@Hotlips4000isback That's a bit harsh. None of them are Bimbo's. Actually, Where Vanessa smokes she hasn't been able to hit the high notes in recent performances, and Rochelle's really standing out. She's definitely the most consistent in the group and she doesn't has to shout. They can all sing, though.
@Hotlips4000isback No, it's not a fact at all. They can ALL sing, with Rochelle at times being better than Vanessa. You can't go round slagging girls off, who clearly haven't done anything to prove your point.
They are really good at acoustic performances. I think that's the biggest thing between them and GA. People like to compare and there really isn't any. They are both good groups. But I think GA are better performers and do better with the dancing and everything. But from the acoustic performances of theirs I've heard, they really don't have anything on The Saturdays.
no way is it better without frankie if u think tht then ur obv stupid i couldnt imagine the sats without frankie let alone without any1 else they all bring sumthin different to the band
i saw them live at the hexagon last night (16th june) i got waves na dwinks from them all :) and i did from pixie d that other woman lol.. i was front row too it was ammmmmmmaaaaazzzzing! x
It's because there are 5 of them and they're with GA's management. They've beencomapred to the Spice Girls because , you guessed it, there were five of them. If they were 3, they would be compared to Sugababes or if they were and rnb group, the 'British Destiny's Child' ( who are the biggest selling female group of all time).
I love Rochelle's voice in this. It sticks out in the back (bass) It sounds so cool. Me and 3-4 other GUYS are going to cover this song for Denver Pridefest 2009!
She might be the strongest dancer, but she has the weakest voice. She can sing though, don't get me wrong, but I don't find her to be as good as her group mates.
Sugababes aren't old news, there should be room for more girl groups than just Girls Aoud and the Sugababes. It's not like British music is saturated with them at the moment. They are practically veterans in this, well Keisha is before Girls Aloud etc. and they have sold more records.
they are good ther.but i think sugababes have alot behind them so they are great even to survive during some girls left its all part of the act 4 them
i love the live versions of up! but i like when there all together singing it.when they all together says "you know just a bit too slow" i love that part.and "keep on"
They're good at singing. Yes, the music sounds different and not as good. But they're voices are brill. Unlike girls aloud and most girl bands these days. If you listened to the sugababes or girls aloud live, it sounds like a cat being strangled. I rest my case.
Not always.. Amy Winehouse's album has been certified diamond, what about Duffy, Estelle, Leona . They've all won grammys etc and/or sold millions'.
Yes image is a big part ( do u want ur fave artist to look like they do in the morning in front of the camera and the mags. no!)but if the songs, are catchy etc ppl are going to buy it. It's called pop. Thats the way it's always been. Not everyone likes the same music or genre
rochelle and vanessa the better all over the world no im sorry the 5 are the best
bryanlomas 3 months ago 2
Una's dance;D 'xoxox
MegaHevie 3 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
Una's dance at the begining was so cute!!!
mollymijh 3 months ago
Up... Yours hahaha!
steph26041969 3 months ago
una has the best voiceeeee
samiscool1992 4 months ago 2
@samiscool1992 yeeess :D
bibipassos10 4 months ago
@yumifan88 frankie stopped smoking years ago :)
rysc123 6 months ago
I wish Frankie and Vanessa wouldn't smoke... when i learned that they did, I almost died...
yumifan88 6 months ago 6
Were if frankie it ain't good without her
selenalover786 7 months ago
Wow! proud of Mollie! usually she and Frankie take the higher harmonies, and she had to do it all by herself!!
dld016 7 months ago
Una!
bibipassos10 7 months ago
WOW in this case, I don't miss frankie.
juicirosi202 7 months ago 4
unna i wanna spoon ya
1pezze 8 months ago 2
love una, great singer AND plays the guitar! thumbs up guys! :D
lemonmuffinbubble 8 months ago 4
where's frankie? :(
jennikidd1 8 months ago 2
@jennikidd1 appendix was removed so she was in recovery
MrTwozerofour 8 months ago
Who's the drummer? =)
ArianaHelen 9 months ago
damn those girls are hot :)
gothrec 9 months ago 3
<3 una :) up the irish ;D
MrsSarahMackey 10 months ago 18
I like it !
Kaddelchen 10 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Vanessa is the singer of the group, she has a great voice naturally and can sing in her sleep if needed, the others are bimbo's!
Hotlips4000isback 11 months ago
@Hotlips4000isback That's a bit harsh. None of them are Bimbo's. Actually, Where Vanessa smokes she hasn't been able to hit the high notes in recent performances, and Rochelle's really standing out. She's definitely the most consistent in the group and she doesn't has to shout. They can all sing, though.
TeamSatsChannel 11 months ago 10
@TeamSatsChannel
Just stating a fact.
Vanessa is the best of the lot, and the others are not.
Hotlips4000isback 11 months ago
@Hotlips4000isback No, it's not a fact at all. They can ALL sing, with Rochelle at times being better than Vanessa. You can't go round slagging girls off, who clearly haven't done anything to prove your point.
TeamSatsChannel 11 months ago 11
@TeamSatsChannel
I'm NOT "slagging them off"
I'm being honest, just like everyone else who posts comment on YT, wither others like it or not.
Its an opinion which i have the right to express.Just like you have.
If you don't like it fare enough, but it won't change my mind, i know what i can hear!
Hotlips4000isback 10 months ago
7 people are down
Njzfinest 11 months ago
Una's voice is unique
Vanessa's voice is stuning
Mollie's voice is beautiful
Rochelle's voice is amazing
and Frankie's voice is cute...
elenor1996 1 year ago 13
This has been flagged as spam show
where's frankie.... I only watch this videos because of her :(
unconsciuswritter 1 year ago
where's frankie.... I only watch this videos because of her :(
unconsciuswritter 1 year ago
why is the man shaking a banana?
Tom61337 1 year ago
i absolutely loove the music
Sumaa95 1 year ago
you don't even notice that frankie is missing vocal wise
erinb3395 1 year ago 5
superb =D
cfcdaviddcfc 1 year ago
frankie!! is the only reason im listening too this crap .. god shes hot
TGibZOoM 1 year ago
Vanessa has beautiful hair!! and she sounds amazing life, they all have good harmonies though
xLycrax 1 year ago 3
Sooo much better than Girls Aloud...
fightforthisglove 1 year ago
we used to dance this song in school
just so crazy 'cause the teachers were really having fun!
while the principal stood up to dance with us hahaha
jadetanchannel 1 year ago
MAN They are incredible live!! Wow!!
kcjonessj 1 year ago
where's frakie?
tnsfmj15 1 year ago
@tnsfmj15 she had her appendix removed so she was resting
ebonumba12 1 year ago
Vanessa's great! Best singer in this group !
PAleaveOfficial 1 year ago 2
Love them accapella they sound amazing!
onelastkiss323 1 year ago
i adore frankie, but everyone says she does the high harmonies, well... they sound amazing here, without her.
whats going on??
una<3
ness; amazing voise.
DogLoverDanni 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Rochelle is amazing she just harmonises so well especially with Una - those two just have the best harmonies in the group.
Vanessa is always on point - luv em xx
Shadyseraph 1 year ago
Rochelle is amazing she just harmonises so well especially with Una - those two just have the best harmonies in the group.
Vanessa is always on point - luv em xx
Shadyseraph 1 year ago
wow, they have good harmonies!
cloudnine32 1 year ago
very good :D
ninallegra 1 year ago
OMGGGGGGG !!!!! This Is SUPERB !!!! Love 'em~~~~
M8073 1 year ago
frankie had an appendisitis so she was resting when they did this
TheCoolgirl17 1 year ago
Vanessa is really good live !
hannah09067 1 year ago 57
Wheres Frankie Doh ?
DaniellaTONTINHA 1 year ago
heyy, im SO happy ive finally figured out how to put vids on youtube, check them out, VERY much appreciated :) x
MissSarajayneXx 1 year ago
No Frankie?? Where is da Gal??
MissCaterine1994 1 year ago
I love Una and Vanessa. Both so different and both really good vocalists!
MMCloverr 1 year ago 6
Love Una sooo much.
Miss Frankie's face on this video though :/
DogLoverDanni 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
una kicks arse here ;)
what u dun wii sexy arsee frankieee
StifflerM8 2 years ago
the guitar sounds a lot like Sweet Dreams my LA Ex by Rachel Stevens hahahha
liob1611 2 years ago 6
yeah, where's frankie?. :(
menardmari 2 years ago
Where is Frankie?
sGaap2 2 years ago
@sGaap2 she was recovering from having her apenddix out
londerner5050 2 years ago
but she sang the other song(s) in this live lounge session :(( maybe cos for this song she soesnt have a solo so she went to have a rest....hmm...
dazzlemedougie 2 years ago
in this session they sang Up and Beggin'.
Frankie didn't appear in either because she was in recovery.
she was in their most recent session just before christmas.
bestboy1986 2 years ago
AAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Una Healy has the Jack Daniels Guitar !!!! I have that same one !! =0=0=0
this is the best day of my life..
McBrideAidy 2 years ago
I want a banana shaker, and the saturdays to kidnap me!
Lisledl 2 years ago
awesome, they can sing this really well live im suprised!
blondieinontario 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
txx0xxt 2 years ago
They are really good at acoustic performances. I think that's the biggest thing between them and GA. People like to compare and there really isn't any. They are both good groups. But I think GA are better performers and do better with the dancing and everything. But from the acoustic performances of theirs I've heard, they really don't have anything on The Saturdays.
jhwb256 2 years ago 4
jeez u really woundnt miss frankie!!
smurphelton101 2 years ago 67
@smurphelton101 all frankie needs do is stand there happy days
donchuckles 1 year ago
@smurphelton101 or Mollie!
KikisChica 7 months ago
what does that guy with a banana ?
(huh?)
likabruining 2 years ago 3
Haha yeah. It's actually a shaker in a shape of a banana.
geetarstar 2 years ago
lol, luv unas dance at the start!
ForeverFirece 2 years ago 2
the blonde girl really luks lik sienna miller!!!
keevawoodscork 2 years ago 5
every one ses thats she's called mollie king
Danotron4Music 2 years ago
lol i know she isnt there.
i just had to sayy
andyscott910 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
err what a accent! same with Harry Pottah!
Good Job!
drawbobo 2 years ago
Comment removed
drawbobo 2 years ago
Da Saturday in Malaysia Penang.. I love this song!! <3 saturday..
sohaiangel 2 years ago
great performance made by the chemistry between the band and the musicians with them (Y)
oh and frankie is hottttttt :D
andyscott910 2 years ago
Fantastic!
lezthewelshman 2 years ago
there harmonies tight
jbandsglover 2 years ago
great.. but it seems a little faster than the starting! but great job!
clhn520 2 years ago
Amazing harmonies! Not JUST pretty faces!
DJCRooK3D 2 years ago
Una Rocks!
letyb1 2 years ago
The Saturdays are one of the best female vocal acts the music industry have seen in my opinion.
glassflute 2 years ago
UNAAAAAA HEALYYYYYYY I LOVE YOU
edmundr93 2 years ago
no its not it sounds just as good there all have amazing voices i didnt even notice she wasnt there i saw them last tuesday and they were amazing
superstarellie118 2 years ago
it's much better without frankie :)
cagatayu88 2 years ago
no way is it better without frankie if u think tht then ur obv stupid i couldnt imagine the sats without frankie let alone without any1 else they all bring sumthin different to the band
team sats 4eva <3 x
stargirl732 2 years ago
their harmonies are beautiful
naiviv1218 2 years ago
i hadnt notice Una sings differently.
i love the saturdays
but i think Una is the best out of all of them!
Juicylu01 2 years ago
so do i.
bennybozoo 2 years ago
i saw them live last nighttt.
i got waves from all of themm.
they are all so sweet and nicee! :D x
xLGD 2 years ago
i saw them live at the hexagon last night (16th june) i got waves na dwinks from them all :) and i did from pixie d that other woman lol.. i was front row too it was ammmmmmmaaaaazzzzing! x
JimBobJnr2006 2 years ago
i saw them on the 23rd they were soo gd
amazing dresses
superstarellie118 2 years ago
OMG I LOVE THIS VERSION!
matty8292 2 years ago
Where is Frankie?
mikidutza28 2 years ago
Does Una have a lisp too?
A1ofAkindChick 2 years ago
no i thinks its just cause she's irish so she sings like that
hypolozzy 2 years ago
oh..sorry if i offended.
A1ofAkindChick 2 years ago
no, no don't worry you didn't i was just telling you lol it's fine i'm a big fan of her and also the sats but i'm not offended at all
hypolozzy 2 years ago
This is brilliant! Amazing how such attractive girls can be really talented as well!!!
thelucy3703 2 years ago
2 of them used to be in s club 8/juniors
walkerciaran0602 2 years ago 2
i like the music better than the orgibnal its my fav saturdays single
DanotronProductions 2 years ago
which one is vanessa?
pinkstarz94 2 years ago
Vanessa is the one with curly dark hair...
dancer20gc 2 years ago
2:14 whats her name?
growupbiku 2 years ago
mollie
pspulse 2 years ago
@pspulse
Actually her name is Vanessa
TheDorutza 1 year ago
where frankie?
musiccloverx 2 years ago
She was ill :( So disappointing, she's so hot!!
iainrough 2 years ago
she had apenasitous so she had to have them out
DanotronProductions 2 years ago
apenasitous??? LOL Apendicitis...
dancer20gc 2 years ago
the left one looks like kelly rowland
Marc22BN 2 years ago
vanessa and una are the stars of the group the rest just provide a pretty face.
chazham1 2 years ago
what about rochelle
jbandsglover 2 years ago 5
i know!
everyone forgets her and she's one of the strongest singer.
ebonyil22 2 years ago 2
Vanessa's voice is killin' it. She's got the strongest voice of the whole group. Amazing!
JewelsCrabapple 2 years ago 5
their all peng
futurekeeper08 2 years ago
Considering we pay good money to the BBC here.. hmmm... shakin a banana.. faking it.. these girls deserve better than cheap bbc stunts! GO girls.
globulas1 2 years ago
It's because there are 5 of them and they're with GA's management. They've beencomapred to the Spice Girls because , you guessed it, there were five of them. If they were 3, they would be compared to Sugababes or if they were and rnb group, the 'British Destiny's Child' ( who are the biggest selling female group of all time).
masbo 2 years ago 4
I love Rochelle's voice in this. It sticks out in the back (bass) It sounds so cool. Me and 3-4 other GUYS are going to cover this song for Denver Pridefest 2009!
stratus110 2 years ago 3
THIS IS AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
amstad100 2 years ago
i think their better without frankie
devil666die 2 years ago
i think they are shit without frankie... she is the best dancer ov the lot and she has an amazing voice!!! without frankie they aint the saturdays
misspoynter1 2 years ago
She might be the strongest dancer, but she has the weakest voice. She can sing though, don't get me wrong, but I don't find her to be as good as her group mates.
Undermedveten 2 years ago
1. The Saturdays 2. Sugababes 3. Girls Aloud.
That order is for better live performances, and higher ammount of stronger singers!
Photographlife 2 years ago
Comment removed
Photographlife 2 years ago
Vanessa's vocals are amazing
Myloveispink94 3 years ago 15
wheres Frankie>??
badwulf2 3 years ago
she had her appendix removed so she cudnt perform wiv the ovas
gigglesgem 3 years ago
I meant to say Estelle and Adele.
masbo 3 years ago
Sugababes aren't old news, there should be room for more girl groups than just Girls Aoud and the Sugababes. It's not like British music is saturated with them at the moment. They are practically veterans in this, well Keisha is before Girls Aloud etc. and they have sold more records.
masbo 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the black girl and uma? una? the 1 with the round face, really pretty, r the best singers. the others r just eye candy
movebutters 3 years ago
they are good ther.but i think sugababes have alot behind them so they are great even to survive during some girls left its all part of the act 4 them
lucyinclonmel 3 years ago
ugh.. utube wont let me view the official vid :(
sophia329 3 years ago
youtube arnt allowing people in britian to view certain music videos, cant remember why.
sadamevans89 3 years ago
i think una and vanessa are my faves
i mostly like vanessa cuz shes short likeme and unas got a great voice
Skercz14 3 years ago
heey where is frankie? O.O
she wasn't there?? o.o
KatSnows 3 years ago
thats what I noticed
MsIsly 3 years ago
she was probably recovering from an operation to take her appendix out.
FrankieGW92 3 years ago
in think una has a great voice vanessa is good but not into rnb sounding voices
nathanpob 3 years ago
Lol, back then thwy were like 14 xD
kakafck 3 years ago
they are a pretty good group
i think they need a bit more practise singing live though
they are good now so they could be amazing if they get singing live better
misslaura2323 3 years ago
Almost every act that perform in radio 1's live lounge sounds crap.
woowoker 3 years ago
no they don't. they all sound very cool. after all, if you have a good voice you should be able to perform accoustic.
justlikethatcherie 3 years ago 3
(L)(L)(L)(L)(L)(L)(L)(L)ilovethisversion.♥
MegannAliice 3 years ago
i love the live versions of up! but i like when there all together singing it.when they all together says "you know just a bit too slow" i love that part.and "keep on"
jessika01 3 years ago 3
They're good at singing. Yes, the music sounds different and not as good. But they're voices are brill. Unlike girls aloud and most girl bands these days. If you listened to the sugababes or girls aloud live, it sounds like a cat being strangled. I rest my case.
Lushinolia 3 years ago
The Sugababes are good particularly Amelle but I agree with you on GA. They're shite.
JStevens988 3 years ago
love their style
neifaen87 3 years ago 2
Frankie is not there because she was recovering from having her appendix out!
d33d334ever 3 years ago 2
wers frankie?
tomahillside 3 years ago
yes they could. can britney or rihanna sing? no. but they still have contracts and are very successful globally
movebutters 3 years ago 3
If any of them where not "good looking" (including Brit and Ri) no one in the music industry would take a second look at them.
Looks sell in todays socioty, NOT talent. Sad FACT
deviouswun 3 years ago
Not always.. Amy Winehouse's album has been certified diamond, what about Duffy, Estelle, Leona . They've all won grammys etc and/or sold millions'.
Yes image is a big part ( do u want ur fave artist to look like they do in the morning in front of the camera and the mags. no!)but if the songs, are catchy etc ppl are going to buy it. It's called pop. Thats the way it's always been. Not everyone likes the same music or genre
masbo 3 years ago
they sound good in harmony but not so good individually. the black one with the black weave is the best singer though
movebutters 3 years ago 3
Luv Una playing the guitar.
IndieLuva 3 years ago 2
i luv ur mom
ungelbertpendo 3 years ago
jack daniels
Dan161093 3 years ago
so... who is black?
mausimpson 3 years ago
tanned
pipmilmol 3 years ago
i think they sound pretty good..
i like their acoustic stuff. it's cool(:
TiashaF 3 years ago 3
amazing :)
lilmissprunemuffin 3 years ago 3
I love the Saturdays! They're actually brilliant together!
jg060291 3 years ago 5
This version is awesome. They should do more acoustic performances. HAHA .:D
hppcdocfan 3 years ago 13
They sound really awesome live!!
vistamadonna 3 years ago 3
This was brilliant!
I saw them supporting Girls Aloud on tour and they were amazing!
mpedley88 3 years ago 7
this is good, not many singers can actually sing live bu they sure can! x
FoxySaz08 3 years ago 11
amazing song!!
ungelbertpendo 3 years ago 5
Where is Frankie?
Man, this sounded awesome. I keep waiting for Vanessa to make a really big note though.
zigazigpartyla 3 years ago 2
frankie had her tonsils removed i think
pspulse 3 years ago
I really loved this version, but I miss Frankie!
JamieZeleneGlades 3 years ago 4![]()