes.. you can have the world and a nice girl with a smoking body! Casey all the way!!!!!
webmasterd 2 years ago 3
katrina just looks slutty and has a big nose, therefore casey is georgous and looks modern. :) haha good going KASLUT.
fluffy122193 2 years ago 2
casey!!!! because she's natural and cute...whereas..katrina hum hum.... sorry
chopikerina 2 years ago
i love sluts but seriously casey is just my type of girl
eidius1989 2 years ago
OMG!! Casey,Duh.Katrina is too slutty,that's bad.
kittymho42 3 years ago
casey definately! at least shes more friendly... UNlike kaslut! katrina is so stuck up her fat but!!...
ps. katrina is pretty tho... (thats the suckish thing)
libra096 3 years ago
CASEY ITS OBVIOUS
YOURTHEFAG 3 years ago 2
They both are BIG SLUTS! Carrie Underwood is VERY PRETTY with TONS of class. These two girls arent sexy, just sluts!
SweetThunder201 3 years ago
Wrong, Casey did this for a calender where all the money went to breast cancer foundations, and she is very sexy
TCSkillz3310 3 years ago 4
yeah casey's were all photoshoots, katrina's were pictures of her about to go out. casey was just modeling, katrina was being a slut.
googlepiggie 3 years ago
Haha exactly
TCSkillz3310 3 years ago
CASEY!!!
LUVShanti220 3 years ago
Casey no contest
torque269 3 years ago
i agree with the ladies, casey is classier and prettier. katrina has a rocking body but shows a bit too much of it.
hurricanechameleon 3 years ago
Casey is wayy prettier.
xxoSamxxo 3 years ago
Casey got the face and bod, FHM material.
Katrina? good enough for tissue paper printing. she will lick our asses!
worldagency 3 years ago
i think casey looks better than katrina because katrina is a SLUT
jovilover2003 3 years ago 4
pretty sure darrell is a dude.
JaceySquires 3 years ago
Casey Carlson is definitely better looking! and this is coming from another girl's perspective. She also looks classier.
bebexion 3 years ago
well to be honest i wouldnt mind havin them both with me HAHA
tennismaster08 3 years ago 2
man Katrina is such a SLUT!!!!
I bet she loves getting shafted in the pooper
Shokeybutsi 3 years ago
CASEY!!!
AznKongGang 3 years ago
casey.
mleigh2008 3 years ago
Katrina is a whore searching for attention!
At least Casey sells to bikinis and all the money goes to charity for breast cancer!
coconuts1995 3 years ago
Katrina is slutty and Casey is tasteful...
wait, why am i here?
jadenhotguy 3 years ago
gross much? HAHAH! that whore Katrina actually thinks shes hot? wow man, thats completely priceless. :) Casey all the way.
wemightneverknow 3 years ago
casey definetly
cupcakeman911 3 years ago
Well lets see one of them looks sexy and classy and the other just looks like a trashy whore....i'm going to go with Casey
sweetcandy121287 3 years ago
katrina has lil tits
Tsiko777 3 years ago 2
I don't like the blonde one AT ALL. she is so shallow, and thinks she's all that. Katrina is WAY prettier.
lilylouisesmiles 3 years ago
WELL, KATRINA IS THE BLOND ONE ....
MahadiaLeBon 3 years ago
katrina is the blonde one, you do know that right?
jiamonx2 3 years ago
casey
cathy41875 3 years ago
I would say Casey because her pictures were 4 a good cause not just to be a whore like katrina
xommmpapixo 3 years ago
i respect Casey, i don't like her but she is taking pics for a good cause. Kat, she is just advertising herself as a whore. c'mon, who wears a damn bikini to an audition when you have to impress the judges, not seduce them.
lenangreg69 3 years ago
They both have a flat ass but casey is so much prettier!
Kantasyxx 3 years ago
Casey!!
Way better Body and very nice BOOBIES Katrina has none get a boob job Kat!!!
JORBRITT 3 years ago
I fully agree and Kat will probs get a set of bolt on's next time we see her..where ever when ever that is..
oldford71 3 years ago
Casey
katou200024 3 years ago
I like Katrina, she can fart the alphabet and I would still be smitten with her.
flubno 3 years ago
casey has bigger tits
cwbyfan93 3 years ago 2
Casey Carlson
vithia2124 3 years ago
o and katrina looks like a barbie doll shes got so much fake tan krap on
eemedrelyt21 3 years ago
pure beauty = casey
pure drama queen = turn off
eemedrelyt21 3 years ago
casey also because Katrina is more of a bitch and slut!!!!!!!1
gemgirl266 3 years ago 3
Casey fer sure
lilsetter2 3 years ago 2
Katrina 100%
iwanttolickbichsnips 3 years ago
casey she hot
iluvpie25 3 years ago 2
Casey obvi.... Katrina looks like shit
rellybois 3 years ago 2
CASEY!
GuitarHitSongs 3 years ago 2
Ka-tramp Darrell is a huge slut. If they let her through, ratings would sink into her cooch
VanSensei 3 years ago
Duhhh, Casey Carlson 100%, its not even close. Casey is not only sexy, but cute and a wonderful woman as well.
She needs to smile in her pics thou.
Poker115 3 years ago 2
Casey... Katrina is full of herself
mommy2sarahjean 3 years ago 3
CASEY.... DUHH.
izziebob68 3 years ago 3
easily casey.
Otherside49 3 years ago 3
stupid question casey carlson is possibly the most beautiful girl in the world!!
doormaneamons 3 years ago
Casey! No doubt about it! She is both beautiful and hot, plus she seems to have a nice personality
Mulleviking 3 years ago
Neither of them-I cast my vote for Jasmine Murray.Of all the races and genders, white women age the worst-they love the sun, love to smoke,etc.Most white gals, by the time they're in their early 30's they all start getting them lines and crows feet. Many black women look awesome when they approach middle age-Angela Bassett, Halle Berry, Vivica Fox,etc. and I bet you Jasmine will look just as hot 25 years from now.
P.S.I'm a white boy, too,lol.
senorbellaco 3 years ago
i ll go with megan fox.. lol..jk
jologs21 3 years ago
casey 4ever..
luv her
mathmajis 3 years ago